4 ms·
> A much better system is a defined contribution, in which the employer makes a contribution to a retirement fund for the employee. I agree, but the government
by matwood 11y ago
> A much better system is a defined contribution, in which the employer makes a contribution to a retirement fund for the employee.
I agree, but the government has so many rules around this I wonder if pensions at one point were a better value and a way to work around these arcane rules. For example, the max an employer can add to a 401k is 35k. Another is if a family clears 200k, then you're not allowed to put money into an Roth IRA without huge penalties. Never mind that $5500 is already not very much to save for retirement, but we definitely cannot let everyone do the right thing and save money.
- kspaans 11y ago$5,500 per year, presumably for many years. And heaven forbid you should be so well off that you have to save for retirement with after-tax dollars and/or in taxable accounts! :P Tax-advantaged savings accounts are to reward savers who might not otherwise save. They don't mean that everyone deserves tax-free saving.
- ChrisBland 11y agoWhile someone living in Dallas would see $200k as being very well off, think about a couple who lives in San Fran, or New York. 100k each is not truly 'well off' in those cities, so they are unfairly punished if they wanted to contribute what little money they have after living expenses to a roth.
- ams6110 11y agoYes, another reason to move to taxing consumption rather than income. However I don't care where you live, if you are earning $200K in a household you can afford to save.
- lukeschlather 11y agoWe have to have a variety of tax bases (consumption, income, property.) Otherwise those with income/assets in excess of $500k can easily move money around to avoid paying a similar share to people who are less well-off.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jrock08 11y agoExcept that consumption based taxes encourage wealth hoarding, and are extremely regressive for families that spend most or all of their income. A better format would be a "average middle class household cost of living" adjustment.
- bobcostas55 11y ago>And heaven forbid you should be so well off that you have to save for retirement with after-tax dollars and/or in taxable accounts! Well, this is where the distortion comes in. The employer uses pre-tax money when funding pensions. The employee doesn't have the ability to do this. It's the same situation with other benefits. So it's optimal to take a lower salary and more benefits. But this is strictly worse than if the taxation regime was the same for both employees and employers.
- cookiecaper 11y agoThe government hates savings. There is no need for it anymore, as loans and the products on which the banks make money appear to be entirely divorced from the deposits on-hand at this point. The Fed just prints more money if the banks overextend. Thus, there is no need for banks to give a meaningful interest rate on savings, and the only reason to put your money on deposit at the bank is that things are intentionally made more difficult and expensive if you don't. We need to recognize that we live under a regime in which bankers have the entire populous by the throat. To live a decent life by American standards, nearly everyone has to take out loans for every major purchase and ends up paying 2-3x the nominal cost in interest. Let the massive scale of this sink in for a moment and you'll get some concept of just how powerful, all-consuming, and critical the banks are in this country. Savings is anathema to this loan-based society that's been concocted. If someone has substantial savings, they may not need a loan, and that's very bad for the powers that be (because they won't get 2-3x the cost of the item over some years). Keynesian economics has been taken to its logical conclusion of sub-zero interest rates and practically everyone is indentured to their lienholders and employers. "The Road to Serfdom" indeed.
- matwood 11y agoI agree that the government hates savings, but I'm confused about two of your points. If rates are at or near zero it does not cost 2-3x to buy an item with loan. The indentured part is certainly true though. The government has helped tie everyone to their company. Health insurance and max retirement savings are two of the biggest items that are almost impossible to do outside of your employer.