6 ms·
>340 to 620 litres I amused myself trying to find the source. The article is based from a quote from the book which is based on a study: The green, blue and g
by tim333 11y ago
>340 to 620 litres
I amused myself trying to find the source. The article is based from a quote from the book which is based on a study:
The green, blue and grey water footprint of crops and derived crop products, Twente Water Centre
http://waterfootprint.org/media/downloads/Mekonnen-Hoekstra-2011-WaterFootprintCrops.pdf http://waterfootprint.org/media/downloads/Mekonnen-Hoekstra-...
I think he is for example counting the rain and irrigation water that falls on the sugar cane that it used to make the Coke.
Quote from the book:
In 2011, in- vestigators from the University of Twente Water Centre in the Netherlands conducted a careful assessment of the total direct and indirect water footprint of a specific soda: a half-liter bottle of a hypothetical carbonated beverage sweetened with beet sugar. They based their assessment on a systematic method developed specifically for this purpose.
The result: 170 to 310 liters per half-liter soft drink. But we don’t care about half liters. We care about full liters. For that, we need to double these figures, giving us astonishing water-use ratios of 340 to 620 liters per liter of soda. The range varied with the type of sweetener and the country growing the sugar. The 620 water-use ratio applied to a soda made with cane sugar grown in Cuba, whereas the 340 ratio applied to a soda sweetened with beet sugar produced in the water-efficient Netherlands. Sodas sweetened with high-fructose corn syrup grown in the United States required 360 liters per liter. These amounts, enormous as they seem in comparison to the prize- winning 1.4, are on the low side of water use for food production; figures for meat and dairy production, for example, are higher.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoBesides which, that water isn't lost; in the Netherlands, it either sinks into the soil to eventually become ground water again (after which it's reused), or it ends up in the sea via canals and rivers. It's not like we have a water shortage in NL, not yet anyway. Besides ground water, there are several rivers passing through NL coming from the Alps, sometimes to the point of overflowing. Really, the only thing wasteful would be the energy needed to pump up and distribute the water. But we get some of the most efficient farmland in return, without harming anyone (unlike e.g. the US that caused the dustbowl thanks to overly aggressive farming) edit: also that's only when irrigation is actually needed, we get our fair share of rain.
- smt88 11y ago> ends up in the sea via canals and rivers That water is "lost" by any practical definition. For humans to use it again, it would have to be desalinated, which is expensive.
- Gargoyle 11y agoIt's desalinated by becoming rain again.
- egeozcan 11y agoI don't think the amount of rain increases by pumping more fresh water to the oceans.
- nbb 11y agoSo what?
- Cerium 11y agoWe are discovering in California that that rain does not always fall back where the water was taken.
- TallGuyShort 11y agoCalifornia's discovering that pretty late compared to much of the rest of the world.
- imtringued 11y agoSouthern india is also taking their time. There is no such thing as a too deep well.
- basseq 11y agoScientifically-speaking, is any water "lost"? Thinking back to those pictures of plains and mountains with a big circular arrow in my seventh grade science textbook: couldn't you say that even the water used by crops, turned into coke, and consumed by humans is eventually returned the ecosystem in some form or another?
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThe large majority of the water used (2/3) is for 'green water', AKA rainfall. If the rainfall wasn't used by the sugar cane, it would probably have been used by another plant occupying almost exactly the same ecological niche. Blue water is groundwater (1/4) and you may be able to say the same thing about it. Some blue water comes from underground acquifiers, so pumping may be bad thing if you're pumping faster than it replenishes; others is pulled up by the root system so is completely natural. 8% is grey water, water required to flush fertilizer and other pollutants. That sounds bad, but it too is often part of the natural water cycle. Most of the problematic water usage is caused by irrigation. Sugar cane & beet can and is produced without irrigation, but doing so requires more land usage and possibly extra fertilizer. In other words, it's a matter of trade-offs.
- colechristensen 11y agoAdding some corn facts, as it's how most American soda is sweetened. 90% of the land area used for growing corn is not irrigated (100% green water) and in this case it's no trade off. It's not irrigated because there is adequate rainfall.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoRight! Here in Iowa we water the corn the way God intended, by waiting for it to fall from the sky for free. I can always tell when flying to CA when I get into Nebraska, those huge 'crop circles' formed by irrigation start to show up.
- brianwawok 11y agoEven in droughts? In Indiana most corn fields have some movable watering things (like http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/x/field-irrigation-system-3454351.jpg http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/x/field-irrigation-system-34543...). They don't get used much, but in a few week dry spell they might get used for a day to keep the corn alive.
- 11y ago
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>sweetened with beet sugar. Not in the US. Its corn syrup or an artificial sweeter. Curious to know if corn's water footprint is more or less than sugar beet. I guess there's a larger issue here on how water like this isn't truly lost or in competition for human drinking water. Its part of a natural cycle of rainwater, runoff, and back into the aquifers or evaporated. A better metric is the real cost of irrigation for those farms. There are a lot of practical areas to grow corn or sugar beet. Those areas are rich in water, so its not a big deal if you use that much water for argiculture. Water heavy farming in the midwest is different than water heavy farming in California.
- drcoopster 11y agoThe parent post has numbers for HFCS too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]