4 ms·
So I hear the washing machine story a lot. And it is true, insomuch as a 1970s washing machine would last for 20 years, and a 2010 washing machine will last for
by brianwawok 11y ago
So I hear the washing machine story a lot. And it is true, insomuch as a 1970s washing machine would last for 20 years, and a 2010 washing machine will last for 6 years. Good read here:
http://vancouversun.com/news/staff-blogs/myth-or-legend-the-golden-age-of-the-indestructible-appliance http://vancouversun.com/news/staff-blogs/myth-or-legend-the-...
The 1950s washing machine cost the equivalent of $5000. A modern one can be had for $300, and wash clothes far far far better. You can buy one every 5 years for the rest of your life, and come out way ahead.. so why not?
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>You can buy one every 5 years for the rest of your life, and come out way ahead.. so why not? For me the main reason is environmental impact which isn't accounted for properly in the price AFAICT. I'm currently trying to recycle parts from an old machine - many of which are polypropylene - but which despite bearing recycling logos aren't seemingly recyclable anywhere. Not even the ferrous seems to be wanted any more - stainless steel drum, few parts from aluminium, rest seems to be destined for landfill. I'm talking about turn of the millennium washing machine (front-loader, UK) versus a current one. Price seems pretty comparable from what I recall.
- brianwawok 11y agoNegative externalities are a big problem in almost any free market type situation. This is no exception.
- allisthemoist 11y ago> You can buy one every 5 years for the rest of your life, and come out way ahead.. so why not? This is the principle behind planned obsolescence [0]. While I agree it may in some cases benefit the consumer, it generally seems designed more to maximize volume of sales and leads to degradation of product quality overall. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence
- brianwawok 11y agoHere is my counter argument to this. If there was a way to say, make a $300 washing machine last 20 years for only $100 more.. there would be a huge incentive for a new washing machine manufacturer to sell a $600 washer machine guaranteed to last 20 years. Sure he only made $200 more profit than the guy selling the $300 washer machine, and he lost 3 future sales.. but he has 0% of the market to start with. Not like he has anything to lose. I suspect we could make a 20 year washer for less than $5000.. but I bet it would still be a lot. Say $2000. And even at that price, still cheaper to the user to throw away the $300 washer every 5 years.
- allisthemoist 11y agoThe argument against planned obsolescence is not an economic one but rather one against the immense waste it creates. The so-called "fast fashion" model now employed by H & M and other clothing retailers also falls into this model and it's an established business model in many other spaces as well. If you create products that need to be thrown out and bought again cyclically, you create a much higher volume of sales. The problem with this is that our current recycling capacity is not able to handle the excess in resultant waste products.
- makomk 11y agoA modern washing machine can be had for $300 in large part thanks to more automated manufacturing, better materials and electronics. I don't think there's any fundamental reason why someone couldn't build a reliable, efficient, repairable modern washing machine for close to the price of current machines - the extra cost would be miniscule compared to the cost of building a functional washing machine in the first place. They just don't because it means more sales.