10 ms·
Dolphins as a model for alien intelligence
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DrNuke 11y agoI think intelligence is overrated in the grand scheme of life, so "alien life" would probably baffle us. Survival of the fittest on Earth is worth nothing if the fittest die as well. Evolution would be slower without intelligence but who cares, is there a race out there?
- hacker_9 11y agoTell that to the chickens you eat.
- simonh 11y agoAlien life would still have to be based on the same chemical and physical laws as terrestrial life, so while I'm sure it would be challenging to understand it shouldn't be an intractable problem. In the end, it's all just chemical reactions. If the fittest die as well everything's dead, so no more life. Not sure what you mean by evolution being slower without intelligence. I'd expect the opposite. Intelligence means you can adapt to your environment behaviourally and technologically, instead of biologically so natural selection becomes less of a factor.
- ZeroFries 11y agoEvolution is faster with intelligence because you get more advanced sexual selection
- simonh 11y agoCan you clarify what you mean by advanced? Edit: I can't reply to your reply, but I can edit this post. Unless the form that mate selection takes radically diverges from evolved patterns I don;t see how that makes much difference. Since survival for intelligent species is much more loosely coupled to their biology I don't see why sexual selection strategies would mitigate against that. It seems to me they'd follow the same pattern in devaluing biological fitness criteria as not being as significant as they were pre-sentience.
- harryjo 11y agoIntelligent individuals can be very quirkily selective with who they mate, dooming otherwise viable genetic lines to non-reproduction.
- RevRal 11y ago(You're probably already aware of this but just in case you're not...) HN restricts the timing of replies deeper into conversations, sometimes annoying but it suppresses flame wars and what-have-yous.
- macawfish 11y agoWhy would it have to be based on the same chemical and physical laws? That's a huge assumption!
- simonh 11y agoIt's only an assumption that, existing in the same universe as us, they would be subject to the physical and chemical laws of that universe. Or are you considering aliens residing in other universes?
- yoklov 11y agoBecause those are, as far as we know, constant throughout the universe?
- bsder 11y agoFirst, as far as we know, physics doesn't change depending upon universe position. So, we assume that life has to obey our standard rules of physics. Second, the chemistry of life balances on a particular set of characteristics: 1) Water is an extremely unusual molecule. It has much more varied reactions than just about any other solvent. This puts life in a particular temperature band. 2) Carbon chemistry is very energetically favorable relative to the other options. Binding energies are close enough that swapping around carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and hydrogen atoms doesn't take excessive amounts of energy. 3) Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen, and Hydrogen are all relatively close to one another in size as well. While carbon chemistry does borrow from higher in the periodic table, that tends to be the exception. While intelligent life will likely be completely different from us, it's very likely that the underlying chemistry is going to be very similar. The interesting question will be whether we have exactly the same basis DNA pairs. There has been recent successful work to synthesize new "unnatural" base pairs which can then be replicated in organisms.
- VLM 11y agoEmbrace and extend: 4) "Room temps" are really comfy for using enzymes to perform energetically infeasible reactions. Too cold and life is too slow to survive and much hotter and you get thermal decomposition faster than life can grow. Its chemically universal... we have the technology to do o-chem and biochem under much weirder conditions than where it actually works best. 5) Trace elements. Despite huge evolutionary pressure and no small amount of experimenting with blood chemistry we're still stuck with red iron based blood. Imagine if you could make blood out of pure protein or even just carbohydrates... But no, every red blooded animal on the planet is stuck refining bioavailable iron, no matter how much of a PITA that is. Would not be surprised if space aliens bleed red like us. 6) Water is awesome for buffer chemistry and this feeds back into your point #1 and my point #4 but homeostasis in the blood or innards in general would be nearly impossible under any other chemistry. I would not be surprised at all if space aliens were quite familiar with hemoglobin, chlorophyll, some of the cycles like the Krebs cycle. Krebs is very complicated and PITA but most earth life depends on it because it works, if something better were possible, it would have gone extinct half a billion years ago... It would be a fun race, seeing if human and space alien physicists or biochemists start communicating first. My money is on the biochemists, more shared background.
