14 ms·
The Blue State Model: How the Democrats Created a "Liberalism of the Rich"
- pink_dinner 11y agoIt's always interesting to see rich liberal cities like San Francisco because there is really no middle class. You are either making lots of money in IT or some other business or you can't afford your rent and are barely scraping by. You don't see this as much in cities that are not as liberally run.
- godzillabrennus 11y agoDetroit is a city historically run by Democrats and is a very affordable. Chicago is relatively affordable and historically is run by Democrats. There will continue to be going to be growing levels of income inequality as automation continues to increase. Either we focus on solving that (Minimal Viable Income sounds like a plan) or we face a true million man March on DC. Something has to change.
- gedy 11y agoProblem with these "million man marches", and other mass movements is, even when they are successful, one oppressive elite is just replaced by another.
- ajmurmann 11y agoEven more reason to preempt it.
- masterleep 11y agoDetroit is more or less a smoking crater at the moment, and Chicago is a smoking crater to come. For that you can thank the wise, forward-thinking stewardship of the Democrats.
- godzillabrennus 11y agoIn Chicago and it's far from a smoking crater to come. The university system is great and let's not forget that Ruby on Rails was born here.
- brobinson 11y agoDHH lived in Denmark when he created the first version of Rails. He didn't move to the US until the end of 2005. He was employed by a Chicago-based company, though.
- vibrato 11y agoLet's hope the universities don't shut down, then. That certainly wouldn't bode well for the surging homicide rate.
- SwellJoe 11y agoThat's a simplistic interpretation of the facts. Detroit is a burned out shell of a city for a wide variety of reasons; very few of those reasons have much to do with local politicians. Trade agreements at the national level probably tell as much of the story as any individual element. But, strategic failures of US car makers also plays a role. And, a rapidly evolving global economic environment also plays a role. Certainly there has been mismanagement of the city of Detroit, sometimes on an absurd and possibly criminal scale. But, to chalk it all of to "Democrats did this" is...well, it leaves a whole lot of the story out. Note that I'm not a Democrat and not defending politicians in any general case. But, I do think it's silly to make the claim that local Democrats caused Detroit's decline, when there are clearly so many other factors in the story.
- ktRolster 11y agoIf 'un-affordability' caused million man marches, then we'd already have seen a dozen of them in San Francisco. The solution, building more housing, is simple, well-known, and obvious, but the people who live there don't want it because it will hurt their property values. It's a classic case of entrenched power vs newcomers.
- adrenalinelol 11y agoI have trouble imagining a policy resembling basic income being politically feasible in the U.S. People who rely on the major entitlement programs already in place (medicare, medicaid, and social security) have very humble lifestyles, and despite this nearly all the political dialogue around these programs is reduction of benefits. A concept like basic income would require the government to collect more taxes on an order of magnitude greater than it already does; I really don't see that happening in our current political climate.
- x0054 11y agoI love it how all the comments to your post center about the infighting between democrats and republicans, and no one wants to talk about the hot potato that is automation. I am not sure if MVI would even be enough at this point. I strongly believe that we are heading for a complete, world wide, economic collapse within the next 30 years. The collapse will not be caused by our failure to correctly apply our current economic theories, but the complete invalidation of the basic economic principles on which those theories are based. To be clear, I am not arguing that capitalism is an invalid theory right now, but it will become invalid with automation, and very soon. And before people rebut this argument with: "this has happened before, and people will just get education and find better jobs" I challenge you, please do, tell me, what job will you get when the robot/AI replaces you? The answer isn't to fear the future though, but to embrace it and figure out how to make it work for everyone. It's a little hard to do that, and to have this conversation, when the overwhelming majority of people refuse to consider this inevitability as even a possibility and dismiss it. Oh well, rent over.
