4 ms·
Baldur’s Gate expansion: Negative reviews because of transgender Character
- alistproducer2 11y agoWhen did we get to a point where every instance of someone being an asshole is news?
- csydas 11y agoThough I'd agree this doesn't really fit with the style of most HN articles, there's a little more to the story than just "someone being an asshole", and it's enough to at least facilitate some discussion, regardless of whether or not said discussion devolves into a Internet fight.
- alistproducer2 11y agoDiscussion of what? That there are assholes who will give a game a negative review because there's something "gay" in it? At what point do we just accept that there will always be assholes in private life. If we're talking about public figures with the ability and will to do harm to folk because of their asshole views, then we can/should discuss. If we had a discussion every time trolls trolled we'd have little time for anything else.
- searine 11y ago>Negative reviews because of transgender Character If you think that's why there are negative reviews, then I have a bridge to sell you.
- Pfhreak 11y agoThe author was able to cite several reviews that were fairly explicit that they felt the game was a 0/10 due to the inclusion of a transgender character. Glancing through the metacritic page, it appears to be the target of some community's ire and there are several reviews claiming the game espouses "extremist views" or "SJW views". It certainly appears to me that there's some relationship between the reviews and the inclusion of a more diverse cast.
- searine 11y ago>The author was able to cite several reviews If that's not the very definition of cherry picking...
- csydas 11y agoNot really in this instance - the claim is that the inclusion of a transvestite character brought about negative reviews specifically about the transgender character. Multiple reviews did just that and were either exclusively about the inclusion or predominantly with a mere mention of excessive bugs next to a fair amount of text regarding the aforementioned character. I will grant - it is certainly possible to infer from the headline that the majority of negative reviews are about the transgender character, which is certainly not the case, but I wouldn't find it incredulous if someone understood the headline to suggest that. But the point being made is back by reviews which do exactly what the author wrote about.
- searine 11y ago>which is certainly not the case So then why are you defending the author cherry picking such reviews? The "point being made" is backed by a small minority. That being the case, it is clear that this article is a deflection to shift attention from the poor quality of the product.
- c0l0 11y agoThat's actually not how I read and perceive most of the negative reviews - sure, people are complaining about the SJW and gender politics content on the sidelines; yet the most substantial criticism complains about the poor writing, a series of critical bugs that render the multiplayer modes unplayable, and a very awkward graphics style, thanks to some kind of upscaling/post-effects filter they use to make avatars look more, er, "smooth", or something. I've been a total Infinity Engine games addict for most of my adolescent and adult life (I'm born in 1985, and played several hundreds, if not a few thousands, of hours of Baldur's Gate (et al.) in my life, mostly in multiplayer sessions with my cousin and friends from school, often spanning the afternoons and evenings of several weeks at a time). I was VERY much looking forward to new content for what is perhaps the most influential computer game I know and cherish, and I was pretty stoked after watching the official trailer last week. However, because of the flak it received over the last few days, I decided to watch a "Let's Play" video on Youtube instead of just blindly buying it. I witnessed about half an hour of gameplay and story development, and, sadly, that was enough to make it completely clear to me that this add-on doesn't live up to its ancestors' brilliance, and that I won't be buying it. The dialouge feels somewhere between forced and cringe-worthy, and the world Beamdog puts your party in seems like a rather badly thought-out scenario from the get-go (one of your companions from the real BG saga explains to you why you are there and what you'll have to do in the very first dungeon/map in such a poor manner that hearing Imoen's original voice actress speak those lines actually made my heart sink a fair bit...). It seems to me that it's just a rather bad game, at least compared to its predecessors, and that the developers try to use the Gamergate/SJW-trolls' whining and bashing as grounds to cover that up.
- Pfhreak 11y ago> That's actually not how I read and perceive most of the negative reviews - sure, people are complaining about the SJW and gender politics content on the sidelines Looking through some reviews myself, it did seem like there were about (very roughly) 25% of reviews that explicitly mentioned SJW or gender politics as a reason to give the game a review of 0/10. Even if that's not most of the reviews, it does strike me as high enough to comment on.
- mcphage 11y ago
- tomjen3 11y agoThis is one of the headlines I really hate: it is almost factually correct in a way that completely divorces from reality. Lots of people complained that a transgendered cleric had been added, but that wasn't because it was transgendered, but because it was forced and fake. Also quite a lot complained that the entire multiplayer part didn't work, that in-game saves were corrupted, etc so don't take meta-critic scores as indicating anything about this issue. I found a reasonable neutral article about the game (http://gameranx.com/features/id/47159/article/trying-to-understand-baldurs-gategate/ http://gameranx.com/features/id/47159/article/trying-to-unde...) with the money quote here (quoting a review): > “While the mechanics of the game are in line with the originals, the story falls short. It sacrifices the narrative and world building of the original Baldur’s Gate in order to break the 4th wall and beat players over the head with messages about social issues with the grace and subtlety of a Saturday morning cartoon from the 90’s.There is no problem with having messages about social issues in a game. The problem comes when one hijacks another franchise, gut out its soul and fill it with vapid maxims and fables in its place. That is one of the surest ways to kill off a franchise, and it is especially odious when it happens to a well-loved franchise. Want social justice? Sure, but stop hijacking the industry and make your own games. You’re not going to improve the industry, you’re just going to kill it from the inside out.” I think we have had the experience of having some well-meaning person at a familiy dinner who just couldn't stop talking about their pet issue. Did you look forward to talking with that person? Do you want that person talking over your favourite game, which you have played for a long time and have an emotional connection with? Incidentally I haven't meet any gamers who had much of a trouble with gays or transgenders. Mostly they are people who want to, you know, PLAY video games.
- pigpaws 11y agoAs a non-gamer, can someone please explain why the character is even mentioned as being trans? What does it add to the game, other than free advertising and drama? Are other players mentioned as being straight? Bi? Political affiliations? religions, etc... ??? again, I'm not a gamer, I don't know this game so I can't say what benefit it brings to the game/story line.
- sgift 11y agoIt isn't "mentioned" that the character is transgender, you have to ask. And if you ask the character answers (probably because the writer thought it was something the character wants to answer).
- stared 11y agoWhen it comes about to games about transgender experience (I would say at some fundamental level), there is SOMA. I mean, it is not the main thread in this survival (and existential) horror (with all things geeks like: x-risk, grey goo, mind uploading), but an interesting take on that subject. SOMA: A Trans-Simon Experience (warning: some spoilers) http://genderterror.com/2015/11/09/soma-a-trans-simon-experience/ http://genderterror.com/2015/11/09/soma-a-trans-simon-experi...
- nrinaudo 11y ago"actually, it's about ethics in heroic adventuring"? Really? Couldn't care less about the transgender character - there's a character, he/she changed gender, who cares when there's presumably a fire breathing dragon over the next hill? - but that line just convinced me to buy a game I didn't think I would.
- thescribe 11y agoArt is subjective, some people don't like this art. Why is this news?