10 ms·
Mining in Space Could Lead to Conflicts on Earth
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoWhat fair solution could be reached? I think it is extremely important to let the private sector mine as long as it fullfills certain safety and environmental standards. We have seen that the private sector is capable of so much more (just look at spaceX). But I also see the need for regulations so that one company can't claim all plantes to mine while still having an advantage because they were the first to start mining. How could territories be distributed fairly so that innovation is possible (and encourage by financial gains) and that there are no monopolies (so that only one country or only one space agency from one country, which would be pretty counterproductive).
- xyzzy123 11y agoWhat country writes those regulations? Whose claim is valid? I think that's where things get interesting and earth politics get involved. Who should have a say? Spacefaring nations or all of earth? [I think this is your point, just being explicit I guess].
- monk_e_boy 11y agoIt would be almost impossible to regulate space. These satellites are tiny and millions of miles away. You should see the problems we have with illegal fishing about 10 miles off our coast. I don't disagree with you, I just think the practicalities of monitoring and enforcement would be almost impossible.
- xyzzy123 11y agoThe scale of the capital enterprise required to pull this off in the next 50 years practically guarantees it will be a political issue if it happens in our lifetime. You can't sweep space mining under the rug. We're a long way off freebooters with fusion drives. And when we have those, AI will see you from 5 AUs out
- unfortunateface 11y agoA auction in which everyone interested bids on access to an asteroid based on... - Time they have access to asteroid - Type of resource they want to extract - Quantity of resource they want to extract Time cost is paid upfront and distributed evenly amongst worlds countries. Type/Qty is paid for on return to Earth in either cash or using resource itself.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoThis sounds reasonable to me. Can anyone point out some shortcomings of an auction-approach? The only thing that stands out to me is if a party has the means they can buy every auction out.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThere will also be people who do not intend to return to Earth.
- jerf 11y ago"one company can't claim all plantes to mine while still having an advantage because they were the first to start mining" That is physically impossible. While the international laws and conventions have lapsed, they can easily be brought back, and one of the principles of settling is that you can't claim something you can't defend. The principles will need to be tweaked a bit since the way in which "defense" is used here isn't 100% applicable, but you could easily say that you have to be occupying it, for instance. There is no way to squat on the million best asteroids. By the time that's not true, our great-grandchildren will have worked out the principles of solving that problem. It may be fun to speculate on their answers, but it's nothing more.
- ajmurmann 11y agoWhat qualifies as "occupying"? Does a person need to live there (not viable for small asteroids) or is it enough if I attach I iPhone sized tagging device to it?
- jerf 11y ago"I'll know it when I see it" really will get you through at least a decade or two. It's not like the doors are going to open and twenty million people are going to emigrate to the asteroid belt overnight.
- nxzero 11y agoWar in space is already happening; weapon systems, attacks, etc. Raw materials are a national security to all countries. China in many respects is the leader in raw matters and they are leveraging this anywhere possible; China stopped providing raw materials to Japan, US complained to the national community, and were told they breaking trade laws by the community.
- marak830 11y agoChina stopped providing materials to Japan? When did that happen? Do you have a link?(a quick Google on my phone only bought up ww2 references)
- ximeng 11y agoGoogle "rare earth china japan". 2010
- marak830 11y agoThanks!
- frgewut 11y agoJust some context on how this developed ('rare' is not so rare anymore). http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-chinas-rare-earth-weapon-went-from-boom-to-bust-1653638596 http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-chinas-rare-earth-weapon-went-fro...
- nxzero 11y agoIt's a "mining economy" so, yes, they're rare relative to other resources. US Government Accounting Office recently said it was still an issue: http://breakingdefense.com/2016/03/pentagon-fails-to-act-on-crucial-rare-earth-minerals/ http://breakingdefense.com/2016/03/pentagon-fails-to-act-on-... It's an issue, but complex, and hard to predict what will happen. Also, given it is a national security issue, it's possible, if not likely that you'll never get a full picture of the issue.
- tom_wilde 11y agoThe Moon is a Harsh Mistress.
- adrianN 11y agoUnless there is a profit to be made in space, I don't think we'll see significant development of space technology. NASA and the other space agencies are chronically underfunded. It's true that science probably will have a low priority if we allow private ventures to do in space whatever they like. But right now, science isn't doing too well either, so it's not obvious to me that commercial space development will be a net negative for science. At least in the early phase of space mining, it seems to me as a layperson that the challenges are very similar to what NASA is researching. Given our poor track record at establishing transnational bodies with actual powers, I wouldn't want to wait until the UN Space Mining Commission has worked out rules and can actually enforce them.
