8 ms·
Why So Many Smart People Aren’t Happy
- ZenoArrow 11y agoIt doesn't surprise me in the least, because smart != wise. Academic achievement does not require wisdom on how best to live, and wisdom is not dependant on academic achievement.
- dominotw 11y agoYep life for smart people is problem oriented for which they have to find solutions. Thats how we are raised; in a problem/solution format.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThat's one possible interpretation, but just to be clear I didn't say they were mutually exclusive, I said they weren't dependant. It's possible to be both academically gifted and wise, but one does not depend on the other to exist.
- gumby 11y ago> If you were to go back to the three things that people need—mastery, belonging, and autonomy—I'd add a fourth, after basic necessities have been met. It’s the attitude or the worldview that you bring to life. And that worldview can be characterized, just for simplicity, in one of two fashions: One extreme is a kind of scarcity-minded approach, that my win is going to come at somebody else's loss, which makes you engage in social comparisons. And the other view is what I would call a more abundance-oriented approach, that there's room for everybody to grow. The best part of his analysis, IMHO. I don't even like being around zero-sum people.
- dismal2 11y agoIt's just so hard to believe the abundance view! I wish I could. Our economy simply does not reward people for being good or ok at things. You have to be amazing. So you are forced into competition simply to survive and pay for your existence.
- jeremysmyth 11y ago"Our economy simply does not reward people for being good or ok at things. You have to be amazing." This is only true locally. I can derive a huge amount of happiness by being the best singer at a party, or the best at telling jokes in the pub, or the best at $SKILL in my team. Even if you consider global geography (as with competing on the Internet as a startup, or looking for a job as a remote worker), you only have to be the best in that narrow area of what is available at that time (or the best at marketing it, or the best at selling it, or just the best at turning up and being presentable). There are many, many opportunities to be "amazing" locally. You just need to define what, and where. The article uses the word "mindset", because happiness about what you think more than anything else.
- alexashka 11y agoSorry, are we living on the same planet? If everyone around me had to be 'amazing', things sure would look different :)
- yolesaber 11y agoI've only been working in industry for a few years, but in my mind the majority of white collar jobs are no different than government welfare, in terms of value derived for society, except white collar people are paid better. The majority of white collar workers I've experienced are mediocre, lazy, and coast through the day on reddit and facebook and earn six figure paychecks. Yet we cheer on these people, congratulate them on getting jobs and hold them up as examples for peers. There's been many a time I've attended a party back home and people have berated their children for not getting a "good job" like me - meaning white collar and well paid. But hell I'll be the first one to admit I don't do shit at my job (and I work for a huge 'world-changing' company that you've definitely heard of) - I'll do what it takes not to get fired but do I feel like I make a difference or help the world through my career? Hell no. I'll close a few tickets and then collect my paycheck and then do something actually meaningful in my free time. Americans love corporations for some reason. If you make $100k/yr at a job and mostly surf the web, people consider that 'made'. If you are on welfare from the government, you're a no good bum. Why?
- nibs 11y agoI think the economy is very positive-sum. In a sense that there is so much more wealth now than ever before, and it is being reinvested and new wealth is being created. The most common instance of zero-sum competition these days is not the economy, but dating. No matter what, dating will be unfair, challenging, and zero-sum. Technology and modern culture can make dating more pleasant, but the dating market itself will always be zero-sum.
- siscia 11y agoMaybe a little off topic. I am a very romantic person and I don't see your point in the comment about dating. I am dating the only person I would like to date, not the smartest, not the hottest, not,the funniest but the only one that now I feel like dating. Right now, not other persons will get as much as she is getting from dating me (I can definitely being a better boyfriend, but I am the best I can be right now) nor I would get anything more from dating someone else but her... I don't see it as a sum zero game...
- alashley 11y agoMaybe we just eventually optimize for what will make us happy across all the various categories (looks, personality, lifestyle etc.) which is "good enough" for lack of a better term.
