3 ms·
Proof by fiction is even worse than proof by anecdote.
by Tichy 17y ago
Proof by fiction is even worse than proof by anecdote.
- david927 17y agoIt's not "proof by fiction" but a parable. He and Warren have always traded based on fundamentals, and he's saying the fundamentals got lost along the way. It's a fair point.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- yungchin 17y agoAs a completely uninformed person, can I ask whom "the good father" in the parable refers to? I have to say that while parables can be very powerful, this one only so thinly veils reality, that it confuses more than it helps.
- GFischer 17y agoI guess it's an amalgamation between Benjamin Franklin, Lee Kwan Yew.. and I can't recognize the third (Google suggests Paul Volcker)
- yungchin 17y agoAha - thanks! The good father indeed sounds like Volcker: http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/17/paul-volcker-finds-a-hammer/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/17/paul-volcker-fi...
- megaduck 17y agoI wouldn't dismiss this piece out of hand. As co-captain of Berkshire Hathaway, Charlie Munger's got a pretty good window into the global financial system. Both he and Buffett have a pretty folksy manner, but behind the goofiness is usually some razor-sharp analysis. To make it more palatable, substitute 'United States' for 'Basicland', and 'investment banks' for 'casinos'. Then it becomes a pretty accurate picture of our current situation.
- Tichy 17y agoI got the analogy, and the story may or may not be accurate. I have heard the name Charlie Munger before, but I don't know what he stands for. I just don't like the general approach of convincing readers with fiction. It appeals to the subconscious rather than logic. I prefer logic in such matters.
- sailormoon 17y ago"Artists use lies to tell the truth"
- hga 17y agoArtists also use lies to tell lies, especially political ones.
- timr 17y ago" I just don't like the general approach of convincing readers with fiction. It appeals to the subconscious rather than logic. I prefer logic in such matters." The idea behind a parable is to encourage you to think for yourself, not to explicitly convince you of an argument.
- Tichy 17y agoMaybe, but it is a deception, because the setup is given by the storyteller. So if you think for yourself, you do so with the assumptions given by the story. I still think it is simply a device to sway people's opinions. Otherwise, why not just give some condensed facts about the real world?
- three14 17y agoI'm offended by this "disproof by one liner." The linked article is a parable, and trying to do exactly what parables usually do; give you enough distance to revisit something that you already have opinions about. Maybe you like it, maybe you don't. "Proof by fiction" is simple mischaracterization.
- Tichy 17y agoI am not saying the story is wrong, so I don't "disprove by one liner". I don't like the device for manipulating opinion, that's all. If you read such a beautiful fairytale, you can nod along feeling comfy all the way (maybe sitting in front of a cosy fireplace among friends). Overall, I am pretty sure opinions are not formed by logic, but by factions - we believe things because it benefits us and makes us belong to our faction. So to create a comfy fireplace fairytale setting is simply a manipulative device. I feel it is a good idea to be wary of such approaches, just as an anecdote is interesting, but should not be sufficient basis for judgment.
- fifi33 17y ago"Proof by fiction is even worse than proof by anecdote." Where did he assert "proof" in that article?