3 ms·
This is correct. However, it's still strane to mention ages in this context. Just replace age descriptions with race descriptions to see how weird and out of p
by golergka 11y ago
This is correct. However, it's still strane to mention ages in this context.
Just replace age descriptions with race descriptions to see how weird and out of place that is.
> She was white, had been with the company for four years, and was told without explanation by her latino manager that she had two weeks to get out.
- halestock 11y agoAge implies wisdom and experience, which I think was the point he was trying to get across. Comparing it to race is just silly.
- aianus 11y ago> Age implies wisdom and experience Age implies obsoleteness and poor health. (I can stereotype too!)
- Dylan16807 11y agoNot in your 30s. If you're trying to prove halestock wrong you're doing a poor job.
- pascalo 11y agoThe way I read it he used the age and gender info in his comment to illustrate that it would be harder for the person to get a job. Hence it being extra cruel to use the weird lingo and act like it wouldn't be hard for her.
- golergka 11y agoIt does. However, it's the matter of how strong that causation is and how hard are you going to rely on it. Because if you think that someone in their 30s is likely to be be significantly more experienced and wise, it also means that you should think that someone in their 50s is likely to be significantly burned out and slow. My point is: the correlation (and underlying causation) is there, but it's not strong enough, compared to differences between individuals.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "Just replace age descriptions with race descriptions to see how weird and out of place that is." How is that in any way a sound analogy? Your age likely has an impact on your experience. More experience doesn't necessarily mean you're better at your job but it's a decent possibility. Race has no impact on performance at all.
- golergka 11y agoRace does not impact perfomance, but there's a correlation between race and education, for example (because ages of institutial discrimination, of course). Do you think people should take this correlation into consideration when talking about others?
- rhizome 11y agoI highly recommend double-checking your work on this line of thinking.
- bduerst 11y agoThey're pointing out the flaws in the logic of biasing based on characteristics, of both race and age. Obviously nobody is going to discount a manager because of their race, but on that same coin people shouldn't discount the same individual because of their age.