6 ms·
Killed by collapsing oil prices, just like other big oil-dependent nations. (Russia, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, ... or in the US, look at Alaska, Louisiana, etc.)
by jacobolus 11y ago
Killed by collapsing oil prices, just like other big oil-dependent nations. (Russia, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, ... or in the US, look at Alaska, Louisiana, etc.)
Before Chavez, Venezuela was nominally a democracy, with two parties, AD and Copei, but in practice, for 2–3 generations, both parties colluded to keep state power in the hands of party officials, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punto_Fijo_Pact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punto_Fijo_Pact – several of the presidents immediately preceding Chavez were hugely corrupt (even doing prison time for it), and the Venezuelan people were entirely fed up with the longstanding political order, which was why Chavez as an outsider was so popular. The general economic problems throughout Latin America in the 1980s – cf. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_American_debt_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_American_debt_crisis – and the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_banking_crisis_of_1994 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_banking_crisis_of_1... didn’t help.
I find Chavez’s particular brand of populism deeply problematic, but he doesn’t exist in a vacuum, and Venezuela’s main challenge at the moment isn’t lack of “high school economics” understanding.
- unchocked 11y agoAgreed. I don't suspect democratic polities elect dictatorial strongmen unless the nation has largely ceased to function at a political level. Then you get a Chavez, a Khomeini, a Castro, a Hussein, an al-Maliki, and in some weird alternate future that's too close to our own... a Trump. * Edit, some of those guys appeared in countries with no history of democracy, but I think the point stands.
- tobltobs 11y agoNever attribute to collapsing oil prices that which is adequately explained by stupidity.
- tim333 11y agoVenezuela hit #1 on the global misery index in 2013. Oil didn't fall below $90 before Sept 2014. Thus the stupid done it. Especially the "Economic policy of the Nicolás Maduro government." It was never quite that bad under Chavez.
- catnaroek 11y agoI have no idea why this got downvoted. This is literally what happened there.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 11y agoOne should never attribute to anything else what can be blamed on any left-leaning government. At least not on Hacker News.
- catnaroek 11y agoDon't get me wrong, I'm no Chávez sympathizer by any stretch of the term. But people don't vote for populist outsiders just because they're stupid (although lack of education certainly plays a role here). They do so when they lose faith in established political parties.
- rbanffy 11y agoThe demise of Venezuela cannot be attributed to a single cause. Incompetent management of the economy, oil prices and relentless sabotage by internal economic interests (supported by external ones) all contributed to the current situation. And probably a hundred more causes could be found in less than an afternoon.
- narag 11y agoVenezuela is highly polarized so it's very difficult to get a fair and balanced outlook of what's happening there. But it's impossible to deny the evidence of stubbornly incompetent and corrupt management of public finances. Printing unlimited money, supporting cuban dictatorship with oil billions, digging deeper in social division and looting public treasure... you can believe in whatever society model you want, but persistence in error to the point of leading the country to misery is irresponsible.
- 11y ago
- BurningFrog 11y agoNone of the other oil states have collapsed nearly as hard, so so this is far from a normal reaction to lower export revenue. Venezuela was uniquely mismanaged even with high oil prices, but the billions raining from the sky covered up things enough to keep things on a regular third world level.
- zzleeper 11y agoI'm surprised that you are grayed out (downvoted), as you are the only comment that brings some information about why Chavez appeared. The current narrative is to blame Venezuela's fuck up on the left, but for me it was the fault of the entire political elite through the 20-30 years that preceded Chavez (and I'm anything but leftist btw)
- coliveira 11y agoIt is common practice to put all economic failures in the backs of leftist governments, but then there is the huge question: why third-world countries have such bad economies before taken over by leftist governments? The truth is that right-wing governments have no solution for poverty, otherwise people wouldn't be pissed off with their way of life. Leftist governments try to realign the economical interests of common people with those of the government. Now, stupidity, global pressures, and corruption can make this difficult to achieve as in the case of Venezuela. But that is hardly a problem that exists only on leftist governments.
- jessaustin 11y ago...the Venezuelan people were entirely fed up with the longstanding political order, which was why Chavez as an outsider was so popular. Hmmm, it seems we've seen at least the initial stages of this scenario play out in some other oil-rich nation of the Americas recently... It's on the tip of my tongue...
- api 11y agoTrump or Sanders? They're both essentially populists.
- scurvy 11y agoLouisiana's oil industry can't fall into the same bucket as the others. Tourism and seafood/agriculture have been larger than petroleum for the past 35+ years. Most of Louisiana's oil is offshore which means the state government gets bupkis.