9 ms·
WebTorrent Desktop – Open source streaming torrent client
- revelation 11y agoLacks a usable volume control, and the one in the View options seems non-linear. Also showed a rather improbable download speed for my home line.
- feross 11y ago> Lacks a usable volume control There's a pull request for that here: https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-desktop/pull/330 https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-desktop/pull/330 It will be in the next release. > Showed a rather improbable download speed for my home line. Thanks for the compliment. We try hard ;)
- lossolo 11y agoAdoption of webtorrent (bittorrent via webrtc) is almost non-existent. Unless uTorrent and libtorrent (used by Deluge, rtorrent, qbittorrent etc) will adopt this, then webtorrent in browser will never start off. Unfortunately i predict that this desktop client will not resolve this issue.
- feross 11y agoThat's not true. Vuze already supports WebTorrent! Check it out: https://wiki.vuze.com/w/WebTorrent https://wiki.vuze.com/w/WebTorrent There's also built-in support for WebTorrent (and IPFS for that matter) in the Playback video player: https://mafintosh.github.io/playback/ https://mafintosh.github.io/playback/
- lossolo 11y agoWhat i wrote is true. You know how much of market is Vuze comparing to utorrent and libtorrent? EDIT: Here you go, data from 2015 http://lifehacker.com/5813348/five-best-bittorrent-applications/1705622513 http://lifehacker.com/5813348/five-best-bittorrent-applicati... Azureus was something but 10 years ago. Things changed.
- dcposch 11y agouTorrent shows banner ads and recently shipped with bitcoin mining malware. It's also a lot more work--and requires a second program, like VLC--to do streaming. I'm optimistic about WebTorrent Desktop adoption. You're right that we need lots more hybrid client adoption to bridge the BitTorrent and WebTorrent networks and really make it work in the browser. I hope WebTorrent Desktop can be that client. Finally, libtorrent is open source. Here's the discussion about adding WebTorrent support: https://github.com/arvidn/libtorrent/issues/223 https://github.com/arvidn/libtorrent/issues/223
- lossolo 11y agoIt dosen't matter that they show banners. They are number 1 anyway. Telemetry didn't change windows adoption and ads didn't change utorrent adoption. I know about this issue from 14 october :) I am not so optimistic, this client has 15-30 times more ram usage and couple of times more CPU usage. You can just install qBittorrent set sequential downloading and watch the movie..
- _antares 11y agoYes it matters. Ads if downloaded from Internet at start time will definitely introduce anonimity/privacy issues and cut user base by large. utorrent is #1 only because older versions (no adds/malware) are easily accessible.
- lucid00 11y agoI feel this is a moot point. I'm pretty sure the install base of WebRTC data channels is far higher than BitTorrent (Chrome, Firefox, Opera and soon Edge and Safari), so existing Torrent clients providing support only helps out the existing torrents out there. Down the line I'm willing to bet that WebTorrent grows to be more widely used than BitTorrent, just off of the lack of friction to get started for both users and developers.
- lossolo 11y agoYou know that you can't connect to normal bittorrent clients from webtorrent in browser right? Which means that you do not have almost any sources of seeders, which means that webrtc adoption dosen't matter.
- lucid00 11y agoI know you can't connect to normal clients. My point is normal clients don't really matter. "Which means that you do not have almost any sources of seeders" All it takes for someone to seed a file is to open a web page. Think about it. At any point if I wanted to promote a song via WebTorrent, I could build WebTorrent into an audio player and encourage my user base to click a checkbox and seed the track (toss in IndexedDB support for storing it offline and it's even better). Complete serverless resharing with almost every benefit of BitTorrent to boot. The only thing WebTorrent needs the existing BitTorrent install base for is the existing torrents, which don't matter as much as you might think they do (most torrents are pirated content anyways). So yes, WebRTC adoption does matter.
- lossolo 11y agoIf this what you wrote was true then you would see big adoption of webtorrent which is not the case. As i said before and i am saying for almost 2 years now. I love webtorrent but it NEEDS support from libtorrent and utorrent. Look at biggest bittorrent sites and on private trackers, i have seen private data on clients usage and i can tell you that adoption is almost non-existent comparing to big 5, which still means that webrtc dosen't matter in this case..
- zanny 11y agoI looked into the complexity of implementing webtorrent (which is just websocket signaling and webrtc data channel connections to peers rather than the traditional http signaling with udp to peers) in libtorrent and it is kind of a giant mess of C++ :p The problem is more that every desktop client, for some reason, has also reimplemented bittorrent. Specifically, Transmission, Deluge, and KTorrent all use their own bittorrent protocol implementations, and none of them are particularly or easily extensible enough to provide webtorrent support easily. But let it be known eyes are on the prize and have at least looked into it, it is just a hard problem, exacerbated by implementation fragmentation.
- vmorgulis 11y agoVery cool announce! Do you think running webtorrent under Duktape could work (with appropriate network APIs) ?
- feross 11y agoPerhaps. You'd want to use the npm package directly for that. https://github.com/feross/webtorrent https://github.com/feross/webtorrent If there's any changes you need to make it work for, just open an issue or send a PR!
