3 ms·
Just in case it isn't clear to everyone (and I don't think it is), this is an opinion piece from a libertarian think-tank, funded by something called "the Liber
by timr 17y ago
Just in case it isn't clear to everyone (and I don't think it is), this is an opinion piece from a libertarian think-tank, funded by something called "the Liberty Fund". Please don't confuse it with anything related to peer-reviewed economic research.
This is why I hate economics: many of its practitioners have absolutely no ethical qualms about blurring the line between publication of their political opinions and their research. Unless you pay exceedingly close attention to the source and context, you can easily be confused into believing that an editorial is somehow an objective analysis of economic theory. And while I'm sure the author raises a legitimate point about the shortcomings of GDP as a metric, this essay is filled with weak assertions and sloppy logic that probably wouldn't pass muster in a real paper.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThis article is certainly an opinion piece, but the opinion expressed is about economic methodology, not politics. The main opinion expressed is that economists should measure well being, not GDP. It supports this opinion by giving examples where GDP != wellbeing (man marrying his maid, TSA harassing people, magical productivity increases) and advocating that economists measure wellbeing rather than GDP whenever the two differ.
- timr 17y ago"This article is certainly an opinion piece, but the opinion expressed is about economic methodology, not politics." Yes, a few of the examples were apolitical (e.g. the man marrying his maid and the economics of slavery), but most were thinly veiled attacks on government programs (e.g. the TSA, government stimulus spending, the cash-for-clunkers program, the dead-weight loss of taxes). The author spends most of his time associating government spending with negative impacts on well-being. This essay advances a vague, unmeasurable quantity as being of paramount importance, disguises the intent of the essay with a few apolitical examples, then proceeds to argue that a number of recent government initiatives are obviously ill-conceived, in light of their impact on this unmeasurable quantity. As a whole, the essay is little more than an attack on government, framed as an objective discussion of economic methodology.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoHe mentioned two recent government initiatives; Bush-era airport security and an Obama-era policy that exemplifies the broken window fallacy. His stimulus example was fictional, as was his "man marrying his maid" and "magical 2x productivity gain" example. His other real life example (slavery) was hardly recent. I think your beliefs about the intent of the essay reflect your views as much as his. By the way, utility is not vague. It is hard to measure, but that's not the same thing.
- bokonist 17y agoHave you read many peer reviewed economics papers? Or even college economics textbooks? They make same arguments about well being, dead weight losses, etc. And they are full of weak assertions and sloppy logic. Peer review can be a process for eliminating error, but it can also be a process for replicating error. Where does your faith in academia economists come from? Have you read a bunch of peer reviewed papers, and decided that they have better logic and reason than the writings of a top econ-blogger ( like Winterspeak ( http://www.winterspeak.com/ http://www.winterspeak.com/ )? Also note that while econlib is funded by the Liberty Fund, most academic economists are substantially funded by the government. There is potential for bias everywhere, let's worry about what people say. Of course, I also think Henderson is wrong in one of his points. GDP is total national income times a price deflator. If government spending does not result in more productive output, then that will show up in the price deflator, and "real gdp" shouldn't rise. At least in theory. The real problem with the GDP statistics is that the calculation of the price deflator is riddled with methodological problems.
- timr 17y ago"Have you read many peer reviewed economics papers? Or even college economics textbooks? They make same arguments....also note that while econlib is funded by the Liberty Fund, most academic economists are substantially funded by the government. There is potential for bias everywhere." Economics papers are reviewed by other economists before publication, and government research funding doesn't dictate political ideology. Also, real economics papers aren't opinion pieces, disguised as "articles" in a "library" of economics.
- bokonist 17y agoAs I said before, peer review means nothing to me, because peer review replicates error just as much as it replicates truth. In general, a piece of writing can contain facts (ex. the stock market crashed in 2009), interpretations of facts (ex. President x's policies reduced unemployment), and oughts (ex. leisure is inherently good). The line between the three can often be blurry. Henderson's piece contains facts, interpretations, and oughts. Most academic papers contain facts, interpretations, and oughts. Denigrating something as merely an "opinion" piece is simply a cheap and uninformative way of saying that you disagree with someone's interpretation of the facts. and government research funding doesn't dictate political ideology Ha! Future economists are selected by present economists based on their interpretation of the facts. Present economists were selected by past economists. The grant system was originally setup by the FDR administration and Vannevar Bush, who all believed in a powerful state managed by technocratic experts. So just as the Liberty Fund tries replicates libertarian interpretations of the facts, academic system tends to replicate the statist interpretations of the facts that the founders of the system believed in. And you still didn't answer my original question. How many peer reviewed economics papers have you read through and carefully thought about? Do you have a favorite paper or two?
- gojomo 17y agoYour critique would be more interesting if you listed the "weak assertions and sloppy logic", rather than impugning the author and publisher.