- pessimizer 11y agoThis is a fantasy. Productivity growth is catastrophically low, and over the last 40 years has averaged about half of what it was in the 30 years before - and since the crash in 2008, been slower than at any time after WWII. http://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm http://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp15116.pdf https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp15116.pdf It's global: https://www.conference-board.org/data/economydatabase/ https://www.conference-board.org/data/economydatabase/ "An alarming result from this year’s estimates in The Conference Board Total Economy Database(TM) is that the growth rate of total factor productivity (TFP), which measures the productivity of labor and capital together, continues to hover around zero for the third year in a row, compared to an average rate of more than 1 percent from 1999-2006 and 0.5 percent from 2007-2012. The challenge on TFP growth is widespread across the globe. Most mature economies including the United States, the Euro Area and Japan show near zero or even negative TFP growth. In China, TFP growth has turned negative, and in India it is just above zero, at 0.2 percent. Both in Brazil and Mexico TFP growth continues to be negative, respectively at -2.3 and -1.7 percent."
- drfuchs 11y agoSF was liberal decades before it was rich. Makes you wonder about possible causality.
- pron 11y agoI don't think Thomas Frank would view the kind of rich SF is as a positive. It is more unequal than rich -- unequal with a peculiarly liberal flavor -- and I believe he would agree to causality (relating to the "new kind" of liberalism).
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago"Liberal" has always been a word so loaded with ambiguity it's practically meaningless. Socially liberal is not the same as economically liberal is not the same as politically liberal is not the same as anti-authoritarian is not the same as Democrat. (And so on.) In fact I think the argument comes down to four positions: I want as much as possible and I don't see why I should care about anyone or anything else I want as much as possible but I suppose I have to care a little about other people because otherwise the non-winners will kill me and eat me Exploiting other people is morally wrong Exploiting other people creates economically and politically disastrous network effects so it's important to allow people the economic freedom to move beyond exploitation They should be clearly distinct. But in the US they're all tinged with rhetoric of crusading personal heroism and slightly manic social signalling, so it can be paradoxically hard to tell them apart.
- ktRolster 11y agoSocialism is another of those words. If you say, "that country is socialist" no one has any idea what you're talking about, you have to explain it. So better to use a different word in the first place.
- jessriedel 11y ago> because there is really no middle class. You are either [X] or [Y] Do you actually think some important distribution is bimodal, or are you just describing your mental categorization?
- jkaptur 11y agoI'm no expert, but I just searched "income distribution in san francisco" and found [1]. The chart labelled "Distribution of median household income in 2013 (number of people)" indicates a multimodal distribution of income. The smallest bar on the chart is the 50k-60k bucket - a traditional "middle class". Of course, there's plenty to quibble about. I've never heard of city-data.com. Maybe this distribution looks more normal if you don't bucket everyone >200k together. But I'm curious where you were headed with your comment. Is there a more important distribution that I just didn't find? [1] http://www.city-data.com/income/income-San-Francisco-California.html http://www.city-data.com/income/income-San-Francisco-Califor...
- jessriedel 11y agoThe bar plot available at your link isn't helpful. It's not just the $200k+ group: the width of the income buckets jumps around from bucket to bucket ($60k-$75k, then $75k-$100k), so of course it has weird structure! My point is that whenever people start mentally divvying up the population discretely (introverts vs. extroverts, rich vs. poor, etc.), this is almost always a mistake; it's a projection of their mental map onto reality, when in fact the variable under discussion is almost always smoothly distributed.
- Maarten88 11y agoI thought it was very helpful: in my mind a healthy society would have some sort of bayesian distribution in income, where most of the people would fall into the middle, few would be rich and few would be poor . These charts look nothing like that.
- jessriedel 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoUrl changed from http://billmoyers.com/story/the-blue-state-model/ http://billmoyers.com/story/the-blue-state-model/, which points to this. This is a political story that has a chance of clearing the 'unusually interesting' bar so let's give it a try. Frank's model of the 'professional class' (a.k.a. top 10%) as the key socioeconomic faultline is an interesting one that deserves a good discussion. If the thread turns into partisan or ideological bickering, we'll demote it. Let's stay substantive.
