2 ms·
"It seems to be really hard to get people to compare driverless cars with real humans, and not imaginary perfect drivers." I think this responsibility falls sq
by jimbokun 11y ago
"It seems to be really hard to get people to compare driverless cars with real humans, and not imaginary perfect drivers."
I think this responsibility falls squarely on the manufacturers of autonomous vehicles.
I think only the people creating the technology really understand the strengths and weaknesses of software drivers compared to human drivers, and are responsible for educating law makers and the general public if they want their products to be accommodated in our laws, road ways, and market places.
- mikeash 11y agoI think journalists are responsible for understanding the facts and implications of what they discuss, regardless of how good the various players are at explaining it. Yes, the manufacturers have a much stronger foundation from which to figure this stuff out, but that doesn't mean the rest of us can't stop doing silly things like acting as if human drivers were perfect when talking about potential autonomous vehicle systems.
- jimbokun 11y agoI think it's very difficult, though, to know what state of the art software driven vehicles are good at and not so good at, though. Maybe the missing-stop-sign-intersection was a problem in version 0.7.1 but fixed in patch 0.7.1.4. Any good articles by engineers describing where current autonomous cars are still worse than humans? And which issues are just "bug that hasn't been fixed yet" vs. "we're still not sure how to solve this one in principle". Agree, though, that a journalist should be interviewing real engineers and trying to summarize, paraphrase, and edit what he hears to the best of his or her ability, instead of just speculating.