12 ms·
Seattle is putting up $50B for transit
- news_to_me 11y agoThe Capitol Hill and U District extension of the light rail is a much-appreciated addition, as ridership shows since they opened. Based on my personal conversations with residents, more corridors like this are badly wanted. For instance, I'm not sure why the Ballard-U District line is ignored as much as it is in official plans.
- phinnaeus 11y agoThe other big missing piece is a cross-town rail line. Currently there are three main corridors for going east-west in Seattle: Denny Way (home to the 8 bus line), Mercer St (a glorified entrance/exit thoroughfare for I-5 and the bridges across Lake Washington), and 45th/50th St north of Lake Union (home to the 44 bus line). Now that UW and Capitol Hill have a station, it makes sense to at least study the feasibility of an east-west line that could provide an alternative to at-grade transit and connect to the Link. Another advantage of a crosstown route north of Lake Union is it could continue east over the brand new 520 bridge, which was designed to support Light Rail and connect to the east side. As a resident of Seattle, the current plan is vexxing. I love transit, and I don't mind voting for something that I'll never see (as long as there are good reasons for the long timeline) but I'd certainly prefer a different set of priorities for light rail.
- news_to_me 11y agoExactly, it's such a chore to go East/West. Ballard-U District along 45th/50th seems like the most obvious addition to me, along with a line to the Eastside - I know that if I worked in Bellevue, the ability to take the light rail to work would be my top priority.
- farnsworth 11y agoYeah, it's practically impossible to work at Microsoft and live in Ballard without driving every day, unless you want to spend (probably more than?) an hour on the bus each way. And even driving is going to be pretty slow.
- rconti 11y agoBallard -> Redmond has gotta be 45 minutes by car at the BEST of times. I'd think it'd be closer to 90min by bus at rush hour. 520 is an unmitigated traffic disaster (granted, I haven't been on it since the tolling began). When I lived in the area I often joked I'd drive 405-90-5 if I was going from Kirkland to the U-District. Having spent 2 hours in traffic on the bridge alone in the past, it's not far from the truth.
- mc32 11y agoIIRC, one of the main complaints from boeing is that the traffic situation is disastrous for their JIT parts deliveries and have threatened to pull out of Seattle b/c of that (not just the HQ, as they did a few years ago).
- DaveMebs 11y agoIf you take the Ballard Connector to MSFT it is not that bad. 45-60 minutes depending on traffic. With the new 520 work on the Eastside, the carpool lanes are speeding things up dramatically and I expect it's closer to 45 most days (I'm in Phinney currently, and I'm usually at 45-50 minutes on the last stop).
- RyJones 11y agoIf you're doing the counter commute, Kirkland->Seattle Business District in the morning, 520 is a great option. Most people have abandoned it due to the toll, but the only area where things get sticky is the merge from 405->520 where you need to merge left twice in short order and then merge left again directly after the Burgermaster exit. The merge across I5 to the Union exit is annoying since the backup for the Mercer exit (and people that never realized the needed to take Mercer) extends almost to 520, but if you wait in the third lane from left until you pass Mercer, you can usually merge gracefully right and take Union. The return commute is only screwy when there's a big con - SakuraCon for example. I did take Mercer for the three months I worked at Lab 126 in Fiona, but I assume it's better now that construction is over. It was much worse.
- xxpor 11y agoIf anyone's trying to find these streets on a map, they're all streets, not avenues, e.g. 45th St., Mercer St. In Seattle, Sts are E/W, Aves are N/S. This is an extremely common mistake in Seattle, and I have no idea why.
- phinnaeus 11y agoFixed. Thank you.
- msandford 11y agoGainesville, FL has got their stuff together. Streets are North/South; Streets has an S in it and so does South, they all also have a T. Ave are East/West; Ave has an E in it and so do both East and West, also Ave and East share an A. It's either really silly, or genius, or complete luck that my overly analytical brain turned into something real.
- xxpor 11y agoI just want to make sure I say I wasn't trying to criticize or anything, just trying to improve the clarity of the post.