- pron 11y agoMaybe OT, but I think the main difference between this story and many other stories on HN is that this story is overtly political, while many other stories (from basic income, through what kinds of technology investors should invest in, to Bitcoin and OSS project governance) are not any less political, just less self-aware of that fact. Actually, HN has more political stories than any other tech-oriented site I'm aware of. I believe that doing and talking about politics while claiming to be apolitical or being unaware of the politics involved just guarantees bad politics. Politics is the practice of affecting how power and resources are distributed in society, and doing/discussing "inadvertent" politics -- a staple of HN, IMO -- is often worse than "unconstructive", polarized, overtly political debates, because while the latter may be futile, the former actively blinds people to politics; it makes them less aware of their role in society.
- jt2190 11y agoThe central premise of the article is faulty: That Democratic policies (or "Innovation Liberalism") created the divide between the wealthy and the working class in Massachusetts, when in fact it has always been the opposite: The divide was already there, and the party in power serves to maintain it while playing lip service to some ideals.
- dang 11y agoYou may be right, but an article with a faulty central premise can still be interesting and worth discussing. It would be better to post your observation as a top-level comment and better still to make it engage more with the specific claims of the OP. (It's also possible that that's not really Frank's central premise, given that this is a excerpt from a book on a larger topic.)
- maxander 11y agoPart of me wants to be a loyal Bostonian and defend my hometown- most of the evils described in the article could be found in any other state, Republican- or Democrat-run alike. But the point about innovation rhetoric does strike true. The "innovation district" is full of big pharma and etc companies that would have had an easy time finding offices anywhere; most of the time when the i-word is trotted out, its because someone is either offering tax breaks to some giant corporation to entice them to grace us with their presence, or launching some gaudy public cheerleading event that no one really cares about. But substantial issues relating to the "creative class"? Such as, for instance, effective public transit? Suddenly the state and city can't spare a dime; its not a "priority"; students and post-car intellectuals (and, incidentally, the working class) are stuck paying through the nose to get on a subway that's broken again. Or, taking an Uber because its past midnight. (Late night service was great for the six months it lasted!) There are other issues of a similar bent; there's a fight going on in Somerville (the neighborhood of MIT, Harvard, and Tufts students, now that Cambridge property deeds come platinum-plated) to allow more than four unrelated individuals to share a house. And they're facing fierce resistance. Most of us who can head to the west coast at the first opportunity; Boston would be SF if it wasn't for its outright hostility to the bright minds pouring out of its universities. The scale of the wasted opportunity is staggering.
- Thriptic 11y ago> But substantial issues relating to the "creative class"? Such as, for instance, effective public transit? Suddenly the state and city can't spare a dime; its not a "priority"; students and post-car intellectuals (and, incidentally, the working class) are stuck paying through the nose to get on a subway that's broken again. Or, taking an Uber because its past midnight. (Late night service was great for the six months it lasted!) I couldn't agree more. The area just absolutely does not give a shit about infrastructure. It took Google coming into Kendall square to get the jacked up sidewalks and roads fixed outside of MIT, and the Longfellow bridge restoration project has been consistently extended. Meanwhile, up the block in Central square we have major Novartis, Takeda, J&J, and Pfizer research centers going in with no apparent consideration for how these workers will commute in and out. Cambridge seems more concerned with forcing people to use reusable bags for shopping than they are with actually instituting useful change.
- themgt 11y agoA major problem I see in the US, compared to basically anywhere else in the world I've lived, is sprawl. Seemingly every other developed country has done a much better job of having the vast majority of people live in at least medium-density areas, which has all sorts of benefits, especially a lower cost of infrastructure/public transportation, and encouraging mixed-use development with small owner-operated businesses and markets within walking distance serving day-to-day needs. All of this helps encourage a more communal, broad-based and functioning working/middle class economy. Whereas the US tends to have a huge divide between high-density "downtown" area and then low density suburbs to exurbs, mixed with island apartment complexes and served almost solely by massive chain stores. I remember moving back to the US from France and landed in one of those terrible cookie-cutter apartment complexes, and one day walking to the central mail box I thought to myself: "I am walking farther to get my mail in the US than I did in France to get to a grocery store, bakery, meat shop or tram line." The nearest place I could buy any food was a gas station with processed crap and soda, 3/4 of a mile away. In France I could walk a block to a mini-market with tons of fresh vegetables, cheese and fresh-baked still-warm bread.
