7 ms·
Facebook Live: Now You Can Never Leave
- tdkl 11y agoI'm less interested in Facebook. With this, I'm even less interested as I were. After deleting the account (which was 6 years old), I came back after 6 months and added a close group of people I actually care about now and in the foreseeable future. I don't like things, don't follow, don't publicly comment on businesses, only use the events and chat. The only app on mobile in use is Messenger with all the data collection turned off, for the site I use a wrapper app. This seemed to me as a reasonable use of FB. All the rest is junk.
- rpgmaker 11y agoI know you see it as a reasonable "middle ground" solution but you have to be aware that you are still telling FB a lot about yourself. The fact that you only added your actual friends the second time may even make it easier for them to extract profit from your account.
- visarga 11y agoBut if you take your center of activity away from FB and participate in other online communities, then in a way FB has lost, even if you maintain a token presence. You can enjoy different forms of social networking.
- tdkl 11y agoTrue, I'm willing to let them have that data for the services I actually benefit from. But regarding data, those friends have probably uploaded my contact details using the FB app anyway, so the Facebook had a shadow profile about me, nevertheless me being registered there. At least this way I can foresee what gets posted online about me and somehow control it. In an ideal world this wouldn't be happening, but I saw that for the mental health sake, it's better to let loose sometimes and just find some compromises. Oh and on the desktop I only login in incognito mode every couple days, since they use the login cookie to track you online. For Messenger, there's a cool Electron app [1], which brings native notifications. [1] http://messengerfordesktop.com/ http://messengerfordesktop.com/
- ZenoArrow 11y agoWhat compels people to use Facebook? That's a genuine question, I don't think I fully understand it. Speaking personally, the only value it has for me is in keeping some form of connection to people I would otherwise have lost contact with. I don't use it for people I keep in contact with in other ways. For me the staying power of Facebook is that it places low demands on staying connected. The setting also seems to add to the informality, I could see myself preferring to email long time friends (and I sometimes do), but perhaps the directness of connection is off putting for some people who are used to sharing amongst an audience. Does anyone here have any views about why people continue to use Facebook?
- sidcool 11y agoIn my opinion, the most compelling reason is that many people are there. There's nothing Google or Microsoft can't do that facebook is doing, technologically, what they lack is people. I still feel facebook is a good platform for running private groups. For others it gives an audience to show off, not necessarily a bad thing. Facebook is what every individual wants but is hesitant of accepting.
- dingaling 11y ago> In my opinion, the most compelling reason is that many people are there. Yes, I've seen this in action with real-world groups that form a Facebook group to replace a mailing list, or ( shudder ) a Yahoo Group. 99.99% of their recipients are already on Facebook, it's free-at-point-of-use and it supports group functions. So they go ahead, freezing-out the ones who aren't on Facebook with quotes like 'just create an account, it's free'. I'd join Facebook if I could pay a subscription fee each month so as not to be analysed and advertised-to, just to rejoin many groups that have moved there.
- type0 11y agoBecause everybody else uses it, that's herd thinking at it's best. There are many features that people use it for, private groups for example. It's great for spreading gossip and what have you.
- 11y ago
- coroutines 11y agoI sometimes wonder if there is no 'After Facebook'. I use different services for different community focuses - like YouTube and Twitch for gaming videos/streams I watch with friends. Instagram for incidental activity picture stuff. Twitter for talking directly "to" companies. Signal for IM stuff. I do actually use Google Hangouts for board game nights and talking about projects sometimes - kinda silly. :-) I just find Facebook a mess with the ads and disorganization looking at so many facets of my friends' lives. Google did good identifying the need for putting people in circles, but Facebook was so well-established by then. I only want to view things my friends are doing if its a mutual interest, really. Facebook is like manually filtering through several streams of consciousness - it's more exhausting than rewarding. I don't think Facebook is ever going to fail and be the next MySpace, but I do think social attitudes have changed about using a 'general' social networking site.
- x5n1 11y agoCurrently there is no FB alternative. There will be eventually. There is nothing that I can think of that has no alternative. Even Google has Bing which is viable. FB has none.
