3 ms·
And in next week's issue of "Gross Misunderstandings of the Very Nature of the Economy": Hot New Trend: Breaking Your Own Windows to Stimulate the Economy.
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
And in next week's issue of "Gross Misunderstandings of the Very Nature of the Economy": Hot New Trend: Breaking Your Own Windows to Stimulate the Economy.
- jriddycuz 17y agoIt really is the broken window fallacy, but in reverse; that working harder could decrease aggregate employment implies that working less hard (or more counter-productively) could increase aggregate employment. This is even more hare-brained than the suggestion that we should all work less to allow more people to be employed. Increases in productivity (e.g. working harder) can only be harmful in a closed economy with very fixed consumption practices. Pretty much any country or region, however, cannot be said to exist in isolation, nor does it have fixed consumption. When either world interest rates go to 0% or people become miraculously content with everything they have, let me know so I can slack off, but until then I'm gonna keep working.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- fburnaby 17y ago>It really is the broken window fallacy, but in reverse; that working harder could decrease aggregate employment implies that working less hard (or more counter-productively) could increase aggregate employment. Not all system responses are reversible. I can start working really hard, making it feasible for my company to lay someone else off. I could later stop working so hard, but there's no reason to expect that job to come back. > This is even more hare-brained than the suggestion that we should all work less Did the article make a suggestion? I think it was more of a scientific statement that this would happen. Of course in a global competitive market it's irrational for any single individual to start working less. That in no way refutes the claim being made. Depoliticize for a second and consider the claims being made. Your stance is right, but you have no need to defend it here.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- timr 17y agoOh, come on, folks...do you really think that the authors of a paper on the website of the New York Federal Reserve Bank aren't aware of the same bit of pop economics that any armchair economist can read on Wikipedia? I suspect that the original paper merits a refutation of slightly greater weight than the parent comment.
- codexon 17y agoThe problem is that the many Austrian economists here feel they are smart enough to disregard the foundations of modern economics. And thus they will use the "broken window fallacy" to refute everything. For everyone else here that has not jumped on the Austrian bandwagon, read the following to understand why you should not be parroting a school of thought that is based on what the founders think is "logical" rather than the scientific method: http://www.gmu.edu/depts/economics/bcaplan/whyaust.htm http://www.gmu.edu/depts/economics/bcaplan/whyaust.htm