- ajmurmann 11y agoZoning rules in the US are one thing I will never understand. Especially since it is very anti market and the US seems to believe on a free market more than most countries. I wonder if it has to do with suburbs of American cities being much more planned than most other city areas. Planned residential areas in Europe suffer from the same problems. Maybe the US just had more planned instead of grown areas?
- iambenrussell 11y agoThe main reasons for zoning are cultural. For some reason or another, US households and governments have a greater preference for income segregation (keeping apartments away from wealthy neighborhoods) and "quiet" residential areas. The fears are/were that the natural beauty of certain types of development would be spoiled by low-income housing, factories, and commerce. Of course, as you say, it's very any I - market. People already tend to naturally cluster based on income, level of education, desire for public goods, etc, so it shouldn't be necessary to have such restrictions. It inevitably comes down to money, too, where minimum lot size restrictions shut out potential tenants/owners who can afford the per square foot cost in low quantities but not a large property. These restrictions are supposed to ensure a high enough tax yield per dwelling, but it's in the name of beautification. You could say it all goes back to the car. When it suddenly became much cheaper for low income people to move out of the city center and commute from traditionally rich suburban areas, the rich got scared. Some moved further away, but governments also used zoning laws to make sure to poor stayed in the city, where they belonged.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 11y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11462513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11462513
- hackuser 11y agoA direct link: http://www.salon.com/2016/04/02/whats_the_matter_with_dem_thomas_frank_talks_bill_clinton_barack_obama_and_everything_in_between_partner/ http://www.salon.com/2016/04/02/whats_the_matter_with_dem_th...
- ScottBurson 11y agoAt a 2014 celebration of Governor Patrick’s innovation leadership, Google’s Eric Schmidt announced that “if you want to solve the economic problems of the U.S., create more entrepreneurs.” I'm a Bernie Sanders supporter, but I totally agree with Eric Schmidt here. In fact, I would go so far as to say that the growing incubator/accelerator industry, of which YC is at the vanguard, is one of the most hopeful, encouraging things happening in the world today. I think it's ridiculous that Paul Graham has to defend himself against charges of exacerbating inequality, when he's done as much as anyone to start the economy down a new path. (Disclosure: I have not applied to YC or any other accelerator, but I might in the future.) So -- is this too much of a contradiction, to be what this author calls an "innovation liberal" while supporting a populist/socialist candidate? Economic change, of the kind the US is now going through, is always wrenching and painful; there are always people on the back side of the curve who suffer. I think the challenge for government is to craft policies that support the changes, and those driving them, while not excessively punishing those left behind. I think that broadly, the pendulum in the US has swung too far in the direction of minimizing the safety net in support of individual responsibility, and the surprising success the Sanders campaign is having -- Bernie himself did not think, a year ago, that he could get as far as he has -- shows that the public mood is starting to swing back the other way. I think that's healthy, to a point, and that's why I'm supporting him. Let's not make this a discussion about Bernie, though. I recognize he is not perfect, and I'm not even 100% certain he would make a good President. I just think the issues he is raising deserve a larger hearing.
- jeremyt 11y agoIt always puzzles me to hear people say that they think the social safety net "pendulum" has been swinging too far in the direction of personal responsibility. By any measure, social safety net spending is significantly higher than it has ever been. News comes out every day of some new government mandate like paid parental leave, paid personal days, etc. The minimum wage is creeping higher every day. Social Security, Medicaid, and Medicare spending has never been higher. We just passed a massive, expensive, entitlement known as Obamacare, which provides (or was supposed to) health insurance to everyone in America. Obama, during his first term, passed a massive expansion of government-subsidized student loans. We are in the process of a significant expansion of home loans for low income and people with dodgy credit. Except for the very limited, bipartisan, welfare reform under President Clinton (which has since basically been reversed), I'm not aware of any shrinking of the welfare state that has happened in the last 20 years.