- techsupporter 11y agoAs a resident of Seattle who lives south of the ship canal, I am going to lose my mind if we don't get to, someday, vote on transit through the Central District. The CD has more riders and more density than the opening-in-2021 station in Roosevelt. Roosevelt is going to be zoned lower than the upcoming rezone at 23rd and Jackson. Yet, inexplicably, nobody ever wants to put a Metro 8 Subway to a vote. I'm already half tempted to vote no on ST3 because running light rail to ISSAQUAH--expected to get 11,000 riders per day, or 70% of the riders that a single route (number 48) through the CD gets--before filling in the gaps in the rest of our system is just...galling. But I'll probably vote yes because it's not like voting no is going to end subarea equity. (See the seattlesubway.org yellow line for what a Denny/23rd Ave "Metro 8 Subway" would look like.)
- OrwellianChild 11y agoNow's your chance to get involved! As a soon-to-be Beacon/Mt. Baker resident, I'm right there with you on the south-end infill... Their final plan will be decided in June, so we have to speak up now!
- Silfen 11y agoThe issue is the outsize power that suburban districts have relative to population. Intra-Seattle light rail would clearly be best for the city, but Snohomish gets as much of a say as the city proper. The U District stop is actually a great example of this. Farther west (e.g. near The Ave), there is much more transit access and substantially more walkable areas. But the priority seems to be getting suburbanites to Huskies games. Disclaimer: That's not to say I dislike the extension. It's the first time Link has been useful for anything other than getting to the airport.
- phinnaeus 11y agoFWIW, they are opening a station in U-District proper... in 2021. Your point stands that the priorities are a little wack.
- gohrt 11y agoAnd when Seattle tries to build its own in-city solutions, county/state voters vote to block it.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoTo be fair, the stop does work for students who want to get to campus (via a bridge). It is about the same walk from the stadium or the Ave to the campus center.
- jroseattle 11y agoI'm waiting for the next station to open at NE65th/Roosevelt, which will help further -- but there is already a building boom happening around there with new condos and such. And it's not open until something like 2021. An east/west option that ran from Ballard, stopped in U-District, and continued to Bellevue and Redmond would be the bomb. Game-changing for recruiting -- imagine living in Ballard and working at Microsoft, or living in Redmond but working at Expedia (after they move.) And your commute not sucking the life out of you.
- mratzloff 11y agoIt's infuriating that it took this long for them to add West Seattle to a Seattle transit proposal. Every day I cringe at the thought of another accident or overturned semi on the West Seattle Bridge or 99 stopping traffic for 60-90 minutes.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoThe article title is misleading. The ST3 package is being put to voters in November, Seattle isn't simply ponying up $50bn. Seattle doesn't have $50bn to put into transit. Here's more information on ST3: http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/24/st3-draft-plan-overview/ http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/24/st3-draft-plan-over... http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/31/how-to-fix-st3-so-seattle-will-vote-for-it/ http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/31/how-to-fix-st3-so-s...
- slagfart 11y agoAs a non-american, I am stunned - if ridership is only 20%, how on earth are all these people parking their cars in downtown Seattle? Carpark skyscrapers?
- xyzzyz 11y agoThere's quite a lot of $10/hour parking in downtown Seattle -- almost every high-rise building has multiple levels of publicly available parking. Also, if you take a taxi/Uber, you don't need parking.
- slagfart 11y agoWhat are the incentives at play here? Is it mandated that buildings need carparks, or is space genuinely so plentiful that this is economic? I can't imagine a carpark-sized area of office space goes for $10/day, even after the cost of carpet and coffee.
- timthelion 11y ago$10 per hour not per day...
- dionidium 11y ago"Is it mandated that buildings need carparks" Yes. Most towns have zoning rules that include minimum parking requirements for new construction.
- mulmen 11y agoMost of the car parks are underground, it's not like they are taking up viable office space.
