12 ms·
I don't understand academia (genuinely): Couldn't the researchers simply publish their own papers? Make torrents etc? Or are they prevented from doing that som
by nailer 11y ago
I don't understand academia (genuinely):
Couldn't the researchers simply publish their own papers? Make torrents etc? Or are they prevented from doing that somehow?
- a_bonobo 11y agoYour career is based on how "good" the journals are that you publish in. If I publish a paper in Nature, Nature Genetics, Science, etc. then I can hand-pick my next position. The more glam-journals I publish in, the better my chances for tenure.
- oarsinsync 11y agoCan you cross-publish / self-publish as well?
- rspeer 11y agoIn practice, people often just put a "draft" of the paper on their personal website without telling their publisher. Papers in fancy journals are more prestigious, but the papers that get cited the most are the ones with full text freely available on the Web. So, when they can, scientists choose both. (The better way to do this is to support a publisher that's both high-quality and open-access and submit to their journal.)
- JupiterMoon 11y agoIt depends upon your field and your country but many journals require a copyright assignment. They also often require that the work has not been published elsewhere previously.
- Vespasian 11y agoIt depends on the venue. In my field of computer science (visual analytics / visualizations) at least some of the leading journals/conferences officially allow you to put a version of the paper on your website. Just today we submitted a paper where the copyright form explicitly mentions that.
- a3_nm 11y agoIt depends on the venue. In computer science, it is often possible, but there are often weird restrictions: embargo delay, only the preprint, must include a link to the publisher version, only on a personal webpage or on certain kinds of repositories, copyright assignment has been signed as well, etc. So you don't always feel comfortable doing it. Further, we academics are incentivized, in terms of career, to publish in prestigious venues managed by official publishers. We aren't incentivized to publish in open access repositories as well. So, even though most of us want our articles to be disseminated widely, not all of us can find the time to make sure that the paper is also available on an open repository. This is a factor that explains why many articles are not available for free online even in cases where it would be legal for researchers to upload them.
- throwawaybookst 11y agoDon't people in CS just ignore that crap and post free PDFs of "preprints" (taken the second before submission of camera ready) on personal websites? IME the publishers fuck up the formatting anyways.
- drewm1980 11y agoYes. Yes they do. RE formatting, publishers ~do enforce page limits, which has value... if you're publishing on paper.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThis is why the scam is so insidious. The journals are really squatting on academic output so they can be gatekeepers of academic status and of career prospects. The product of publishing isn't the dissemination of insight and innovation, but of gold stars academics can put on their resumes. Sci-Hub doesn't just threaten copyright, but the entire status factory.
- dalke 11y agoJournals are used as a proxy for quality. A publication in "Science" or "Nature" is generally regarded as being better than a publication in, say, the "Proceedings of the National Academy of Science". Bibliographic metrics, like the number of publications and where they are published, are use as a proxy for the quality of someone's research. It can affect grant funding and career advancement. Researchers can publish their own papers. But researchers also tend to want that work to be disseminated, both to spread knowledge and get recognition for the work. Journals help simplify that process. A field typically has one or two main journals, which most people in the field track. It's more likely that a publication will be noticed if it's published in one of those papers.
- chris_wot 11y agoIf we were to work out what makes a journal so prestigious, what are the objective measures that should be considered?
- kowdermeister 11y ago100 years of track record publishing the least amount of junk.
- chris_wot 11y agoWorst metric evar.
- parenthephobia 11y agoMainly it's a chicken and egg situation. A journal is prestigious because the papers it publishes have an allusion of quality, because they are published by a prestigious journal. A prestigious journal publishes high-quality papers because it can attract high-quality authors and reviewers, because it is a prestigious journal. A journal is prestigious because researchers choose to (try to) be published in it, because their articles will be widely read by other researchers, because it is a prestigious journal. If you were trying to bootstrap a new journal, you'd have a tough time; unless you didn't care about its quality. The bare minimum would be a staff who have the time and skill to sift through obviously junk papers and then know which reviewers to use for the legitimate papers. Your best bet would probably be to assemble a staff of well-regarded researchers in whatever field(s) you wanted the journal to cover.
