16 ms·
Cisco’s Attempt to Dodge Responsibility for Facilitating Human Rights Abuses
- solotronics 11y agoHas anyone heard of similar abuses by Juniper Networks?
- abpavel 11y agoI'd focus more towards the merchant silicon of Marvell/Broadcom/Fulcrum
- walrus01 11y agoif somebody wants to sue a layer 2 ethernet fabric chip maker they're insane. any asshole can use a switch to do any sort of terrible thing with their nation's internet infrastructure. it's like suing intel because they made the 1GbE NIC in a server seized for kiddie porn.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNot if they backdoored it for money to aid nation-states in I.P. theft or murder of innocents. I'm not saying I recall above companies doing that. Just that it's one legit reason among many to sue or bring charges against a telecoms, semiconductor company. And we know more than one vendor that previously did exactly that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 11y agoShow me any documentation whatsoever that proves a pure layer 2 Ethernet switch has been put on a test network and observed (via packet capture on its upstream) sending data home.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt's not the switch itself. It's the I.P. in the switches. And you've narrowed the situation enough to ensure nobody could meet your criteria unless representing the most wreckless spies on Earth. Note: One fun fact of layer 2 Ethernet is it's insecure enough by itself that many just tap straight into the lines somewhere. Led to development of MACsec standard.
- walrus01 11y agoNot at all. "Put a suspicious device on an internet connection, let it run, and capture all packets to see where it phones home" is a fairly basic process.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe connectors in TAO catalog use RF to make that impossible without unusual spectrum analyzers. I did that, too. Another trick is covert channels to make it invisible in network traffic. Covert channel analysis is mandated in high assurance specs but almost nobody does it. Anyway, you're not going to see a switch subverted by pro's in action. They won't blow that cover. They'll use it to facilitate a normal attack and plant evidence it came through a normal vector. That's how subversion works at pro level.
- cloudjacker 11y ago> Cisco’s attempt to try to leverage the Wassenaar discussions into legal immunity for itself is unfounded and should fail. More like attempts to get a civil penalty in the United States for business in another country should fail
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAs a US citizen, you can be held responsible for violating certain US laws outside the United States. Why would this be different?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoI'm really tired of "business" being used as an excuse for oppression and torture.
- rayiner 11y agoThe US is entitled to use its leverage to effect cultural change abroad. One way we do that is combat foreign corruption by holding American companies accountable when they engage in fraud abroad. We also hold Americans who participate in sex with minors in foreign countries accountable. This is in the same vein.
- burkaman 11y agoWhy not? Seems like there is lots of precedent for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_Tort_Statute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_Tort_Statute Also, do you think it matters that one of the plaintiffs is a US citizen?
- mtgx 11y agoThose people who helped increase the quarterly earnings at the time by selling this tech to the Chinese government must've felt pretty proud of themselves.
- exolymph 11y agoIt's disturbing that I didn't even know Cisco was involved until now.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhat's your intended meaning?
- exolymph 11y agoA combination of feeling guilty that I haven't been paying more attention to unethical things that US companies do abroad and being disappointed that this wasn't bigger news.
- ultramancool 11y agoYeah guys, sue the firewall vendor for your unencrypted internet traffic getting you fucked. Are we supposed to forbid companies from complying with customer requests, even if they're unaware or just don't really care how those will be ultimately used? I know I'd implement similar things if it were requested of me. I doubt this will be a popular opinion on HN, but I don't think Cisco was in the wrong here. Once traffic crosses your network boundary, it's fair game.
- teraflop 11y ago> Are we supposed to forbid companies from complying with customer requests, even if they're unaware or just don't really care how those will be ultimately used? "Unaware" is a red herring because Cisco knew exactly what they were doing. From the court filing: 174. In October 2002 and September of 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2010, Cisco shareholder resolutions identified concerns regarding potential human rights abuses arising from Cisco network technology solutions provided to foreign countries, including and especially China, and called for investigation into Defendant Cisco’s complicity in these abuses. These resolutions were presented to the Cisco Board of Directors, including Defendant Chambers, and in each instance, the Board of Directors issued a statement recommending that shareholders reject the proposal. Well after this point, Defendant Cisco continued to help the Party and Public Security officers to suppress Falun Gong through use of the Golden Shield. 175. Cisco’s Golden Shield files include several court and prosecutorial reports identifying the douzheng of Falun Gong and other “hostile elements” as one of the five tasks of the Strike Hard campaign created to suppress Falun Gong with the Chinese for the term “element” designating targets of persecutory campaigns in the PRC. 176. Cisco’s marketing materials in China repeatedly boasted that Cisco’s technology solutions could guard against Falun Gong, block and track Falun Gong, monitor and profile Falun Gong, and in other ways persecute Falun Gong. If someone "just doesn't really care" about actively helping a foreign government to capture its political enemies and torture them to death, I have no problem making a moral judgment about them.