- mjevans 11y agoThe problem with the region is that geographic constraints spread everything out; if you look at the terrain a giant sound, a bay, and Lake Washington divide what should be one nicely sloped set of density across narrow strips of hilly land. The region is plagued by horrid traffic steaming from several interacting issues. * There are four large cities, each of which also has numerous suburbs and even un-incorporated areas. Urban planing across these regions sure seems like it doesn't occur. * 'The Rent is Too darn High'; because there needs to be /far/ more supply side control of the market. * Housing near jobs (and near quality education for workers with children) is consequently very expensive; contributing to workers living far from their jobs. * Jobs are no longer permanent lifetime things, with a single 'bread winner' able to easily support their family; contributing to workers living far from their jobs. * Moving is a PITA; contributing to workers living far from their jobs. * Transit isn't laid out in a mesh, thus doing anything other than suburb to downtown (a model that worked in the era of big companies and lifetime employment) takes many transfers and a lot of time; encouraging workers to /drive/ (for freedom). The best solution that I see is making it possible for at least the major bus lines to be run as self-driving systems. A 'car pod' version of bus transit with point to point automated driving, particularly if those pods could link up and/or draft for improved efficiency on the long hauls looks like a far better solution.
- timthelion 11y agoI for one, am extremely dissapointed with the concept of "bus rapid transit". I live in Prague, and so I experience all three froms of mass transit: metro(subway), tram, and bus. Busses are extremely uncomfortable. They rock as they drive, and they have really awful seating arangements due to the need for tall wheel wells. I don't see the point in including busses as a part of a modern system. They also have a much shorter lifespan, and have horible gas milage/electric efficiency compared to tram cars which last over 50 years. I think that busses are only included in the system due to the convenience of not having to have a line to the depo, and perhaps the corruption of the consultants involved. As Americans, you may have this impression that mass transit is a horrible thing for poor people. That impression comes from busses, where the bus is rocking around so much that you cannot whip out your cellphone and read on the way to work(one of the big advantages of mass transit over a car). Trams, however, are very comfortable. The floor is always extremely stable, you can comfortably read or do work on your laptop. You no longer feel the stress of driving and your commute can become a "free time" part of your day, rather than a stressfull period between home and work.
- rsync 11y ago"As Americans, you may have this impression that mass transit is a horrible thing for poor people. That impression comes from busses" This cannot be overstated. There is nothing in the urban, built environment that is as terrible aesthetically and functionally as some big lumbering bus bonking its way through the city (and usually belching black smoke as it goes). I am a huge advocate of public transit and I will do anything to not ride a bus. Always remember the quote from Steve Jobs about tablets and the stylus: "If you see a (bus), they blew it." edit: Yes, yes I know all about BRT. Lipstick on a pig.
- munificent 11y ago> There is nothing in the urban, built environment that is as terrible aesthetically and functionally as some big lumbering bus bonking its way through the city (and usually belching black smoke as it goes). I'm pretty sure the NYC subway in the 80s could give it a run for its money: https://www.google.com/search?q=new+york+subway+80s&espv=2&biw=1326&bih=805&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjyneHHpvvLAhVY62MKHU0wBRYQ_AUIBigB&dpr=2 https://www.google.com/search?q=new+york+subway+80s&espv=2&b... I agree totally that buses have a negative stigma, some of which is rightly deserved.
- seattle_spring 11y agoThis won't pass with the current proposal. No one is going to vote to significantly increase their taxes for something they won't even see in 20 years. Most people have no idea where they'll be in 5 years, let alone 20. Further, the entire proposal is for at-grade rail. That means that these trains will be delayed by both road and waterway traffic. Do you really want to be stuck in a train for 30 minutes while some rich guy needs to float his yacht through a major city?
- frankus 11y agoThe timeline sucks, and there's arguably too much at grade, but the particularly congested part (from Uptown to International District) would be in a new tunnel.
- CamperBob2 11y agoAgreed, it won't fly. I'm not going to vote to spend $50E9 on a transit system that will be finished just in time to be rendered obsolete by autonomous vehicles.
