18 ms·
Tesla Intrigue Deepens with Musk's Twitter Barrage
- arcanus 11y ago'The rear-wheel drive cars will be able to go zero to 60 in less than 4 seconds. ' I don't believe that.
- grecy 11y agoIt's a typo, it's been clearly stated and reported as less than 6 seconds.
- jacquesm 11y agoIt is also absolutely irrelevant for normal driving. 0 to 100 km / h in 10 seconds or even more is perfectly acceptable, and lower accelerations are actually better for the range.
- vvanders 11y agoHaving the ability to tap into faster acceleration doesn't hurt range, in fact with dual motors it you can actually have a faster car that is more efficient. One of the motors is turned off when not needed so you can run essentially half-power and yet still have the second one available in a split second.
- jacquesm 11y agoFast acceleration (not the ability, but the actual acceleration) does use more power, it's just not as bad a difference as it would be with an ICE.
- vvanders 11y agoThere's actually a subtle difference, with an ICE you pay for the larger displacement with more fuel usage at idle and inefficient RPM ranges(things like VVT help mitigate it but physics is physics). For EVs you're largely just fighting against Ohm's law(constant voltage requires that you draw more amps which means resistance generates heat, etc) and to a lesser degree weight. Which has much less impact like you note. My basic understanding of ICEs is that they are most efficient when you can run them at a specific RPM(and tune for that RPM) which is why you see Diesel-Electric Locomotives where the ICE largely acts as a generator.
- jacquesm 11y ago> My basic understanding of ICEs is that they are most efficient when you can run them at a specific RPM(and tune for that RPM) which is why you see Diesel-Electric Locomotives where the ICE largely acts as a generator. That's spot on. This is why you can't use the cam from a generator on a car and vice versa (even if it is otherwise the exact same engine, such as with the Willy's engine). The cam on a generator will be very pointy to open and close the valves across a very sharply defined moment in the engine cycle, whereas on the car version the cam is much more smooth giving a wider operating range (but at lower efficiency). The reason why Diesel Electric locomotives use the electric motor to drive the wheels rather than using the diesel directly is twofold, one the efficiency that you already noted, the second reason is that the electric motor does not need a clutch and has a torque curve much better suited to getting a large weight accelerated (much like steam power is better than ICE's at this, it's the exact same reason).
- vvanders 11y agoYup, was aware of point #2 as well. They mitigate that in part by backing up too(thus putting slack in the cars) before moving forward. Always fun to hear the cars going thunk, thunk, thunk as they get ready to head out.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoWell it's handy for keeping pace with middle weight bikes when they're trying to show off I guess :)
- marssaxman 11y agoI pulled onto I-5 behind a Model S once while riding my 750cc Honda and was really impressed by the fact that I simply could not keep pace - it pulled smoothly ahead like it wasn't even trying. I have never seen any other car do that; it's part of the fun of riding, since cars on the freeway typically feel like they're all half asleep.
- james-watson 11y agoGet an S1000RR, an RSV4 or an R1 and you can go back to treating any Tesla like a normal sleepy car :)
- marssaxman 11y agoHah. I am too much of a hooligan to let myself acquire a proper sportbike; I get into enough trouble as it is. I'm actually thinking of switching to a BMW K75 or K100, since I'm no longer commuting via bike (nowhere to park downtown, alas) and something suitable for long weekend cruises might get more use.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoHeh. Me too. SV650 at moment. I'd like another Triumph 955, my licence wouldn't. :)
- manarth 11y agoThe model S 0-60 varies from 2.8s (P85D in ludicrous mode) right up to 5.9s (2012 Base model), so it's possible that they'll also release a version of the model 3 that will be able to go zero to 60 in less than 4 seconds. It sounds like less than 6 seconds is what we should expect from the base model though.
- elorant 11y agoIt’s a known fact that electric cars have superb acceleration mainly because they deliver all power from the beginning, in contrast to internal combustion engines that need to reach certain rpms to achieve the same thing. Even if it’s 6 seconds instead of 4 it still is an impressive number for a car at that price range.
