4 ms·
Inherent unfairness? I'd love to see that argument laid out. The US has an extremely progressive tax code. The top 1% receives 19% of all income and pays 49% o
by adventured 11y ago
Inherent unfairness? I'd love to see that argument laid out. The US has an extremely progressive tax code.
The top 1% receives 19% of all income and pays 49% of all income taxes. The top 10% pays 82% of all income taxes. What exactly do you plan to do, to make it more fair?
Most other developed countries have dramatically higher income taxes on their middle classes and have less progressive income tax distribution in terms of who pays. Which is why the US has roughly 50% higher median household disposable income than what Sweden, Britain, or Germany do: it's thanks to much lower taxes on the middle class (in those countries it's used for eg healthcare; in the US, people have a choice as to what they do with that disposable income).
http://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2015/03/joint-tax-committee-the-top-1-receives-19-of-all-income-.html http://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2015/03/joint-tax-co...
- mjevans 11y agoIt is a logical fallacy and disingenuous to compare how much in absolute dollars how much the top/middle/bottom income earners pay in absolute dollars rather than in their relative (per income earned) tax rate. If you have money to pay for experts in knowing all of the loopholes to exploit, and the types of investments / 'responsibilities' that special interests have had written in as possible deductions (the top n%) then the effective tax rate (per unit of currency) paid is less. Edit, adding this: I suppose you've also asked what I would consider fair. I find it easier to reach a stance of agreement that the current system is /unfair/ and needs a fresh start, so I hadn't elaborated on the outcome I'd like to see from such a process. I would find a system with a simple, preferably automated, process to be more fair. I would find a system where the more you make, the more you take home, to be fair. I would find a system where the more you make, the higher your relative rate of being taxed to be fair. (Is anyone REALLY worth 100 other people? 1000? At what point to you reach the true value of life: priceless (free)?) The best approach that I've seen so far mentioned is to tax assets. Property, objects, financial instruments (dollars to contracts of various sorts) all have a market value. You are not directly taxed on your income, but your net worth. Obviously there would be some forms of shelter (deferred net worth, like for retirement. Insurance buffers, etc).
- adventured 11y agoIn fact it's not disingenuous at all, nor a logical fallacy. You can derive those rough specs from the absolute numbers very easily. If the top 10% earn 45% of all income and pay 82% of all income taxes, that means the bottom 90% are earning 55% of all income and paying 18% of all income taxes. Which is another way of saying, the bottom 90% are paying a very low tax rate. And in fact, another important thing is extremely obvious as a connection to this: The bottom ~50% in the US pay nothing net in income taxes. This is a pretty well known tax fact. That means the bracket between 50% and 10%, that 40% group, is paying an increasingly very low rate as you go down the income scale, as the 10% to 20% bracket is carrying a high share of that remaining 18% income tax revenue base just as the top 10% group is. Put a very simple way: the bottom ~70% of income earners in the US, pay an extraordinarily small share of all income taxes, and inherently must have a low tax rate given their share of the income base (but that's also another trivially easy stat to retrieve). Explain to me again how anything I said is incorrect or disingenuous, and or how the rich aren't paying their fair share of income taxes. The sole argument you have left that I can see, is to claim that the top 10% should go from paying 82% of all income taxes on their 45% income share, to paying 100% of all income taxes off of that 45% share of national income.
- mjevans 11y agoI can't seem to locate a graph (within my time constraints) that shows, by percent (not by grouping higher/lower) how much, relatively /each percent/ or each income bucket pays in taxes. This however comes close. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressivity_in_United_States_income_tax#Effective_income_tax_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressivity_in_United_States... A fair tax system would not have a hump, or a ramp that then levels off, but would instead be a slowly rising graph with a continuously accelerating rate of being taxed, such that past some arbitrary point that extra return for every unit earned is virtually nothing (reflecting the stratospheric difference that already exists). I say that would be fair because I believe that even a truly exceptional person, let us say that they are unquestionably a genius instead of merely someone particularly good at business, is not worth 1000s of times or more what someone else is worth. If you're earning more than 1000s of peoples worth of taxes, you should be /paying/ like you're 1000s of people (without the per person tax credit).
- imron 11y agoAnd in Europe and other western countries with national healthcare, people don't go bankrupt from unplanned medical emergencies.
- adventured 11y agoAbsolutely correct. And that has nothing to do with the tax system, nor how progressive the US tax code is, and that problem can be legislated out of existence at any time by the US Government.
- imron 11y agoIt's inherently linked, and you even mention that in your previous post.
- abalashov 11y agoA valid, but technocratic defence. The overall justice of the socioeconomic system and the policy themes it actively promulgates is certainly a valid question, and it encapsulates both issues. That is to say: for the marginally lower taxes we pay in the US relative to other developed countries, what do we get? With healthcare, it turns out: not much! Not only do we have to pay our healthcare ourselves, on top of our tax burden, but we pay hyperinflated prices at that. Our insurers operate like cost-plus defence contractors that take the spiraling provider costs and just pass them on to the policyholders. For paying ever so slightly higher taxes, our W. European/AUS/NZ/Canadian brethren get a lot more social safety and peace of mind for their money. We mostly get a military-industrial complex and corporate welfare. This is relevant to the question of how we implement taxation and how we distribute the tax burden.