- rayiner 11y ago> Because it is serving areas without major jobs centers or walkable neighborhoods, the long light rail corridor is inherently oriented toward suburb-to-downtown commuters. This is the biggest problem with transit outside NYC/Chicago. Those cities are surrounded by walkable suburbs that justify regional rail. Everywhere else, the surrounding suburbs were not designed at all, and it's questionably valuable running rail out to them. I take the Silver Line to work in D.C. None of it runs through any sensibly designed area. There are a tiny handful of apartments within walking distance of any Silver Line station, and even the closest ones are separated by enormous dangerous parking lots. My commute is actually takes longer than it did back when I used to commute from a walkable New York suburb into midtown, even though the physical distance is about 40% less. I'm pretty skeptical of the return on transit dollars in place like Seattle. It seems to me that it's simply too late to turn these places into real cities.
- slagfart 11y agoWhy are the parking lots dangerous? Honest question
- 1stop 11y agoUsually not well lit, and easy to hide/escape/etc
- rayiner 11y agoBecause NoVA drivers are all blind.
- TulliusCicero 11y agoI don't know about dangerous, but walking through a sea of parking lots is generally pretty unpleasant as a pedestrian. Unlike a driver, where your immediate environment is the car, which you control, a pedestrian's immediate environment is the street and neighborhood.
- timthelion 11y agoMaybe OP was reffering to sexual violence...
- bkeroack 11y agoLA has a proposal for $120B in transit investment over a similar timeframe. http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-transit-projects-20160311-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-transit-pro...
- pklausler 11y agoA plug for a technology that amplifies the reach of transit: the folding bicycle (e.g., Bromptons). You can't run trains to everybody's home or workplace, but you can run trains to within a couple of miles of the endpoints of the commutes of many persons. Can some of this large budget somehow be used to subsidize folding bikes?
- phinnaeus 11y agoSeattle has a problem with casual bike ridership: it's very hilly. There are a bunch of bike commuters, but they all already own their own bikes. There is also a bike share system which is failing horribly primarily for this and one other reason: the stations were spaced horribly around town and riders can not know with confidence that there will be a station near their destination to park. Also, 8-9 months of the year Seattle is pretty miserable to bike in without the proper gear -- even with the proper gear it's very far from what I would call "appealing."
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> There is also a bike share system which is failing horribly primarily for this The point of bike share is for casual cyclists or people who want to pair bike share with transit for the last mile (which is annoying to do with your own bike). It's a niche that's not really intended to compete with people owning their own bikes. > the stations were spaced horribly around town and riders can not know with confidence that there will be a station near their destination to park. Agreed. Apparently this is supposed to get better with the city taking over the program, because then they can pair the stations with transit stops better. > Also, 8-9 months of the year Seattle is pretty miserable to bike in without the proper gear -- even with the proper gear it's very far from what I would call "appealing." Seattle isn't really that rainy. It's actually less rainy than Munich, for example, and Munich has more than 4x the bike mode share as Seattle.
- prodigal_erik 11y ago> Seattle [is] actually less rainy than Munich Seattle doesn't get heavy rain, it's just damp for weeks at a time. How do they compare in dry days per year rather than total amount?
- Apocryphon 11y agoif only the Bay Area likewise had some sort of similar industry as lucrative as that in Seattle, which similarly yields the tax revenue to fund such endeavors
- rdl 11y agoHow does Seattle get such a generally reasonable city government (and even better in the surrounding cities) compared to San Francisco (and the neighboring cities, too). As far as I can tell both places are roughly the same in demographics, education, and only recently has SF surged ahead in wealth (and SF used to be even worse than it is now.)
