3 ms·
> Apple, and most of Silicon Valley, thinks and acts like they are more important and powerful than the country that granted them a corporate charter and the pu
by trhway 11y ago
> Apple, and most of Silicon Valley, thinks and acts like they are more important and powerful than the country that granted them a corporate charter and the public infrastructure with which to do business.
Apple was defending the fundamental rights of the public - "we the people" (i.e. country that granted them a corporate charter) - against an agent of said country who tried to overstep the bounds of the power the country (again "we the people") granted them.
The court was the way for the agent to prove what they don't overstep the boundaries of the power that the public granted to the agent, and for all we know the agent failed to do so.
to the "venomsnake" below : i didn't say Apple always defends the fundamental rights, i even didn't say that Apple in this case was motivated by the defense of the fundamental rights. The fact that we do know is that Apple in this case defended the fundamental rights - for whatever motivation, probably for profit as a corporation and that would be my guess is that Tim Cook was doing it for the fundamental rights really or may be just to piss off FBI for fun.
- venomsnake 11y agoIf apple believed in any form of fundamental rights for their users they would have given root, unlocked boot loader and alternative appstores to the people.
- wmichelin 11y agoIf they had given root access, the following things here would be up to the community to create. I don't know why you listed all of these things as if Apple owes them to us.
- venomsnake 11y agoBecause they do. Otherwise you don't own your device, you just rent it. And all of these are fundamental rights of owenership in the digital era.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 11y agoYou can believe in a fundamental right to privacy without a fundamental right to full control over devices. In fact a strong enough emphasis on privacy leads you to restricting the ability of the user to undermine their own security. You dislike apple's methods, which is fine, but it doesn't make them hypocritical.
- venomsnake 11y agoYou can't have privacy without control. It is impossible. You cannot hide from your sysadmin - that is axiom.
- Dylan16807 11y agoUnless you have a staff of experts, you're not going to be able to secure the device yourself. So Apple has to be involved in almost everyone's security whether you like it or not. Putting the user in charge is good for freedom, but it takes you from one failure point to two failure points.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]