6 ms·
So....block ad blockers and HN screams. "I will pay for content", they say. "I just don't like your 25MB flash ads." Link to crap, and HN screams. "Is journa
by paulddraper 11y ago
So....block ad blockers and HN screams.
"I will pay for content", they say. "I just don't like your 25MB flash ads."
Link to crap, and HN screams.
"Is journalism dead? This stuff is just click bait. I appreciate good writing and quality content."
Put up a paywall and HN screams.
"Why u make me pay?!?!?!?"
- ChristianBundy 11y agoSolution: don't do shitty things (e.g. block ad-blockers, write awful content, or use paywalls). Easy.
- dredmorbius 11y agoTo be fair, this doesn't address publishing's revenue problem, though it does the public good element. See my earlier comment.
- tracker1 11y agoServe first-party ads that integrate well with your content, and establish direct relationships with your advertisers... same as print has done for over a century.
- manigandham 11y agoThis does not scale and has been proven over and over again. Print never made much money and they had both subscriptions and advertising together to help.
- tracker1 11y agoThat's pretty much bullocks... Print media costs massively more for publishing costs vs. online publishing. Same wrt television, both of which handle upwards of millions of customers every day just fine.
- manigandham 11y agoI'm not sure what point you've made. Print media does have more costs, but its advertising also costs more. Print also has subscriptions/purchases to actually get the material in addition to the advertising it contained so they have 2 revenue streams, allowing the advertising to be simpler and not carry the entire cost. And it still wasn't a great business model with many outlets just breaking even. Regardless, there were never "millions" of advertisers or publishers like we have in digital which is why selling direct does not work, unless you only want the top 1% of sites to make any money...
- tracker1 11y agoNYT within the past year is claiming 2 million subscribers... now some of those may be online only... but there's every bit of potential they could setup a first party ad system.
- manigandham 11y agoThey do, it's called native advertising. It still doesn't scale for the 100s of millions of pageviews they get. And that's the biggest and best publisher there is, which goes back to what I last said: even if the high-end pubs do it, mid-tier and long-tail pubs definitely couldn't handle 1st party ad serving and thus would not be able to make any money.
- merb 11y agoactually the problem is sharing content that is behind a paywall. nothing against putting that behind a paywal and i definitly would subscribe wsj if i would like their stories / has interests in the content they are posting. (however I don't like such stuff) I've read some articles of wsj that where accessible through google (pretty controversial). also mostly I watch hn and click on a link to read the comments first and then I know that I mostly could ignore certain links.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe problem is the business model. All of these behaviors 1) are hostile to high-quality accessble content and 2) are fundamentally driven by advertising (or its failure). Information is a public good. This doesn't mean it costs nothing to produce (the contrary), but high-quality public information has a high positive externality to the common wealth (that is, the commonwealth), and is essential in a democratic society. Some see the solution as micropayments. I disagree strongly, see Nick Szabo, Clay Shirky, and Hal Varian as to why not. Superbundling might work, but the ultimate superbundle is a highly aggregated, means-based fee. Either a direct tax (income or wealth-indexed) or bundled into broadband services. The former strikes me as more equitable, the latter as more viable. The costs are low. A $100/year average fee per $30k in income, charged only among OECD nations, would cover all online advertising revenues. A $500/30k rate would cover the entire advertising industry. ($30k is chosen as roughly median OECD per capita income.) (Note: corrected from earlier figures which applied to worldwide population: $20/person and $100/person would cover everything, if paid by everyone, though I see an argument for progressivity applying the tax to developed nations.) The distortions, perverse incentives, inefficiencies, privacy invasions, security risks, and more, of the present model simply aren't worth it. HN's policy is that paywall-based stories are acceptable. I disagree strongly with this view. The WSJ is trying to play both sides of the subscriber-only / viral content game. And are providing increasingly slanted, unreliable, Murdoch-tainted content to boot. I view it as barely above spam. There are other sources, they should be allowed and encouraged. WSJ should be blacklisted. And yes, I absolutely would like to see an alternative publication financing model pursued. I'm not holding my breath. But supporters of the model I've proposed include Richard M. Stallman of FSF and Phil Hunt of Pirate Party, UK, among others. Previously, on global advertising spend, publishing models, and per-capita costs: https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/post https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/post /adKy4gM317c Several posts on content syndication, and inherent problems of information goods and markets: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=content+syndication&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=content+syndic... Hal Varian (UC Berkeley economist, Google's chief economist) on information goods and markets: http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/Papers/japan/index.html http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/Papers/japan/index.h...
- 11y ago
- theklub 11y agoWell HN isn't just one person so yeah you're going to get different responses.
- paulddraper 11y agoYes, you're right. And if a community of educated, well-informed, and frequently like-minded technology professionals can't come to a semblance of consensus about this matter, don't be surprised if the day comes when publishers -- with an audience far more diverse in opinion than HN -- just throw up their hands and do all three: ads, paywalls, and click bait. I don't mean to point fingers, as much point out an unfortunate reality.
- Quinner 11y agoI work for a publisher. I appreciate quality content. This is a rehashed press release, I shouldn't be expected to pay for it.
- manigandham 11y agoFacts are cheap/easy but its still content and you should be expected to pay for it (either via ads or subscriptions). Nothing is free.
- nitrogen 11y agoIn the case of a press release, it's paid for by the company releasing it to the press, so end recipients shouldn't also have to pay as if they were getting an originally produced story.
- Joof 11y agoIt's a problem with the model. It's far too much for subscribing to a single site; especially when it's linked to from social media (HN) where it's required to have access to participate in community discussion. HN will pay for content, but they won't pay under these terms.