8 ms·
It's still stupid though. It's like raiding the mailman's house for delivering an illegal letter with no return address. Sure, it could have been sent by the ma
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
It's still stupid though. It's like raiding the mailman's house for delivering an illegal letter with no return address. Sure, it could have been sent by the mailman, but it could have been sent by anyone. There isn't any more reason to suspect the exit node operators than anyone else in the whole world who could also have used the exit node.
- dogma1138 11y agoNo it sounds actually like good police work. Running a Tor exit node shouldn't give you some blanket against police investigations.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoI would have said the same, if it were not for the police's unnecessary and demeaning execution of their warrant at 6:00AM. If the police knew he was a tor exit node operator, then surely they could have executed this search at a more reasonable hour?
- homero 11y agoBut a no knock swat raid killing people's dog is more fun
- brbsix 11y agoAt least he still has intact ear drums and door frame. Sounds fairly reasonable at least by contemporary standards.
- throweway 11y agoThey didn't seize the house either
- kbenson 11y agoWhen planning an operation like this you need to plan for a time when the suspect is likely to be home. I imagine the most likely time someone is to be home is right at their regular waking time (people often get home at different times). Additionally, 6:00 AM is not excessively early for a large swath of the population. It's not a convenient time, but when is?
- Godel_unicode 11y agoI couldn't help but imagine the police sending a request to view his outlook calendar while reading your comment.
- dogma1138 11y agoLike at an hour when kids are up and running around maybe just on their way to school?
- pc86 11y agoA. That's not what "demeaning" means. B. As others have said 6:00 AM is among the most likely time that most working professionals will be home. C. I'm not sure what his status as an exit node operator has to do with the hour at which a search is executed?
- logfromblammo 11y agoYou are correct. The thing that should give you the blanket against police investigations is the fact that an IP address does not identify any particular person, and never has. It identifies--temporarily, I might add--a network interface. A warrant based on an IP address should be specific to the computing device associated with that IP address at the time it was logged. The cops should never be able to threaten someone with additional seizures--beyond what is specified on the warrant--to coerce cooperation.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoI wonder if it wouldn't be prudent, if you wanted to run an exit, to pay for dedicated static IP, maybe even on a totally different ISP. Hard to guess what the warrant would cover, exactly, in that case (probably still a free pass to all your machines). Of course, it's easy to imagine the opposite situation, where someone connects an exit node to ${random neighbors ap}, with terrible results.
- Godel_unicode 11y ago"...The computing device associated with that IP..." Just the NAT router? Computer(s) behind the NAT router? Phones which have wi-fi and may or may not have been on it at the time? Computers on the other end of the site-site VPN which routes traffic out that NAT router to get around Geo IP restrictions? Any computer in the world which has TOR installed and therefore may have been "behind" that NAT router? The Internet is really complicated, how specifically would you write that warrant without details of the network design?
- FireBeyond 11y agoThose defenses - whilst valid in many cases, and for many reasons - also are a core part of the "reasonable" in "reasonable doubt". Many conflate reasonable doubt with "any doubt whatsoever", and think that any excuse that can be concocted which is technically feasible is an alibi. "But Your Honor, it is possible that someone snuck into his house, spoofed his MAC address to get on his Wifi, used that to download this and that, and then left undetected!" So there's a standard of reasonability, and there should be corroborating evidence. Should, at least. In theory.
- voxic11 11y agoPretty sure no one was claiming it should. Rather they are claiming that the police should be required to collect evidence showing probable cause. If raids on tor nodes find CP more then 50% of the time then yeah they are collecting enough evidence. But if they don't then the police are in violation of the Constitution.
- lucb1e 11y agoI disagree. I like Tor so I'm kind of advocating the devil here, but although anyone could have used the node, it would be way too easy if any child pornography maker could install Tor and be completely exempt from checkups. It's more like raiding the return address even if it says "I was just forwarding this, this is not the actual return address".
- brbsix 11y agoIf you're messing around with CP, why would you want to use your own exit node though? Why not just use someone else's? I suppose it might help mitigate the risk of de-anon attacks on the Tor network, but it still sounds pretty sketchy.
- kbenson 11y agoThere's no guarantee you would use your own node. It's entirely possible that the police could find actionable evidence on his systems even if the initiating evidence wasn't actually because of him. Sort of like a police office seeing what looks like a beer bottle in a drivers hand and pulling him over, only to find it's a rootbeer bottle, but the driver actually is drunk.
- ikeboy 11y agoAh, the joys of Gettier.
- Dylan16807 11y agoTo make it fit this case, the police know it's root beer before they pull the driver over, but they do it anyway.
- kefka 11y agoAnd that's what we get when simple possession of an image is a statutory crime with no means rea. I can watch videos of people getting killed on reddit. I can watch rape videos. I can even watch videos of horrific crimes.... But how dare I watch someone under 18 get naked through a computer. Even if that someone is myself. The worst part is that, while in most other crimes, account for intentionality is considered. (Something falling in my cart while I walk out the store isn't shoplifting, yet shoving something in my pocket is.) Instead this "crime" frankly shouldn't be. It is proof a crime took place however. Its too easy to have a potential dangerous image... even from hosting a Tor gateway Edit: at absolute minimum, there should be a mens rea requirement where possession or transmission of child pornography took place.