- siscia 11y agoMaybe, but I don't think so... Or, at least, it didn't happened to me. The first time of dating is like a bet, the partner is "good enough", you definitely look around and see more beautiful woman, smarter people or funnier mates, but for one reason or another you stick with her. After a while you know her better, she know you better and something more happens, you start to care for each other, you want to care for the other, you do things against your self interest for the other. Then you develop some sort of intimate caring and empathy, her becomes like a part of you, you see all of her flaws but they don't matter, you can understand her just by looking, you can feel when something is wrong, you don't image to share the same experience you had with her with some one else. (And this is the phase where I am now) However, I am still physically attracted by other women, I cannot image nothing but sex with some one different from my partner; not romantic walks, not dinner together, not talking about me and my hopes or fear; but sex, definitely yes. Sorry for the long off topic post :)
- neap24 11y agoI agree that people with the "scarcity-minded" approach aren't fun to be around. However, this is the unfortunate reality of some jobs. If you work somewhere where the revenue stream is relatively fixed (non-profits), then a huge raise for one person necessarily takes away from the pool to distribute raises to others. Even for profit enterprises are scarcity driven in any given year. Everyone is competing for the budget surplus to go to their own paycheck. I don't think this view necessitates engagement in social comparisons...it is merely a realistic perspective of business operations.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoJust to play devils advocate for the scarcity-minded, it is a hell of a lot more fun to spend a night out with someone who knows that time is scarce and strives to make the most of it than someone who is easily contented by the tidal wave of modern material abundance.
- gumby 11y agoI think they're orthogonal. You can have fun and be really driven and still not think you're succeeding at someone else's expense. While you can be contented or consoled by material abundance -- if you think it's zero sum and feel discouraged from succeeding, you may seek comfort in zoning out. I think a lot of resistance to basic income, and a lot of fear of job loss due to outsourcing and automation, comes from the scarcity mindset. And if that's your world view, Trump makes sense.
- ddt_Osprey 11y ago> I don't even like being around zero-sum people. So, you don't like being around people with limited resources?
- gumby 11y agoNot sure if that's a joke on what I said or if I was unclear so in case it was the latter: I mean people with the zero sum mentality. I grew up with pretty limited resources (some weeks not much to eat at the end of the week) with two war-survivor parents with a pretty careful/cautious view of budget and resources so I certainly am comfortable around people who don't have a lot or don't have a lot of status. I just don't enjoy people who think that winning is the point, and that in order to win another must lose.
- betenoire 11y agobuilding off that, I find myself drawn to sports/activities/challenges where I compete against myself, primarily. Rock climbing, music, programming, etc. It seems related to me, that I enjoy the things where the only person holding me back is myself. I've never been good at team sports, or even been able to enjoy them as much. I don't know if it's the zero-sum nature of the game (a winner and loser, and rankings), or if it's the teamwork I just avoid.
- gumby 11y agoThat's the essence of jihad, despite what those death cult nutjobs say. I'm not a muslim but I found that word really useful...until about 15 years ago :-(. Need a better word acceptable to anglos in the west.
- betenoire 11y agoInteresting, I didn't know that. As you suggest, the word has way too much connotation to be useful in that sense anymore.
- aaroninsf 11y ago
- mdorazio 11y agoIt's difficult to comment on this without sounding arrogant or entitled, but still I personally think this interview misses a couple of points I've seen in my own circle of friends. 1) Smart children are raised with expectations of doing great things because they are smart. If you have two children and one is obviously smarter than the other, the burden of your hopes and dreams will naturally fall on the smarter one, and equal accomplishments between the two will not have equal praise. Later in life this turns into being unhappy because you feel like you could do more because you are smart. It's a constant burden. 2) Being smart brings with it a certain level of ability to "peer behind the curtain" so to speak, and see just how dirty the real world is. It can make it seem like sinking time and effort to make meaningful changes is just futile because of how many things are messed up. And that kind of mindset saps happiness in a hurry.
- sgift 11y ago2) sounds a lot like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depressive_realism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depressive_realism which is still contested as a theory, but seems to fit experiences I've witnessed.
- alexashka 11y agoYour two points are really one point - the mistaken idea that one can 'change the world' in a significant way if only he/she works hard. That's a tough idea to shake when people connect their self esteem and meaning in life to it. The solution is to re-discover what you want your life to be about and then get to it. People usually either figure it out somewhat by the time they're 30 or they get burdened by self-imposed obligations to a point where they give up trying and just go with the flow. So really, a temporary hurdle in the scheme of things :)
- im_down_w_otp 11y agoHey! I resemble this remark.
