3 ms·
I've been trying to evaluate the different editors. https://github.com/melling/EditorNotes/blob/master/vim.org https://github.com/melling/EditorNotes/blob/mast
by melling 11y ago
I've been trying to evaluate the different editors.
https://github.com/melling/EditorNotes/blob/master/vim.org https://github.com/melling/EditorNotes/blob/master/vim.org
To me it feels like the vim key bindings are more efficient for programmers. No one has ever done a scientific comparison, and it always seems to end in a religious war, but we should do a better job of evaluating our tools. Then hopefully, we can improve them.
- majewsky 11y agoThe problem with evaluating editor efficiency is that you are more likely to measure the user's proficiency. The vim editing style is only as efficient as the number of motions that you know. (I use about half of them actively, but I have a lot of vim users sitting around me that barely know "w".) So to really compare efficiency of, say, Emacs vs. vim, you will first need to find two users. One who is as proficient in Emacs as the other is in vim. Good luck with that. :)
- todd8 11y agoYes, but there are a number of people that have gone though periods of using one and then the other. I have, at least anecdotal, experience with both. I worked on the first release of AIX for IBM. Their lawyers took a couple of years to get comfortable with the Emacs license so I switched to using vi for two or three years. (At one point I had to demo a Lisp system running on AIX at at AAAI conference and I could barely work the built in emacs-based editor.) Eventually, I was able to switch back to Emacs on AIX. My own preference is Emacs for it's breadth of features and its customizations, but I still miss the feeling of speed that I had while navigating source code with Vi or Vim. I still toy with Vim every so often, but I've forgotten so much that I just plod along. Spacemacs is currently on my system, but I usually prefer my own set of customizations and just stick with Emacs and its ordinary bindings. Nevertheless, Spacemacs is an work of genius. I'd encourage everyone to learn basic vi (say what's taught in the tutorial), it's everywhere. After that, IMHO, either of these ancient editors is wonderful and worth adopting. Someday I'm hoping that a new Emacs will be developed built along the lines of Neovim. Digging into the internals of a big Emacs package is pretty painful for me when all I am doing is trying to fix some aspect of my editing experience (see https://xkcd.com/1205/ https://xkcd.com/1205/). I'd like a more modern extension language than elisp. While I'm dreaming, someone please rewrite LaTeX to use a real programming language instead of its Turing complete macro language.
- e12e 11y agoI recall seeing a study that concluded with mouse/gui-based editing being more efficient, even if users felt more efficient using vim. You might want to look at ACME[1]. For me personally, I can't use the mouse much, or my carpal tunnel comes back quickly. So I need a keyboard-only workflow. And I'm happy with vim. "A Tour of the Acme Editor" by Russ Cox https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dP1xVpMPn8M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dP1xVpMPn8M