- diegorbaquero 11y agoWebTorrent CLI: https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-cli https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-cli WebTorrent Hybrid: https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-hybrid https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-hybrid
- dcposch 11y agoThis is what Feross and I have been working on the past few weeks. It's been a lot of fun. Here are a few of the things I learned: * Electron is surprisingly nice to work with. It is simple, pragmatic, and thorough. System tray integrations, desktop notifications, launcher progress bar in OSX, installers for all three platforms, seamless auto updaters for Mac and Windows, a crash reporter, and so on --- all built in. Many of the little things that an app needs to feel native and professional have clean cross-platform APIs. * Shout out to Cheng Zhao, aka zcbenz. He's incredibly prolific and seems to be nearly single-handedly developing the Electron project. Every single page of Electron docs or code I've looked at on Github, the latest commit on it is zcbenz. * Peer-to-peer is moving very fast. WebRTC support in browsers was flaky and buggy until very recently. Even today, Chrome has a few big bugs left ( eg https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=392651 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=392651 ) and WebRTC is not yet supported in Web Workers ( https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=302019 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=302019 ). But things are improving quickly. Edge is getting Data Channel support soon. Safari is almost certainly gonna get WebRTC support as well -- it's already in WebKit, just not enabled in Safari yet. Tons of cool new uses of the web are just at the edge of becoming possible. I'm really excited about the way WebTorrent Desktop bridges the WebTorrent and BitTorrent networks. If enough people end up running it, BitTorrent in the browser will really happen. Projects like the Internet Archive can make huge files available for immediate streaming on their website, without paying for bandwidth. It's going to be interesting times.
- terhechte 11y agoJust wondering, because it is not explicitly mentioned in the docs, does it only stream or does it also seed the downloaded chunks?
- feross 11y agoIt seeds, like all good torrent clients.
- dcposch 11y agoYes. All torrent clients I know, including WebTorrent Desktop, seed while downloading. WebTorrent Desktop keeps seeding after you've finished downloading a file, and keeps running in the system tray after you close the window unless you explicitly tell it to quit. We want to be good citizens and keep the swarms healthy.
- ifelsehow 11y agohow does the webtorrent team respond to criticisms of sequential downloading in torrents? while i personally believe folks should mirror & seed torrents regardless of how others consume these torrents, i'm curious about the developers' perspectives on this issue in any case, this desktop app looks very slick, thanks webtorrent team for all work pushing webrtc and torrenting forward
- feross 11y agoWebTorrent supports two download modes: sequential and rarest-first. In sequential mode, pieces are fetched with high priority when they're immediately needed for streaming. In rarest-first mode, the traditional approach is used. We're going to add automatic mode switching to a future release, so rarest-first will be used most of the time. The only time sequential mode is needed is right when streaming begins and every time a seek happens. I think this is a nice balance between helping the local user and keeping the swarm healthy.
- dcposch 11y ago* It only download sequentially when you're streaming. If you're just downloading a torrent, it will use rarest-first. * We plan to switch to a hybrid strategy: it will download the blocks it needs, but once enough video is buffered, it will transition to rarest-first. * It doesn't really matter. This used to be more of an issue back when torrents took hours or days to download and upload speeds were slow. If you download the entire torrent in five minutes and then seed it for days, it doesn't matter for the health of the swarm what order you downloaded the pieces in.
- kylecordes 11y agoThis might be more complexity than you are ready for, but here's what I suggest: * Remove the notion of two different modes. * Remove the ability to switch between two modes. Because with this capability, people will inevitably switch it to the greedy mode, even if they have no need to, out of an inane fear that they might need to. * Implement your hybrid mode, again without a "switching" mechanism: * In your implementation of "rarest first", artificially apply extra weight to the next N segments that will be needed for the current play point. I think this will result in very good behavior, in all cases. It is completely hands-off. Users tight on bandwidth will inevitably spend all of their bandwidth downloading the extra weighted segments needed to place soon. Users with any spare bandwidth will easily get past the next and segments, and then the rarest segments will automatically be the next fetched. All without any switches for users to set wrong.
- nly 11y agoPretty amazing, but burns CPU like no other. What really sucks is that Opera added native BitTorrent support almost 10 years ago (June 2006 in Opera 9), and no other browser has had the guts since. Something to think about.
- dcposch 11y agoGlad you like it. It's still very beta. We're going to try to make the app more efficient. (I think it feels pretty snappy even now, though.) You might have run into this Chrome bug. WebTorrent Desktop is an Electron app, which uses Chromium, so we inherit this bug. Chrome's WebRTC internals sometimes use 100% CPU on one core: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=392651 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=392651 It will hopefully be fixed soon.
- nly 11y agoSorry, I was referring to the in-browser version. FF 45 on Linux.
- SimeVidas 11y agoProgressive web apps (which work offline, btw) can already be installed on Windows (demo video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUma1l3BKOI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUma1l3BKOI) via Chrome — all the app needs is a manifest and a service worker — so it might be worth experimenting with supporting it (for people who’ve “grown out of” installers).