- awinter-py 11y agoyes, survival of the fittest makes less sense if the fittest don't survive
- nsajko 11y ago> Survival of the fittest on Earth is worth nothing if the fittest die as well. I'm not sure what are you saying here. The "fittest" are the ones who don't die (before reproducing).
- maus42 11y ago>Evolution would be slower without intelligence but who cares, is there a race out there? I'm quite certain that does not have anything to do with "speed of evolution". I am not a biologist, so I can't come up with a better source, but I'd suggest that everyone would very carefully study at least the Wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution which looks like a reasonable summary.
- stared 11y agoDolphins are mammals, and they are hardly "alien". I would rather look at cephalopods, who had a different evolutionary path (including reinvention of eye).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- simonh 11y agoOk, but in order to analyse a form of communication, you have to have communication to analyse. Do Cephalopods meaningfully communicate? If not, your investigation isn't going to get very far.
- xemoka 11y agoThey totally do, cuttlefish and some squid have colouring that they can manipulate. They can flash colours across their body to communicate: http://acp.eugraph.com/cephal/ http://acp.eugraph.com/cephal/
- zachrose 11y agoThey also sense light through their skin: https://www.theguardian.com/science/neurophilosophy/2015/may/20/octopus-skin-contains-light-sensors https://www.theguardian.com/science/neurophilosophy/2015/may... DOI 10.1242/jeb.110908
- awinter-py 11y agocuttlefish are the coolest! Their mimicry skills stay sharp across generations because during breeding season, while the strong males are competing physically for access to females, the smaller males with better mimicry skills are mimicking females (!) and sneaking past the boxing ring for a quickie. The female cuttlefish can also store lots of sperm and decide later whose to use. Gross.
- vixen99 11y ago
- ommunist 11y agoLooking at humans "mind" they decided not to communicate for greater good. So long, and thanks for all the fish.
- btown 11y agoI find it hard to believe that Zipf's law is at all meaningful for non-human species. We have evolved in a very specific way, such that we are limited in the bandwidth of our transmitted communications, as well as in our ability to memorize large vocabularies. There is no reason that this is true for other species, including dolphins; they may be able to distinguish and produce significantly more nuanced "words" (if that concept even exists); they may be born with, or be able to quickly learn and commit to memory, the "distance graph" between a huge number of distinct signals that represent nuanced concepts. Consider an organism that can quantize a dense signal, treat it as a hash table lookup, and reference a specific concept in their memory; these transmissions would look like pure noise to us, and any error correction might be written off as periodicity. We'd never know.
- Houshalter 11y agoRight. Any series of bits can carry information in some encoding. Testing if it matches Zipf's law is an interesting sign that it might be a human like language, not proof. It's certainly interesting that their language has statistical properties closer to human languages than that of other animals tested.
- greeneggs 11y agoA few people speculate that sperm whales might be transmitting sonar "images" in their communications [1]. At first it seems like a crazy idea, and maybe it is---but it isn't impossible since the whales perceive their environment via sonar. If we could directly and efficiently communicate synthetic images to each other, then "words" might never arise. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/16/opinion/sunday/conversation-with-whales.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/16/opinion/sunday...
- macawfish 11y agoThe closest thing to "alien" in my worldview is late industrial technology. Including this very thing I have sitting in my lap, which consumes energy like a living creature and responds dynamically to its environment in a way that keeps it around (it's my trusty laptop). I have opted to keep it around rather than throwing it in the trash (evolutionary selection).
- JBiserkov 11y agoThis reminds me of the "Free airport WiFi" "virus" that was "just" an ad-hoc network being spread by Windows XP? laptops.
- RevRal 11y agoI see that you're getting downvotes but I wish to cast my support for your comment. I suggest those interested in the thought process please check out the book What Technology Wants by Kevin Kelly. The book basically says that technological growth is almost independent of human input.
