5 ms·
Investors have shown that they are willing to buy non voting shares so he will likely get what he wants.
by maxerickson 11y ago
Investors have shown that they are willing to buy non voting shares so he will likely get what he wants.
- JimboOmega 11y agoI've always wondered what you're really getting with a non-voting share that has no dividends attached, especially from a company as big as Facebook that isn't going to get acquired. Related: has there been any academic investigation to how investors value votes?
- SapphireSun 11y agoThat's pretty strange. You'd only get liquidity unrelated to selling the shares from the company being bought or liquidated or in share buybacks. I guess it's more likely that a company of facebook's size can't really die, just sliced apart until nothing at the core remains. Some of those cuts will be profitable and some unprofitable...
- dpark 11y ago> Related: has there been any academic investigation to how investors value votes? Apparently they don't value them very highly. Goog and Googl are only about 2% apart.
- maxerickson 11y agoWith significant insider or founder control, the other voting shares don't really have much influence anyway. Or just in a so called blue chip. What meaning does 1000 voting shares of Ford really have?
- kang 11y ago> What meaning do 1000 votes have Then why don't we ask the same in a democracy?
- beeboop 11y agoDemocracy doesn't have proxy voting when it's the public voting for representatives.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoBut that's exactly what a representative is: A delegate you entrust to vote on your behalf.
- maxerickson 11y agoBecause there are people that directly control millions of votes in companies and no similar structures in a democracy. The number of shares is the wrong number to reason about, it's the percentage of control that is interesting. If an individual has 51% (or more) control, the comparison to a democracy is obviously nonsense. (I used 1000 shares because it feels like a big number of shares but is still an utterly insignificant portion of Ford, which has a bit less than 4 billion shares)
- kang 11y agoSo minorities should not vote?
- maxerickson 11y agoThey should do whatever they want to do. My point is that when a situation is futile, they should recognize that it is futile. A protest vote for a board member of a company strikes me as one of the more pointless ways to exercise a right to process.
- ndesaulniers 11y agoUnlike a democracy, in the stock market you can pay to have your vote count for more than others'.
- lisper 11y ago> what you're really getting A shot at some day finding a bigger fool than you to buy your shares for more than you paid.
- ywecur 11y agoAlso the profit the company chooses to distribute at the end of the year...
- aniro 11y ago>>a non-voting share that has no dividends attached
- forgetsusername 11y agoThis sounds cynical, but you're absolutely right: that value of a share in a company which will never return capital to its shareholders is precisely zero. People find that hard to believe, but it's true. Why would the last "greater fool" pay anything for it? Work backwards from there.
- onewaystreet 11y agoMost of the daily trading in stocks these days is not from people that are long term.
- jhh 11y agoIsn't the voting right attached to a stock irrelevant to almost all individual stock holders?
- nothrabannosir 11y agoIt (hopefully) makes them more valuable to potential buyers who do intend to own a significant portion.
- msellout 11y agoThe buyer of non-voting shares is betting that eventually the company will start a dividend or share-buyback program, or that there will be a subsequent buyer that will pay more than the current price.
- funkyy 11y agoAt least in theory...
- cbhl 11y agoA lot of engineers will probably get non-voting shares as RSUs, especially new engineers, acquihires, and refresher grants. They're hoping that they will get more shares than if the company had to continue issuing only voting shares, because it doesn't dilute the founders' control of the company as much.