7 ms·
How the rise of finance has warped our values
- macawfish 11y agoMoney itself warps our sense of value.
- dbcurtis 11y agoSummary: Some people have different values from me and I don't like it. They should be forced to change their values so that I am not challenged.
- nipponese 11y agoAdditionally, if we hand over all our earnings to the government, they'll always spread wealth equally and eliminate scarcity from the planet.
- astazangasta 11y agoI think this reverses causality; our values were carefully eroded by right wing think tanks and so on pushing free market ideology. Deregulation resulted, along with financialization.
- vixen99 11y agoGeneralized claptrap. You merely use cliches like 'free market ideology' which unless you give a specific example could mean just about anything. By the way, which right wing think tanks advised governments to take on borrowing to the insane levels that some have? The house will come tumbling down one day. As for 'financialization'. What does that mean? It certainly sounds terrible and we should stop it immediately.
- mcnamaratw 11y agoIn the US, the high borrowing levels are pretty much straight Reaganomics. Arthur Laffer was an early proponent. GHWB lost an election by trying to apply the brakes, and here we are.
- astazangasta 11y agoFinancialization means the fraction of GDP in the finance sector. You can graph it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financialization https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financialization Free market ideology means stuff peddled by CEI, Heritage, Grover Norquist - tax the rich less, deregulate, fight unions. This doesn't seem especially nonspecific to me. Also, spending as fraction of GDP hasn't changed that much over time. What has changed is interest rates, which leads to debt accumulation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mdorazio 11y agoI agree with the premise of the article, but what is a practical solution? The financial industry arises naturally from the time-value of money combined with human greed. Every time something like Dodd-Frank comes along to try and put a damper on things, people find a way around it or else redirect profiteering in another direction (like the stock buybacks we've been seeing).
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago> The financial industry arises naturally from the time-value of money combined with human greed. Well, no. There are very definite regulatory changes that allowed bigger banks to eat smaller banks, for instance. I still remember how my parents opened my first savings bank at a bank that was regional to Northern New Jersey, which was then later eaten by something I don't remember, than by Bank of America. Likewise, the whole "mortgage tranche" fiasco happened because we allowed loan originators to sell off the ownership of loans to other parties, rather than having to eat the lunch they'd made for themselves with their own levels of risk-taking.
- Avshalom 11y ago"rather than having to eat the lunch they'd made for themselves with their own levels of risk-taking" This is sort of the big problem. All the money being made is justified by citing the risk banks/traders/funds take and yet we are constantly told that X is a good thing because it increases liquidity/decreases risk.
- autokad 11y agoselling loans wasn't ever a problem, and I'm not aware of any time in recent history it wasn't allowed. the problem was that companies were allowed to buy insurance against bad loans they didnt even make, and insurers were allowed to sell more of that insurance than they had capital to back them up. so when a person defaulted on their home, the homeowner lost, the bank lost, the insurer lost, and the company who bought the near garentee win insurance also lost. capital flows froze, then companies who needed liquidity lost, and losses just kept chaining.
- 11y ago
- mcnamaratw 11y agoBuyback mania isn't necessarily good for shareholders. Paying too much for share buybacks is as bad as paying too much for anything else.* And, empirically, buyback mania tends to be strongest when share prices are high. By contrast in early 2009, when the US stock market was a great deal, buybacks were rare. To be fair, though, overpriced buybacks do benefit investors who have warrants or options. ----------------------------- *Unless you happen to get lucky and time the market. Very few people can do that repeatably.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>And, empirically, buyback mania tends to be strongest when share prices are high Stock prices are high because profits are high and hence companies have lots of cash with few places to invest. https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CP https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CP
- mcnamaratw 11y ago"Stock prices are high because profits are high" -- Stock prices are high compared to profits, is the point. Look at the P/E ratio of the S&P 500 over time & compare to today's 24:1. http://www.multpl.com/ http://www.multpl.com/ In which years was the trailing P/E of the S&P 500 higher than 24?
- forgetsusername 11y agoQuite a few. Going back to 1990 it looks average-to-slightly-high. Not sure what your point is; if you try to use P/E as a predictive metric, you're going to have a bad time. Maybe there are people out there who have a higher rate of expected earnings growth than you do, and are will to pay more for it in a period of unprecedented low interest rates?