- darawk 11y agoI'm genuinely curious: what is the alternative here? Keep taxis around? Encourage people to take more manufacturing jobs? These don't seem like sustainable or viable alternatives. Over the coming years, all jobs are going to require an element of creativity, innovation, and probably some degree of higher education (not necessarily university-based, but some form of specialized, knowledge-intensive learning). This is something that is inevitable, and it's coming up fast. To the extent that we subsidize and protect dying industries to maintain the jobs of their workers, we hinder their retrainment in new professions and further entrench the inefficiencies of the past. In even the medium term, this is nothing but harmful. Now, I think there are things that probably can and should be done to help these people get into new jobs. Subsidizing retraining and education, providing interim assistance to help them get through these periods, and maybe eventually even a universal basic income (fundamentally the economics of this probably don't make sense quite yet, but I think they will in the future). But what is fundamentally not ok, what is never ok, is shielding dying industries under the aegis of employment.
- pron 11y agoThe word "inevitable" always makes me uneasy. I think it usually embodies an actual observation, combined with a certain agenda and/or a lack of imagination. That technological progress is inevitable is one thing; that it benefits mostly a certain class of people is another. On a more philosophical level, I am not at all certain that efficiency should be society's goal[1], but I think that at least for the foreseeable future, fighting such unquestioned axioms is an uphill battle... [1]: It's fascinating how long it took in the early modern period to convince society that efficiency is a desirable goal at all; see Max Weber's classic 1905 book, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.
- darawk 11y agoYa, I grant you that 'inevitable' is probably too strong. But it does seem that way to me, and that also seems to be the prevailing opinion. And, at the risk of misinterpreting you or putting words in your mouth, I think you may be interpreting 'efficiency' as necessarily squeezing more and more out of workers. And this is, in general, true. However, efficiency can also ultimately mean a society where people no longer have to work at all - where only a comparatively small number of people need to be engaged in intense knowledge work, and the rest of civilization can live entirely from the fruits of those people's labors, and the automated production processes they operate and advance.
- x0054 11y agoMy wife refers to this problem as the Alan Shore Democrats (Alan Shore from Boston Legal TV Show). People who care about the plight of the working poor, but then you find out that they only do so to appease the poor so they don't rise up and revolt against the status quo. It's the politics of fear. Democrats yell "Vote for me, I will keep those evil republicans from making abortion and being gay illegal." And the Republicans yell "Vote for me, I will keep those sodomites and baby killers in check." They paint the other side as evil, split the poor people in half, and stay in power. The truth is, they desperately need each other, because, if people stopped hating their neighbor for a second, and turned around, they might realize that they are being fucked by their elected officials on both sides.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vacri 11y agoThey might even realise that you can't have only two parties represent a population of 300 million people in a multicultural society spread all the way across a continent, sea-to-sea.
- cs702 11y agoThe main claim is that today's liberal establishment has no patience with the idea that everyone should share in society’s wealth. Instead, what today's liberal establishment really pines for, the author writes, is a more perfect meritocracy. Unfortunately, there is no solidarity in a perfect meritocracy, for the ideology of meritocracy negates any esteem society's winners might feel for poorly educated, low-achieving losers. Rings True.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fiatmoney 11y agoYou can understand a lot of "progressive" policy as devoted to screwing the white working class as hard as possible (and in fact a lot of the white working class does see it through that lens, which is why, eg, Trump sees such support from that demographic). For instance: - Hollowing out icky manufacturing & extraction-sector jobs, while ensuring maximal support for FIRE & "knowledge sector" jobs via IP protections & lax regulations. - Importing vast amounts of cheap labor to compete for service-sector jobs. - Ensuring that "live in an expensive neighborhood" is the only mechanism to ensure your children go to vaunted "good schools" (or even safe schools). - Devoting recurring two-minutes-hates to attacking their cultural symbols.
- paulpauper 11y agoWhat Thomas Frank does not realize, or is ignoring, is that it's still the 'elite' who create jobs, and antipathy towards them won't improve the situation for the millions who are without work. The reality is, without job creators, most people wold fail, as the success rate for entrepreneurship is very low.
