4 ms·
"This article is certainly an opinion piece, but the opinion expressed is about economic methodology, not politics." Yes, a few of the examples were apolitical
by timr 17y ago
"This article is certainly an opinion piece, but the opinion expressed is about economic methodology, not politics."
Yes, a few of the examples were apolitical (e.g. the man marrying his maid and the economics of slavery), but most were thinly veiled attacks on government programs (e.g. the TSA, government stimulus spending, the cash-for-clunkers program, the dead-weight loss of taxes). The author spends most of his time associating government spending with negative impacts on well-being.
This essay advances a vague, unmeasurable quantity as being of paramount importance, disguises the intent of the essay with a few apolitical examples, then proceeds to argue that a number of recent government initiatives are obviously ill-conceived, in light of their impact on this unmeasurable quantity. As a whole, the essay is little more than an attack on government, framed as an objective discussion of economic methodology.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoHe mentioned two recent government initiatives; Bush-era airport security and an Obama-era policy that exemplifies the broken window fallacy. His stimulus example was fictional, as was his "man marrying his maid" and "magical 2x productivity gain" example. His other real life example (slavery) was hardly recent. I think your beliefs about the intent of the essay reflect your views as much as his. By the way, utility is not vague. It is hard to measure, but that's not the same thing.