4 ms·
In USA there are format shifting rights in the Fair Use doctrine I gather. So one could buy the book and scan it and create an ebook, as this is logically equiv
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
In USA there are format shifting rights in the Fair Use doctrine I gather. So one could buy the book and scan it and create an ebook, as this is logically equivalent to getting a copy from a torrenting site but is far less economical and wastes more resources it seems the moral thing to do is buy the paperback and send it for pulping and download a copy of the ebook?
The author gets paid, the publisher gets paid, you get the copy you want with less resource waste than scanning it for yourself.
Anyone have a moral objection to that they'd care to elucidate.
- soperj 11y agoIs the torrenting it really illegal when you own the book already?
- tasnent 11y agoFor now.
- Crespyl 11y agoArguably, yes, since in bittorrent downloading content is directly tied to distribution of content. By torrenting a work you own in a different format, you are (potentially) also distributing that work to someone who doesn't already own a copy.
- Falcon9 11y agoI'd wager so since you own a book, not the content of the book. But the law is a funny thing.
- coldtea 11y agoYes it is. But illegal might be the wrong question. Is it unethical?
- soperj 11y agoI'd say no.