7 ms·
Terrifyingly Convenient
- walterbell 11y agoProtonet Zoe is a crowd funded Echo competitor that claims to perform local-only voice recognition with some open-source code based on CoreOS, http://readwrite.com/2016/04/07/zoe-smart-home-hub-amazon-echo-dl1/ http://readwrite.com/2016/04/07/zoe-smart-home-hub-amazon-ec... & http://experimental-platform.github.io http://experimental-platform.github.io
- mst 11y agoThe most interesting thing from my POV was the existence of http://x.ai/ http://x.ai/
- BatFastard 11y agoAmy is a great assistant. But she has a long waiting list.
- theoh 11y agoIt's a shame they didn't minimally push the boat out for sexual equality by offering "adam" as a male alternative. Amy is (arguably) a stereotypically girly name and given that what's being offloaded here is administrative work, I think it looks bad to make it a female responsibility.
- nkurz 11y agoThe posted article suggests that they already do allow this: Unlike some other intelligent assistant companies, X.ai gives you the option to choose a male name for your assistant instead: Mine is Andrew Ingram.
- tomaskazemekas 11y agoAs far as the fiction can envision the techno future and human AI interaction, one of the more interesting books for me was SNUFF by Victor Pelevin. In it the main character is a freelancer drone camera operator living with a humanoid as a partner, tweaking her settings and getting very emotionally and sexually involved with her. And the devise is so human like and autonomous, that it eventually runs away from the owner leaving him with huge debt still unpaid.
- wtbob 11y agoY'know, I have a terribly powerful desktop always running at my home; I'd love to be able to load a container on it which does all this processing locally.
- amelius 11y agoIs there a (comparative) overview of all the tasks smart agents can do?
- jveld 11y agoEnough with the 'woe humanity the machines are coming' pieces. After ten years of facebook, and three years of snowden leaks, I have a hard time finding sympathy for people who purchase 'smart' (read data gathering) devices from large conglomerates before considering the privacy implications. The cards are on the table; we all know what the terms of this kind of convenience are. If you're concerned for your privacy, then stop opting in for fucks sake. You've just voted with your dollars for a future of ubiquitous, autonomous surveillance. Again. Knowingly. The ignorance card is utter bullshit at this point. The 'inevitable' future bewailed by these types of articles is only inevitable because this kind of 'shiny! buynow thinklater' mentality. To paraphrase Sartre, "we have the surveillance state we deserve." If you're comfortable with the tradeoffs, I have no beef. I'm not saying that people shouldn't buy these things if they want them. And they are cool, wantable things. But it's 2016. You can have your thing or your soapbox. Both are respectable choices. But you can only have one.
- massysett 11y agoI agree with you on the people who buy these things, but I think a more interesting question is how they affect the people who do not buy them. Facebook is similar. I don't care one whit about Facebook users who complain that the company is using their information and that they have no privacy. That's what you signed up for, duh. More interesting is that Facebook amasses a lot of information even about people who do not use the service. Right now the Echo is only listening inside of homes, so logically you can figure there's not much risk of third-party harm here. But this gets more tricky if these things start listening in public spaces, or if they're on phones...suppose the pizza delivery guy gets a cell phone that listens all the time, and it hears something interesting while the pizza man is at your door.
- greenyoda 11y ago"Right now the Echo is only listening inside of homes, so logically you can figure there's not much risk of third-party harm here." If I visit a friend who has an Echo in their home, I'm having my conversation listened to without my consent.
- aftbit 11y ago"When I Google “kinkajou,” I get a list of websites, ranked according to an algorithm that takes into account all sorts of factors that correlate with relevance and authority. I choose the information source I prefer, then visit its website directly—an experience that could help to further shade or inform my impression of its trustworthiness." While the Google experience is certainly more direct than the Alexa experience, you're still allowing Google to filter and order your search results. Check out the "filter bubble" if you haven't heard of it before. The HN title, "Terrifyingly Convenient", hits the problem on the head. As long as technology users broadly continue to sacrifice security, privacy, and choice for basic convenience, these sorts of issues will continue occurring. There's a potentially very dark future ahead of us where all of our choices are made by entrenched mega-corporations who see us as nothing but a source of revenue. "CONSUME!"
