8 ms·
Lyft’s Logan Green on Building Uber’s ‘Happier’ U.S. Rival
- pbreit 11y agoI would love for "happy" to win in this market and would settle for it staying in the game.
- sokoloff 11y agoI care about safe, convenient, and efficient/economical in personal transportation. All other things being equal, sure I'd like for "happy" to be part of it, but not at the expense of the first 3 measures.
- ethanbond 11y agoImplying that Lyft doesn't accomplish those?
- mavrc 11y agoA rudimentary search or two would seem to indicate that driver happiness and driver safety are connected. I don't know how to effectively measure it, but it would seem to me that at least some consideration should be paid to driver happiness as a safety factor.
- rdtsc 11y agoI tried both recently and noticed that some drivers also use both. Depending on time of day, demands, other factor they will alternate between being Lyft drivers and Uber drivers. Also noticed Lyft-only drivers are friendlier or just more content. Is it because they encourage tipping? Some claimed because company treated them better (those who started working for Uber). One driver switched recounted he picked up some scary drunk and disrespectful passengers when working for Uber and he found little recourse by talking to company. So that was the moment he jumped ship.
- piptastic 11y agoAren't passengers rated? Assuming consistent bad behavior they should be able to avoid these customers. What exactly did they want Uber to do?
- rdtsc 11y agoThere were a bunch of things, one thing that stuck in my mind, they were concerned with lack of internal customer support for the drivers and a lack attention.
- wtvanhest 11y agoOn average, Lyft Drivers and passengers seem to be more talkative, more interactive and more fun to ride with. Typically I select Lyft over uber, except when... I don't feel like talking to anyone. I get the impression that other people do the same. Basically I pick Lyft when I want to be social and Uber when I don't. Having both choices makes my life better, and probably better for drivers as well.
- lucasmullens 11y agoFor Lyft I believe they recommend sitting up front if you want to talk, and in back if you don't.
- readams 11y agoThe no tipping thing is one of the best things about Uber. I wish we could get rid of tipping everywhere.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ndirish1842 11y agoI've only taken Uber (Lyft is not available in the city where I go to university), but I find most of my Uber drivers as extremely friendly. I've had some very interesting conversations with Uber drivers during my rides, and they nearly always seem happy to talk. I wonder if Uber drivers in cities without Lyft are happier because Uber is the only option.
- dnautics 11y agoThey're also smaller towns, so the driver demographic is different and probably skewed towards happy relative to the driver demographic in big cities.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jcomis 11y agoI find most Uber drivers to be very friendly, but if you venture into the driver forums that are out there it's really a different story. So many drivers that seem to absolutely hate everything about Uber, the passengers in particular, but continue to drive. It's weird.
- vkou 11y agoIt's almost as if their livelihood depends on it...
- bbulkow 11y agoI have found exactly that: Lyft drivers are happier. I had an Uber driver coerce me into rating him a few weeks ago, while I was in his car. He had a BS reason for wanting the rating now, it was just a ploy to get 5 stars. He was also insanely talkative. Uber might be a little more professional, but one is also playing the odds. Right now, I check Lyft first, and take that if available. Unless I'm in a downtown area, then I will check an actual taxi app ( flywheel or yotaxi in SF ). If the lyft cars are sparse, I take uber. Just so I can keep mixing it up and trying different services. ( Flywheel has a terrible new design where they ask you for a "guarenteed tip" before the car is called. I tried to bail out of that - I don't like tipping in general, and I really don't like tipping before I can judge the service ), and I was charged $6 for cancelling. Whoa. No wonder people don't like Taxis.
- hspak 11y agoI find that most drivers (that I've had) in SF drive for both Lyft and Uber so it feels wrong to say Lyft drivers are "happier", but I'm just a single data point.
- pbreit 11y agoThat's conventional wisdom but I don't think really accurate. While drivers may be set up for both, they typically favor one.
- junker101 11y agoSince Lyft actually 'supports' the ability for riders to tip their driver, I would suspect the same person is always happier when their fair is using Lyft's app.
- fapjacks 11y agoDing ding ding! Free money usually makes people happier than no free money. I exclusively use Lyft, and talk to my drivers all the time. They also say Lyft riders are better than Uber riders. Not sure if free money plays into that, but I guess so.
- homulilly 11y agoI exclusively ride Uber because there's no tipping. More honest pricing is great.
- draw_down 11y agoI'm just lazy and don't feel like signing up for yet another service. I hate entering all those stupid details for the millionth time.
- dnautics 11y agoThere is really no expectation of tips on Lyft. When I was a driver, only about 20% of my rides tipped (and I was a 4.9-4.95 driver, though it could be a race/gender thing) and it's frankly nearly impossible to track who tipped you or didn't.
- SilasX 11y agoYeah. While I like what Uber is doing about tipping, even with Lyft, the system is a lot better because I don't have to decide the tip while also trying to get out and be on my way, or with someone staring at me.
