5 ms·
The thing is, the last A-10 rolled off the production line 32 years ago. Airframes have finite lifespans.
by TylerE 11y ago
The thing is, the last A-10 rolled off the production line 32 years ago. Airframes have finite lifespans.
- the_ancient 11y agoThen Build more Airframes... Start up the production again, I would rather them scrap the F35 program, which is vaporware at this point, than the A10
- adamson 11y agoHuh? F-35s are in production
- bpodgursky 11y agoF-35s will not be able to fire their cannons until the 2020's (last I checked), because the software has not been written.
- vonmoltke 11y ago2019 That said, the decision to declare Initial Operating Capacity with a software load that only has 89% of the aircraft's functionality is some politicized bullshit by the USAF.
- mikeash 11y agoThat must be one fancy-pants cannon if it takes three years to write the software to drive it. How is that even possible?
- ceejayoz 11y agoCannons have substantially nastier failure modes than the latest Twitter clone, and as such have much longer software development and testing cycles. A look into a similar process with NASA: http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff
- mikeash 11y agoMy incredulity is not because I think it's easy to write reliable software, but because a cannon shouldn't need more than "if button then fire." From the other reply, apparently it's way more complex than that though.
- engi_nerd 11y agoAdditional complexity comes from the F-35's Stores Management System (SMS). In addition to the basic accounting tasks of keeping track of what kinds of weapons are loaded, and on which stations, the SMS keeps track of how much the stores at each station weigh and provides that information to the flight control system (FLCS). FLCS can then compensate for the weight distribution of the stores. The gun must integrate with the SMS. http://www.dtic.mil/ndia/2010armament/TuesdayLandmarkADougHayward.pdf http://www.dtic.mil/ndia/2010armament/TuesdayLandmarkADougHa... for some more information.
- gozur88 11y agoBecause you don't engage manually any more. As I pointed out in above, the A (air superiority) version has only 120 rounds of ammo, which is three seconds worth. If you're using the gun you tell the computer "I want to shoot that guy", at which point you try to get him onto the pip on your display, which is going to move around depending on your relative velocity and distance. The computer actually fires the gun when it decides the round will hit. If you had to do it manually you'd most likely run out of ammo before you hit anything. The air-to-ground system is similar. So the software isn't just firing the gun. It's integrating data from all its sensors to figure out when to fire based on what you're trying to hit. I assume they have cut-outs friendlies as well, so you don't accidentally shoot your wingman.
- gozur88 11y agoBecause the cannon is useless. It's only there because every time you point out it's useless people start yammering about the F-4, a plane that came out five decades ago. Even when the gun is working, the A version is only going to have 120 rounds. Which is three seconds worth of ammo.
- engi_nerd 11y ago180 rounds for the A variant gun. Doesn't impact your point at all, just advising on the correct number.
- the_ancient 11y agoYea, they are producing a non-functional aircraft, that under preforms, and can not keep pace with aircraft 20 years older than it... Yea USAF.... the F35 is terrible plane...
- novembermike 11y agoIt would probably cost more to start up the A-10 lines again than finish up the F35. There's a lot of tribal knowledge that goes into building an airframe and most of it has been lost for the A-10. You'd pretty much have to start from scratch.
- gherkin0 11y ago> It would probably cost more to start up the A-10 lines again than finish up the F35. It's not just about cost of the platform, but also the capabilities provided by it. So even if the F35 is "finished" it won't necessarily fill the void left by the A-10, so more A-10s might be a better investment. From what I understand, the F35 did not gain effectiveness in proportion to its cost.
- gozur88 11y agoIt's pretty difficult to call an aircraft "vaporware" when over 100 are in service at this point.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThere are over 100 F-35 aircraft in existence right now. You might not like the program, but calling it "vaporware" is just flat out wrong.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoIn that case, if the design itself is still viable, it seems like it would make more sense to just produce more A-10s. Tooling up won't be cheap, but it might be cheaper than throwing yet more money at a wastefully expensive replacement. (Also, I think that a bunch of the A-10s in service were recently overhauled, which according to the article added "many decades of service life". I don't know if that's literally true, but it does seem like a thorough rebuild of a military airframe might be more economical than doing the same for, say, a mass-produced civilian car.)
- gherkin0 11y ago> In that case, if the design itself is still viable, it seems like it would make more sense to just produce more A-10s. Tooling up won't be cheap, but it might be cheaper than throwing yet more money at a wastefully expensive replacement. One hiccup to that idea is that apparently the original A-10 blueprints were "lost" over the course of several defense-contractor mergers. I don't think that should be a huge hurdle to overcome though, since they've been able to modernize the planes and design and build major replacement components for them (like new wings). However, the Air Force brass would probably make a big deal out of the missing plans in their smokescreen. I think they should just transfer the close air support role (along with the planes, personnel, and all associated budget) to the Army.
- commandar 11y agoAs mentioned in the article, the Air Force has already paid Boeing to rewing the A-10 fleet and subsequently extend the lifespan of the airframes out to ~2030-2040.
- ams6110 11y agoAirframes can last pretty much indefinitely with proper maintenance. 32 years is not anywhere close to the limit.
- dredmorbius 11y agoStress cycles and aluminium are your limitations. The A-10 flies a pretty dynamic mission. Now B52s, which mostly fly high and straight, are a different story (takeoff-landing cycles affect wings). The newest B52s were build in the early 1960s. They'll be flying through 2040, an 80 year lifespan. Ultimately it's wing fatigue that takes them down.
- msbarnett 11y agoAnd, again, as the article points out the A-10 fleet has literally just been rewinged, extending their expected lifespan to ~2040
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe key words in the post I was replying to being "indefinitely" and "proper maintenance". Yes, if you rebuild your Ship of Theseus, it may well last forever. But that raises other questions which have been debated for some time. Aluminium has specific concerns in that when it fails it has a strong tendency to do so catastrophically and with no warning, unless you've been very closely examinging for developing stress fractures. I've had personal experience with this, and there's a rather well-known video sequence of a fire-suppression air tanker undergoing an unscheduled dewinging above California a few years back. Cumulative entropic stress throughout the airframe does ultimately raise concerns over predictability of structural integrity. The more dynamic your flight patterns, the greater those stresses are, and more unpredictable.
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe newest B-52 is more than 50 years old, and they're expected to serve into the 2040s.