- amelius 11y agoThese smart people should really be working on a plan to make the economy more fair.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoHas anyone considered the flipside to this? Maybe a lot of unhappy people just assume they're "smart" instead of depressed or other mental illness, or are just asocial personality types. I've met more than a few mediocre people who have this attitude and engage in talk about "sheeple" and such, but they're not remotely exceptional intellectually. In fact, most of them are fairly average or perhaps do slightly better than average in one small area in their life and play that up as justification for their greatness. I think its easy for the depressed or people who are just misanthropes to hide behind a "the world will never understand my genius" attitudes we see portrayed in the media. They see themselves as a John Nash or a misunderstood artist, when they're just, well, ordinary. This isn't a hypothetical in my world. When we do hiring its hard to filter out the asocial smart guy from the asocial bullshitter for technical jobs, especially for entry-level. Shockingly, I find the asocial bullshitter personality is mostly unaware at how terrible he is for the job he's applying for. Maybe its Dunning-Kruger or just old fashioned arrogance, but it can be hard to spot. We have a bad hire like this and its incredible how much damage he has done to the department and how he's unwilling to accept that he's, at best, below average. Instead he engages in this "tech master" personality with non-technical staff that is bizarre to witness, especially when you listen in and hear that 50% of what he's saying is just completely and obviously wrong.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> Maybe a lot of unhappy people just assume they're "smart" instead of depressed/mental illness, or are just asocial personality types. I've met more than a few mediocre people who have this attitude and engage in talk about "sheeple" and such, but they're not remotely exceptional intellectually So the people showcased on /r/iamverysmart?
- alexashka 11y agoI think you've described 'delusional' perfectly. It is indeed a massive epidemic, as far as I can tell. A lot of people are in on the game and perpetuating it however - so what can one expect?
- gnaritas 11y ago
- pessimizer 11y agoI think it's because generalized intelligence isn't a thing, and if you're an early reader, or an early computer user, so end up scoring far from the norm on early tests, the identity of being "smart" is assigned to you for life - and the only thing left for you to become is a disappointment. This leads to perfectionism, which is crippling. http://www.hillaryrettig.com/perfectionism/ http://www.hillaryrettig.com/perfectionism/ http://www.huffingtonpost.com/hillary-rettig/perfectionism-and-addicti_b_396056.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/hillary-rettig/perfectionism-a...
- jeremysmyth 11y agoThe word "smart" appears in the title of the book being publicised, and in the title of the article, but appears nowhere else in the article. The comments here, and the title of the article, are quite misleading about the content of the article. "Smart" has little or nothing to do with it. It so happens that whether you're smart or not is not a predictor of your happiness. The article might as well be called "Why so many people born on Tuesdays aren't happy."
- kobayashi 11y agoI'm amazed that your comment is so low here. Typically, title misdirection is something which HN users seem to viscerally dislike.
- wayneotau 11y agoIgnorance is bliss. 'Nuff said.
- burnt1ce 11y agoI think people who believe to be smart and depressed might be a slave to their own pride/ego. They may have high expectations that comes with a high cost to their well being.
- visarga 11y agoSmart people suffer from isolation, they can't easily find friends that can keep up with them. If you have an IQ of 135, there is maybe one person as smart as you in 100 people. If your IQ is 145, then it's 1 in 1000. They have little chance of socializing on their level, so most of the time they have to hold back. In extreme, that creates a state of feralization - they are like lone humans amidst animals, so they are almost alone.
- Retric 11y agoHaving really close friends within 20 IQ points of you is completely reasonable. Further, people more or less self stratify by IQ. So, 145 is not 1:1000 at even a run of the mill state school. IMO, the real issue is smart people fall into the same traps as everyone else. They just end up feeling worse about it. Yes, getting a PHD in molecular biology was probably a bad plan because getting a PHD is generally a bad idea. Which is sadly the same trap as becoming a Hair Stylist just aimed at smart people.
- TheCowboy 11y agoThere is no rule that you can only socialize with people "on your level". This can turn into a self-fulfilling prophesy where people impose this view that a lack of intelligent peers is problematic, and they feel and become isolated as a result. It can be a problem if the population adopts an anti-intellectual strain of thought, which I think persists in America to some degree. It is important to have people who are supportive of other people's intellectual interests. But even intelligent people can be dismissive of intellectual pursuits, especially if they're outside their own set of interests. It is possible to have a good social life with people who have had less education, or are not as intelligent. There are ways to lead a satisfying intellectual life without having access to the Stanford CS department happy hour, and this is more true now thanks to the Internet.
