3 ms·
Your concrete example doesn't work. In a system of equal wages you'd still get paid for developing your steam engine even if it didn't work - the safety net me
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
Your concrete example doesn't work.
In a system of equal wages you'd still get paid for developing your steam engine even if it didn't work - the safety net means that engineers won't have to take a risk (beyond wasted materials) in order to develop new designs. You'd need a central bureacracy [which is the problem] so you could apply to a group akin to the InstMechEng and they would asign finances for your project or not (or you could self-finance if the costs weren't too high).
It also however means that when they make the new design everyone can benefit rather than just them. For sure, some people will consider it only worth working to improve things for themselves and so refuse to work to make new engineering advances.
A better example you could give IMO would be something like coal miners. "No one would want to work in a coal mine, as it's high risk, if the reward is the same as working in an office as that's low risk.". I don't think it's true, some people will still want to work manually, despite the risk - people take risks for pleasure so the economics are far more complicated than "people only take risk if there's greater financial compensation".
It's a source of sadness for me that one might feel the only reason to do something is to have more than other people rather than to give more, to make everyone's world better. Greed is hard to combat, I certainly haven't managed that, but it's not the only motivation to work.
- synthmeat 11y agoGreed is easier to fabricate (just turn the inequality knob up) than creativity or some other source of intrinsic productive motivation. Fear similarly so.
- whatok 11y agoIn a system of equal wages the supply of engineers would vanish because there would be no incentive to spend four years in college and whatever local licensing. Literally no one would know how to do the job. In a system of equal wages the supply of coal miners would dry up because no one will risk their life doing backbreaking labor when there are much more safe opportunities out there.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSo, no physicists ever do physics because they can get jobs as quants earning vastly higher wages? Building, farming, construction, mining ... no one chooses to do these jobs because there are safer jobs available?
- whatok 11y agoUnder our current wage system? No. I have not claimed any of those scenarios. I'm claiming that by reducing pay incentives from the equation, you will see a decline in certain professions and also the education typically required for those professions. These professions are also the professions that already have a supply glut and by removing one of the naturally occurring incentives for these jobs (a market wage), you only make it harder to find people able to do the work.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoIf there's a glut in supply and you reduce the financial incentive shouldn't that lead to a greater proportion of people who are passionate about the work of itself. That clearly doesn't work in all vocations, however. Can I ask, what motivates you to perform your particular functions in society, is it only the financial reward?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Patient0 11y agoIt's true that, in principal, an efficient central bureaucracy could do a better job of allocating people's efforts. For example, the Government could be responsible for all R&D - and arguably this was effectively the case when the US govt paid for all those Moon missions. So... maybe bigger government + social safety net could actually lead to more efficient outcomes. Re "taking risk for pleasure": I would need to adapt my argument to start talking about corporations and not individuals, for one thing. I think it's probably more important (for economic efficiency) that large-ish corporations are compensated for taking on risk than individuals. Corporations have a duty to their shareholders to not take risks without commensurate compensation. It gets complicated quickly... The key point I wanted to make was that there is a good justification for inequality, and it's about economic efficiency, not just what people think they deserve. As you have done, you can also still argue against inequality while keeping economic efficiency (by introducing concepts as social safety net, centrally planned R&D)... That's a whole other debate which unfortunately was also not really made in the article.
- objectivistbrit 11y ago"You'd need a central bureacracy [which is the problem]" It's more than a problem - you couldn't implement such a system without a totalitarian state. "It's a source of sadness for me" It's a source of sadness for me that you haven't thought through the details of your plan to "make everyone's world better".
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago"one might feel the only reason to do something is to have more than other people" Are you saying you do ascribe to this position, that your only motivation to work is to get more money (and by extension luxuries) than everyone else has? My plan, which I haven't mentioned is to guard against my own tendency towards greed and basically follow Ghandi's maxim of "being the change you want to see in the world". Do you have specific objections to that plan?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- objectivistbrit 11y ago"Are you saying you do ascribe to this position, that your only motivation to work is to get more money (and by extension luxuries) than everyone else has?" No. I never said anything like that, and you are arguing dishonestly. (For the sake of other readers: the goal of work is to achieve eudaimonia, productive happiness. The false dichotomy between "material greed" and "spiritual self-sacrifice" causes massive and unnecessary misery. See the books in my profile for details). "Do you have specific objections to that plan?" The change you said you wanted to see in the world was everyone earning the same wage. Here's a specific objection: let's say I'm a plumber living in your utopia, and some of my neighbours complain that InstPlumbing is often slow fixing their pipes. Though it's a fair bit of work, I'm willing to do it myself in exchange for a few of their hoarded dollars (or cigarettes, or whatever), which I later barter for extra bread rations for my kids. Whoops, now I'm earning more than other plumbers and we have inequality again. Should I be banned from performing this greedy, selfish activity? And how are you going to stop people from engaging in such voluntary trades without totalitarian surveillance?