- seanp2k2 11y agoInteresting thought, and I've been there before, but I've also come to think of technology as an extension of humans. As computers are not currently capable of independent thought, they must [generally] be instructed by humans on what to do. We've also laid out their CPUs and GPUs and busses and power circuitry. Their physical evolution is based on the business roadmaps at places like IBM, Intel, AMD, NVidia, Micron, Dell, etc driven by tasks which they can perform to further the economies of humans. Contrast this to animals, where there is a drive for survival and furthering the species. Computers don't have this sense because they don't have life. Technology is impressive, but in terms of what a computer wants, I don't see it as much different from a shovel; it's a tool created and used by humans for the benefit of humans.
- meric 11y agoInheritance of genes separates life from chemistry. Inheritance of knowledge separates animals from plants and microorganisms. [1] Inheritance of capital separates humans from animals. [2] In the same way DNA is an integral part of life, and in the same way the knowledge to live in a particular environment is an integral part of an animal, technology is an integral part of being human. Raise a human in the wild among goats without human culture, without human technology. As long as that human is separated from culture and technology, would an alien be able to differentiate the human from animal? [3] [1] Animal born in captivity can't be released to the wild because they didn't have the opportunity to learn from their wild parents. [2] Hammer, houses, watches, factories, passed down from generation to generation. [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child
- jaybosamiya 11y agoObligatory reference to Douglas Adam's "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker's_Guide_to_the_Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker's_Guide_to_the_... The existence of the Babel Fish would make such questions much much simpler.
- macawfish 11y ago"They're made out of meat." "Meat?" "Meat. They're made out of meat." "Meat?" http://www.terrybisson.com/page6/page6.html http://www.terrybisson.com/page6/page6.html
- sunstone 11y agoHow about octopuses?
- smegel 11y agoI agree. Far more fits the "Alien" bill than a flipping (no pun intended) mammal.
- ViolentCheese 11y agoI think the point of the article was that mammals are the closest thing to us that are still (almost) completely foreign. If we can't talk to dolphins then how would we communicate with octopi? If not even octopi then how aliens? I think that was more the point rather than trying to find the most alien intelligent animal to attempt to communicate with.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoDolphins don't make tools. Cephalopods too. It's kind of hard for us to talk to somebody who doesn't make tools and thus has to rely on subsistence.
- Mtinie 11y agoThere are tool using dolphins. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/04/these-genius-dolphins-are-using-sea-sponges-as-tools/361168/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/04/these-...
- beeboop 11y agoIf subsistence is effortless and never a problem, is it really a problem that they never make tools? If humans had a matrix-like virtual reality, you could do whatever you wanted, and never to work a day in your life, I would imagine many people would never work or make tools.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago'If humans had a matrix-like virtual reality, you could do whatever you wanted, and never to work a day in your life' I imagine I won't have many common points in discussion with them.
- meric 11y agoUnless they played 40k the whole day. ;)
- seanp2k2 11y agoCephalopods can use tools: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AP_dpbTbess https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AP_dpbTbess
- RevRal 11y agoI've always gotta throw in a plug for my favorite sci fi novel Blindsight (available to read free on the internet: http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm) when I see threads like this.
- sehr 11y agoThe core idea of that novel was so ridiculously alien and interesting, couldn't put it down when I first read it. Fantastic book, great hard sci fi. His rifters trilogy was decent too, got a bit wacky in the last 2 books but still a fun read
- ViolentCheese 11y agoConvince me to read it please.
- gbhn 11y agoBlindsight is a very compelling exploration of the idea that there may be different roles of consciousness in advanced intelligence. We know that a conscious decision on say the visual processing loop ends up costing 120ms or so. Why is this a good thing? What if you can have advanced intelligence without consciousness? Some work in AI (and some worries people have about AI) suggests this may be a real possibility as well. The end result for me ends up being a much more intense feeling of the kinds of varieties of intelligence that may exist in the galaxy, or that we may end up creating ourselves.
- jholman 11y agoHey. Just read it start to finish, since reading your comment. It was good. Thanks!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- partycoder 11y agoDolphins (and whales, or cetaceans in general) are still mammals. Which means they have a mammalian neocortex that is very similar to that of a human. I think crow intelligence is more interesting. They are very smart and capable of using tools. And they evolved brain structures independently from mammals that enable them to do those things.