- mratzloff 11y agoIt's exhausting explaining things to others that seem obvious to you, or holding back for fear of completely alienating other people. Doing so is essential for relating to the rest of humanity, but at some level it's not being true to yourself, either. Romantic relationships can be especially difficult if you are looking for an intellectual equal. Intelligence isn't the only measure of a person, though. Wit, humor, and empathy are also very important. Humor and empathy, at least, aren't always paired with deep intelligence.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoBecause human intelligence is overrated https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11572527 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11572527
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThe only people I recognize, time and again, as having an "abundance mindset" are people who prioritize wealth and material objects first and foremost, because they recognize there's a whole lot of that stuff out there for the person willing to go out there and get it however they can. Otherwise, I kind of see the term as not very useful. Actually, it might be inherently wrong. A major part of the 'unhappiness' that I see a lot of "smart" people deal with is kind of the opposite of this "abundance" thing - in reality, there aren't enough of 'everything' to go around. Good jobs, reasonably priced things, work-life balance, adequate sick and vacation time, opportunities to advance in a company...it's not that smart people reject these things, it's that some of the conditions are pretty un-sympathetic to merit and integrity based approaches. For all the talk about the US having a very mobile system of social and economic status - which I think it does, global context in mind - it's still a bell curve of haves and have nots. Being smart enough to see that conditions are not very appealing doesn't jack up the seratonin feelings of "oh everything is just great" in my neighborhood. Relevant quote: Peter Gibbons: Our high school guidance counselor used to ask us what you'd do if you had a million dollars and you didn't have to work. And invariably what you'd say was supposed to be your career. So, if you wanted to fix old cars then you're supposed to be an auto mechanic. Samir: So what did you say? Peter Gibbons: I never had an answer. I guess that's why I'm working at Initech. Michael Bolton: No, you're working at Initech because that question is bullshit to begin with. If everyone listened to her, there'd be no janitors, because no one would clean shit up if they had a million dollars.
- sametmax 11y agoUnderstanding something doesn't mean you are able to: - solve anything; - improve anything; - even do anything at all. E.G: I know very smart people, perfectly understanding the theory of social interactions, knowing second to second the dynamic our group is engaged in, and yet, absolutly enable to flirt with the girl they fancy. And it makes them miserable.
- insmod88 11y agoThere is a great quote from Mad Men on happiness. "But what is happiness? It's a moment before you need more happiness." Happiness is like a high that we chase. When I was 25, I was unhappy. But, I was making 150k a year, was very healthy, had good relationships with parents, siblings and friends. I had everything that I needed. I had a good social life and a good job that challenged me intellectually. I was working hard towards my long term goals of climbing the corporate ladder. I had many hobbies that I devoted serious time to. Yet, there was a sense of unhappiness. An "is this all to life" feeling. I'm 27 now. I still feel like this on some days, but what has made is better is the notion that I can use my skills to help other people improve their lives. I've also learned not to pay too much attention to how you feel/what you're feeling. /rant
- popdoit 11y agoWait 'till you hit 30.
- typedef_struct 11y agoI'm 4 months out, don't leave me hanging!
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's a known state of mind. Heck, did you ever watch The Jungle Book (1967)? Now I'm the king of the swingers, whoa/The jungle VIP/I've reached the top and had to stop/And that's what botherin' me
- munificent 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill The best solution I've found for coping with it is to actively, constantly push down my expectations and deliberately foster a sense of gratefulness about all of the wonderful things in my life.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoSeconded. And I am so much happier for it.
- atom-morgan 11y agoPair this article with "Average Americans Think They’re Smarter Than the Average American". https://www.nationaljournal.com/congress/2014/05/12/average-americans-think-theyre-smarter-than-average-american https://www.nationaljournal.com/congress/2014/05/12/average-...
- TheRealDunkirk 11y ago"For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow." - Ecc 1:18
- kobayashi 11y agoGreat cursory assessment of capitalism and happiness: >On the face of it, it might look like I'm saying that capitalism in general is not very good at promoting an abundance mindset. But I don't think that that is entirely accurate. If you were to break capitalism down into two very important tenets, one is the freedom of movement of people, thought, and goods, and the freedom of choice. The second aspect is a distribution of resources according to people's abilities rather than according to people's needs. >That first tenet of capitalism, I think, is beautiful, and I wouldn't let go of it. And if that ideology comes with the baggage of distribution of resources according to abilities, then I take that package, rather than a package where you restrict people's freedom of thought and what kinds of choices they can make, even if it's combined with a distribution of resources according to people's needs.