- rplnt 11y agoEven 15+ ton trolleybus will accelerate faster than your basic diesel car.
- lttlrck 11y ago6 seconds at that price point is pretty normal for a car portending to be a sporty. For example a CLA is in its price range and does 0-60 a tad over 6 seconds.
- elorant 11y agoA CLA doesn’t have six seconds acceleration. The CLA 200 which in Europe is priced around €30k does 1-100 (or 0-60 miles) at 8,4 seconds. Unless you’re referring to the AMG version which does it at 4,6 seconds but costs north of €50k.
- encoderer 11y agoThe version in the US is a 2.5 liter.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Even if it’s 6 seconds instead of 4 it still is an impressive number for a car at that price range. Not really. There are multiple Ford and Suburau models (off the top of my head) that will run sub-6.0, some models $10k cheaper than the Model 3.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoHow many of those can do it without revving the engine and popping the clutch? An electric car's low end torque is usable for everyday driving. Of course, where most people judge a car's power while driving it normally is the 60-80 mph time. That's the only time most people floor the accelerator, when they're pulling out to pass someone. Gasoline vehicles have a marked advantage in this metric.
- grecy 11y agoUnveil part 2 is "super next-level". And the "steering controls and system feels like a spaceship" And Musk tweeted a little while ago about getting a special team of Software Engineers reporting directly to him for self-driving that was "top priority" within the company. And there are no gauges directly in front of the driver at all, which has been confirmed to be like that for production. At this point, can it be anything other than full autonomous? (and maybe you'll have to take over sometimes, but I'm thinking 95%+ of the time it will be driving itself)
- pmalynin 11y ago"95%+ of the time it will be driving itself" That's a shitty metric. Does it mean it will need intervention every 950ms for 50ms?
- kaonashi 11y ago> At this point, can it be anything other than full autonomous? On American roads? Not likely.
- davidiach 11y agoBy definition, fully autonomous means that you will never have to take over.
- NickM 11y agoIt seems impossible that they could have it be fully autonomous to the point of not needing a steering wheel though. You can tell an autonomous car "take me to the mall", or "pull out of the garage", but there are so many edge cases that seem like they would still require manual control. How do you tell it which spot to pick in a parking garage? Or how do you tell it to, say, drive on to a lift while inside a building with no GPS reception? It seems like they must still have some kind of manual controls: even if they somehow implement full autonomy, and take care of all the edge cases, and get past the regulatory hurdles...people just like to drive cars sometimes. So I could believe you're right, and they have massively improved autonomous driving features, but to me that still doesn't quite explain his comments about the steering controls being massively different and "feeling like a spaceship".
- wesleytodd 11y agoWARNING: Auto-playing video ads that are not muted
- mattbeckman 11y agoYeah. Also, TIL you can "Mute Tab" in Chrome before anything starts playing.
- aerovistae 11y agoPlease elaborate.
- rincebrain 11y agoChrome at some recent point grew a "Mute Tab" option on the per-tab right-click menu. cf. http://i.imgur.com/QCM78rl.png http://i.imgur.com/QCM78rl.png
- bluehawk 11y agoRight click, mute tab.
- bryanlarsen 11y ago@mattbeckman said you could do it before anything starts playing, is that possible?
- pritambaral 11y agoCtrl+M on firefox mutes a tab. Helped me a few times.
- mattlutze 11y agoI'm hoping we'll indeed see some tweaks to the nose -- it looks like a blank waiting for a cut-out to fit a grill and will leave the car feeling nearly-finished if it stays that way for production. Only bit that wasn't really a home run for me (for a pre-production, anyways). But otherwise... shooting for autonomous-first at launch will be interesting indeed. How would that effect the opinions of the folks now on the wait list? I wonder how much we're really going to need/want these levels of performance with the car doing the driving for us, of if having the go-fast will end up being mostly a safety feature for collision avoidance?
- danielhooper 11y agoAgreed, the nose design bothers me. Looks unfinished.
- cptskippy 11y agoForm follows function, the grill's functions primarily as an air scoop for the radiator to cool the engine. It's unnecessary and thus eliminated. It's definitely unusual and I'm leaning more towards disliking it at the moment but I can see that removing it would eliminate drag.