- walterbell 11y ago> There's a potentially very dark future ahead of us where all of our choices are made by entrenched mega-corporations who see us as nothing but a source of revenue. How about corporations who see us as nothing but a source of data, not even as customers? http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/the-digital-debate/shoshana-zuboff-secrets-of-surveillance-capitalism-14103616.html?printPagedArticle=true http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/the-digital-d... & https://vimeo.com/110222526 https://vimeo.com/110222526 "While advertisers have been the dominant buyers in the early history of this new kind of marketplace, there is no substantive reason why such markets should be limited to this group. The already visible trend is that any actor with an interest in monetizing probabilistic information about our behavior and/or influencing future behavior can pay to play in a marketplace where the behavioral fortunes of individuals, groups, bodies, and things are told and sold. This is how in our own lifetimes we observe capitalism shifting under our gaze: once profits from products and services, then profits from speculation, and now profits from surveillance."
- Joof 11y agoWe're largely there already; it's just not obvious because it's incredibly ingrained in our culture. We've been there. One aspect of brands selling people an 'identity' (think apple or more profoundly, rolls royce). That's the consumer culture everyone hears so much about. Companies have larger weight in American government than people do. Lobbyists and campaign contributions go a long way. Aaron Schwartz became dedicated to campaign finance reform for precisely this reason. Part of the problem (and part of the solution to that problem) is that large scale companies must always optimize for money. They can care about certain things more, but still must optimize for money. Sometimes this benefits the general public, but sometimes it works against them too. Decoupling industry from politics may be a good idea; we can give more weight to what is good for people than what is good for companies. Although politicians like Trump make me think that might not be ideal either :P.
- futureiswithus 11y agoI always had imagined this convinient future to be about an intelligence that lived within my home and not a remote server farm. That way everyone had their own personal AI that grew with you and not connected to any others. There was no big brother since it wasnt centralized. Why cant a startup be formed to make this real?
- rorykoehler 11y agoGood AI requires huge amounts of data, like you would find on a server farm.
- futureiswithus 11y agoa single person produces enough data in my mind to train an AI for him or her. We just need to apply existing algorithms to the problem. We just need a lot of data to make a generic AI that works for all. Which isnt the case for the above proposal
- Godel_unicode 11y agoThe problem isn't the algorithms, the problem is the labeled training sets which those algorithms need to create models. Also, to recommend news stories a la Google Now you need to scrape an appreciable portion of the Internet and extract features to score against your model.
- yjisawesome 11y agoSo what you are suggesting this trend will be perfect as long as we control like keeping private home network? What a novel idea!!! However, in order for startup to be interested, this idea gotta have some commercial potential aka profitable. How do make this idea profitable though?
- greenyoda 11y agoNot all innovation comes from startups. There are probably lots of people who would be interested in working on a free, open source AI system if someone were to organize such a project. It would be interesting to see who the "Linus Torvalds of AI" will turn out to be.
- Animats 11y agoIn your car, OnStar listens to you. That was the first widely deployed "always listening" system of that type. On January 1, 2014, GM changed their privacy policy to allow them to use any info about what your vehicle is doing, including where it is, for marketing purposes.[1] At home, Echo listens to you. Amazon's is vague about how much they listen to.[2] And, of course, there's the XBox 360. It sees you when you're sleeping. It knows when you're awake. It knows if you've been bad or good. You'll never be alone again. [1] https://www2.onstar.com/web/portal/privacy https://www2.onstar.com/web/portal/privacy [2] http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/forums/ref=cs_hc_g_tv?ie=UTF8&forumID=Fx1SKFFP8U1B6N5&cdThread=Tx26V9TT6C3TD21 http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/forums/ref=cs_hc_g_tv...
- GuiA 11y ago> You'll never be alone again Or, if this bothers you, you can choose to avoid the hedonistic treadmill altogether and not outfit your house with an Alexa, a Kinect, and countless other mostly useless devices that people lived happily without 10 years ago.
- rodgerd 11y agoThe problem with this nice theory is you'll be getting it whether you want it or not. As revenue comes in from the sureillance society, manufacturers will (and alrewady are) crammin the functionality into devices. You, as a customer will have no choice: sooner or later you'll need a new fridge, and a spy fridge will be your only option.
- dima55 11y agoThat is simply not true. Maybe the latest and hipsteriest devices will all have those features, but the market is vast and caters to all sorts of humans and price points. You just have to care enough to make that choice as a consumer.
- r00fus 11y agoTry to buy a high-end TV without Wifi/Smart/3D useless anti-features. It's getting harder each day.
- hinkley 11y agoI think this problem is on the verge of solving itself again. It'll come back by the end of the 2020's of course, but we are at least due for a respite. There's so much work being done on scalable server tech right now, and enough broadband to use it. O little nudge and we'd be close to having a server appliance that people could have in their own homes, and call from their mobile devices.