- jseliger 11y agoThe short answer is voters. The longer answer is complicated. 1. Some urban planning decisions are made at the state, not local, level, which means that more housing gets built and prices are lower: http://www.vox.com/2016/4/6/11370258/honan-zoning-reform-bill http://www.vox.com/2016/4/6/11370258/honan-zoning-reform-bil.... 2. The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) is insane. For example, it allows anyone to sue anyone building anything on environmental grounds. 3. CA has Prop 13, which is also insane, and Prop U in LA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposition_U https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposition_U which is insane. Prop U encourages some people at the margins to pick SF over LA. 4. SF has rent control, which means that many voters are encouraged to say no to everything. 5. The cities' histories are different: http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing. SF has a longer history of radical, economically illiterate politics than Seattle. 6. Seattle's city government is not quite as reasonable as it looks. Google "The Seattle Process" or Kshama Sawant. It only looks better than SF because SF has uniquely terrible voters.
- rdl 11y agoWhich eastside city is the most sane? Bellevue? Issaquah? Redmond?
- teacup50 11y agoYou can't really make the comparison being made in #1 without a lot of assumptions that just don't actually hold water in the market. Seattle has a population of 652k, with an average density of 8k/sq mi. San Francisco has a population of 864k, with an average density of 18.5k/sq mi. And yet: Seattle has a jobs-to-housing ratio of 1.5 SF has a jobs-to-housing ratio of 1.6 So what explains SF's higher costs? Density coupled with massive wealth inequality. Period. Upzoning increases land value in a tight market. Markets remain tight in desirable locations and no amount of development has been able to keep up; population is growing, job growth in the tech sector is high, and the wealth gap coupled with high demand means that there's enormous price elasticity for some, who then push the rest out. High density construction carries a higher barrier to entry, and is almost exclusively allocated to rental units. Additionally, high density construction allows one to combine multiple profitable uses in the same plot; commercial and residential. This accelerates the wealth divide, putting more money into the hands of fewer and fewer land owners, with rents tracking whatever the high demand is capable of sustaining. Nobody else ever builds up equity, the city winds up being owned by fewer and fewer, and the low end of the market is priced out. This then requires attempts at government correction, through subsidized housing; either as outright grants to developers, zoning variances granted to allow higher margins in exchange for permanently affordable (but still rental!) units, tax credits, etc. This further accelerates the growth of the wealth divide, as development and development investment companies begin to specialize in cornering access to (and brokerage of) these economic perks that are unavailable to individual potential home owners. Density does not fix housing. It literally never has, and I do not even begin to understand how this conception became the norm amongst housing activists. As near as I call tell, it's something that's been green/liberal-washed as a necessity by those who profit the most from the government-funded development incentives.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoI hate it. I hate it so much. I think if we spent $50,000,000,000 on infrastructure to support autonomous vehicles it would both be better and we'd see returns sooner. Light rail is expensive to build, slow to build, more expensive to maintain, and completely inflexible as needs of the city change. I will vote no in the fall. And I'll encourage my friends to do so. This makes me a minority in Seattle but I'm ok with that. Some additional food for thought: http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/11/why-dont-we-know-where-all-the-trains-are/415152/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/11/why-do...
- manacit 11y agoI'm not trying to change your opinion (HN is not the place to change one you clearly hold very strongly), but as someone who lives in NYC and spent 4 years living in Seattle (I moved away in 2014), I will happily say that the article you posted has nearly no correlation to your earlier points about light rail, and that the NYC Subway is an amazing piece of (partially) publicly funded work that has shaped NYC and the surrounding region in innumerable positive ways. There are about 1.7 billion rides taken on it every year with over 200 miles of track. It'd be an understatement to say that the city could not exist the way it does now without it - autonomous vehicles won't get the sheer number of people moved every morning and every night that the subway does. A full order of magnitude more people take the subway on a daily basis than there are taxi rides, all for a maximum of $2.75 regardless of how far they're traveling. It might not be the best thing for Seattle (personally, I am a big proponent), but a blanket distaste for light rail is antithetical to what has proven fundamental for cities around the world. As far as spending public money, there are already efficiency concerns (something that your article definitely demonstrates) - I'm curious how you think public money could help fund technology that fundamentally does not exist today? Is that not a higher risk for future technology?
- marssaxman 11y agoI'll vote no but for the opposite reason: I think we need lots more light rail and we need it in Seattle, not in the suburbs. Autonomous vehicles cannot possibly solve our transportation problems because the best they can do to reduce congestion is nothing; at worst, they will aggravate problems by increasing the number of trips taken.