- kuschku 11y agoMany researchers do so – but the established magazines are used for evaluating the quality of a researcher, and also used for ranking universities. You might notice that universities which recommend to their researchers to self-publish do not even show up in any university ranking.
- sklogic 11y agoActually, quite a few of them do publish at least preprints outside of the peer review journals. For about 80% of the papers I needed recently that were behind a paywall, I managed to find PDFs published by the authors somewhere else.
- return0 11y agoThe problem is nobody is going to read them. That's because the people who these scientists are targeting (other established academics, funding sources) choose to ignore the rest of the internet and only read the well known journals. This is almost exclusive to life sciences though. In CS, physics and other disciplines people just upload their preprints on arxiv and don't really bother about impact factors and such.
- Al-Khwarizmi 11y agoI don't think most scientists bother much about impact factors. Institutions and funding agencies are the ones who bother about impact factors. I work in CS and I know that if I want my paper to be read by the community I have to publish in a conference and/or arXiv, as almost no one read journals in CS. But then comes one of the almost infinite assessments the bureaucratic system in my university and country makes me jump through, and what do they look at? Impact factors, and conference publications are worth next to nothing. So I constantly have to juggle between what is good for being relevant and known in the community, and what is good to keep my job, which are often incompatible. This depends on country, though. In the US, I think the funding agencies have left behind the impact factor fetishism in CS and authors can (and often do) just publish in conferences. But in Spain if you don't publish in journals you just don't get a position in academia, in fact some universities are starting to require > X ISI JCR-indexed publications to be able to become a PhD. And I have heard that in e.g. China it's the same thing.
- return0 11y ago> I work in CS You 're fortunate. I bet sci-hub is mostly used by life scientists.
- impendia 11y agoThis is actually common, at least in mathematics: Researchers simultaneously submit to a traditional journal and to the preprint server http://arxiv.org http://arxiv.org. Usually I don't have any difficulties finding contemporary papers. It is papers from, say, thirty years ago, that are usually stuck behind paywalls.
- hanklazard 11y agoInteresting. I wonder why nothing of that sort exists for the biomedical sciences? Maybe it's been tried but these publishers won't allow it?
- tomkinstinch 11y agoThe biomedical sciences have bioRxiv: http://biorxiv.org/ http://biorxiv.org/ It is not used as broadly as arxiv.org, but that may be starting to change.
- hanklazard 11y agoNice to know, thanks!
- mattkrause 11y agoIf you are funded by most US or Canadian agencies, you're required to put make something publicly available. Depending on the journals' contract, it might be the published article, or the final version of the text before they copy-edit/reformat it.
- crocowhile 11y agoYou are absolutely right. Scientists are the only ones to blame for this. It's true, as someone else replied to you, that scientists tend to chose journals based on their reputations but it's also true that nothing prevents a scientist from publishing their unedited manuscript on their personal websites. It's absolutely legal and absolutely uncommon.
- joshvm 11y agoMore and more universities are paying for 'gold' (open) access publication. They're beginning to realise that you get more citations if people can actually read your papers without needing to go through the paywall. One of the advantages of publication is peer review. When you cite someone's work, if it's in a reputable journal then you can assume that someone reviewed it and would vouch for the quality of the research. You have to take it with a pinch of salt (reviewers are never totally unbiased and they make mistakes), but in fields where research is easy to verify like computer science, a publication in somewhere like Pattern Recognition holds a lot of weight. If you just cite a random paper that someone's self published on arXiv, you have no real idea whether what's being presented is true. Again, this isn't so much of a problem for CS papers where you can implement and test the work yourself, but for fields like physics where you're relying on other people's data, you want to be sure that someone smarter than you checked the numbers.