6 ms·
Why so many celebrities have died in 2016
- yeldarb 11y agoI can believe that the long-term trend is upwards but the demographic reasoning seems like it should apply on the scale of decades not years. It doesn't explain why 2016 would be worse than 2015 or 2014. This year is likely just an outlier.
- endymi0n 11y agoMUCH more likely than the original shallow fluff piece: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clustering_illusion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clustering_illusion
- onion2k 11y agoIs that actually more likely? Sometimes statistical "streaks" are real. Given that "celebrity culture" really kicked off in the modern way we have it now in the 1960s, so the number of celebrities from that era is far higher than previous eras, and that those celebrities are now of the age when people typically die, I don't think there's anything illusory happening. It's likely to be a very real, and very easy to explain, phenomenon.
- coldtea 11y agoThe link you sent is about an effect that occurs with random sequences. Neither the baby boom, nor the huge growth of the media industry (radio, TV, recorded media, etc) after the fifties are "random". And then there's the fact that the earlier real stars we have now (as opposed to merely people famous in the past but already forgotten) are in their 70s and 80s (e.g. the 60s and 70s musicians and actors etc, all still quite relevant for modern audiences thanks to vinyl, VHS, tape, TV, CD, DVD and cable distribution, and --something previous generations lacked until recently-- instant access to all their works and news from the streaming, YouTube and the web). This is no clustering illusion, it's the inevitable combination of life expectancy + tons of people becoming stars en masse with unprecedented global distribution at more or less the same time that sees them now in an advanced age.
- shalmanese 11y agoThe magnitude of increase can't be explained by demographic factors. It's far more likely that this is mostly due to a statistical blip with only a minor contribution from everything else.
- coldtea 11y agoThe magnitude of the peak for 2016 isn't what's important. The steady yearly increase is what's important.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoPrince doesn't really fit into that model, being 57, although maybe there's some modification for being a male of african-american descent? Congenital cardiovascular issues, and whatnot.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoAre celebrities more prone to substance abuse problems?
- Aelinsaar 11y agoI don't have any idea, and any guess I'd make would be... lacking. I will say one thing however, which is that they would certainly have unlimited access to substances to abuse. I'm not sure what the life expectancy of an opiate addict who could afford a lifetime's supply really is. It may be that we're starting to find out, but then, maybe not.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoI'm thinking more in terms of a lifetime of treating your body like shit, to include all substances (not just opiates).
- Aelinsaar 11y agoI bet the genetic component starts to dominate over long time periods, mediated by access to top quality medical care. That in turn is probably further mediated by the fact that (see Michael Jackson) buying a doctor is not always in your best interest.
- jtolmar 11y agoNot all individual celebrity deaths have to fit the model for the phenomenon to show up, though. The proposed model just has to be one of the largest (or spikiest) components. As long as people who die for other reasons are fairly constant, they don't prevent the spike from showing up.
- MicroBerto 11y agoThe biggest and scariest issue is that all of these celebrities are going completely unreplaced. I am a fan of rock and heavy metal, and it is clear that rock stardom is literally dying off. The days of filling American arenas with rock concerts are quickly coming to an end, and that deeply saddens me. Where are the twenty-something kids with attitude who will replace a band like AC/DC? Is Justin Beiber the best we could do? It's pathetic. Even a guy like Bon Jovi... Who is next in that line?? Seems like nobody. It's depressing. This is why I'm going to as many shows for bands like Iron Maiden as possible right now. When it's over, rock and roll may truly be dead. This is one of those moments where I realize I'm getting old. I never understood life extention and the quest for immortality. As things change, eventually they leave you behind. Find me a 90+ year old who really cares to stay. And that's how I'm going to feel when rock and roll dies.
- dominotw 11y ago>Where are the twenty-something kids with attitude Attitude is not relavent anymore. We are all introverts now, people have wide varieties of musical tastes and preferences .there is huge amount of experimentation going on in music due to the fact that process of creating music has become much more accessible. There are tons of awesome music being produced everywhere you just have to dig deeper.
- JoBrad 11y agoExactly. I personally know 3 different people who have multiple side projects where they record, mix, and produce amazing music, from their homes. It's much harder to stand out when so many people have great music.
- derefr 11y agoI almost feel like a genre has to "die" at some point in order to live (i.e. gain relevance) again. Something that stays in the public consciousness past its prime gains association with being "something your parents like" and eventually "something your grandparents like", and these are bad associations if you want something to get wildly popular. A lot of brands that have carpet-bomb "get everyone hooked at once" marketing campaigns, like Old Spice, end up with this effect where nobody wants to use the product since it's what their dad uses, and they don't want to smell like their dad. So Old Spice has set upon the strategy of letting its marketing go quiet for a few years, and then, pretty much once per generation, running a new fleet of ads claiming that Old Spice is "not your dad's deodorant", but is in fact best associated with buff 20-something men. The same happens in clothing (look at e.g. 80s clothing coming back into fashion just as everyone's mom had finally stopped wearing it.) Now, I've never seen anyone cite explicit evidence of it occurring in music as well, but it would fit the general mechanism. It might be why e.g. disco has mostly stayed dead (it's survived in the public consciousness with the image of the aging, pervy "uncle", a white guy with an afro wearing white suede and rollerblades, trying to retain his relevance); while genres like jazz are perennial (getting once again associated with being "young and cosmopolitan" at each turn of the clock.) If rock can truly die—if we can let go of "classic rock" music stations and dads sporting worn-to-dishrags "rock concert" tees—and allow the ground of the genre's image to lay fallow for a bit, we might be able to sew something new there.
- jcoffland 11y agoLots of "unimportant" people die every day.
- copperx 11y agoAbout 100,000 of them, to be more precise. Your comment made me want to revisit Feynman's Letter: http://www.lettersofnote.com/2015/10/do-not-remain-nameless-to-yourself.html http://www.lettersofnote.com/2015/10/do-not-remain-nameless-...
- sandebert 11y agoSurprisingly often I find myself thinking about poker in everyday life (even while not playing poker, that is). And surprisingly often I find something I learned in poker is also applicable in life outside the game. In this case, the concept of variance comes to mind. Basically that values (for instance number of deaths of celebrities) are spread out. Sometimes there are more, and sometimes there are less. And that's just how it is, it doesn't automatically mean there's a trend change either way. Lots of pages out there to read about it, here's one that might give more insight than my comment: http://www.thepokerbank.com/strategy/other/variance/ http://www.thepokerbank.com/strategy/other/variance/
- derefr 11y agoOr, from another field: it might look like some stock investors are "hot" or "cold", but that doesn't mean that investing with a currently-"hot" investor will give you any better odds. The variance in the market is high; sometimes people get a streak of wins without that being any more than luck. (Some people, like Warren Buffet, do more; but if you know enough about their strategies to differentiate between the people getting lucky and the people "playing smart", you know enough to do your investing yourself.)
- Lost_BiomedE 11y agoDay trading is similar. I have even read poker books to help with my day trading. There are tons of knowledge-of-self and life lessons within both. In this case, I think we have both variance and a cycle. Given the age range of many bigger than life stars, the current cycle is just gearing up. Within that cycle we will have clustering and variance.
- sod 11y agoMaybe there are just more and more people with each generation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population
- swagv 11y agoThis is like the guy who doubts global warming because it's 30C outside.
- stretchwithme 11y agoThe year I was born, nobody that I knew died. Slowly, but surely that number started to rise, as I got to know about more people. And now with the Internet making us aware of so much of what's going on and who's doing it, that trend is amplified. And the more one focuses on that trend, or how long ago something happened, the older one feels. Which is another reason that living in the moment is often a very good thing.