4 ms·
" I just don't like the general approach of convincing readers with fiction. It appeals to the subconscious rather than logic. I prefer logic in such matters."
by timr 17y ago
" I just don't like the general approach of convincing readers with fiction. It appeals to the subconscious rather than logic. I prefer logic in such matters."
The idea behind a parable is to encourage you to think for yourself, not to explicitly convince you of an argument.
- Tichy 17y agoMaybe, but it is a deception, because the setup is given by the storyteller. So if you think for yourself, you do so with the assumptions given by the story. I still think it is simply a device to sway people's opinions. Otherwise, why not just give some condensed facts about the real world?
- tdoggette 17y agoYou're opposed on principle to rhetoric?
- olefoo 17y agoThat's a prejudice that goes back to Plato.
- Tichy 17y agoAm I supposed to like rhetoric?
- halostatue 17y agoLike? No. Understand and be able to use, because it makes a lot more sense to a lot of the people on this Earth? Yes.
- Tichy 17y agoSo you basically agree that it is designed to sway the opinions of people who don't like to think hard about what they hear? Another place I know parables from is the bible. Does that mean I have to be religious?
- halostatue 17y agoNo, I don't agree with that proposition at all. Rhetoric is something you don't have to like, but to dismiss it entirely as you have done in this subthread is to do a disservice to yourself. I happen to find rhetoric fascinating, as it has to do with human communication and interaction. If you've ever given a presentation, you've performed rhetoric (the art of using language to persuade). If you've presented based on measurable facts, you've still used rhetoric. (Indeed, without using other language to help organize and interpret the facts at hand, it's very easy for facts to be used to confuse an issue.) Parables are rhetorical devices usually used to illustrate a moral or religious lesson. Yet, they can also be used to illustrate other lessons, too. A quick search for "secular parables" resulted in the "Parable of the broken window" as a lesson to be learned about economics. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- smcq 17y agoYou can't handle the truth.
- JoelSutherland 17y agoA listing of facts contains editorial opinion.
- Tichy 17y agoYeah I know true objectivity is impossible, but that doesn't mean we can not at least try to be as objective as possible.
- JoelSutherland 17y agoTransparent bias is better than imperfect objectivity.
- Tichy 17y agoI still wonder: did this story make you think "hm, I wonder if trading derivatives is just like gambling in the casino", or did it make you think "yeah, those roothless traders were just gambling, I knew it"?