7 ms·
People like to claim that background checks are used when someone is placed into a trusted position. However in my experience lower end jobs (where you're often
by Someone1234 11y ago
People like to claim that background checks are used when someone is placed into a trusted position. However in my experience lower end jobs (where you're often trusted less) are often much MORE likely to have a background check.
To give a specific example: Work in a fast food place handling small amounts of cash and they'll background check you. Work in a company handling SSNs, Credit Cards, and medical records and they didn't even ask me if I had a criminal record (I don't).
So I cannot help but wonder if ex-convicts are going to suffer more while getting a low end job than they would if they were applying for high end positions. I guess the assumption is if you have a degree that you are somehow above crime...
I guess that's why so called "white collar crime" often goes undetected for longer and is often more successful overall.
- lettergram 11y agoThat may be your experience, but having worked for a large medical billing and large bank, both do heavy background checks. I've even been finger printed, and had my Facebook searched.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoYour Facebook searched? What do you mean?
- lettergram 11y agoI mean, they asked for my login information to search my Facebook. I actually declined, but they still ran through all the public information and connections I had.
- tibbon 11y agoBest answers I can think of here: "I'm sorry, I don't use Facebook as it seems an invasion of personal privacy" or "Ok, here's my Facebook account" and then give them some uber-sanitized account that just has photos of kittens and messages on your mom's wall about her cookies.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoIn case one, wouldn't it be incredibly obvious that you're lying, and in the second case, only marginally plausible that you keep such an empty, vanilla profile?
- matwood 11y agoSo not having a facebook account means I'm lying? I really do not have a facebook account so I guess by definition I'm a lier :/
- pavel_lishin 11y agoNo, that was addressed to tibbon's comment, which I read as him actually having a Facebook account.
- lmkg 11y agoActually, one valid answer is "That's illegal in the state of California." It works best if you're actually in California, but even if not, it might give them pause.
- facetube 11y agoThat results in them finding a different excuse to not hire you and then documenting it in case you sue.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoWhy not: Here is my link to my facebook portal (include public link). I cannot give you my credentials because I am in a legal agreement with facebook to not give my credentials to anyone.
- erroneousfunk 11y agoHad your Facebook searched? Does that mean they ask for your login and look through it, or look through all the publicly-available information?
- lettergram 11y agoI mean, they asked for my login information to search my Facebook. I declined, but they still ran through all the public information and connections I had. Later, I worked on some of their creepy background checking software. Essentially, without the login, they can still get all the information about me they need.
- jeromegv 11y agoThis will of course depend on your existing privacy settings.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoThose change over time so Facebook exposes more of your information you meant to keep hidden. I have to check my Facebook every few months to find out what sort of content is now visible to a new group of people that was hidden by me in the past.
- sghodas 11y agoReally? I haven't found that to be the case. Everything that I've set to specific privacy groups (me only, friends, etc) has stayed the same.
- ipsin 11y agoIf this happens to anyone else, just quote Facebook's Statement of Rights and Responsibilities. https://www.facebook.com/terms https://www.facebook.com/terms 4. You will not share your password (or in the case of developers, your secret key), let anyone else access your account, or do anything else that might jeopardize the security of your account. It's not iron-clad, but it may dissuade the nosy.
- psykpsyk 11y agoHad your Facebook searched? Either you were really desperate for a job or you're spineless...
- richardthered 11y agoYou've had your Facebook searched? What was that process like? I've gone through tons of background checks / drug screens for federal and state governments, and financial companies. But I've never had a Facebook search... Is that even legal?
- vitd 11y agoIt's legal, though I believe Facebook has stated that it's against their terms of service.
- matwood 11y agoThey have probably looked at your public facebook.
- matwood 11y agoFYI http://m.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/2016/04/opm-seeking-social-media-tracking-background-checks/127380/ http://m.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/2016/04/opm-seeking-social...
- hobs 11y agoYeah, temporary firms/staffing agencies are huge consumers of background checks, and they often are just hiring someone to run a machine/be an admin.
- Kinnard 11y agoHow bizarre, this seems economically unjustifiable, that is to say— I smell a rat.
- whatok 11y agoBelieve it all comes down to insurance and having someone else to blame. Think about why most jobs use urine instead of hair for drug testing. Hell of a lot cheaper, don't care about accuracy, and just want to be able to say that they did it.
- superuser2 11y agoNothing compared to the reputation damage and fallout when something happens and the client is incredulous. "You hired a felon?"