- friendzis 11y agoA thing to note on looks: there will be a number plate to complete the looks. And remember there are at least US and European versions of that to consider in the design. This is entirely subject to personal taste, but Alfa Romeos' (e.g. 147) fronts look nice in PR, but look hideous with a number plate attached literally "wherever there is some space for it". New Audis suffer from similar problem: even though the number plate does not look hideous it still looks sort of out of place on the asphalt reaching grilles.
- exhilaration 11y agoA lot of American states don't require front license plates and their motor vehicle agencies will only provide you with a single rear plate.
- Someone1234 11y agoTesla could have done a better job communicating that the internal look or feel wasn't finalised. Clearly that didn't impact pre-orders but I think a lot of people didn't love the internal look even if they thought it was nice looking externally (disclaimer: I was one of these people). In my OPINION the 3 won't be fully self driving (for certification/legal reasons). But we can reasonably speculate that it will have things like auto-braking, lane keep assist, automatic cruise control, and similar. Since competitor's vehicles have this, and in order to achieve "five stars in every safety category" you actually need to have auto-braking. Look at the requirements for the IIHS's "TOP SAFETY PICK+" which is the gold standard for safety. A system like EyeSight, Honda Sensing, or similar is required in 2016[0], and this vehicle will be looking for the 2017 or 2018 TSP+ rating no doubt. So suggesting that it will have "auto-pilot"-like functionality[1] is very reasonable. But that doesn't mean it will have full self-driving ("hands off"), in particular given the regulatory landscape, development stage of the technology, and the costs. We'll see. [0] "Vehicles with optional front crash prevention qualify for either award only when equipped with the technology." http://www.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/TSP-List http://www.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/TSP-List i.e. without frontal auto-braking as an option you cannot appear on the TSP+ list. But even vehicles on the list only quality as TSP+ rated when the auto-braking option is installed (without it they're TPS tier only). [1] https://www.teslamotors.com/presskit/autopilot https://www.teslamotors.com/presskit/autopilot
- the_economist 11y agoThey probably didn't want to make it too clear that they were just showing off a completely unfinished prototype.
- smackfu 11y agoThey barely communicated anything at the reveal. It was like a few minutes of leadup, five bullet points about the 3, and then they showed the cars and ended it. Given the audience they had, a bit of a wasted opportunity.
- teh_klev 11y agoI wouldn't exactly call ~300,000 one thousand dollar deposits in less than 4 days a wasted opportunity.
- po 11y ago> The Model 3 will come with standard rear-wheel drive, with an option for dual-motor all-wheel drive. It better be fully autonomous if you've ever seen how rear-wheel drive performs in a north-eastern snowstorm. Sure, there's a lot of weight over the back wheels but that sounds crazy to me as the default.
- wmeredith 11y agoEh, you may be defeating your own argument there. The main reason that front-wheel drive is better in slick conditions is more weight over the wheels in the typical front engined car. Rear wheel drive may actually be better if the battery pack is sitting on top of it.
- macintux 11y agoThat surprises me, given my extensive experience pushing shopping carts vs pulling them.
- jameshart 11y agoSince you don't push your shopping cart by turning the wheels, those intuitions are probably not that helpful. The force you exert on the handle of a shopping cart is not automatically aligned with the direction the cart is facing, meaning it's unstable - any deviation from a direct push generates a turning torque. But the rear wheels of a car are fixed so they will always generate a forward force aligned with the car's axis, never a turning motion (diffs and grip variance across the axle aside).
