3 ms·
I would nuance that: 1. investors were fighting to get their hands on subprime assets. There was so much liquidity around that it was the only way to make a li
by cm2187 11y ago
I would nuance that:
1. investors were fighting to get their hands on subprime assets. There was so much liquidity around that it was the only way to make a little bit of money, very much like today. Investors have been piling cash into tech companies and EM markets where they probably shouldn't have. Is it financial intermediaries' role to bar them from doing so? Is it the supermarket's role to bar you from buying snacks and sodas because it's bad for your health?
2. what annoys me is that these "unsuspecting investors" were professional buyers. It is people who's job it is to do their homework and understand these products. We are not talking about selling complex products to grannies. These are highly educated, highly paid finance professional who simply did not do their job of vetting what they were buying.
Now if Goldman made misrepresentations (i.e. lied) on the nature of the assets, then there is clearly fraud, and by reading quickly the DoJ announcement it seems to be what Goldman is accused of. But in my opinion investors bear a very large part of the blame for this credit bubble. It's not a case of nasty Goldman vs nice unsuspecting investors.
- prostoalex 11y ago> It is people who's job it is to do their homework and understand these products. We are not talking about selling complex products to grannies. These are highly educated, highly paid finance professional who simply did not do their job of vetting what they were buying. Sure, but how many of professional money managers had their clients entire portfolios in subprime mortgages? My guess is that it was mainly allocated to the portions of portfolio deemed "high risk", and if they're not buying subprime mortgages, they're buying high-yield bonds, Puerto Rico munis, assets of bankrupt North Dakota frackers, and high-risk high-yield real estate projects like casinos and theme parks. There's daily trading activity on JNK and MORL and similar other instruments. I don't think there's any pretending going on that those are high-quality assets, and I also doubt anyone (in a clear state of mind with no gambling addiction) is going 100% into those ETFs.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not sure of that. The financial system is built to absorb expected losses. Where things go really wrong is when a big loss occurs where it was not expected. A lot of senior tranches in subprime RMBS had AAA ratings, which made then eligible for safe, low yielding portfolios. Banks could also pile them up on the balance sheet because the RWA footprint was really small given the rating. And that's why when it went "bang" it really hurt.
- prostoalex 11y agoRight, the AAA rating is the cornerstone of the entire thing. On one hand you have originators eager to offload risk, on the other pension fund managers are under the pressure to boost their yields, but are limited into what they can invest. The credit agencies are to blame, but they were an enabler. AIG FP was the main cause of the AAA rating by simply lending its name to the whole deal and promising to make the pension funds whole in case of any defaults.
- nradov 11y agoThis is another reason why defined benefit pension plans are a bad idea and ought to be discouraged as a matter of public policy. Pension fund managers tend to take excessive risks in order to meet unrealistic return targets. They have little personal stake in the outcome and if they fail then employers and taxpayers are forced to cover the gap. As a thought experiment, consider what would have happened if that money had instead been in defined contribution retirement plans utilizing low-cost index funds. I think that would have reduced the severity of the financial crisis.
- inthewoods 11y ago"2. what annoys me is that these "unsuspecting investors" were professional buyers. It is people who's job it is to do their homework and understand these products. We are not talking about selling complex products to grannies. These are highly educated, highly paid finance professional who simply did not do their job of vetting what they were buying. Now if Goldman made misrepresentations (i.e. lied) on the nature of the assets, then there is clearly fraud, and by reading quickly the DoJ announcement it seems to be what Goldman is accused of. But in my opinion investors bear a very large part of the blame for this credit bubble. It's not a case of nasty Goldman vs nice unsuspecting investors." Well, it's a combination. Goldman packages up crappy mortgages as bonds, then has the rating agencies rate them and magically transform them into Triple AAA instead of junk. The due diligence required of the investor, even a profession investor, is rather extreme - and having the rating agencies in your pocket only makes that worse.