- r0muald 11y agoYes, at the same time dolphins have been evolving separately from humans for ~100 million years. That's a lot of time.
- partycoder 11y agoIf you look at cortical columns in a microscope it's hard to distinguish which is which.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoI'm reminded by an idea from deGrasse Tyson, not sure if it's his... on worms, who share 70% of their DNA with us. Yet they're completely oblivious even to our presence as we walk by, forget being able to communicate with us, or grasp the intricacies of human civilisation and its history. What are the odds then, that there may be a species not even insanely different from ourselves, which we simply cannot even observe or be cognisant of. If true, it'd make all our efforts to seek out, let alone communicate, with aliens, naively cute. It's a fascinating idea, although I've never explored whether it has any merit. It may just be one of those ideas that sounds amazing but falls apart if more closely inspected.
- SerLava 11y agoI'll try. It's a lot easier to be hidden from the perception of something that isn't even capable of perceiving itself or its surroundings, only reacting to simple stimuli. A lot of animals are smart enough to at least get a pretty decent picture of us. It could maybe follow that there are beings that we would be unable to really comprehend the way we comprehend other humans. But it would also be pretty likely that we could develop models, heuristics and statistical analysis to extract meaning about these theoretically confusing aliens. We understand quite a bit about our society- which is basically a hyper complicated animal. We deal with the gaps in absolute knowledge pretty well.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoNot only that, but without careful study, we really have no idea what is going on in the worms' heads, and we can't even easily tell them apart. Even with lots of study, we still don't understand the worm's perspective. If aliens visited us, we probably would not even recognize that they arrived, or we might see their arrival as some natural phenomena. We best start with dogs, who at least, we can bond with.
- im3w1l 11y agoWe have a very good idea of what is going on in the heads of at least one worm species: C. Elegans. It has 302 neurons and we have mapped how they are connected. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans#Research_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans#Researc... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/c-elegans-connectome/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/c-elegans-connecto...
- jp555 11y agoI always thought the closest thing to aliens to us would be plants. I imagine taking to an alien species would be closer to taking to trees than dolphins.
- tlb 11y agoI hope we value the lives of intelligent aliens more than we value the lives of dolphins and cephalopods. Judging from current efforts in avoiding fisheries by-catch, it's more than zero but less than $1/lb.
- seekingnames 11y agoThis is interesting...but Zipf's law was discovered (according to the article) in 1930's and the paper on the dolphin gradient (or language pattern) being similar to humans was written in 2009. So...6 years later any updates? Seems to me they just found a fact that was interesting and decided to wrap an article around it.
- ajuc 11y agoI wouldn't take this law too seriously, for example from my short experiments with cat textfile.txt | tr '\ ' '\n' | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn it doesn't seem to work for Polish (there's no articles in Polish, "of" is expressed as changed ending of noun, and in most texts I tried "is", "to", "from", "in" etc. are the most common with very similar frequencies). I would think dolphins and aliens may be more alien than Slavs.
- kylebgorman 11y agoI don't know how big "textfile.txt" is, but try it with a much larger body of text? Also you'll almost surely want a much better tokenization algorithm than that. Zipf's Law can only hold "at the limit" of an infinite stream of text, so as a consequence you get a better approximation with a larger sample.
- puppetmaster3 11y agoYes, based on all the aliens, this checks out.
- bawana 11y agoIt has been demonstrated that echo patterns captured from dolphins are a 2d planar projection of the 3d objects in the environment facing them. Thus, dolphins use a form of hieroglyphics where the 'words' are really pictograms. The real question is how humans went from this kind of pictogram/sign language (that our ancestors used) to the abstract mapping of sound<->writing<->picture that we use today. We attribute intelligence as the catalyst for this change. Yet intelligence , per se, evolved to facilitate survival in the face of increasingly efficient predators. Aliens with intelligence would certainly be using a similar abstract mapping. I shudder to think of their predators tho.