- apalmer 11y agoNot sure that the whole ideal of job creators really holds up in the light of day. Or rather job creators as 'elites' with enormous amounts of capitalism and economies of scale dont drive jobs growth. I guess its a matter of scale... A single WalMart certainly employs less people and provides lower salaries than the 20 small businesses it replaces... If by elite we are including the typical small business owners then yeah they are job creators... If by elite we are talking the investor class executive class then not in aggreememt
- paulpauper 11y ago'investor class' you realize that businesses don't spring out the ground like plants, right. typically, someone has to invest
- Maarten88 11y agoOr something, like a pension fund or a bank... It doesn't have to be someone rich.
- ktRolster 11y agoIt's complex because there are job creators, and there are bankers and investors who create value in the country, and generally make the world a better place. At the same time, there are also corrupt thieves wearing corporate clothes, who destroy companies and sell them off in pieces; there are bankers who lie and cheat and buy laws to make them money; there are senators who use insider information on the stock market, or connections in other ways to make money. So how to keep the good while getting rid of the bad? That is the central question.
- rayiner 11y ago> What Massachusetts liberals pine for, by and large, is a more perfect meritocracy -- a system where the essential thing is to ensure that the truly talented get into the right schools and then get to rise through the ranks of society. This rings true, and explains a couple of the key failings of modern American society. Liberals' wholesale embrace of meritocracy combined with their traditional alignment with public unions has manifested in this bizarre fixation with education. Education has become the sole means for achieving traditional liberal goals within the framework of meritocracy. That trend has directly resulted in the college bubble: a society where everybody spends inordinate amounts of money getting an education that for most of them is a waste if time. More fundamentally, the leadership of the liberal establishment doesn't seem to really believe in the idea of a flat, egalitarian society. Among the liberal elite in San Francisco, D.C., Boston, etc, there is an intense disdain for the folks who form the backbone of the middle class in other industrialized countries: non-college educated blue and white collar workers. In places like Germany, you can get a white collar job and live a middle class life with just 16 years of formal education. In the U.S., even the liberals don't seem to think that is a desirable state of affairs.
- Futurebot 11y agoIt's worse because 1) even with the "best and brightest" in charge, we've had one disaster after another and 2) the "meritocracy" we have is horribly broken on its own terms. Making the meritocracy we imagine should exist would require fairly radical reforms in terms of taxes, redistribution, college funding and regulation, youth economic and educational support, and a whole host of other interventions that supporters of the present establishment find anywhere from distasteful to anathema. "In public life, our pillar institutions and the elites who run them play the mechanic’s role. They are charged with the task of diagnosing and fixing problems in governance, the market, and society. And what we want from authorities, whether they are mechanics, money managers, or senators, is that they be competent—smart, informed, able—and that they not use their authority to pursue a hidden agenda or personal gain. We now operate in a world in which we can assume neither competence nor good faith from the authorities, and the consequences of this simple, devastating realization is the defining feature of American life at the end of this low, dishonest decade. Elite failure and the distrust it has spawned is the most powerful and least understood aspect of current politics and society." "..what we’ve seen time and time again is that the two aren’t so neatly separated. If you don’t concern yourself at all with equality of outcomes, you will, over time, produce a system with horrendous inequality of opportunity. This is the paradox of meritocracy: It can only truly come to flower in a society that starts out with a relatively high degree of equality. So if you want meritocracy, work for equality. Because it is only in a society which values equality of actual outcomes, one that promotes the commonweal and social solidarity, that equal opportunity and earned mobility can flourish." - Chris Hayes, Twilight of the Elites There's a good reason social mobility in places like Denmark is so high compared to the US; they do meritocracy better.