- ultramancool 11y ago> Cisco’s marketing materials in China repeatedly boasted that Cisco’s technology solutions could guard against Falun Gong, block and track Falun Gong, monitor and profile Falun Gong, and in other ways persecute Falun Gong. Note that none of the things you list include torture. You've shown nothing more than a tangential possibility of awareness. Without showing their direct knowledge of the torture and a direct link to requests from Cisco, you've proven nothing. In fact, if anything you've shown they really went the extra mile to look into it. That's way more work than I would have done at least . the reality is that looking into something like this makes it more likely you'll get screwed over if it comes up legally later. What do you think about manufacturers of end to end encryption tech? Certainly there's evidence that it can be used for bad things too. I worry that cases like this, if successful, could be used against Signal or similar next.
- squidlogic 11y agoWow, I knew Cisco helped with the GFW, but didn't know they made a module specifically designed to find and capture Falun Gong participants[0]. Thats ... pretty messed up. [0]https://www.eff.org/files/2016/01/12/113_second_amended_complaint_does_v._cisco_9.18.13.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/2016/01/12/113_second_amended_comp...
- sneak 11y agoI think the term is "criminal".
- tptacek 11y agoIt's not criminal. It could and should be outlawed, but hasn't been.
- sneak 11y agoConspiracy to commit murder/torture is indeed illegal.
- tptacek 11y agoWords mean things. When you draw wild connections like these, you endorse the notion that society should be governed by the moral feelings of citizens and not by laws. That may feel good in the moment, but I guarantee you that in the long run, it's people like you and I who will suffer the most if that worldview prevails. Conspiracy to assist the unethical law enforcement operations of another country is not, in fact, a crime in the US. I wish it were. But to be guilty of a crime, it has to be a crime when you commit it. It doesn't work retroactively --- that's one of the first safeguards against despotism the founders came up with.
- sneak 11y agoIt's not a wild connection; conspiracy in the US to aid murder/torture abroad is currently a violation of US law. Couching it in "unethical law enforcement operations" doesn't really change the fact of the matter, does it?
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoSo it's wrong to abuse, humiliate, and torture someone in the United States but if you do it elsewhere it's ok? Oh wait...
- cloudjacker 11y agothis case is about selling an internet filter. It would not be wrong, as in illegal or subject to any civil penalty, if Cisco sold that internet filter to the United States' agencies. so that highlights the delicious irony in your retort
- jonathankoren 11y agoFirst, they built special hardware to target a specific group that is internationally known to be a frequent target of oppression. So that's going beyond what they normally provide. Second, if you're selling something to a known person, and you have a good reason to know what they're going to do with it. And let's be clear, Cisco totally knew what they were going to be used for in this case. Then you're an accessory.
- cloudjacker 11y agoand they also would not be subject to any civil remedy if they sold such thing to a US agency. the only thing I responded to.
- Swannie 11y ago| First, they built special hardware to target a specific group Is that stated as a fact in the case? I didn't find anything that makes that suggestion.
- jonathankoren 11y agoThe article explicitly says, "Cisco built a special Falun Gong module into the Golden Shield". Reading the abstract of brief, it looks like "built" is being used to me "specifically sold and configured hardware." So it's not necessarily some special asic, but rather machines configured specifically to target and identify Falun Gong members. Anyway, in the 21st century, the line between hardware and software that runs on dedicated hardware is pretty ill defined.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- swombat 11y agoIf they're doing this for China, what do you figure they've been doing for the US government?
- tptacek 11y agoYou mean apart from the fact that the US Government doesn't operate a "Great Firewall of the United States"?
- sitkack 11y agoDoesn't it? It is just transparent and the traffic shaping is self enforced.
- tptacek 11y agoNo, it doesn't.
- manicdee 11y agoYou ate correct of course. Five eyes is not a firewall. Tapping into fibre optics, spying on civilian satellite communications, and keeping tabs on everyone's phone calls, emails and web browsing s not a firewall either. But it is an invalid comparison snce it isn't the GFW that is gettng people killed, it's the packet inspection and traffic monitoring.
- peteretep 11y agoI sincerely thank you for pushing back on all the crap in this particular thread. HN seems to have devolved in to "well the world SHOULD work the way I want it to" recently, and you're doing sterling work here being the voice of reason.
- djrogers 11y agoThat's not a firewall any more than a river is a damn.
- 11y ago
- abpavel 11y agoWell boo hoo, Google is trafficking in human information, Facebook is trafficking in human information, FourSquare remnants are trafficking in human information, all realizing Orwell's sweaty nightmares. But a company that is affecting someone overseas, and not it's own citizens, is in the wrong?