- dclowd9901 11y agoThe Bay Bridge one mile bypass cost about $6.4Bn. It was quite contentious too, and did nothing to make getting through the city any easier. It amazes me how unwilling most municipalities are to make this kind of investment in transit that would actually make it easier for people to get around rather than just pumping more lanes into freeways. Seattle should be lauded for putting their money where their citizens wants are.
- tn13 11y agoCity administrations are not good at figuring out the needs of transportation especially when they give less importance to market needs and focus more on propaganda. D.C.'s Metro system: http://reason.com/blog/2016/03/20/dc-metro-repairs-closed-escalators http://reason.com/blog/2016/03/20/dc-metro-repairs-closed-es...
- BIair 11y agoIsn't this money squandered, if autonomous vehicles are likely by the time of its completion?
- timthelion 11y agoOnly if you don't care about the environment. Autonomous vehicles, even electric ones, are inefficient compared to mass transit.
- tdicola 11y agoEven if the cars drive themselves there's still not enough lanes to let them flow right now, much less in 20+ years. There was a study done that found Seattle's needs _22_ lanes of highway to meet the current demand. However because of how the highway system was originally built through the city we're stuck with 6-8 lanes at best. We need mass transit to get cars off the roads and reduce traffic.
- CydeWeys 11y agoReally smart autonomous vehicles that automatically do ridesharing and that intelligently pack vehicles full of 4-6 people on their way in could do it. At that point you're dealing with an experience that's not too different from a bus though (i.e. sharing a space with strangers). There's not enough capacity for everyone to commute in on their own individual autonomous vehicle, nor is there enough parking downtown, so the vehicles would have to be commuting twice daily.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoAutonomous vehicles don't really solve the core congestion problem. At the end of the day the road is only so large, cars are relatively big, and it's rush hour and everyone is travelling at the same time. Public transit is more efficient.
- transitthrow 11y ago(I pulled these numbers off Wikipedia, but they seem about right.) Light rail can carry up to 13,000 passengers per direction per hour. A highway lane carries up to 1,900 cars per lane per hour. It takes about 6 lanes of highways to match 1 lane of light rail given current car usage (1 passenger per car). If usage patterns change (say, an automated carpool that maximizes the capacity of the vehicle -- say 5 people per car), you still have 1900 * 5 = 9,500 passengers per lane per hour, which is good, but still worse than a single lane of light rail. Hey, worse is better right? However, the bottleneck in many cities isn't the highway, but rather the smaller city streets the highway feeds into. Transit can sidestep this bottleneck altogether with subway tunnels, which automated vehicles can't. Even after everything else, light rail is still more economical and more environmentally friendly.* Finally, light rail converts to automated train operation quite handily (further increasing capacity), especially if all the other cars around it are automated too. * I was about to say more comfortable, but is being crammed into a small car more or less comfortable than standing on a cramped train?
- calcsam 11y agoMetropolitan Seattle has 3.5m people. This project will cost ~$15k per resident, roughly equivalent to the per-person national debt.
- CydeWeys 11y agoIt will cost that much per resident over 30 years. The actual per-year cost is a good deal smaller. A better comparison to the annual debt would be per capita annual transit spending vs per capita annual national budget deficit (not total debt).
- avn2109 11y agoIf I still lived in Seattle and had the choice between a) Functional transit for a one time payment of $15 grand and then chump change for train fare for the rest of my life and b) Buying, fueling, insuring, maintaining, and driving a car at a vastly greater cost (probably around 10 grand per year all-in) for the rest of my life I would pick A) every time. It's not even a contest, I would pick A) at twice the price. Hell, it would probably be economically rational to pick A) at 5x the price.