- thomasahle 11y agoOnly if you want everything integrated. I think that was OP's point.
- x5n1 11y agoGoogle failed at social because of integration. Integration can be as much of a turn off as a lock in. Also I wish facebook would stop stalking me with you have more friends than you think messages.
- tim333 11y agoThere are lots of alternatives technically speaking - G+, Diaspora, Ello and others. Socially though FB is probably where your friends and family are.
- franbulax 11y ago"We study how the fence weaves into and out of the trees. And one day, when the sun has gone down and the guards are asleep, we catapult over to the other side, and see all the things we couldn’t see before." Yep, and some of us even see the fence being built and make sure we stay on the outside. It's easy to fence-in dopey ruminants, but wily canids prefer to keep their options a little more flexible. I refuse, as much as possible, to be herded around, sheep-like, and am repulsed at the thought of being used, as do these "social" sites seeking to "monetize" me, as grist for their psychological-manipulation-for-profit mills. No product, I!
- tim333 11y agoMeh - I've got 20 tabs open, one of which is Facebook. Sometimes I click on it, sometimes not. I don't consider that a great feat of fence jumping.
- pessimizer 11y agoDon't worry, it's always got your mic open; no need to click on the tab.
- rtpg 11y agoSerious question, do you feel like Facebook provides much value to its users?
- nibs 11y agoIn a sense that addictions provide value while simultaneously extracting event more, all with the willful participation of the user (consent seemed like the wrong word).
- losteric 11y agoOh definitely, just like a crack house. They've got their friends and "friends" in a walled off room, socially connected by leisure activities with questionable value to the residents. It's more of a slum filled with degenerates and graffiti... but hey, people come for the high not the scenery. The heavy users are there for life but even the occasional users keep coming back. Then of course there's the dealer managing the place... they're the only one to actually benefit from the operation. I'm being a little facetious, but in short: no. There are a multitude options for chat that provide a better experience, keeping in contact was not a problem in the first place, and all that's left are games or wanting to show off/snoop on lives. I would argue it provides a largely negative value if you consider filter bubbles and their impact on society. Shareholders are the only ones that derive value from FB.
- chillingeffect 11y ago>insure ownership Wow, never thought I'd catch you in a typo, newyorker...
- flavor8 11y agoIt's deliberately part of the New Yorker's writing style. http://www.writersdigest.com/online-editor/ensure-vs-insure http://www.writersdigest.com/online-editor/ensure-vs-insure
- terda12 11y agoCould care less. I'll still continue to use Facebook to talk to my high school friends.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- h1fra 11y agoFYI: this article does not display at all when using adblocker (with no message whatsoever)
- nibs 11y agoFacebook is the 90s/00s Oracle of social media software. Horrifically evil, impossible to get rid of and only hipsters use the alternatives. Open source eventually got enough strength to rival the functionality and everyone who could jumped ship. If you continue the analogy, the only way to beat Facebook is for an open protocol like email or something else to gain traction among Facebook detractors. Because mobile is a walled garden, we are going through the IBM, Oracle, Microsoft, all-in-one is better phase. I am optimistic that there is some as-yet unindentified format for open communication that will win in a way that allows everyone to access it exactly how they want to (like email). Sure, the most fearful, slow moving among us might stick to the tried and true. But at least my parents and high school friends will have an account with the open protocol, allowing me and everyone else not to have to choose between social inclusion and using Facebook.
- dsacco 11y ago>> Horrifically evil... If Facebook and Oracle are "horrifically evil", I'm at a loss for what you'd call atrocities of war. I don't mean to pick you out personally, but considering that this is the top comment in the thread, the anti-BigCo sentiment on Hacker News is getting a little ridiculous.
- amelius 11y ago> If Facebook and Oracle are "horrifically evil", I'm at a loss for what you'd call atrocities of war. Horrifically evil along a different axis?
