6 ms·
Plenty of Passengers, but Where Are the Pilots?
- mathattack 11y agoSeems like an economics problem. The airplanes are full. The airlines are making lots of money. There aren't enough pilots. Hmm.... Perhaps pay them more?
- th0ma5 11y agoThis is what all the pilots I've met are saying.
- bayesian_horse 11y agoIt's what every employee in any profession is ever saying.
- mpweiher 11y agoWell, if there is an employee shortage ...
- x0x0 11y agoCareful: don't apply that thinking to the "engineering shortage" or you'll never hear the end of it on HN. Engineers live in magicland, and in magicland, supply curves don't exist. People should work for passion and $60k, and if you don't, you're not a real engineer.
- narsil 11y agoNot sure what you mean. Plenty, if not most, engineers on HN are compensated at market rate for their region and skill-set. The uproar over the anti-poaching scandal involving Apple, Google, etc. from a few years ago was due to the artificial wage deflation that it created. I can't recall folks from HN siding with the corporations during that time. Sure, sweat equity is valued at early-stage cash-strapped startups, but that is in addition to "passion" and a lower salary.
- taneq 11y agoThat's only half of the equation. They can't get more pilots by paying more, because the requirements to become a pilot are so arduous. According to the article, trainee pilots have to pony up ~$150k in training costs, as well as spend many years working in scarce non-commercial-carrier jobs. So in part, the solution would be to create more non-commercial-carrier pilot jobs, and/or for airlines to start sponsoring trainee pilots to make it more attractive (or even possible) for them to get qualified.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_exer 11y agoI've been watching this government-made crisis develop over the last 24 months. Currently, you need 1,200 hours experience from a designated aviation college or 1,500 hours experience from GA. I believe airlines will lobby Congress to halve the number of hours in the very near future as they get data on the massive pilot shortage.
- cr1895 11y agoWasn't this requisite level of experience upped by Congress not terribly long ago?
- steffan 11y agoYes. In the US, originally you could be a First Officer without holding the ATP (Airline Transport Pilot) certificate. The ATP requires 1500 hours of flight time. Prior to the rule change, you would see regional airlines recruiting pilots with as low as 400 hours of total time (TT) for FO positions, allowing them to build the requisite hours to obtain their ATP.
- x0x0 11y agoThe article mentions JetBlue is running a so-called ab initio program where they train pilots directly for the low sum of $125k! That's right -- pay $125k to (maybe) get a good job in 15 years. As long as they charge 6 figures, there isn't a real pilot shortage. This is just the industry whining in the hope of finding a sucker (US taxpayers) to subsidize a training program for them.
- noja 11y agoTinfoil hat: underpay the pilots... "oh look we don't have enough pilots"... automation time!
- atemerev 11y agoIt's not a tinfoil hat, it is the only solution that will inevitably be implemented. In the world where I routinely get cross-Europe plane tickets for $30, airline pilots are about as glamorous as truck drivers, and will be replaced by robots about as soon. And no, nobody wants to go back to the time when average ticket price was $300 or more.
- atemerev 11y agoSince when airlines make a lot of money? Their profit margins are so thin I wonder how they survive at all. The solution is obvious, of course. Machines can drive cars, hence, they will be also flying planes soon. Pilots complaining their jobs are routine? Good. All routine jobs are to be eliminated, the sooner the better.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoI believe the airports themselves need more automation.
- atemerev 11y agoA modern large airport is the pinnacle of efficiency. Most of things there are already quite automated, or on the way to it.
- mathattack 11y agoIn a historical context, you are right. Warren Buffett once said something to the effect of, "A far-sighted capitalist would have shot down the Wright Brothers" [0] More recently the combination of consolidation, less competition and lower fuel costs have created record profits. [1] [2] [3] Also, machines are already doing most of the flying. "Autopilot" comes from aviation. :-) Automatic planes are actually a less tricky problem than automatic cars, as there's much less random stuff to navigate in the air. [4] [0] http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2011/12/business-quotations http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2011/12/business-quo... [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/07/business/energy-environment/airlines-reap-record-profits-and-passengers-get-peanuts.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/07/business/energy-environmen... [2] http://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/flights/2016/01/12/airline-profits-2015/78647924/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/flights/2016/01/12/airl... [3] http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jun/08/us-carriers-airline-industry-record-global-profits http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jun/08/us-carriers-... [4] http://www.cnn.com/2012/03/24/travel/autopilot-airlines/ http://www.cnn.com/2012/03/24/travel/autopilot-airlines/
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bayesian_horse 11y agoNot the whole issue. At the very least, raising wages significantly would mean higher ticket prices which in turn means lower demand. The airlines are also afraid to put pilots in a situation of power at the negotiation table.
