7 ms·
Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment
- deepnet 11y ago"If one would give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest man, I would find something in them to have him hanged", Cardinal Richleu. 'Nothing to hide' privacy naysayers imagine innocence a perfect defense. In practice a prosecution presents select facts in the order best suited to convict. Under mass surveillance they have all the facts; the defense only has what one still possesses/ remembers. With such resources, enough well cast aspersions could convict anyone of something. Counter intuitively innocence can be harder to defend as the guilty will have prepared alabis. (part2 @) Lawyers advise their clients not to talk freely to police for very good reason.@ @ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- joering2 11y agoSpot on! But don't forget SCOTUS Scalia saying that basically if you are later on found not guilty, but the trail on its own was done properly with no misconduct, you will still get the death penalty! http://www.businessinsider.com/antonin-scalia-says-executing-the-innocent-is-constitutional-2014-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/antonin-scalia-says-executing... What a country! :)
- tmuir 11y agoI wonder if this means that the NSA's definition of "collect" has conveniently reverted back to the widely accepted meaning. Their previous defense was that "collect" meant to actually inspect the information.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rboyd 11y agoWhat's best as a society is to fight. What's best as an individual is to conform.
- niels_olson 11y agoAnd then they came for me.
- partycoder 11y agoWestern press always mocks eastern countries because of their policies around surveillance and censorship to restrict free speech. They rarely report on what is going on around here.
- capote 11y agoThey are two different worlds. There's no comparison. In the west, with cases like these, and people like Snowden, we're trying to defend our free speech and privacy by our standards. We're doing alright, but there are some big problems to solve. And yes, the media needs to cover this more. But comparing this to censorship and related problems in China and Russia (single-party states with control of speech at the policy level) is just silly, for lack of a better word.
- ThomPete 11y agoI think the point was more that maybe we should spend less time on others and more time on ourselves.
- bkor 11y agoYou didn't really address his argument other than to say it is silly? In China it is very clear what is happening. In e.g. US it is all considered a secret. Everyone in China is aware of the "Great Big Firewall" and all the various laws restricting what you can and can not say. Someone linked once to an article explaining that knowing of the existence of a monitoring system results in people changing their behaviors. This even though some of them support the system. Seems easily comparable to me.
- tumblen 11y agoBut which direction are we moving in?
- tobbyb 11y agoThis is like 2 prisoners arguing about their level of freedom.
- rco8786 11y agoWe all knew it was coming, but dang that was fast.
- Karunamon 11y agoCould someone clarify something for me? As I understand it, PRISM is not a thing that lets the NSA willy nilly search the internal networks of companies they've onboard, It is instead a thing for companies who would be the target of large volumes of these requests just because of their size to upload the data they're legally required to because of NSL or similar, in a rapid fashion. Is this assessment correct?
- readams 11y agoPRISM is just one small program. There are many other ways the NSA collects your data.
- gshulegaard 11y agoAs I understand it (so take it with a grain of salt) PRISM mandates that targeted companies collect and turn over data that matches a set of ("court-approved") guidelines without prompting[1]. This as opposed to the government finding probable cause, getting a warrant, and asking the company for the data (if they have it). Instead, the onus is placed on the company to comply with the guidelines set forth without first being asked. It is unclear to me whether or not companies had to start collecting/reporting data they were otherwise discarding before, but this quote sounds like they are/were: > "The NSA can use these PRISM requests to target communications that were encrypted when they traveled across the internet backbone, to focus on stored data that telecommunication filtering systems discarded earlier,[8][9] and to get data that is easier to handle, among other things.[10]" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)
- tacos 11y agoIs anyone aware of a source for this type of news that isn't quite so one-sided? It seems all we have is hyper-lefty "sky is falling" stuff and hard-charging right-wing "shut up kids, the government knows what's best for you." I want reporting, not advocacy. The better of the mainstream press outlets are balanced to a fault but get the interesting details wrong or leave them out altogether. The fringe outlets target their core audience with lots of spun details and a lack of opposing viewpoint. EDIT: If anyone can get past "lefty vs righty" and answer my core question I'd really appreciate it. This is a genuine query for information, not a clever way to troll.
- gshulegaard 11y agoI...hmmm...I don't know if my personal bias is influencing my perspective, but I usually find the EFF as a reasonable reporting source. They tend to fall on the left, but I struggle to see them as "hyper-lefty". The key for me about the EFF is they are usually good at providing sources. I am going to take the time to read the linked Memorandum and Order document and form my own opinion: > https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/20151106-702Mem_Opinion_Order_for_Public_Release.pdf https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/20151106-702Mem_Opinion_... Although, I do tend to agree with the EFF on a fair amount of issues (not always though).