- the_cat_kittles 11y agoas a current resident of nearly 25 years, i agree wholeheartedly.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoSeattle has 3.5 million people now. A good rail system will be serving the city in MANY generations to come. And yes future cost of money but it also seems these projects become ever more expensive too if delayed. Anecdotally, I've traveled a reasonable amount. Any city I've been to with a world calls metro system (6 I've seen) are all hugely appreciated by the local and tourists alike. I've never head someone say "that underground was a waste of money". In cities without metros I've heard a bunch of complaints about the lack of the ability to move around quickly/easily.
- 11y ago
- WalterBright 11y agoSeattle also can run tracks across the 520 bridge for $200M and can use an existing 100 foot wide rail corridor on the Eastside from Renton to Bothell for a song. This would nearly double the trackage and communities served by light rail for well under $1B. But that's nowhere in the $50B plan.
- free2rhyme214 11y agoI think Seattle is better off allocating $50B towards self driving projects. Seattle isn't Tokyo but that's what its trying to be here.
- roflchoppa 11y agoi just wanted to say that I'm jelly about y'all getting funding for extension on transit. BART is a joke.
- 1024core 11y agoIf the Bay Area spent serious money on good public transportation, we would not have a "housing crisis" like we have today. People prefer the vibrance of SF, and choose to live in SF because getting to/from SF is a pain in the ass. And BART shuts down before midnight. We can build as much housing as we want, but as long as we lack a solid public transportation system, we'll be miserable: more cars on the roads, longer commutes, etc. SF itself has to fix its MUNI; we need a 24-hr BART that is cheap and reliable; a CalTrain that runs very frequently and is 24-hr again; and feeder routes in the smaller cities.
- kazinator 11y ago> You’ve got $50 billion for transit. Now how should you spend it? I'd get everyone a decent, quality bicycle loaded with all the right features for commuting/road use, and improve the cycling infrastructure. No idea what I would do with the gobs of money left over after that. I'd definitely not waste any on some buses, though.
- npunt 11y agoWith $50B, I'd focus on building an autonomous vehicle network. Here's how: 1. create autonomous vehicle road network by both creating new roads and retrofitting existing roads with physical barriers where desirable. This would be similar to building rail lines in places (say elevated or tunnels), except with much more flexibility. 2. put up a RFP/challenge to auto manufacturers for fleet of autonomous electric vehicles, likely of a few types for different passenger loads (2-10) and needs (disabled access, small cargo). 3. put up a RFP/challenge to build efficient routing backend for fleet. 4. put up a RFP/challenge for both card-based (for those without smartphones) and app-based pickup and destination setting, as well as car interface to handle route changes. Plan financially for frequent improvements due to rapid tech changes. 5. create infrastructure of very small depots throughout city where autonomous charging as well as manned cleaning & minor repairs could happen. 6. rope in social services to have progressive prices based on income, allowing typical subsidies for seniors, disabled, low income, etc. Here’s why: * Separate lanes are helpful for near term autonomous vehicles that are not as good at avoiding things. They’re also good as a backup for smaller human-driven busses in the shorter term as the autonomous vehicle development ramps up. * Can use existing highways, sectioning off a separate lane and creating select off-ramps to connect to autonomous road network. * Roads are cheaper per mile than rail. * Rather than large highway tunneling projects (oh seattle…), can build small one-way tunnels over certain stretches where useful - say a few blocks that typically have terrible traffic. * Smaller vehicles with fewer passengers helps the inconvenience factor and last-mile problem of busses by providing flexibility in pickup/drop-off locations * smaller vehicles and more convenience in locations helps to improve public image - it’d be like uber/lyft but without the traffic. * Kickstarts rapid improvement in autonomous vehicle industry by being a large customer, which can benefit city with better tech over time (vs aging train cars). * Adds useful infrastructure for the future where private fleets and privately owned cars can participate with their own autonomous vehicles. Essentially, it allows for a phase-out of publicly owned/run autonomous vehicle fleets in the future, were that to be something that makes sense. I could see GM/Lyft and Uber being bidders in this process, among other auto manufacturers. There may even be an opportunity to own less of the fleet and simply rent at a particular per mile rate. In short: spend money on the future of transportation, not the past.