- dsacco 11y agoIf I accept the premise that attempting to quantify "evil" is coherent, I'm willing to agree that there are different axes to do so. But I honestly can't see Facebook as an entity being very far along any of them.
- nibs 11y agoI think this is half true. Really, we are not measuring evil, we are measuring character. And evil as a metric of character is different from evil as a metric of war crimes. Doing things because you can instead of because it is the right thing to do. Highly subjective all around.
- wallflower 11y agoFrom the article about Facebook Live > If anything, Live further exposes Facebook’s active, seemingly unquenchable thirst for more ways to become the middleman in your digital interactions. It literally wants you to broadcast your life on the platform. But, as noted earlier, being caged doesn’t come that naturally to humans. From "The Circle" by Dave Eggers - a "fiction" novel about a Facebook-like mega infoglomerateorporation. > Lionel can give me access to any of the cameras he wants. It's just like friending someone, but now with access to all their live feeds. Forget cable. Forget five hundred channels. If you have one thousand friends, and they have ten cameras each, you now have ten thousand options for live footage. ... The words dropped onto the screen: ALL THAT HAPPENS MUST BE KNOWN. "Folks, we're at the dawn of the Second Englightenment. And I'm not talking about a new building on campus. I'm talking about an era where we don't allow the majority of human thought and action and achievement and learning to escape as if from a leaky bucket." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(Eggers_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_(Eggers_novel)
- sakopov 11y agoWhen I check my Facebook feed, as I do once every 3 months or so, I find literally nothing from my friends and a whole lot of sponsored posts or posts from groups I follow. I've shared this with friends and basically confirmed that Facebook has become this place you don't really have much use for anymore but you can't really leave because of years of shit you've dumped into it and connections you've made. So now you just sort of quietly linger, read some spam and close the tab for a while.
- ec109685 11y agoUnfollow those groups then.
- amelius 11y agoI'm still hoping for some open technology to replace FB. Messaging is a solved problem. Perhaps we can build something on top of IPFS to share statuses (timeline) and photos with proper access control. Groups with restricted access could be an interesting challenge.
- RodericDay 11y agoFor me it would be as simple as an alternative messenger that followed me around from page to page. It could be injected like a Greasemonkey script or browser extension, even.
- codingdave 11y agoPeople do not stay on Facebook because of its technology or features. They stay on Facebook because of the people they are connected to. I was in my 30s when Facebook came around, which was young enough to still care about, and be excited by re-connecting with old friends from school. The thought of losing touch with them all again made leaving Facebook a difficult choice. I eventually did so, but had to come to terms with the fact that I was dropping a large set of "friends" for the second time in my life.
- darkclarity 11y agoIt just seems unhealthy keeping in contact with that many people who were resigned to the past. Never mind all the game-theory-esk psychological manipulation that social networks push on us. If people want to keep in contact with their past friends, then get their phone numbers or become pen pals (email or post). There's no dodgy third party trying to manipulate with those methods, just enthusiasm from the participants.
- nibs 11y agoYeah, I meant it more along the axis of I'm a hot girl and I can get away with anything I want evil, than war crimes evil.
- dsacco 11y agoI don't mean to be pedantic, but if you broaden your definition of "evil" to include both of those extremes it becomes meaningless as an adjective.
- tome 11y ago> I'm a hot girl and I can get away with anything I want evil What?
- anonbanker 11y agoThis is a topic into itself: traditionally-beautiful women that happen to be very manipulative tend to end up committing pretty evil acts, and are able to get away with them because, ultimately, the other party doesn't want to ruin a potential chance at mating, so lets the act go without repercussion. This increases the likelihood of committing a similar act in the future, due to the success.
- dang 11y agoA throwaway comment like this is as guaranteed to ignite a pointless flamewar as anything we see. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11462520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11462520 and marked it off-topic.
- foxly 11y agoHoly browser fingerprinting, new yorker! https://imgur.com/XDUCt0R https://imgur.com/XDUCt0R
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 11y agoI just added this extension, but in your experience, how common is this method by sites? I received 11k+ on newyorker, is that a lot in comparison to some other sites?