- golemotron 11y agoThis is a complex topic but the article is dead-on. Scott Alexander wrote years ago that the US has created a divide that he calls Blue Tribe vs. Red Tribe that is far deeper than Dem vs. Repub - it's cultural. Today it is extremely common for someone in the "blue tribe" to know no one who is in the "red tribe" - people who (to use a few stereotypes) are Christian, enjoy NASCAR, and unabashedly eat at chain restaurants. People in either tribe don't encounter each other daily and as a result both tribes have little understanding of each other's worlds or the number of people who are not in their tribe. Inequality is deeply problematic and there are no easy solutions. Liberalism recognizes this. The problem is that the tribal line now runs along an economic fault line. Red tribe hasn't been doing well - red states are full of disadvantaged people. Worse, because of identity politics they have been made "the other" and rendered relatively voiceless. Liberalism can champion the disadvantaged but it has to approach them with solutions. As technological displacement of workers continues it is hard to see what they will be. I am blue tribe but I flinch when I see my colleagues in the tech industry complain about things like the injustice of having to go to a whiteboard in an interview to get a job in a Crèche-like work environment with play-balls while people outside the industry are lucky to get jobs driving cars, cleaning tables, or lifting boxes without health insurance. We don't see our own sense of entitlement. It is transparent to others despite our liberal signaling. This isn't going to be a pretty ride.
- ae_keji 11y agoUnfortunately I believe the rise of the fourth economic stage, an information based economy, has turned the US into a uncomfortably divided state, just as you described. The red tribe not only doesn't know any blue tribe members, but also only reads red tribe books, and watches red tribe television, and vice versa. Simply because there is a big enough market for it to exist and be profitable, the American people are divided in thought (at least with the information they consume, which eventually does lead to thoughts).
- bsder 11y agoThe problem is that the "red tribe" happily sold out the members of the "blue tribe" that were closest to them. When automation decimated manual labor in the early 1980's, the "red tribe" happily took up their pitchforks and stabbed the "blue tribe". Now, nobody left in the "blue tribe" has any really solid reason to give a damn about anybody in the "red tribe".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- haberman 11y ago> Like so many other American scenes, this one is the product of decades of deindustrialization, engineered by Republicans and rationalized by Democrats. [...] Even the city’s one real hope for new employment opportunities --- an Amazon warehouse that is now in the planning stages -- will serve to lock in this relationship. If all goes according to plan, and if Amazon sticks to the practices it has pioneered elsewhere, people from Fall River will one day get to do exhausting work with few benefits while being electronically monitored for efficiency, in order to save the affluent customers of nearby Boston a few pennies when they buy books or electronics. Let me get this straight. The elite are bad for taking away working class jobs in industrial sectors (jobs which could be so brutal to workers that they basically spurred the invention of the labor unions). But they are also bad when they create new working class jobs. There is definitely a problem for working class people today. Maybe it feels better for people to believe that it's because today's politicians and business leaders are uniquely malfeasant. But it's not really accurate. Technology changes the picture and we have to figure out how to respond to that. Read about the Ludlow Massacre and try and tell me that industrial America was "the good old days."
- brownbat 11y agoPolitics is the mindkiller. It opens with the assumption that everyone shares the author's policy prescriptions. How can anyone write about politics and think that it's full of issues with only one obvious answer? Is it through screening all interactions to avoid anyone with different opinions? And there's no reason to single Frank out on this. Why does almost everyone on both sides of the aisle write and talk about politics in exactly this way?
- anon4this1 11y ago"The Oxfam report An Economy for the 1%, shows that the wealth of the poorest half of the world’s population has fallen by a trillion dollars since 2010, a drop of 38 percent. This has occurred despite the global population increasing by around 400 million people during that period. Meanwhile, the wealth of the richest 62 has increased by more than half a trillion dollars to $1.76tr. The report also shows how women are disproportionately affected by inequality – of the current ‘62’, 53 are men and just nine are women." OK so assume these top 62 people give all their money to the poor. 1.76 trillion is distributed among 3.5 billion people giving $502 each. the average net worth of these people goes from $500 to about $1000. 1 year later what will have happened? probably not much. These people will increase consumption somewhat, some might invest a bit, but mostly the money will just disappear. Huge swathes of the population have minimal net worth, like many of my friends, and live happy, comfortable lives. If they had an extra $500 they would spend it quick. This isn't the rule obviously, and there is a lot of poverty, but these statements don't really quite give a true picture of the issue.
- Maarten88 11y agoIf 3.5 billion people were to spend $500 quick, that would give an enormous economic boost globally. Most of those people would probably spend it wisely, improve their lives considerably, start businesses etc. I read it has been shown that simply giving money to the poorest people is a very effective way of stimulating the economy.