- aje404 11y agoForewarning: I don't have WSJ, so I can only really comment on the title and get a little context from the comments. I've only used Lyft and Uber in NYC, but I use both frequently (or have; I was "scammed" by a Lyft driver and had a kafkaesque experience with Lyft's management trying to resolve the situation, since which I haven't used their services). I almost always engage my drivers and try to get to know them. Frankly, I haven't noticed any difference whatsoever in their "friendliness". Topics range anyway to US politics, their home countries' politics, to their job, to their family, to whatever else. Almost all drivers will engage me (assuming their English is good). The only difference in engagement I've noticed is from Taxi drivers, who, of course, expect tips, and thus, I don't think there's much merit to the preconception that "they're nicer to me because they want my money!". Most people enjoy talking to others; when they're stuck in a car with someone for a half hour, they just might want to chat about life. I think it's that simple. I've asked nearly every driver, with either Lyft or Uber, how they feel about either company, and they rarely have any complaints (and no, I don't think they suspect I'm auditing them or anything along those lines). At least in NYC, bear in mind that the vast majority of these guys are in some combination of: 1. Working for both Lyft and Uber (whenever they feel like it) 2. Driving as a part time gig 3. Coming from a Taxi gig, and thus, the grass is much greener regardless of whether either Lyft or Uber empirically "treats them better" Just as well, I really can't imagine that customer treatment varies wildly between Lyft and Uber. All of these guys have horror stories about customers, just as us, as passengers, have horror stories about drivers. So, I think, despite not reading the article, Lyft, via Logan, is likely just spewing marketing nonsense, and a lot of commenters leaning towards a particular company might want to rethink the bases for their conceptions.
- qq66 11y ago"no, I don't think they suspect I'm auditing them or anything along those lines" How can you be sure of this? When you're dependent on an organization for your paycheck, it's best not to say bad things about that organization, whether you actively suspect someone of being an auditor or not.
- aje404 11y agoThe same as I would when conversing with anyone else; it's generally obvious when someone you're talking to is putting on their political filter, no? I don't come out and ask things like "has either Uber or Lyft screwed you over?" (or any other inquiry of that nature), but plenty of peripherals come up in conversation. Granted, neither company is a paradise for a would-be driver. I'm sure they all have their complaints. It's essentially a customer-service position, and their have been plenty of threads on here discussing the downsides of either company. Regardless, again, many of them are content with their job, and the lifestyle it incurs. Most drivers I've spoken to are animated when talking about setting their own hours, "being their own boss", and many even are animated in discussing company politics or current events regarding them. Don't take my word for it, though, actually talk and get to know your drivers; an abstracted analysis or a news article isn't the best way to get an impression of the situation.
- realdlee 11y agoI've taken both Lyft and Uber 100's of times over the last few years (mostly in San Francisco but in other cities too). Both are great services that are light years better than taxis. I like that Lyft gives the option to tip. When drivers go above and beyond what is required or are especially friendly, then it's nice to have the ability to tip.
- theseatoms 11y agoBut what are the social norms around Lyft tipping? Whenever I ride with Lyft, I feel obligated to tip since I assume that drivers keep a lower cut of the ride revenue. Is this actually the case?
- arasmussen 11y agoLyft gives drivers a larger portion of the ride's cost (80% instead of 70% IIRC). I never feel obligated to tip, but tip if the service was great.
- dopeboy 11y agoI'll tip when driver went up and beyond what I was expecting (helping me load and unload furniture, stopping at a point not on the lyft line route, etc).
- pbreit 11y agoNope, the opposite. Lyft's basic take rate is lower. And active Lyft drivers can have their fees cut in half or even eliminated. Tipping on Lyft is not awkward. Defaults to 0.00, tip if you want. Driver doesn't find out immediately.
- mahyarm 11y agoYou can just give uber drivers a cash tip if you feel so inclined.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoFor some uber riders it's standard operating procedure. Especially if you are with overly drunk people or asking something special (more people in one car than is reasonable, ferrying a dog etc)
- ameyamk 11y agoQuestion remains - if this is winner takes all market. If it is - only one company will survive. As a consumer most important thing for me is to get cab as quickly and cheaply as possible maintaining the basic standards of cleanliness, and politeness from service providers. If quality of service is more or less the same - then I'd argue that the platform generating more demand and supply in the market will prevail and take on outsize market share (80%+). if this is true - then only one will prevail.
- danieltillett 11y agoI have my doubts that this is inherently a winner take all market, but it maybe because of funding. It appears that the investment community believes it is a winner take all market and on that basis it will be a winner take all.
- aoeusnth1 11y agoI don't see why people think this will be a winner-take-all market. The marginal cost for Uber or Lyft is nearly zero, so competition should drive the cost to zero. Lyft and Uber are both past the network-effect barriers to entry, so there's no way for one to boot out the other without slashing rates to try to drive the other out of business. Neither appears to be trying to do so yet. More fundamentally, there's nothing stopping drivers from driving both Lyft and Uber, so there's no reason one should go out of business just because the other is more successful.
- TTPrograms 11y agoIt seems pretty clear that it's not a winner-take-all market. There's, what, 3+ competitors out now that are competing on price and service, and furthermore the drivers can switch between them more easily than any other prior form of employment. This means that they're facing strict price competition for both drivers and riders. The infrastructure required is all relatively basic software, so costs are relatively low. As you said, all the customer cares about is "as quickly and cheaply as possible" - all you need is new competitor that drops the cut for riders and drivers (+ advertising) and people will switch. This is exactly Fasten's strategy. Without fundamental change to the landscape everyone's just going get their margins eaten in this environment. Uber knows this, so they're trying to own self-driving vehicle technology to give them an edge over their competitors. Then they're in competition with the other self-driving technology providers who might partner with Lyft etc., so that doesn't even put them fully in the clear even if they can pull it off. Self-driving technology and how it plays out determines if these companies actually reach the high valuations, IMO.
- autotune 11y agoI had an Uber/Lyft combo driver rant about how the Uber CEO was planning on replacing them all and advocating for self-driving cars, so there's that: http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self-driving/uber-could-be-first-to-test-completely-driverless-cars-in-public http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self...