- mcnamaratw 11y agoI was hoping the high-trailing-PE years when things looked fine (1991, 2001, 2008) might ring a bell for some readers. Those weren't favorable economic times. People who invest in stocks should probably have some inkling of what my point is after looking at that chart and thinking about what those years were like. Of course this may be a new era, and stock prices may have reached a permanently high plateau.
- fanzhang 11y agoImprecise thinking abound. The author starts with talking about the problem of big banks (fair enough) and then descends into longing for a command economy [1]. The author laments borrowing money to pay dividends, but the two are net-zero activities (investors are just shuffling their investment from stocks to bonds). The author finally argues that real investment has fallen since the mid-century. This is not true in a real dollar sense [2]. As a share of GDP though, investment has fallen from the 1950s because we are no longer rushing to build up capital destroyed in WWII. As noted by Paul Graham [3] and more technically by economist Robert Solow [4], it was the decades surrounding WWII that was the exception and not the rule. Finally, the finance sector has already been retreating as of circa 2005 [5]. The predicate of the article may then no longer be true. If it is, would the author agree we're seeing less issues and more social justice now than in 2005? There are many precise, carefully thought-out treatments of inequality or the problems of financialization out there. I count Philippon's and Piketty's research among them. But this article seems to move in fuzzy concept space between "finance has gone up" and "we don't have a caring command economy". I wish the author spelled out his thinking more clearly. It sounds like it would be an interesting argument if made well. [1] "The state becomes submerged and hidden from our everyday lives, working through elaborate and blunted market mechanisms rather than helping citizens directly." [2] https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GPDIC96 https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GPDIC96 [3] http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html [4] https://newrepublic.com/article/117429/capital-twenty-first-century-thomas-piketty-reviewed https://newrepublic.com/article/117429/capital-twenty-first-... [5] Figure 5 of http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~tphilipp/papers/Finance_Efficiency.pdf http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~tphilipp/papers/Finance_Efficien... Incidentially, Philippon's graph is used by the Wikipedia article on "financialization" but cut off at the 2005 peak to make it look like an unrestrained explosion upwards.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- qj4714 11y agoThe article is arguing for more government intervention in the economy which I would argue is exactly what has led to this form of crony capitalism. What is the answer to 'to big to fail'? Failure. But the problem is that the government made a decision decades ago to bail out Chrysler, and the Fed cut rates in 98 and after to bail out the markets. The we had QE1, QE2, ZIRP, etc...All of these GOVERNMENT policies have created a massive excessive of capital in the system and creates all kinds of temptations to do share buybacks and boost dividends. Verizon workers are covered by unions, which are supposed to ensure their workers get a fair wage. This article is paint by numbers economics designed to whitewash all the problems caused by the gov't and demonize corporations for taking advantage of a situation the gov't created.
- tobylane 11y agoHow does the repeal of Glass-Steagall fit into that?
- qj4714 11y agoI would argue that the repeal of Glass-Steagall in itself was a government intervention, because it happened after Citi merged with Travellers, and it was based on lobbying from Citi. But there were other pieces of legislation, namely the Commodities Futures Modernization Act, that had a more damaging effect. The more general problem is that the market prices risk based on the underlying assumption that if anything bad happens the government(s) will step in and bail out the bad actors. The mentality leads directly to risky behavior and, in fact, induces risky behavior. If you take away that inducement, these actors will behave differently.
- unclebucknasty 11y agoYou're confusing naked government intervention with corporate influence and regulatory capture.
- unclebucknasty 11y agoYour comment started appropriately in that it acknowledges crony capitalism. Then it strangely diverts to decrying the government as if it alone created problems that corporations simply (and innocently) exploit. You had it right at the beginning. It's the fusion of government with corporations that's the problem. Corporations manipulate and influence government for their benefit, not the other way around.
- tonybaroneee 11y agoWhich country has an economy that most closely resembles the ideals of this article would you say? I would want to move there.
- ilaksh 11y agoThe answer is not a command economy or giving more control to a state that has a monopoly on force. The big issue is centralization. Technologies that facilitate decentralization can help combat the negative effects of centralization. Better technology integration into society in general is also necessary. Look at things like Bitcoin or Ethereum, decentralized autonomous organizations, etc. We have and can continue to develop better ways to cooperatively regulate our society while avoiding concentration of power and allowing systems to evolve freely. Money is very powerful but it's a type of technology that needs to be updated.