- allisthemoist 11y agoFind me a specific incident perpetrated by GOOG/FB that has directly facilitated human rights abuses. This is not an accusation of a vague misuse of information. This is a direct action by the company that they knew would facilitate torture, etc.
- abpavel 11y agoThat's their business model - people are their product. That's how they make money. That's the only way they make money. They sell people to advertisers. What's not wrong with that?
- rosser 11y ago"Sell[ing] people to advertisers" != "sell[ing] people to an oppressive regime."
- abpavel 11y agoThat's one way to look at it. But Chinese view US regime as oppressive, and any opinion to the contrary would result in the downvote fairies of the 50-cent army slashing your karma to oblivion, in a similar way I lost about 25 points on this post.
- jessaustin 11y agoWat? Nothing you've said above or below would incite the ire of 50¢A. If anything they would upvote you.
- 11y ago
- abpavel 11y agoDon't forget that China has a "50-cent army": http://www.rfa.org/english/news/china/propaganda-03122014184948.html http://www.rfa.org/english/news/china/propaganda-03122014184... And the "Citizen Score": https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/chinas-nightmarish-citizen-scores-are-warning-americans https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/chinas-nightmarish-cit... Which is aking of FB/GOOG collecting metadata of your activities and having "paid likes", but being used in a more specific and direct way.
- abpavel 11y agoCisco provides Internet Protocol services, not what is being done with them. If Electricity from France is exported through Russia to China, can they be held responsible too? And what about the oxygen produced by the US flowers? Are US farmers responsible for providing oxygen supplying the evil Communist regime with oxygen? That electricity was as crucial to conducting the dreadful things just like IP, and just like oxygen. This logic has no bounds.
- ng12 11y agoDid you even read the article? Cisco (allegedly) built custom software to persecute a religion.
- abpavel 11y agoYes, the article, yes, but I've also been a part of too many projects like this, when a technological marvel is being developed for a number of years, creating new capabilities, technology innovations, and driving efficiencies. Thousands of American man-hours were spent in creating this marvel, only for someone to summarily judge on a whim of what was that effort was about. It wasn't about what EFF said. That just simply wasn't in the RFP/RFC/RFWhatever.
- jonathankoren 11y agoThrowing up your hands and saying, "I just built it! It's not my job to think about how it's used!" is a cop out. It's also against the ACM Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct[0]. [0] https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-professional-conduct https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-profess...
- ultramancool 11y agoHow about "it's just a tool"? You could say the same thing about knives, cars, Tor, Bitcoin or the Internet itself if you wanted. You can't blame a creator for how a finished product is used. Their vision might greatly differ or it might not exist at all.
- MichaelGG 11y agoFalun Gong is essentially a magic-believing cult. How is this any different than the US hunting down, say, communists?
- allemagne 11y agoWho are you arguing against? Most people would say both are very wrong.
- MichaelGG 11y agoJust that it seems odd that the US would prosecute entirely legal actions in other countries, especially when they're guilty of similar things as well. Edit: I apologize, I'm incorrect in this entire thread and didn't understand how this was happening. My fault for not reading and thinking it was the US filling charges. Though perhaps China can just claim Falun Gong is a terrorist group and Cisco should be in the clear then. In the end, helping governments go after dangerous cults seems like something that should be legal.
- tptacek 11y agoFor starters, it's different because the US does not in fact hunt down communists, but the Communist Part of China does hunt down, imprison, and torture Falun Gong adherents.
- MichaelGG 11y ago
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoThere's a surprisingly large number of people in this thread vigorously defending Cisco in really disingenuous ways. Is this the 50 Cent Army in action? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party) I know it sounds tinfoil-hattish, but China's homegrown grassroots propaganda is pretty well-documented, and the volume of stuff I'm seeing here is pretty unusual for HN comments.
- delinka 11y agoI'm trying to find where tptacek defends Cisco on this page. Not seeing it. Can you provide links?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoI didn't intend to imply that he did, apologies. I realize my original post was poorly phrased, so I edited out that part. It's the people saying either that Cisco couldn't have possibly known what China would do with tech designed specifically to track a suppressed religious group, or else doing the Werner von Braun defense[1], that I'm referring to. [1] "'Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down? That's not my department,' says Werner von Braun." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjDEsGZLbio https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjDEsGZLbio
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoDoes anyone have a specific objection to my post? If not, all the comment-free downvotes aren't doing much to allay my suspicions.
- dang 11y agoOn HN, you're not allowed to accuse people of this without evidence, and an opposing opinion is not evidence. If you suspect abuse, you can email us at hn@ycombinator.com, but invoking this kind of thing as a rhetorical device in an argument is both uncivil and a low-quality (because formulaic) addition to a thread. Please don't do it here.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]