- mathattack 11y agoRight. This is the joy of a market. If a skill is scarce, people pay more for it. That encourages people to supply more of it.
- nvader 11y agoThe article says most flying is automated these days. I can see the need for a human in the loop for special conditions. However, humans do make errors, and sometimes act maliciously. How far are we, do you think, from self-flying planes?
- nvader 11y agoMaybe freight would be the initial area to introduce them, as the risk of loss of life is minimised.
- venomsnake 11y agoIn the air. On the ground the risk is the same.
- runamok 11y agoEven in the US there is a whole lot of open space. And I don't think massive distribution centers are in extremely urban areas with high population density.
- jonathankoren 11y agoYeah, but where are the airports? They're inevitably in population centers. Case in point: FedEx flies into SJC, and the planes on the approach fly low over downtown, and very low over 101, since the end of the runway is right next to 101.
- bayesian_horse 11y agoAn unmanned cargo plane could suicide in an emergency such that no human is harmed.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI think we are already there given that flying is a much easier task than driving. See http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/03/has-the-self-flying-plane-arrived/472005/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/03/has-th... As one conspiracy theory, low pilot pay could be the industry's way of forcing the issue, given the psychological barriers to completely automated flights. Additionally, partial automation leads to lots of boredom for pilots, which could detract from rather than improve safety (full automation avoids that problem). We should see it happen in our lifetimes, anyways.
- noja 11y agoDidn't the nytimes run an article about pilots having to work in starbucks to supplement their starting income?
- wannabepilot 11y agoAs someone would have loved to become a pilot, but went into another industry because I wanted to be able to feed my family, the airlines have no one to blame but themselves. The pay for regional pilots is insultingly low. I don't think pilots qualify for H-1B but perhaps the US gov't could come up with a scheme to allow experienced foreign pilots to come to the US and get trained and certified at the airlines' expense.
- hendler 11y agoPiloting is bellweather profession for many other jobs vulnerable to automation. Is the debate about visa programs or universal basic income when all these jobs are gone? A combination of pay, educational requirements, and job security holds people back from many professions that they are motivated to perform. But I don't know that there is a solution that government can provide alone. We all need to participate in creating work, security, education. There are still great dreams to dream and jobs to have. I hope your current industry is also fulfilling.
- Hyperized 11y agoWanted to become a pilot, so I did the maths. Didn't add up so I got a job in IT, now it does :).
- meric 11y ago1. The lack of pilot problem affects only regional carriers but not national airlines level yet. 2. Regional carriers can't afford to increase pilot salaries because national airlines are stingy. This problem will begin to resolve, when the lack of pilot issue works up into the national airlines level. Eventually national airlines will be out of pilots, and they will be forced to either raise pilot salaries or institute training programs, or provide more favourable deals to regional airlines. The problem initially started by passing of the bill in 2009 increasing the number of hours First Officers require by 5 times. Since it takes a decade or more to train a pilot to that level, it may take a decade or more for the issue to percolate into the national airlines level. By 2019, national airlines will be feeling the pinch in pilots and be forced to act. As they ramp up salaries, or provide more favourable deals to regional carriers, or implement trainee programs that train new recruits from from the ground up, or fully subsidising they training, the number of pilots entering flight schools will increase, or automating pilots away entirely. By 2029, due to the previous ten years of work national airlines had done to attract pilots, or reduce dependency on them using automation, the issue of a lack of pilots will be resolved.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoIt's kind of scary that fixing pilot problem is going to take longer than it took aviation to go from first passenger jet to first 747! Comet entered service in 52 and Jumbo Jet flew commercially in 1970. Compare this with 2009-2029 range you proposed. The pace of change in "modern" world is depressing and that we are content with it is depressing even more. How about next year? Also note how fast you can break something. Pass an act in a month, fix its fallout in 20 years.
- meric 11y agoYou could move to Beijing, they're planning to open 18 new subway lines between now and end of 2020[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Subway#Future_lines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Subway#Future_lines
- 11y ago
- klagermkii 11y agoThis is another industry with a brutal gender gap (95%-5%) that I don't see referenced in the article as being an untapped source for talent. http://www.womenofaviationweek.org/five-decades-of-women-pilots-in-the-united-states-how-did-we-do/ http://www.womenofaviationweek.org/five-decades-of-women-pil... Is it an industry that can get away with relatively low pay and bad hours, because it offsets those by preying on the stereotypical fantasies of young boys "I want to be a pilot when I grow up", thus making it difficult to attract "normal" career minded individuals?
- sdrterterw 11y agoNursing has the opposite gender gap.
- belorn 11y agoIts a common trend when I see an article about a profession that is having trouble to find enough people to recruit. Nurse, midwifes, carpenters, preschool teachers, dentists, plumbers, and so many more professions only recruit from one half of the population, and has thus problems when demand fluctuate.