- kerryfalk 11y agoNot true. I've always driven RWD and have competed in National Amateur racing events with the SCCA (and taught high performance driving techniques at my local club). I setup my cars with a heafty amount of rear toe-in (1/4"). When the weight transfers left/right or one of the rear wheels hits a bump/hole it will push the car in one direction similar to torquing one side of a shopping cart with your hand. A RWD setup allows the car to be more efficient with its tires (using one set for turning and one for power vs. one for both). FWD is just seen as safer because most people panic when a car oversteers. As the saying goes among driving enthusiasts: "Oversteer scares passengers, Understeer scares drivers"
- dorianm 11y agoI couldn't believe it was gonna be a fully autonomous car long-term until I saw the empty dashboard in the video: http://i.imgur.com/XcUjuDv.jpg http://i.imgur.com/XcUjuDv.jpg
- vrfcodf 11y agoHow could it be? The regulations don't allow it. I don't see it happening sooner than 10 years. If so, what is their plan?
- mdorazio 11y agoThere are already draft regulations in California [1] for exactly this. I expect that at least some states will have cleared the way by 2018, though obviously not all. Autonomous driving will likely be location-restricted to start with as a result. Remember, there is a lot of pressure on politicians from many companies and people to get autonomous vehicles on the road as soon as possible. [1] https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/vr/autonomous/auto https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/vr/autonomous/auto
- zardo 11y agoNHTSA is scrambling to make it possible, this is the biggest safety innovation in cars since the seat belt. And as long as they have the hardware capabilities, Tesla wouldn't have to launch it with full autonomous mode available.
- johnward 11y agoJust imagine how safe we will be if we reach Level 5 autonomy, no driver control possible? I think the Model 3 is going to be the first production car to reach Level 4. I'm hoping that's what the "part 2" update is.
- knodi123 11y agoCan someone clarify for me- will the existing Model S have any features NOT present in the vastly cheaper Model 3?
- CardenB 11y agoSince when is the model X cheaper? Did you mean the Model 3?
- knodi123 11y agoYes, I meant model 3.
- aeharding 11y agoA hatchback
- aerovistae 11y agoNot that I can tell, aside from being bigger and thus seating 7. This was the plan after all.
- cookiecaper 11y agoI assume an S II is going to be coming out sometime.
- osteele 11y agoSpeed (acceleration). Current Model S 0-6 times are from 5.2s to 2.8s, depending on trim. The Model 3 is “under six seconds” and maybe “substantially faster”: it could overlap the slower current Model S trims. Range. Current Model S ranges are from 240m to 270m, depending on trim. Model 3: 215m. Cargo volume. The Model S has 31.6 ft^3. The Model 3 looks much smaller. Free lifetime use of superchargers? I haven't seen this speculated, but I'll be surprised if the Model 3 includes unlimited supercharger use; I suspect paid use of the network will be a new Tesla revenue stream. On the other hand, smaller makes for easier parking and maneuvering, in addition to the cost savings. And I expect the Model 3 to have more and better sensors, in support of better autonomous driving, than the current Model S can support. All said, IMO the major advantage of the existing Model S is that it exists today. Owners are paying a huge premium to get semi-autonomous driving a couple of years ahead of schedule. “The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed.” – William Gibson
- S_A_P 11y agoSo I watched the Model 3 unveil. I found it to be pretty awful. I had seen Musk unveil the battery swap, and felt that he looked way more polished than he did in the Model 3 unveil. The reveal kind of stressed me out the way he was stammering over the words. It seemed as though he had either not practiced the script, not written one, or had a bout of stage fright. He really didnt "sell" the car. Just said yes its going to be great and gave 3-4 bullet points on features. It was not something that I would compare to any apple product reveal by any stretch.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoHe's going through a massive divorce that could cost him billions.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAssuming its 'his' to begin with. Not hers already?
- rewqfdsa 11y agoI'm quite sure that Musk is the one responsible for the increase in value of his companies, not someone who's been uninvolved in running them.
- JoeAltmaier 11y ago...said somebody totally unacquainted with marriage.
- rmwaite 11y agoI am able to concentrate on growing my career because of my spouse, not in spite of them.
- rohit89 11y agoThat's not the case for everyone.
- mentos 11y agoDidn't realize the price point has dropped to $35k that is the biggest news for me.
- mrtron 11y agoPart 2: Some sort of heads up display in the windshield? Could work well with self driving mode on highways.
- ycombdev 11y ago"The rear-wheel drive cars will be able to go zero to 60 in less than 4 seconds." Wasn't it like 6 seconds before? Or is this the top level rear-wheel drive version?
