9 ms·
Just take the bike out of the race entirely. Declare a year in advance that the bike will be XYZ model Q so people can train on them, and the race maintains cu
by paulmd 11y ago
Just take the bike out of the race entirely. Declare a year in advance that the bike will be XYZ model Q so people can train on them, and the race maintains custody of all race bikes, spares, etc.
It's already a money-competition to see who can buy the best super-bike. Yes, you have to have a minimum weight, but that just means that you can take a superbike and spend the extra weight applying aerodynamic fairings whereas someone else has to spend that weight on their frame or whatever.
Just take the bike out of the picture entirely. You ride this bike. Or one of these three models. Or whatever.
- wl 11y agoThe last time I bought a new bicycle, I had to try a lot of them before I found one I really enjoyed. I'd imagine world-class cyclists are even pickier than I am.
- stbtrax 11y agoI think they're picky about who pays them the most.
- danielvf 11y agoThey are picky about winning. Money will make all the difference if they have no preference, but if they don't like something or are slower, there's no way someone who finishes in the top three would be willing to trade more money from one sponsor for moving down in the rankings.
- bobbles 11y agoYeah, it'd be like telling marathoners they have to wear a specific model of shoe. There's so many factors that go into comfort etc.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- elinchrome 11y agoExcept that the team get sponsored by a manufacturer, and it's not picked by the riders.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- someone_welsh 11y agoTo an extent, and seemingly always with frames. But pro riders often use parts that aren't "sponsership approved" - they just make them all black or similar (rather than have another manfacturer's logo on them)
- dagw 11y agoAnd the manufacturer then works with the team/riders to make sure they get a bike that works for them.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoThe biggest differentiator is height. I assume taller people have more muscle power hence should be put in different category.
- paulmd 11y agoFrame size is actually quite important for fitting a bike to a person. However, it's certainly something that could be varied within a model, just like a shoe has different sizes, or whatever. Multiple frame sizes are available on everything but the cheapest bikes - I had a choice of frame sizes on a standard Schwinn aluminum-framed bike 15 years ago. Given the choice of 5 high-end bikes and the ability to select a proper size I don't really see a problem.
- nradov 11y agoMost champion cyclists aren't tall. What matters isn't power, but rather power to weight ratio.
- Someone 11y agoThat depends on the discipline. In general, track sprinters are heavyweights, kings of the mountains are flyweights.
- techterrier 11y agoTaller people also have more person to carry around.
- bigfudge 11y agoThe biggest challenge is aerodynamics. If you're over 6'3" and want to be at all comfortable you're going to present a much larger frontal area than someone shorter.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- buro9 11y agoThey get team bikes. They aren't picky. Long gone are the days of a pro rider turning up on a relabelled bike of their choice (their bike, their sponsors' logos). The bikes tend to be distinct enough that they are definitely riding the frame of their team sponsor, and the wheels have become similarly distinctive too (no more Lightweights disguised as Mavic).
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoAt the amateur level, bikes are always customized by the rider to some degree. Teams are usually sponsored by both a manufacturer and a bike shop, so riders have a good source of discounted components. It's not uncommon for them to strip the bike down to the frame and rebuild it the way they like. The manufacturers also ask for feedback on the frame designs and tweak them every year. I can't imagine things are much different at the pro level.
- ekianjo 11y agoThis is not about fixing the problem. Actually in professional cycling nobody is interested in fixing the problem. They want to give the appearance that it's fair, but there are massive conflicts of interests between organizers, sponsors and teams to prevent a "clean sport" equilibrium to take place.
- jdietrich 11y agoTechnology is an integral part of cycling, just as it is in motorsport. There are some one-design motorsport racing classes, but they are far from the most popular. Fans like to see innovation, we like to coo over the beautiful new machinery on display. Some of the greatest moments in cycling are directly related to technical progress, most obviously the Obree/Boardman battle for the hour record. On one side a professional champion with a million pound superbike, on the other an unknown amateur with a bike he built himself. Many fans complain that the current regulations are too conservative and provide too little opportunity for technical innovation. Cycle racing exists in a symbiotic relationship with cycle manufacturing. Race wins sell bikes, bike sales fund race wins. Cut the manufacturers out of the sport and they take a huge chunk of sponsorship with them.
- dclowd9901 11y agoIf technology is integral, then why ban motors at all? Small motors and powerful compact energy supplies are technological advancements.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 11y agoIt's a balance between man and machine, between tradition and progress. F1 racing cars would be faster if they replaced the driver with a computer. The fans want to see the skills of the driver tested, so the sport bans common driver aids like traction control and anti-lock brakes. Cycling with motors isn't cycling, it's motorcycling. Allowing motors would change the sport in an undesirable and irrevocable manner. In cycling, technological progress is governed by the Lugano Charter. Technology is an intrinsic part of the sport, but it is not allowed to play a dominant role. http://oldsite.uci.ch/imgarchive/Road/Equipment/The%20Lugano%20charter.pdf http://oldsite.uci.ch/imgarchive/Road/Equipment/The%20Lugano...
