3 ms·
The human brain is better than the elephant brain. The fact that the elephant faces extinction at the hands of human brains and is only being saved from extinct
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 11y ago
The human brain is better than the elephant brain. The fact that the elephant faces extinction at the hands of human brains and is only being saved from extinction by the work of other human brains is evidence at least at some level.
- amelius 11y agoPerhaps humans also face extinction at the hands of human brains ...
- premasagar 11y agoThe elephant brain is better than the human brain. The fact that the elephant faces extinction at the hands of human brains and is only being saved from extinction by the work of other human brains is evidence at least at some level.
- andrewflnr 11y agoYou could as easily say that snails' brains are better than human brains because some humans try to save snails. It doesn't mean anything about the snails or elephants, it just means the human brains don't all agree on this one topic.
- gumby 11y agoI guess might makes right, eh? "Nature red in tooth and claw." Hmm.
- InquilineKea 11y agoI don't think that's intrinsically a good argument [heuristic]; the Neanderthals were also intelligent and faced extinction at the hands of human brains..
- gumby 11y agoBTW neanderthals were humans, just not homo sapiens sapiens like us. But nit-pick aside your point is good.
- raddad 11y agoBrain: We must prepare for tomorrow night. Pinky: Why? What are we going to do tomorrow night? Brain: The same thing we do every night, Pinky - try to take over the world!
- astrobe_ 11y agoJoke aside, the real question is: why didn't those animals evolve to human-like intelligence? Why are we the only remaining species of the Homo genus?
- gumby 11y agoYour first question presupposes that human-like intelligence is the "goal". If it's valuable, some other species could get there; unlikely to be another mammal, but after we kill ourselves off perhaps it will be some dependent of the cockroach or a fish. Clearly a mutual ancestor of chimps, gorillas and humans did develop human-like intelligence. I'm not sure it's meaningful to ask why, say, chimps didn't develop in that way since they ended up being a subgroup subject to different evolutionary pressure. Evolution isn't magic, it's just in an inherent process of an adaptive system. Like I wrote above, I think of it as a huge, loosely coupled hill-climbing computation, but the different nodes run at different rates and interact. You could also think of it as a neural net without a directed training system. I think your second question is very interesting and I have wondered about it too. Ignoring the case of the neanderthalers for a moment, it's likely there were lots of variants who just suffered some environmental issue (e.g. a drought where they lived, or an invasion from some carnivore) that impacted a population too small to survive the threat. (and for purpose of discussion we presume this group were legitimately speciated from us). This happens to animals all the time. So we look back with survivorship bias. The neanderthalers are more complex since they did survive until very recently and may not have been a completely different species. My guess is the threat they faced was homo sapiens sapiens. Is that an inherent property of humans? Seems like it :-(. BTW by "human-like intelligence" I assume you mean "able to make complex tools that multiply its own functions in a non-linear fashion, support a complex society, and develop the capability to live apart from the earth". Since a cockroach civilization would have different objectives and metrics from ours their behavior wouldn't look anything like ours either.
- DenisM 11y agoHumans faced extinction at the hands (?) of Black Plague.