4 ms·
> But the argument goes both ways here as well: take an arbitrary human (such as yourself, if you happen to be human) and try placing this human in the cockpit
by rtkwe 11y ago
> But the argument goes both ways here as well: take an arbitrary human (such as yourself, if you happen to be human) and try placing this human in the cockpit of a landing jet plane, in a semiconductor factory, in the oval office of the White House, in the kitchen of a gourmet restaurant, on a horseback in Siberia, or equipped with only a spear in the middle of the Amazonas jungle. There are humans that have been programmed to do well in each of these situations, but it is very unlikely that the human you were thinking of (perhaps yourself) would know what to do in more than at most one of these situations.
At least the random human will have a chance at doing something and if the situation isn't life or death like the landing plane or the Amazon jungle could with time actually learn to operate in the new environment even without interacting with other people who could teach them. That's what's missing from AI the flexibility to operate in a chaotic environment. Until relatively recently the slightest thing going wrong in even moving through an area or performing a simple task like moving a box would completely break.
> (It's hard to understand why anyone would want to be in a plane flown by a human, now that there are alternatives.)
Detecting and ignoring spurious inputs and extreme edge cases are one of the main reasons that I feel better if there's a person alert and at the controls of a plane. Extreme cases like Quantas 32 where a huge number of systems are absolutely destroyed would be a huge challenge for modern autopilots which are great but aren't tested or designed for emergencies. [1]
[1] http://lifehacker.com/the-power-of-mental-models-how-flight-32-avoided-disas-1765022753 http://lifehacker.com/the-power-of-mental-models-how-flight-...
- tlb 11y agoThat's partly because nobody has tried very hard to write one piece of software that's good at landing planes and being the president. Why not just write two pieces of software? What business model would a combined piece of software enable? Specialization of software is mostly a virtue.
- shawabawa3 11y ago> Specialization of software is mostly a virtue And generalization of humans is mostly a virtue
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoSpecialization of humans has its virtues as well. Interdependence and "networking" humans has huge multipliers.
- uremog 11y agoIsn't it somewhat the same with humans though?
- tlb 11y agoYes. Because a specialized pilot or president will always be better than a generalist at that particular task. Part of the argument given for the virtues of generalization is about availability. Like, if you find yourself the only available person in a plane over the Amazon, you can improvise a landing. But as the network connects more things in more places, this becomes less and less important.
- rtkwe 11y agoI'm not arguing that writing 2 different software isn't a solution or against software specialization. I'm saying (in part) that comparing a domain specific program(s) to a generalist human and calling the strictly domain specific 'intelligence' better misses some very critical points in capability. Even a combined program that's able to fly a plane and run a factory (changed from being president because doing that job well would probably require a full strong AI which could do any other task) is still just as constrained except now to just 2 fields instead of 1. To me it's not about the exact number of tasks that a particular bit of software can perform but that to call it's intelligence better than human it has to be able to increase it's own capability over time in novel tasks and environments. I'm also extremely resistant to equating simple calculating and data look up speed with intelligence as the author does with the multiplication and random SSN look up examples.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoBut what we might want is a "code base" that has some percentage of those two activities lying latent in them so we can exploit them in less time. Then again, maybe not - it may be that from-scratch works better. We can't really tell until we do it. And the hard part is the analysis of the business model, anyway.
- baddox 11y ago> Detecting and ignoring spurious inputs and extreme edge cases are one of the main reasons that I feel better if there's a person alert and at the controls of a plane But what is more likely: a human pilot detecting and resolving problems with the computer systems, or the human accidentally crashing the plane?
- rtkwe 11y agoI think a human has a better chance of determining which inputs are false and which are reliable. I'm also not talking about a random person there. A random person off the street would be more likely to crash but that's true even if the plan is doing just fine judging from what I've seen of youtubers in flight sims.
- baddox 11y agoBut aren't there just empirically way more plane crashed caused by pilot error than there are serious computer incidents resolved by pilots?