- bigiain 11y agoInterestingly though - those now-banned-in-F1 driver aids are all over showroom floors and making regular cars safer. (as are older technologies initially developed in top level racing - disk brakes, fuel injection, radial tires, etc...) Racing in all it's forms is nearly always conducted under some entirely arbitrary artificial constraints (even when the rules don't enforce it, money ends up taking the same place). Sometimes those constraints are "we'll sell more cars if they all look a little bit like Fords or Chevys", sometimes they're more like "we've got home-team advantage, so we'll make the rules say you've got to sail your America's Cup contender to Newport to compete, even if you come from Europe/New Zealand instead of Rhode Island...". Sometimes the constrains are "these new 4WD supercharged Group B Rally Cars are killing too many people, lets stop racing anything that fast thru the trees - lets race showroom floor shopping trolly hatchbacks instead..." Keep in mind that "Cycling with motors" isn't motorcycle racing either - in motorcycle racing there's engine capacity limits, number of cylinders, number of gear ratio limits, minimum weights, restrictions on brake materials, even things like limits on the number of motors used for a season and work allowed to be done on motors between races, and MotoGP are now "standardising" the engine management electronics/software as well... WorldSBK have homologation rules, where you need to sell a certain number of your racing motorcycle to the general public as road bikes to be allowed to race (modified) version in the race series. (I'm currently riding round a two stroke 125 Cagiva Mito that's a roadgoing version of the now banned/superseded 125GP bikes... These day's you've got no choice but to compete on a 250cc four stroke in that race series/class. In the past there were 8 cylinder bikes, and bikes with 16 speed gearboxes - all just history/legends now...) A lot of "the balance" seems to end up being about money - either to stop the guy with the deepest pockets from wining everything (who'd want to go sail boat racing against Larry Ellison without some rules about how much he can spend?), or to make sure the sponsors keep pouring money into "the sport" (how many F1 rules do you suppose there are relating to drivers meeting corporate and sponsor hospitality and media requirements, rather than technical regulations about what you're allowed to race on the track?)
- esturk 11y agoI agree. This is what happened to swimming with the super-suits. It became a matter of who can buy the best technology and a bunch of records came crashing down until they banned all the high-tech suits. Ian Thorpe's 400m freestyle record was thought to last for a least a decade or two and poof it was gone.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoI don't know a lot about it, but Keirin racing is super highly regulated on the equipment side. Essentially everyone has to have the same bike, with there being only a handful of parts manufacturers that have to make everything conforming to a certain spec. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keirin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keirin
- akgerber 11y agoMoreover, the spec has held pretty much steady on mid-1970s equipment.
- hatsunearu 11y agoEssentially the original "Formula" idea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- crawdog 11y agoUCI already regulates weight and aero features on the bike. The rules should change to mandate 1 bike, no swaps to keep riders from changing from a "doped" bike to a non-doped one before finishing - or provide better chain of evidence reporting on existing bikes. There's a huge difference in weight/tech from pro/non-pro bikes. Take a look at what's available for triathlons vs. UCI time trial bikes.
- backtoyoujim 11y agoPeople that don't write software but use software say the same thing about operating systems. "Why are there even more than one? It is absurd!"
- wutbrodo 11y agoWow is this really what your sample is like? Most people I know implicitly understand the concept of consumer choice and don't have any trouble applying that to OSes. IPhone vs android probably played a big hand in that, but even before that, there was a good solid chunk that understood that Mac was an alternative to Windows (before OS X really blew up)
- backtoyoujim 11y agoMy guess is that you rarely spend time with people outside of tech without tipping them.
- little500 11y agoOne of the more interesting bicycle races of the year does exactly this: the Little 500 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_500 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_500) All the bikes are identical in spec (single speed, coaster brake, flat pedals). This is the race that features in the movie Breaking Away. I wish more were like it, but I guess part of its charm is its uniqueness.
- 07d046 11y agoIt sounds like a good idea, but in reality, the sport of road cycling is and always has been extremely heavily dependent on bicycle manufacturers. You could probably make an argument that professional cycling exists mostly for the purpose of selling bikes. At the moment, five of the eighteen WorldTour teams (they're the top level teams) have names like BMC Racing Team and Trek-Segafredo, and I don't think they'd be very happy about everybody riding unbranded bikes.
- zuzun 11y ago> Just take the bike out of the race entirely. Or let riders register their preferred bike components at the start of every season, and then UCI could check the weight of bikes during races.
- rplnt 11y agoWhat are you proposing is to cut out money from the sport.
- btbuildem 11y agoMeh. Hopefully this will eventually result in a cool electric bike that could be mass-produced.