13 ms·
I'm not sure whether, in all the brouhaha over this lawsuit, anyone has paid much attention to the fan film around which it revolves. "Star Trek: Axanar" is cur
by throwanem 11y ago
I'm not sure whether, in all the brouhaha over this lawsuit, anyone has paid much attention to the fan film around which it revolves. "Star Trek: Axanar" is currently in production for a mid-2016 release, and the short film/long trailer, "Prelude to Axanar", is a remarkable piece of work in its own right. Don't let the "fan film" label put you off, either; these are professionally produced works, with a compelling storyline and real actors (some of whom will be familiar to fans of the BSG reboot and/or Star Trek: Enterprise), and their take on the Star Trek universe should be a breath of fresh air for anyone frustrated with either Roddenberry's unrealistically optimistic perspective on humanity's future, or JJ Abrams' "lens flare all the things!" brodown.
If you're a Star Trek fan at all, you owe it to yourself to at least give Prelude to Axanar a watch: https://youtu.be/1W1_8IV8uhA https://youtu.be/1W1_8IV8uhA
(And as an old Babylon 5 fan, I'm delighted they included a sly reference to that show in Prelude, too. See if you can catch it!)
- saizai 11y agoYou forgot to link to it: https://youtu.be/1W1_8IV8uhA https://youtu.be/1W1_8IV8uhA
- throwanem 11y agoI did! Thanks for catching that.
- chris_wot 11y agoHoly crap! These fan films are getting better and better all the time! I can see why the studios are crapping themselves. No longer are they competing on mere copying, now they are competing on creativity! Seriously, if fans can do this with Star Trek, I wonder if they should take the central precepts of Star Trek, make their own entirely seperate universe and to hell with it - the studios who refuse to continue much loved series can be cut out entirely and fans can make their own series. In fact, they could make their own series but have a central authority to allow for basic continuity but maximise creativity. Now that would be remarkable. The fans could find their own games and spinoffs pretty nicely too.
- BugsBunnySan 11y agoWell, in a small way, someone did that: Star Wreck - In the Prikinning (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0472566/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0472566/) available for free here: https://archive.org/details/StarWreckInThePirkining https://archive.org/details/StarWreckInThePirkining (These are the guys who then went on to do Iron Sky :D )
- gulpahum 11y agoAnd they are also planning a new Star Wreck short film! http://www.starwreck.com http://www.starwreck.com
- saganus 11y agoWow. Is that really fan film? I mean... I was just mad that it ended after only 20 mins... I was so hooked I wanted it to keep going. How does a fan film get those actors? I mean, I can imagine that a lot of ST fans have money, but still. Thanks for linking. That was awesome.
- saizai 11y agoThey had a kickstarter for the preview film (to prove they could do it) and then another for the full. Also, "fan" might make you think they're amateurs. They're very much not; take a look at the cast and crew list.
- saganus 11y agoYeah, that why I Was surprised by the term "fan film". So what exactly does qualify as one? just as long as you don't have the copyright I guess? I mean, at which point is "fan fiction" illegal? is the legality status correlated with the production values and budget?
- CM30 11y agoThe general line between fan fiction (or any type of fan work) and a professional one is whether the production is trying to make money. That's why fan films and series are likely to be shut down if they try and market them via Kickstarter or Patreon or a similar service or distribute them on a service where money is involved (like Steam, or as a published work on Amazon). If they're trying to make money from this Star Trek film and don't have permission from the franchise owners, then it's not particularly surprising that they're being sued. It's a similar situation to a certain Zelda movie that got shut down when it tried to sell tickets to cinema screenings.
- throwanem 11y agoThere's a reasonable distinction to be drawn between trying to make money off the production, and using Kickstarter to crowdsource the capital necessary to make the production at all. As far as I can tell, Axanar has remained solidly in the latter camp. Is there anything to show otherwise?