8 ms·
You never have to allow notifications. AFAICT any site that wants to use notifications needs your consent first.
by oh_sigh 11y ago
You never have to allow notifications. AFAICT any site that wants to use notifications needs your consent first.
- coldtea 11y agoHow about the site NOT bothering me in the first place? Not even for my consent?
- lessQQman333 11y agoSeems like someone put a lot of effort into thinking through the use case. Browser based chat apps like Slack, webmail, among other things are the sort of stuff I like some notifications on. Yeah there's a "app" for Slack, but it's a web view. Easier for me to have it as a pinned tab and always know where it is since it's either Chrome or terminal where I spend most of my time.
- coldtea 11y agoThat's a valid point for such apps as Slack or Gmail etc. But then: a) the majority of the apps asking for notifications are spammy sites (as always the louder offenders). b) Slack, Gmail etc can have its notifications enable toggle hidden in Settings (and Slack indeed has significant customization options for notifications there). If we start saying "ok, Slack is useful, so it's OK to allow it to show an unsolicited popup asking to show notifications" then next thing we have half the useless web also doing the same. It's not a slippery slope either -- it's just how the web and spam works, with spammer sites/ads/etc exploiting any given opportunity to be loud and soliciting to the max...
- Touche 11y agoIf you're so easily annoyed you should really be surfing with JavaScript off. The reality is that sites can do any number of things to annoy you because you are giving them permission to execute code on your machine. If you don't trust them with this permission then don't give it to them.
- coldtea 11y ago>If you're so easily annoyed What's "easy" about it? My annoyance is the age old popup annoyance, something tons of web users have lamented for ages. Ever heard anyone say they LIKE unsolicited popups? Even if it is to ask permission for something? >The reality is that sites can do any number of things to annoy you because you are giving them permission to execute code on your machine. If you don't trust them with this permission then don't give it to them. Sounds like a slippery slope. I don't understand these kind of half-thought arguments. I never said I want webpages to act as simple text. I like dynamic pages and apps -- I just don't like unsolicited popups and dialogs. The same holds true for the desktop, and countless people have expressed their frustrations with such popups there too. Starting from Clippy, the most annoying popup of all time, to the backslash against Windows (Vista?) "asking for admin permissions" dialog, which made them tone it down, and all the way to today...
- Touche 11y agoIf you don't like dialogs at all I don't know why you are getting so bent out of shape over this feature. Any webpage can do alert("look at me") and you actually HAVE to act on that.
- coldtea 11y agoWhat I don't get is how expressing my opinion -- necessarily in multiple comments, as people respond to my initial arguments or misinterpret them and I get back into the discussion, not to mention me being naturally chatty --, makes me "bent out of shape", "so easily offended", etc. over the feature. How about not making personal characterizations?
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> How about the site NOT bothering me in the first place? Not even for my consent? So you'd rather no one have the ability to receive real time notifications from a web application just so you can't be bothered for a second from a permission request that you can actually ignore in its entirety? I don't really understand your view point. Web applications can provide very rich functionality so why would you want to limit that to non-real-time?
- coldtea 11y ago>Web applications can provide very rich functionality so why would you want to limit that to non-real-time? Because applications also provide very shallow functionality -- and especially most of the ones I see asking for notifications (makes sense too: marketers and spammers and the first to jump on such features). Also because a user can always go to the settings of the application and explicitly enable it. That's why there are settings. If they don't like settings pages, and think users would not find them, they could also have an "enable notifications" link/button somewhere prominent in the header/footer etc for the user to click, instead of directly asking users. As for non-tech savvy people, notifications and popups just confuse most of them, and they blindly tend to click to dismiss them, either yes or no, often without even reading the message carefully (or at all). That's something that has been hammered on by UX experts since the dawn of time.
- Touche 11y agoAs already mentioned, there's already a setting for turning off notifications globally: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11433799 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11433799 Having a web feature off by default is essentially damning it to not exist, so that's a non-starter. If you don't like the features that are enabled by web standards most of them can be globally disabled by turning JavaScript off.
- coldtea 11y ago>As already mentioned, there's already a setting for turning off notifications globally That's good, but might be too blunt a hammer. What should be is a standard way to turn them on/off per individual site, WITHOUT unsolicited popups. >Having a web feature off by default is essentially damning it to not exist, so that's a non-starter. As an IT teacher in a past life I've seen 10 year old kids go through 10 layers of obscure program settings to enable a particular behavior / proxy their way out of a school network / etc. If people care enough for notifications, they will find a way to enable them. If they don't, no harm done.
- smussmann 11y agoThere's a setting for this! Chrome allows you to deny all notifications requests automatically, without even a prompt coming up. See https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/3220216 https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/3220216 for the method.
- tdicola 11y agoAwesome, now how about we make this default to on just like we default on pop up blockers etc?
- scrollaway 11y agoIf people didn't want web notifications, they wouldn't have been explicitly added in to the specs. This thread is getting ridiculous. I appreciate people don't like notifications but the very few sites that request them are sites like gmail, discord, irccloud etc which the majority of people absolutely do want notifications from.
- tdicola 11y ago> If people didn't want web notifications, they wouldn't have been explicitly added in to the specs. Web standards aren't a democratic process that all the web users vote on. They're defined by a consortium of companies each with their own special interests and agendas. Pop-ups were allowed by web standards and we've gone out of our way to build tools to prevent them.
- ino 11y ago> If people didn't want web notifications, they wouldn't have been explicitly added in to the specs. Which people? The developers or the end users? It's a cliché but I can't see my non-techie mom or dad, or cousins, aunts, uncles ever wanting website notifications on their laptop, not even for gmail. So now everybody gets alerts to accept notifications so those 0.001% techies/devs who want them can use them? they could enable it themselves. The _very few_ sites include also techcrunch and others. I see people thinking they got a virus because they're getting notifications on their OS by a website they've accepted by mistake.
- oh_sigh 11y agoThen you can set your consent to always deny. This isn't that hard.
- eertami 11y agoObviously but I mean why disable it when you can instead post snide, edgy, holier-than-thou diatribe on the internet? /s
- coldtea 11y agoBecause sane and non-intrusive defaults matter. And also because "always deny" or "turn off" is too blunt a tool. And because the HN crowd is full of people that design and code such defaults in their apps (including lots of browser developers), and their webpages. It's not a forum with people merely looking for the quickest solution to solve a personal problem with how their browser behaves. But why think about those issues when you can instead post snide, edgy, holier-than-thou snark on the internet?
- Zarel 11y agoChrome's implementation of "always deny" isn't particularly blunt as a tool; you can still turn it on for sites on an individual basis. The default of "ask" is ideal for me and most users. Judging from the number of downvotes you've received in this thread, it seems like your preference isn't particularly common. It doesn't seem too much to ask you to change a setting in Options to accommodate your uncommon preference.