- cloudwalking 11y agoHe said 6 seconds at the presentation. I think 4 is a typo.
- johnward 11y agoThe 4 seconds comes from speculation from an article before the reveal. Maybe that's the target for the performance variant?
- tkinom 11y agoIs there any good analysis on the impact of EV on the gas and oil demand on the world? ??% of Ca, US cars are EV, as results, ??% of Ca, US gas/oil consumptions are reduced. If the trend continue, here's what happen when % of EV reach 10, 20, 30, 50%, the global oil demand will be drop by ??,??,?? %.
- alexhawdon 11y agoI'm as incredulous as the next person that a mostly self-driving car will be available by 2017-8 and that this will be it. That said, on the way to full autonomy I can foresee a car that can handle 99% of the driving itself but calls on the driver to help out during the other 1%. In such a scenario the car may know where it is and isn't safe to drive, but not exactly where, or when. Examples include the 1-lane, 2-directions-of-traffic rural roads. Unmapped car parks and private premises. Navigating around roadworks. Basically all the 'edge-case' scenarios people often cite. The car could guess the route and you use a joystick to control the forward speed. You can use the joystick to change the proposed route as you drive. And if you wanted to leave the detected 'safe area' ("no, I really do want to drive into that car - it's a tow truck and I need to get on it!") you acknowledge a bunch of ominous warnings and control the car directly, albeit at a very low speed.
- jusben1369 11y agoOne of the things I find fascinating, and that Tesla has to grapple with at some point with real ramifications, is: are they a self driving car company that just happens to be an electric car company? Or the other way around? I would argue that electric car companies are appealing to a much smaller subset of potential customers than are self driving cars. But the mission behind each is very different and that flows into all the key design and marketing decisions you have to make. Tesla can easily pivot from one to the other. But Musk is so passionate about the first, and therefore so are so many of their key people, that you wonder what happens if they pivot to being first to market with the best self driving cars that just happen to be electric.
- electrograv 11y agoWhy do you need to define a car company in a single adjective like "[self driving] car company" or "[electric] car company"? Both are clearly the future. So what's wrong with doing both? You say "pivot" as though these are incompatible goals, when in fact they're perfectly complementary paths to a future ideal of ground transportation. To me, your point is like asking "Is Google a search company, or an advertising company?" They're both, in a fully symbiotic sense. You cannot describe it as one of these accurately, without the other.
- jusben1369 11y agoEverything about Tesla has been around helping/saving the environment by accelerating the adoption of battery driven cars vs ICE. Nothing about self driving cars says they have to be electric. In fact, if the first fully self driving car was gasoline that would probably impede Tesla's growth. So it impacts where your limited R&D, manufacturing and sales and marketing $$"s go. I don't think a company as small as Tesla can be both - at least not effectively. One will have to give to the other.
- saturdaysaint 11y agoNothing about making computers says you have to make phones (Apple). As the GP mentioned, nothing about search says you have to sell advertising (Google). And none of the above say you have to make a self driving car (as both are reported to be attempting). I think you're drawing some arbitrary distinctions here. Making big bets in several areas is no small part of why Apple, Google and Tesla are magnets for the best engineers and programmers. There's nothing unfocused about marrying great software and hardware, which is ultimately what Tesla is doing. A lot of Musk's bet in AV is founded on the understanding that the existing automakers are/were quite capable of making a good electric car - they just have too much incentive to drag their feet. Autonomous driving will actually be the major differentiator in an industry that didn't have the software expertise to create a decent infotainment system.
- djloche 11y agoI wonder, when Tesla unveils something that doesn't fit within the parameters that those people think of as a 'car', how many will drop their reservation? Since we don't know the details yet, we don't know how much of a departure it will be.
- electrograv 11y agoI doubt that the demographic that pre-orders a Tesla Model 3 (years before shipping), is a demographic that is unwilling to embrace change. I also doubt that it will have no manual control mode, so it shouldn't an issue regardless. Tesla is clearly going the route of being a strict super-set of the capabilities of other cars, until the market decides what features are obsolete many years down the road (e.g. steering wheels).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- djloche 11y agoIt's really a question of demographics. How many people that have put down a reserve are buying a car to drive vs buying a means of transportation? Obviously, this is all speculative since they haven't revealed what they're talking about.