- adrusi 11y agoThe rich are just suspicious of the poor. They trust people from similar backgrounds as themselves. Employers irrationally think they can gauge a person's trustworthiness just by interacting with them for a few hours during an interview. And trustworthiness is virtually impossible to test for in higher paying roles: people earning low wages ususally don't have the power to defraud the company too much, but there's a lot of people with that limited power so they're a threat. Wealthier employees could engage in petty fraud too, but they have less incentive to do so because they don't need the money as much, and there's not as many of them, so even if they did it would be less damaging. Instead the concern over richer, more skilled and educated employees is that they'll steal large amounts from the company, and unless they end up in prison, nobody will ever know (contrast with working-class fraud which will usually only end up losing the person their job, so there's less incentive to avoid being caught). There's probably no conspiracy, just generalized classism.
- iamdave 11y agoI definitely observed this phenomenon while I was out of work for a little while, and even directly asked the recruiter when looking at two roles on their career portal: "Why does the lower wage, lower responsibility, and lower risk job come with higher barriers for employment eligibility than its managerial counterpart?" She asked what I meant so I spelled it out more directly "Why does a file clerk role require a background check, credit check and drug screen but this role here, a Senior accounting role asks only for relevant job history?" She admitted she didn't know. I wish I could say this was limited to that company, but I saw it so much over the course of about 3 months that I started to really wonder what the hell is going on..
- morgante 11y agoClassism lies at the heart of it. If someone is in a lower income job, higher ups are desperate to avoid hiring the "wrong sort of those people." In higher end jobs, they'll readily make excuses for past behavior (oh, it was just a youthful mistake). It sometimes amazes me that I've been hired into positions where I could have singlehandedly cost a company millions of dollars in revenue, but never had a single background check. ---- Of course, a much more charitable explanation would be that there's an "efficiency wage" effect behind background checks. For good jobs, the job itself is good enough that employers assume you'd be stupid to somehow jeopardize it by stealing or committing a crime. In contrast, shitty retail jobs are bad and everybody knows it—the company assumes that your loss from the job wouldn't be big enough to offset the gains you might make from stealing. This could be a similar explanation for why immigrants commit fewer crimes: they have more to lose.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Classism lies at the heart of it. This seems overly-dramatic. The reality is that there is a lot of petty crime with people who handle cash, compared to those on a white collar career path. Petty crime happens so often its not even reported, and white collar crime is so rare it makes the news, so you may be skewed to think that casual stealing from retail employers is rare, but it certainly is not. On top of it, the kinds of people most likely to work with a cash register are those who are largely unknowns. Yes, I do trust the guy with 15 years experience in finance more compared to the teen getting his first or second job to better handle money. Also criminality goes down with age. Experience tells me 15 year career guy has made it this far without getting arrested and has a lot of skin the in the game. Its not "classist" to think so. Its basic risk analysis. Just because something seems distasteful to you doesn't mean its wrong. I wish more people understood this simple concept. That said, I've gotten background checked at every white collar job I've had. Companies need a CYA for new hires and that's how its typically done. This has been the standard in my field for decades. Not sure where the idea that white collar people are immune from background checks comes from. It certainly isn't common in my peer group. It may also be that a lot of entry level retail jobs are mostly from large corporate employers who have top-down policies regarding background checks. Sure, Walmart did a check on you but your uncle didn't for a summer job filling out TPS reports at his company. That's not a sign of a conspiracy, but different values/risk assumption from two different organizations.
- valine 11y agoThe company I interned for last year year ran a background check on me. I kept getting emails from them requesting 10 years of work history. In 2005 I was 8 years old. I think they put me down as unemployed.
- whatok 11y agoI also had a background check asking for ten years of history. Many of the companies were either out of business or outsourced HR which created issues. I also ran into an issue with job titles not matching exactly or external job title (which I was familiar with from the hiring process) not matching up with internal title (which I was not familiar with at all). The month or so of back and forth on this was easily the most stressful period of my life.
- Gibbon1 11y agoAiiiigghhh! When I was 8 years old Jimmy Hendrix was still alive.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoMy own experience has been background checks always. Work with military data was by far the most extensive (required approved clearance). Government positions were the most varied, with one being very thorough (not quite as bad as the military), and an other being the least intensive. Financial institution were middle of the road. But everywhere where I had database access required a background check and only one place didn't require a drug test. The lower income positions I worked required neither. One thing I did notice from my friends is that smaller shops are less likely to have institutionalize policies. A small startup is less likely to background check you than a fast food chain likely has a policy requiring it. But this applies to any large organizations, not just lower income positions.