- wrong_variable 11y agoImagine we go to space and get access to infinite energy and infinite natural resources. Does it solve world hunger ? Don't we already have more than enough food ? Does it solve cancer ? .. Does it solve the economical crisis we are in ? Its mostly due to lack of political organization and lack of education. I think the argument that Neil Degrasse Tyson makes - about inspiring the young - it can be done by trying to solve world hunger, cancer, etc. We do not need to burn more fossil fuels to try to figure out how to mine the moon. The biggest argument would be that we already have infinite resources here on earth. Space mining doesn't make much sense when you can much more cheaply extract resources from earth. I think the biggest issues in society is education and healthcare. And the free market seems to direct us towards that anyway. Healthy and educated people are inspiring - space mining seems to be trying to solve the wrong problem for the right reasons.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bad_user 11y ago> The biggest argument would be that we already have infinite resources here on earth. Earth's resources are very much finite and that's a fact. It's only a matter of a couple of decades before fossil fuels become extinct, our oceans are dying due to overfishing and pollution, rainforests are cut to make room for more agricultural land, existing agricultural land is acidified due to overuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides, potable water sources are vanishing, those solar panels that people keep talking about and the iPhone in your pocket need rare metals to be mined, etc, etc. Also have you seen how open pit mining looks like, have you seen what it leaves behind? Earth mining is cheap only because the costs are subsidized by the environment. But of course, our children will pay the real bills.
- jakozaur 11y agoAnything can provoke war. Abundance of rare resources would rather make wars less likely than lack of resources and fighting over them.
- bcook 11y agoWhich country/organization has this so-called abundance? Do they freely share it out of the goodness of their heart?
- jakozaur 11y agoTo your point, there were many wars with gold/oil being the main motive. However, I hardly can remember any wars where coal resources was the main motive. Both are fossil fuels, but one is more precious than the other.
- bcook 11y agoI am very likely biased by my love of the sci-fi (dystopia) genre... :) Regardless, if there is something of worth, people will kill to have it.
- throwaway049 11y agoI think the threat to coal supplies from Poland was a significant factor (but not main motive) in Britain declaring war with Germany in 1939, but I can't find a reference to back this up.
- daemin 11y agoWell the Silesian region was a major (coal) mining centre in Poland, both before and after the war.
- arethuza 11y agoI've never heard that mentioned as a factor in the events leading up to WW2 and this graph suggests that the UK didn't even start importing coal in any quantities until the 1970s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_mining_in_the_United_Kingdom#/media/File:UK_Coal_Production.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_mining_in_the_United_King...
- madaxe_again 11y agoMining on Earth leads to conflicts on Earth, so what's the difference? Additionally, the '67 Outer Space Treaty was specifically written with open-ended provisions to allow for the commercial exploitation of space - at the time, they quite honestly thought that Hilton and Pan Am (yes, 2001 did it) would be operating in space within decades. They even thought so as far back as '58, before man had even been to space. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20120712-where-is-hiltons-lunar-hotel http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20120712-where-is-hiltons-lu...
- xyzzy123 11y agoWhat I find interesting about it is new questions of sovereignty versus co-operation among the nations on earth. None of the space treaties were written with the anticipation of actual profits in mind. You could make the same argument about Antarctica, but [actually I don't have a good argument why we haven't exploited the resources there and would be interested to hear one. Just political suicide? Too expensive?] When it's feasible to make money space mining absolutely all of these things will be rewritten, probably with a heavy dose of realpolitik.
- mirimir 11y agoTwo reasons come to mind: Penguins are cute. We ought to leave somewhere untouched, so let's pick the poles, because they're too bloody cold, and all. /s
- xyzzy123 11y agoMaybe it's just too hard to navigate public opinion and regulation for things involving multiple governments? That would not bode well for space mining... Also yes if there were space penguins: no chance
- clem 11y agoJust picturing the uproar over a space polar bear clinging to a tiny asteroid.
- chris_wot 11y agoI've got a weird question: if it became feasible to do lots of mining on other planets and bring it back to Earth, at what point will it be a problem where the mass of material on Earth starts to become a problem? Odd question I know, but I've often wondered this.
- whiskers08xmt 11y agoI don't think it's a big problem, as earth mass is already increasing my quite a few tons per day, from comets burning up in the atmosphere. If the asteroids are refined and processed in space, which makes more sense than trying to land them, it should be a non-problem.
- rtkwe 11y agoEarth is massive. Pretty much nothing we can do on a human scale is going to impact that. To put it in perspective taking the entire raw iron ore mining output is only 5.3916492×10^-13 of the Earth's mass. (used a 2014 estimate) Honestly I'd worry about heating up the atmosphere too much from the resources being delivered before mass even vaguely comes into the picture unless we figure out space elevators.
