6 ms·
It is strongly worth nothing that there has been a shift in comment sentiment/quality over the years. In early HN, comments were more hostile and would definite
by minimaxir 11y ago
It is strongly worth nothing that there has been a shift in comment sentiment/quality over the years. In early HN, comments were more hostile and would definitely be killed by the modern mod team. (it's where the HN stereotypes originated)
See my old list of the Top Comments for each month of HN since 2006 and note the difference between the old comments and recent comments: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZwonVX_KlDYhuhPnAAnVpdVRgu4LxldP74-c_kvOd5k/ https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZwonVX_KlDYhuhPnAAnV...
At the least, there is no situation nowadays on HN where commenting with http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/ would be considered appropriate.
- api 11y agoThis might be the only online forum I've ever seen get less hostile over time.
- oolongCat 11y agoFor some odd reason if anyone is missing the hostility, there's always IRC, one of the best places to learn but also one of the best places to get flamed.
- mrdrozdov 11y agoI'm not sure how to get started with IRC. Could you recommend any general channels?
- j_koreth 11y agoSort by the largest and start from the bottom
- throwanem 11y agoGeneral-purpose channels on IRC seem to fall into two categories: on the one hand, small and populated by mutual acquaintances who view un-vouched-for outsiders with suspicion; on the other, gigantic, purposeless, and either dead idle or too busy to keep up with. Starting from scratch, you're better off looking for channels relevant to your specific interests, and branching out from there.
- yompers888 11y agoIt seems to me that current HN is understood as a juxtaposition to Reddit, both in post quality and commenting civility. At least, that's what I try to support with my commenting and voting.
- igravious 11y agoThe way I see it. It's not that the HN crowd don't appreciate humour and memes, it's that they don't want HN to descend into a forum where every second comment is a reflexive wise-crack and/or meme-vehicle. So that type of behaviour is actively policed against and newcomers think HNers are a dour bunch of so-and-so's. Not so! If I want to chuckle for a while I'll head over to Reddit. If I want to see what can happen to a forum when the intelligentsia leave I'll head over to /. for a while. To remind myself of how bad things can get if we allow the lunatics take over the asylum I'll read the comments in YouTube while I watch a video. Though not a news site, comparable sites to HN in terms of comment quality are TheRegister and ArsTechnica though you'll rarely get the level of detail in comments that one does on HN - the reason being (to go back to the point I made at the start of this comment) is that one does not fear that one's voice will be drowned out by dross.
- antod 11y agoThe main improvement HN has over Ars for me is simply threaded replies. It's been relatively old fashioned for a long time now, but it makes a huge difference for having actual conversations. Although I must say, the technical content on Ars has slipped a bit in the last few years. The science content is still OK though. Hopefully that's not just a reflection of my relative ignorance.
- digi_owl 11y ago/. may be the closer comparison. And I think the death kneel to /. was their JS heavy D2 commenting system. As for Reddit, i think the issue there is "community of communities". With each of them having their own rules of what is acceptable or not.
- rm999 11y agoIn general the tech community has gotten a lot softer (online and IRL) over time as the field has become more professional and mainstream. In my experience the stereotypical tech jerk with open contempt for everyone - see for example Nick Burns 'your company's computer guy' from late 90s SNL - has been replaced by a friendlier, more diplomatic (but perhaps just as cocky) sort. My experience when I first joined HN (2009) was truly terrible, it left a sour taste in my mouth for a couple of years. If HN were still like that I definitely wouldn't be here. And if my coworkers all behaved like that, I'd probably be in a different field entirely.
- lackbeard 11y agoThis comment is super weird to me. I've been here since the beginning and I think comments have gotten more hostile since then. Also, I'm not aware of an at-large "HN stereotype". No one outside of HN that I interact with discusses HN, and if there's ever discussion of this stereotype here, I've missed it.
- Alex3917 11y agoIn the beginning comments were mostly civil because every commenter knew each other, and today there's no point being hostile because there are too many people to make any sort of permanent impact anyway. There were a couple years in the middle that were a little chaotic, some of which I definitely contributed to, but things seem to have mostly settled down.
- nostrademons 11y agoI've also been here since the beginning and thought that comments have been getting meaner...but when I actually look back at old threads, I'm reminded that that's not, in general, true, and we were just as bad back then. The obvious conclusion to me is that my standards have changed. I'm older, hopefully wiser, and less inclined to put up with bullshit. So Hacker News has improved over the years, but my expectations have gone up faster than the rate of improvement, and so it seems like the quality of discourse has gone down. Reminds me of a comment I left on Reddit in 2012, which was basically that while it wasn't as engaging for me, it's worth remembering that there are still millions of new people who are just finding the site for the first time. https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/rbqwc/by_request_i_discovered_reddit_the_day_it_opened/c44k24i https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/rbqwc/by_request_i_di...
- cbHXBY1D 11y agoI've been here and on Reddit (I remember that exact post of yours on Reddit) for years and I've had the same realization after going over old threads. I think that while the quality and meanness haven't changed much here on HN, there has been a marked shift away from "hard tech" content. For example, the article posted the other day about suicide in Greenland wouldn't have been posted here years ago. It was an interesting read and a thought provoking discussion but it doesn't fall in the realm of hacker news.
- WA 11y ago> It is strongly worth nothing that there has been a shift in comment sentiment/quality over the years. At least, the feeling that HN changes in one way or the other and some sentiment about these changes is almost as old as HN.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoHave HN comments gone downhill? Well dang, who can resist weighing in on that one? :) The problem is that a crowd of 100K is just a different animal than a crowd of 5 or 10k. I noticed sometime in the first few years that I couldn't say much of anything without somebody misunderstanding me -- or getting offended. So then I spent a lot of wasted time either 1) writing comments the size of the Titanic, or 2) responding 43 levels down to help define what the definition of "is" is. One of the things I used to like about the old HN was that it was startup focused, but open-minded. We'd post all kinds of stuff, but at the end of the day the conversation all came back to "And what could we do right now to help fix that?" Now the conversations just spin off along traditional lines, the same as you'd see anywhere else on the net. (Admittedly, the mods make it much nicer than most places) This relates directly to the "Friends" story now on the front page. I'd rather belong to a smaller, more focused group, one that shared my interests (but not my opinions, problem-solving methods, or worldviews) I find this is both better for me and for the discussion as a whole.