- marssaxman 11y agoI might like to buy a car with the Model 3's general parameters - I had the electrical service on my house redone a couple of years ago in part because I wanted to have the capacity to add a car charger someday - but I am almost completely uninterested in a Tesla because I am not on board with their "just sit back and trust us" philosophy. No, thank you, I don't trust you, or any car maker, and don't want your auto-updating auto-everything machine! And I basically just hate trying to deal with touch screens. They get smudgy and gross at the blink of an eye, and their total lack of tactile feedback demands a tedious degree of conscious attention which makes them inefficient ways of performing routine tasks, which adjustment of an automobile's cabin controls ought to be.
- dismal2 11y agoAnyone else getting a vaporware vibe from this car?
- ska 11y agolooks like it's just you. I don't think any reasonable definition of "vaporware" can be applied to this car, given Tesla's track record. They could have all sorts of tweaks and production issues yet, sure. But it's a pretty good bet that a tangible version of this exists and will ship.
- aerovistae 11y agoLmao what? After he's delivered the S and the X, and created reusable rockets, you think this is vaporware? Wtf?
- johnward 11y agoPeople are still trying to call Tesla the new Delorean. Even after all the successful deliveries.
- spectrum1234 11y ago"Musk said the company was hoping for 0.21 drag coefficient. That's exceedingly sleek." I looked into this. 0.21 is insanely low for a production car. How come this isn't bigger news? This alone is fascinating.
- andersen1488 11y agoThe Model S is already at 0.24 (most efficient car in production)
- jandrese 11y agoI'm guessing Tesla gets to cheat a bit since they don't use heat engines and don't have to run a bunch of air over a giant mesh screen to keep the engine from burning up. Also, that giant pane of smooth glass over the top probably helps.
- greglindahl 11y agoThe battery has a front air intake. It's smaller than one for an ICE, which might be why many HN commenters seem to have not noticed it. (Same thing for S and X.)
- erikpukinskis 11y agoSo by "cheat" you mean "solve the same problem in a better way"?
- jandrese 11y agoThey get to play on a tilted playing field. They do have to lug around the weight of the batteries, but for cruising at highway speed (where the aero figure is most important), extra weight matters little.
- bobwaycott 11y agoThe VW XL1 is the most efficient car in production. According to VW's site, it comes in at 0.186.
- pbreit 11y agoSo does communicating on Twitter comply with regulatory requirements around public company communications? Cool, if so.
- johnward 11y agoI'm not a lawyer but it's a public site.
- justifier 11y agomy only head scratch on the design is the giant tablet attached to a thin pole on the dash i live in sf, where a book on your passenger seat will get you a broken window and lose you a book the tablet looks like it is going to inadvertantly encourage broken windows and is inevitably going to be ripped out of the dash here's to hoping it retracts to under the dash when off
- adventured 11y agoIt's an unfinished cabin design. I doubt they're going to leave a monitor sitting in that spot as the end look. Most likely it'll be mounted flush into the dash in some manner.
- johnward 11y agoThe Model X has a tablet sticking out like this for the pre-production but the production model has it molded into the dash.
- esterly 11y agoOne of the folks Musk responded to, Brian Reed, did an nice job filling in the gap in this article and video http://bgr.com/2016/04/04/tesla-model-3-hidden-details-video/ http://bgr.com/2016/04/04/tesla-model-3-hidden-details-video...
- gist 11y agoWindshield stretching from front to back (the roof) will be quite a bit more expensive to replace than a standard windshield no doubt. Ironic given the price point.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThere are seams, it's not one giant piece of glass.
- davnn 11y agoJust flying over the comments I find it interesting that a lot of people try their best to find negative aspects of self-driving cars. I always try to be open to all parties, but a lot of people are wayyy too confident in human abilities. We are pretty bad, seriously.