- anon4this1 11y agoI know when I was broke, working crappy jobs and in debt, $500 would basically have put a small dent in my credit card, and not much else. Meanwhile, Elon Musk has $16 billion dollars and hes making significant strides towards colonizing mars and slowing global warming.
- jt2190 11y agoThe article reverses the cause and effect of Massachusetts' divide between the wealthy and the worker in order to lay the cause at the feed of the Democratic Party. Take the examples: Universities, Banks, and Large Companies (Mills in the past, Pharma today) were dominant well before the Democratic Party become dominant [1], and were not somehow made powerful as the result of Democratic policies alone. We've really always has a "________ of the rich", where the blank is either "liberalism" or "conservatism" depending on the current party in power.
- Animats 11y agoHere's the other extreme - the liberalism of the working class, the Union Pacific Railroad. 150 years in business. 40,000 employees. 86% belong to a union. 20% are military veterans. UP claims 3 million hours a year of training time for their employees, and that's all paid time. It's not an easy life. Here's a recruiting video.[1] They open by showing workers in a railroad yard in Chicago at 5:47 AM in a snowstorm. Management training starts with jobs like that. They show a management training session on how to deal with conflict. There's a lot of travel. One of the trainees says "UP operates in 23 states, and I went to 21 of them in my first year." It's the total opposite of the "brogrammer" culture. Not only does UP hire many women, the women go out in the field, wearing all the heavy protective gear and doing hard work. UP is insistent about this.[2] It helps that they're a union shop, where employee discipline is formal. And this is in a culture much more macho than programming. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMViWazEYoc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMViWazEYoc [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DVH8pASu-og https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DVH8pASu-og
- tzs 11y agoWell that was a bit unusual: > Posted by Thomas Frank ... > Reading Thomas Frank's new book, Listen, Liberal, or What Ever Happened to the Party of the People? [...] ... > Let me just add that, as Frank makes clear in his brilliant new work [...] ... > [...] Frank does a typically brainy thing. You usually don't see people review their own books from a third person viewpoint, or point out how brilliant or brainy they are. The few times I have seen that have been in contexts where they were obviously trying to project an image of a giant ego for humorous purposes. I'm not familiar enough with this author to know if that's what he's going for in this review, or if he is seriously praising himself.
- mturmon 11y agoNah, you are mistaken, and the article has led you astray. The writer who wrote a few introductory paragraphs to the large book excerpt is not Thomas Frank himself. It's not 100% explicit, but the person writing these laudatory words is almost certainly Tom Englehart, the editor of TomDispatch. I've seen Thomas Frank speak and followed him for many years, since he and others founded the Baffler in Chicago in the late 80s. He's a Midwesterner through and through, grew up in suburban Kansas City, and has the characteristic modesty of the area.
- tzs 11y agoThat does appear to be the case, based on looking at some other reviews. It looks like it works like this, at least for authors who are TomsDispatch regulars: 1. Author Foo writes a book. 2. Tom Englehart writes a review, which consists of introductory material and then a long excerpt from the book. 3. Englehart's review appears on the site, but it says "Posted by Foo" at the top. The only mention of Englehart is that it says "Tom" in italics immediately after the last sentence of the introductory material. 4. At the bottom it says "Foo, a TomsDispatch regular, is the author of <name of book>". 5. At the bottom it says "Copyright <year> Foo". Basically everything on the page except for that lone italicized "Tom" after the introductory material makes it look like Foo wrote the review. In the case where firstname_of(Foo) == "Tom", everything on the page makes it look like Foo wrote the review.
- 11y ago
- srtjstjsj 11y agoThis is Bill Clinton-esque "neoliberalism", right? socially liberal, economically oligarchist, to contrast with the Repbulicans socially conservative economically oligarchist.
- jwatte 11y agoMaybe if the Republicans weren't in the pockets of anti science right wing religious nuts and climate change deniers, the well educated would be more willing to consider them?
- dang 11y agoI'd like to think it's a mark of HN's improvement that unsubstantive, snarky putdowns turned out to be rare in this thread.