- williamcotton 11y agoThese native apps powered by electron allow for much better desktop integration than the kind of web application you're talking about here. Traditional installers are required for these kind of desktop integration that most people have grown accustomed to. It's a trade-off!
- lucid00 11y agoThat and they wouldn't get classic BitTorrent compatibility in a web app.
- SimeVidas 11y agoI thought WebTorrent already is BitTorrent-compatible, no?
- shawabawa3 11y agoNo, WebRTC cannot make normal TCP connections so it can't be used to connect to a classic client. In theory all bittorrent software could implement WebRTC connections though
- RubyPinch 11y agofeels pretty and nice. really easy to share files with this too (no more waiting to upload to a host, etc etc) Once this gets the standard set of features (file selection being the main one for me, since datacaps exist here, and spending 14 GB to watch the first ep and then decide I don't like whatever I'm watching is a bit of a pain) (also compact mode), I think this might very-well become my go-to client
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lewisl9029 11y agoJust gave this a spin and really loved the ease of use, but I can't quite replace my go-to torrent client (currently Hadouken) with it just yet. Here are some suggestions for future improvements to consider in case they're not on your shortlist already: 1) Ability to monitor multiple folders and automatically add torrents (and ideally the ability to specify a different download location for each) 2) Ability to run as a headless service/daemon with a thin management UI like Deluge/Transmission/Hadouken/etc
- feross 11y ago> Ability to monitor multiple folders and automatically add torrents I don't think this is a bad idea, but that's definitely a feature for v2. 2) Ability to run as a headless service/daemon with a thin management UI like Deluge/Transmission/Hadouken/etc reply This isn't exactly what you're asking for, but you might appreciate webtorrent-cli: https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-cli https://github.com/feross/webtorrent-cli which works entirely from the command line.
- math0ne 11y agoThere's a bunch of these already but none of them allow you to limit bandwidth so they are unusable on residential internet in most cases. Baffles me...
- feross 11y agoThis is a planned feature. Will be fixed soon: https://github.com/feross/webtorrent/issues/163 https://github.com/feross/webtorrent/issues/163
- williamcotton 11y agoKeep up the great fucking work!!!
- ashitlerferad 11y agoDo torrent trackers need support for WebTorrent before they work with WebTorrent clients?
- irascible 11y agoDamn this is cool.
- esturk 11y agoI just tried it out. It's pretty cool but for some reason there was no audio. Its going to be interesting to see how to guys handle the hodgepodge of video and audio codecs out there.
- subinsebastien 11y agoThe website is so beautiful, I want to bookmark it.
- noffle 11y agoExcellent work; gorgeous website! Congratulations on the release.
- theresnochoice 11y agoWhat about Peerflix (https://github.com/mafintosh/peerflix https://github.com/mafintosh/peerflix)? This has been around for a while. You can actually play your videos/other stuff in the media player of your likings, like VLC, which is a mature and stable video player. Why build an entire video player so you can stream..
- SeanDav 11y agoUnless I am mistaken, this does not appear to have a way to easily limit upload/download rate, which would be a deal breaker for me. Happy to be proven wrong on this of course.
- _antares 11y ago+1 Would definitely use if I would be able to cut the upload entirely. Currently under jurisdiction that prohibits sharing illegal content, while perfectly legal to download any music/videos for personal use only if available in the network.
- mariusmg 11y agoI still prefer peerflix over stuff like this. Small CLI app and you can use a superior video player (VLC, SMPLayer, mpv etc).
- aluhut 11y agoSince Popcorn Time I've been confronted with a rising number of people who have no idea that those "streaming" portals are also uploading. I'm being confronted because they got a letter from a friendly lawyer telling them to pay a lot of money. I hope you are communicating that fact properly.
- bluesign 11y agoI think opensubtitles integration can be a good feature too.
- ultramancool 11y agoTake note developers of similar things - the use of freely licensed content in your demo screenshot might save your ass legally. This is something many people seem to screw up - just yesterday a similar torrent streaming tool had pirated screenshots. The OpenBazaar guys actually suggested using it for illegal things at one point... Like it or not, courts have recognized a difference between soneone who built a tool for legal uses and someone who built a tool for piracy.
- J_Darnley 11y agoNot fucking again! This is not a torrent client. It cannot speak to any other existing client. The browser is not the right place for a torrent client.
- edraferi 11y agoIncorrect. This client knows both the WebTorrent and BitTorrent protocols, bridging the two networks.
- cm3 11y agoWill browsers prompt (like mic and video) for permission before opening p2p traffic? I'm afraid random sites could behind my back make my machine (via nat traversal if needed) participate in illegal torrenting. It's the legal world we live in, and while I welcome the new browser abstractions, this must be behind a permission popup and provide a way to permanently disable without building a custom browser. What's the status on that?
- arnaudbud 11y agoProbably the best WebRTC app made with Electron! Congrats to Feross & DC! Guys, would you like to present at the next SF WebRTC Meetup on April 28th? http://www.meetup.com/SF-WebRTC/events/229430038/ http://www.meetup.com/SF-WebRTC/events/229430038/
- feross 11y agoYes, we'll do it :) Email me!