3 ms·
Comcast, Charter and the satellite companies are already getting in knife fights over content. I think I'm more and more in favor of some hostile rules like req
by maxerickson 11y ago
Comcast, Charter and the satellite companies are already getting in knife fights over content. I think I'm more and more in favor of some hostile rules like requiring major content distributors like the cable companies to offer $0 licensing of their owned content to their competitors.
(such a rule would obviously need some mechanism to see through obfuscating ownership structures)
The premise is that rather than building up content in order to benefit their customers, they are building up content because they can leverage it to extract rent.
- dimino 11y agoYou would legally force a private company to share its property with others?
- yarou 11y agoComcast is publicly traded. And it behaves closer to a utility more than anything else.
- dimino 11y agoIn content production? No, it's not a utility. The ISP? Yeah, sure whatever. Not on the table right now, though. We're talking about NBCUniversal's content library. This is basically saying the US government should take over the movie making business. Why?
- maxerickson 11y agoThe point is to make it painful for the ISP (or meaningful parent) to own the content company, so it sure is on the table. Requiring divestiture is a frequent thing in mergers, it is not nationalization.
- yarou 11y agoWhen you are talking about "Comcast" as a business entity, those are one and the same. Comcast has a natural monopoly because of its utility status, and a result of those network effects, can enjoy a free distribution network. You don't think that should be regulated? Edit: autocorrect fail
- strange_quark 11y agoNot NBCUniversal. Why should it? Would you be ok with forcing Netflix or HBO to license their content for $0 as the parent suggested?
- adventured 11y agoThe parent comment likely meant private as in non-government (I doubt they were unaware Comcast is publicly traded). Being traded on a stock index has nothing to do with that, you're still wholly owned by private shareholders. Property rights don't vaporize just because you do an IPO. By current law Comcast is not in fact a utility - they offer a utility product that is regulated by the FCC, there's a critical difference between those two concepts.
- maxerickson 11y agoI'm proposing regulating the meaningful operator of the ISP business and saying that they are not allowed to set a price for customers of their content business. If they want to sell off the content business, I expect they would still get the market price for their property. The point is to enjoin the cable company from leveraging content to make competitive offerings less attractive.
- dimino 11y agoThis has nothing to do with the ISP arm of Comcast, and everything to do with you wanting content without paying for it.
- maxerickson 11y agoI really don't understand how you got that idea. I really don't. I just don't want a corporate entity that owns an ISP to be allowed to own content production companies. You're riding a ballistic missile (rather than making a leap) to get to me wanting to get content without paying for it.
- dimino 11y agoAnd I don't want the next two Avatar movies to get made, but I'm not the one advocating we get the US government to enforce such a thing. It makes zero sense for the US government to get involved in this deal.
- maxerickson 11y agoYep. They are a bit of a special case in that they often enjoy protection from competition in their cable business, so such a rule might make more sense attached to that (which would be nice for the satellite operators). I don't really buy the story that an ever bigger Comcast does the public in general any good at all (there would be plenty of investment in the cable space if there were 20 companies operating). The basic premise of a corporation is that it is beneficial to afford the shareholders some extra protection to encourage investment, so I'm fine drawing lines that I don't think will hurt investment but will probably benefit or protect the public.
- dimino 11y agoYou're talking about nationalizing NBCUniversal.
- maxerickson 11y agoHow do you figure? Under my proposed rule, the people who own it now are free to meaningfully split it off from Comcast and operate it as a content production company, probably with Comcast as a customer. No national ownership involved at all. I'm certainly talking about restricting what we allow privileged capital structures to do.
- dimino 11y agoNo, under your proposed rule NBCUniversal would be forced to share the content it spends millions of dollars creating for free with its competitors because of a government mandate. This isn't divesture, this is nationalization. You're forcing a company's investments into the public's hands.
- maxerickson 11y agoThey have the option of splitting the ownership! It would be incredibly foolish not to take that option. But that is sort of the point.
- nitrogen 11y agoCompulsory licensing already exists for music covers. Why not for mass market video?
- dimino 11y agoProfit motivation. Do you really think Comcast just can't help but make TV shows and movies, like musicians can't help but make music? You're basically ripping out the budget from the hands of producers and directors, for absolutely no reason. People are willing to pay, it's a completely optional resource that impacts in no way the quality of one's overall health, why the hell would we regulate something like this? Not seeing a movie/TV show is just not a big deal, certainly not a big enough deal to have the US government force content producers to share their IP...
- nitrogen 11y agoNo, I think all IP (at least above a certain scale) should come with compulsory licensing, with RAND or better terms. Then I could, in theory, pay directly for any TV show in an amount commensurate to the advertising revenue my viewing would generate, as could any streaming provider, cable/satellite network, etc.
- oldmanjay 11y agoNever underestimate the logical contortions people can make when they want free entertainment.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's not about free content, I know I put the $0 up there in the comment and it makes it hard to read the rest of it, but it's about ownership structures. I made a ~dozen comments explaining myself before you posted this snipe.
- rhino369 11y agoThe reason comcast is diversifying is because their monopoly (it really never was a monopoly) over tv distribution is essentially dead in the water. Not only does satellite exist, but now virtual cable companies already exist. Sling and PS vue offer full blown cable over the internet. Netflix, Amazon, Google, Apple, Hulu etc. offer most tv content streamed over the internet. Google and Apple have much bigger control over our media content consumption than Comcast does. Apple extorts 30% from all media sold to me on a phone I bought. It's bullshit. Google uses it's actual search monopoly to weasel it's way into other markets. >they are building up content because they can leverage it to extract rent. Isn't that why all content is made? I do think it would be useful to have a pay per stream statutory royalty rate like we do for radio music. Set it at say, 3 dollars per hour long episode, 2 dollars for a half hour. OR even just require all content have a reasonable MSRP rate so that any serious streaming company can sell it easily.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhy should I care if Comcast is able to diversify or not? I don't see where Comcast getting bigger is especially important to the economy in general, it seems like something that probably benefits shareholders more than the general public. I think encouraging business activity is great. We should be careful when we regulate it. The other side of that is that we shouldn't hesitate to regulate businesses when they try to do things that do net harm to the public.