- marktangotango 11y agoEveryone assumes (from the comments I've read so far) that mined materials would be used on Earth. My challenge is to imagine how the material could be used in space; o'neil colonies, moon cities, etc. Did you know that nuclear pulse propulsion can theoretically reach .1c and that's fast enough to reach the nearest star in a human lifetime? Think big people!
- swalsh 11y agoI'm not sure everyone believes that. I seem to remember one of the biggest things they talked about when Planetary Resources was first announced was the mining of water for use in space.
- jfig 11y agoAnything can lead to conflicts on earth.
- rdtsc 11y agoAs a side note, Syfy channel's Expanse show takes place in that kind of an environment. There are "belters" whole generations who have worked mining asteroids. There is the "Mars" faction, descendants of Mars colonizers, and of course Earth. They end up conflict + some added human interpersonal drama mixed in etc, etc. As a show not top notch, but not bad either. It was interesting that it was exploring the Solar system as opposed the traditional space sci fi plot with aliens invading or having to go through wormholes to outer rims of the universe.
- moomin 11y agoSo tempted to spoiler you here :)
- dtromero 11y agoReally enjoyed this show. Found the inter-planetary political games particularly interesting.
- akeck 11y agoMobile Suit Gundam covers this ground as well. I think that when we settle beyond this planet, there will be "13 colonies -> United States" transitions - probably with conflict. “History doesn’t repeat itself but it often rhymes" ~ Unknown
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoI saw the free pilot and it was pretty good. Does the quality hold up and is worth buying the whole season?
- wmccullough 11y agoNo offense meant but, duh! We still can't decide who's allowed to use which bathroom. Of course we'd fight over space resources.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoThe author's thesis is that we shouldn't allow uncontrolled development of asteroid minerals, because it would lead to conflicts on Earth. He proposes an international body to regulate space development. I would disagree with the author's thesis for one simple reason: space is dangerous. Those nations and groups of nations that establish footholds in space are sacrificing much blood and treasure to get there. The U.S. alone has lost 24 people to accidents in space and space-related test flights and catastrophes like Apollo 1 and the USSR lost several cosmonauts as well. The grim likelihood is that there will be more deaths, an inherent risk of such dangerous exploration. In addition, the US, USSR, EU, Japan, China, and India have collectively invested trillions of dollars in space exploration and development since the 1950s. It's hardly likely that these great nations will submit to the authority of an international regulatory body and curtail their exploration; there's simply too much at stake. At most, they'll agree to some standards and shared values, based on the Law of the Sea, e.g. agreed-upon mayday signals, standardized airlock connectors, etc. I believe that those nations and groups of nations that establish footholds in space and exploit the vast potential mineral wealth in the Belt, on the Moon and on Mars, will be the superpowers of the late 21st Century and the 22nd Century. Far from a cause of conflict, this vast new wealth will usher in a new era of peace and prosperity and technology far advanced beyond even what we can imagine.
- amelius 11y agoWouldn't it be easier to start mining Earth's core?
- 0xffff2 11y agoThe Earth's core (and mantle, which is the only inner part of the Earth that is even remotely reachable) does not contain the rare metals that are the primary focus of asteroid mining. Even if it was easier it would be orthogonal to this discussion.
- jernfrost 11y agoLoads of rubbish. It should be free far all to spur innovation and get companies involved. This is what will get the dormant space industry going. There has to be great profit prospects to drive it. The sheer amount of resources in the asteroid belt makes an obsession about possible conflicts an overreaction. We fight for resources on the earth because we are billions of people with limited resources. That is not the situation in space. It is the opposite. Vast amounts of resources but with nobody to argue over it. "Space as humanities common heritage", that just makes me wince, what arrogance. We are a tiny insignificant spec in the universe. Space is not our heritage. That is a nonsensical statement. I wonder what the aliens on Alpha Centuri thinks about being labeled the heritage of some bipedals down on Telus.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> Loads of rubbish. It should be free far all to spur innovation and get companies involved. You need some sort of legal framework, still, because there will be conflicting claims and other problems. Plus, when it comes to planets, it's still worth trying to keep them as isolated from Earth life as possible - otherwise, you may ruin the chance to discover new types of life and advance science.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ginko 11y agoI wonder is something similar to the Norwegian oil fund, but on a global scale could work for space resources.
- deepnet 11y agoNASA estimates that Cometary Resources could support a population if 10 quadrillion people and a single 2km Near Earth Object would be the equivalent of 30,000 total Earth GDPs to launch* It is a new frontier, vast on a scale that dwarfs everything we are now. What is the population density required for a cometary level civilisation to develop interstellar technology ? * http://nix.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20050092385&qs=N%3D4294966819%2B4294583411 http://nix.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=20050092385&qs=N%3D42949668...