- djsumdog 11y agoCongratulations, you're now on an FBI watch list. In honestly though, you're not wrong. Richard Stallman has his controversial stance on child porn as well and I tend to agree with him. It is really really bizarre that modern western society doesn't seem to have a problem with video of soldiers shooting up little kids in Baghdad, yet a picture of a teenager showing her breasts to her boyfriend via text is instant grounds for being locked up (in Australia there is a zero tolerance police and teenagers have gone to jail and are on sex offender registries for just that; although their sex offender databases are confidential and not as fucked up as America's). However, sexual assault on children is a heinous crime. It's sad and destroys the lives of kids who parents hope to keep from getting tainted by the world as long as possible. It's not unjustified to hate this crime to the degree which it is, but it's also kinda bizarre we don't treat videos of kids getting shot the same way. People get off on that stuff too; sexually. What's even more interesting about this case is that the police knew CP was downloaded from his IP address. That might because the United States has mandatory ISP reporting, or potentially his IP was found on a raided website: http://chartsbin.com/view/q4y http://chartsbin.com/view/q4y I'm more interested in how that information was obtained, and whether that process involved violating the rights of individuals of people not associated at all with any crimes.
- kefka 11y ago
- geofft 11y agoThe mailman is operating on behalf of the postal service. Since the postal service is basically the government, that's confusing, so let's say that we're talking about a FedEx delivery person delivering content that is inherently illegal. (Perhaps it's a controlled substance with no medical uses, perhaps it's counterfeit money, perhaps it's a chemical weapon, etc.) It seems to me that it would be patently unreasonable to raid the FedEx employee's home, but it would be perfectly reasonable to hold FedEx the company responsible for not delivering such things. If it happened once, sure, raiding them is excessive. But if the government knew that FedEx, by design, actively did not care what they were delivering and made it hard for themselves to figure that out until it's loaded onto a truck for local delivery, and they had evidence that some drugs or weapons were being delivered, then sure, raiding the local FedEx distribution center and searching it seems within the realm of reasonable actions. Seizing all packages at that distribution center would be unreasonable, but the analog (seizing the computers) didn't happen.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIsn't that how UPS and FedEx actually work? You can go to FedEx with an already-sealed box and pay them cash to deliver it. They don't know what it is, they're not going to open it, it could be anything. Presumably they have some kind of policy against illegal substances, but how are they supposed to verify that? Some of the packages they deliver most certainly are narcotics or child pornography or some other illegal thing. You're saying that should justify the FBI going to all the FedEx hubs and opening all the packages to check for various illegal stuff?
- geofft 11y agoI do in fact think that if the FBI knew that certain people were using FedEx to reliably traffic in illegal substances inside sealed boxes, they would put pressure on FedEx to make it stop somehow, and raid them if they flatly refused. This might involve having them open the packages, but it more likely involves them identifying the people who these boxes come from and go to, and having them drop them as customers. And I am pretty confident that this does happen, because the profession of drug smuggling continues to exist, and druglords aren't just outsourcing their logistics to FedEx and UPS. I certainly agree that some fraction of their packages are illegal, but it's not straightforward to use the service this way. Unlike UPS and FedEx, Tor makes this straightforward, and also tries to avoid knowing the identities of people who are sending things via their service. So the police don't have that option. (Note that the above is simply a description of what Tor is currently doing, as I understand it, and not an attempt to make a moral judgment one way or the other as to what Tor should be doing.)
- Godel_unicode 11y agoYou have this backwards. The only person in the world who can be suspected of having originated that traffic is the person from whose network the requests can be seen originating. There's no way for law enforcement to know he didn't make those connections until they investigate, and thus (as others have said on this thread) it would be dereliction of duty for the officers not to have raided him. If you're going to run a TOR exit node, which you are absolutely free to do, you have to expect this to happen from time to time and be prepared to explain why you are not responsible for the traffic you appear to have originated. Cost of doing business. If standing on principle was free, it would be unremarkable.
- harshreality 11y agoThat cost of doing business is unacceptably high. It amounts to, "run a tor exit node, lose your 4th amendment rights... and your 5th amendment rights, if you want to keep your hardware... and consider your hardware compromised." Who's going to run a tor exit node if that's the legal precedent? It's also pointless. While it's possible for a CP collector or distributor to run an exit node as cover, why would they when they can just use tor for real for all their CP dealings? Think of the ultimate consequences. Such a legal precedent would have CP and other criminal activity causing more collateral damage rather than less. If all it takes to get most tor exit node operators to shut them down is engaging in illegal activities that will draw the attention of the authorities, then I can imagine a lot of countries' intelligence and military services would have an interest in engaging in criminal activities using U.S. tor exit nodes to reduce the available pool of tor exit nodes.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pmocek 11y agoShould they investigate libraries and coffee shops as well? How about the offices of businesses that offer VPN-based proxy services? Homes of those businesses' staff?
- 11y ago
- JohnTHaller 11y agoNot really. The mailman is operating on behalf of the government with specific policies and laws associated with it. Tor is more like you operating as a volunteer delivery guy who is willing to pick up a locked box anywhere in the city for free and drop it off anywhere else that is requested. You have no idea what's in the box nor who you are picking it up from or dropping it off to.
- pmocek 11y agoRight--a common-carrier delivery service, like UPS, DHL, or FedEx, only they cannot snoop into the clients' private business, and clients are by design anonymous.
- nitin_flanker 11y agoYeah, but if they are aware of the "type-of-content-that-may-be-in-the-box" can be illegal or inappropriate. It's still their fault to deliver. This doesn't stop police from raiding them.
- pmocek 11y agoCommon-carrier delivery service, like UPS, DHL, or FedEx are "aware of the "`type-of-content-that-may-be-in-the-box'." They are not held responsible for the actions of their clients of which they are unaware. The same holds true for telephone companies, Internet backbone providers, Internet service providers, and more. The same should hold true of Tor exit node operators.