- tacos 11y agoMy personal bias is way in favor of the EFF but the tone still irks me. And don't be fooled by footnotes! Unlike EFF, Wikipedia consciously strives for balance and they often come up way short, too. Any decent advocacy organization knows how to play the "references" game.
- studentrob 11y agoI agree with you, often the tone of EFF feels off. It can vary a lot by article. I think this is evidence of a nascent tech community. We are fractured in our approach to some things (e.g. RMS vs others) and this shows in the varied responses by EFF. I definitely don't agree with everything they have to say about tech and policy but I am glad they exist. They keep pretty good tabs on government and private company policy. Sometimes it feels weird when they criticize some private company for a policy which I feel is not a big deal, but I just register my disagreement and note they're not me ;-)
- revelation 11y agoSo the FBI is now the equivalent of Gestapo, secret Police.
- CamperBob2 11y agoNo, not yet, but they certainly can be. Handing this technology to the next J. Edgar Hoover -- and rest assured, there will be a next J. Edgar Hoover, even if Comey isn't him -- will be like giving an atomic bomb to that kid in high school that everybody was pretty sure would end up in jail. If the judges and politicians had half a brain, they'd understand that they, and not us, will be the first to experience the downsides of a security state gone berserk.
- DenisM 11y agoA lost opportunity. Had they asked for the court orders from the FBI, that could set the framework for the future - information is collected, but cannot be searched without a court order. That could have been a decent compromise. This is not going to be a popular opinion, but I think a compromise is necessary. There is no way to stand up to the train of data collection. For one, the public being afraid of this and that will demand to be protected at all costs, no matter how small the threat. The more scandalous the news cycle gets, the more panic we will see. And then the technology improves so fast, soon enough publicly installed video cameras will track everyone, and all within the constitutional framework. A middle ground would be to create the fourth branch of the government that is tasked with data collection, but will only give it up on court order. Orders may be for individual incidents based on reasonable cause, or for data-mining, based on a judgement of proper scope.
- guelo 11y agoNot so fast. The public was split on the Apple vs FBI case. As electronics penetrate deeper into our lives and identity thefts, spam, virus, social network attacks, credit card leaks, password leaks, etc become more common and more consequential, and the spread of the hopeless feeling about the lack of control of our data, we as a society are becoming more acquainted with security issues and more aware of why they are so important. I predict that governments will eventually be forced to come down on our side in the fight for maintaining our data private and secure.
- lettergram 11y ago> There is no way to stand up to the train of data collection. For one, the public being afraid of this and that will demand to be protected at all costs, no matter how small the threat. I disagree. I think government data collection on citizens should not be allowed, period. I know many people external to tech who agree with me. The issue occurs when government officials talk about terror attacks. If they were honest, and told anyone it never prevented a terror attack, more would be inclined to not be tracked. Coupled with this, is the fact I don't trust the government databases not to get hacked, and neither does anyone else.
- 11y ago
- DannyBee 11y agoErrr, reading the actual decision, i don't see a lot of support for the EFF's claims. It seems pretty cherry picked. In fact it clearly states they can only retain stuff long term if the DOJ notifies them explicitly that they have a continuing litigation/preservation hold necessity (which is usually not the DOJ doing it,but say, a civil lawsuit that carries with it preservation obligations). It also makes further clear that in all cases, the only people with access to most of any retained data is system administrators, not investigators, and that it can't be used for investigative purposes. It does say general querying is allowed, but only people explicit 702 access rights are the ones who must be making such queries, or making such decisions. In all cases all records of who accessesd what with what query terms and their access level are explicitly logged, etc. It also explicitly states that information acquired under section 702 will not be introduced as evidence against a person in a criminal proceeding, without 1. Explicit approval of the attorney general 2. in criminal cases related to national security crimes In any case, this is not new, this viewpoint is something going back to FISC precedent from 2002. So it's not like this just happened. Additionally, the statute is pretty clear here. It says: " (h) “Minimization procedures”, with respect to electronic surveillance, means— ... (3) notwithstanding paragraphs (1) and (2), procedures that allow for the retention and dissemination of information that is evidence of a crime which has been, is being, or is about to be committed and that is to be retained or disseminated for law enforcement purposes; and" So again, nothing new here, this has been law for quite a while. In short, i may hate a lot of things about FISA/FISC/etc, but i think the EFF is stretching to say this is a new problem, or to blame the court for it.
- tacos 11y agoWhy is this being downvoted without any attempt at refutation? When I dug in I came to similar conclusions.
- guelo 11y ago"Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pcrh 11y agoMan... this is depressing... I'm counting on you lot at HN and beyond to create the technology allowing widespread encryption that makes such surveillance moot.