13 ms·
The Panama Papers: how the world’s rich and famous hide their money offshore
- jacknews 11y agoWell this is cool. But notice on the https://panamapapers.icij.org/ https://panamapapers.icij.org/ page there is a "leak to us" button, so we can share information with the journalist consortium, but no "show me the leaked data" button so they can share with us. Where do we get the actual leaked data, so we can investigate companies ourselves, instead of relying on mass-media "analysis"? And what about the other law firms (this is only the fourth largest, apparently)? Is it just a coincidence that Putin is implicated in this, the only leak?
- funkyy 11y agoIt will be released in future. They keep it that way probably to slowly leak data to increase the impact it will cause.
- bvrlt 11y agoWhere did you find that this will be released in the future? There are public persons in this batch of data and it makes sense to know this information but there must also be a lot of private information and I don't think it would be right to have them released in the while. My guess is that this is the main reason why it's not publicly released. Edit: Le Monde has an article on the subject (French) http://www.lemonde.fr/panama-papers/article/2016/04/04/pourquoi-le-monde-ne-publie-pas-l-integralite-des-donnees-des-panama-papers_4895241_4890278.html http://www.lemonde.fr/panama-papers/article/2016/04/04/pourq..., translated: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.lemonde.fr%2Fpanama-papers%2Farticle%2F2016%2F04%2F04%2Fpourquoi-le-monde-ne-publie-pas-l-integralite-des-donnees-des-panama-papers_4895241_4890278.html https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=auto&tl=en&u...
- jacknews 11y agoAnd who decides? IMHO it's no longer legitimate to leak to "the press" if they are unwilling to properly disseminate the whole truth.
- bvrlt 11y agoIn theory the person who leaked to the press could be prosecuted for leaking information. But press has the right to protect their sources, which prevents that from happening, so you get a balance between information and privacy. That wouldn't be the case if it was leaked to the general public. You'd also leak passports, SSN etc. to the general public.
- funkyy 11y agoThe organization responsible for investigating it. They are quite reputable for staying independent.
- funkyy 11y agoSome data should be released. Not sure if all, but all data related to information published will be released, so maybe they will spare average "Joes" from it. You can find on Reddit people involved in this commenting regarding releasing data, I have seen few comments last night after release.
- ptaipale 11y agoSome data should and will be released, but do we know how the released data was chosen?
- skylan_q 11y agoThe data isn't available because it's only for specific media outlets to report on. They would hate to incriminate anyone who isn't Putin by accident.
- skylan_q 11y agoScroll to the bottom: https://www.occrp.org/en/panamapapers/ https://www.occrp.org/en/panamapapers/ Look at "Who supports our work" It has Soros' fingerprints all over it. He's at it again: attacking nationalism (Russia, far-right parties) and promoting globalism. The whole operation isn't exposing anything we don't know: rich people are rich and use whatever means at their disposal to keep rich. In fact, this is a media operation more than anything to villainize Putin and anyone associated with him. The truth is, pretty much every nation and its leaders are guilty of this.
- KingMob 11y agoTrue, but like Snowden and the NSA, there's still a difference between cynically assuming "of course the NSA spies on everyone", and being confronted with the reality.
- Tepix 11y agoHardly. The data was originally leaked to Süddeutsche Zeitung (SZ). They then asked ICIJ for help because they can't deal with 11.5 million documents by themselves. Details at http://panamapapers.sueddeutsche.de/articles/56febff0a1bb8d3c3495adf4/ http://panamapapers.sueddeutsche.de/articles/56febff0a1bb8d3...
- sammydavis 11y agoWell, we all know that Russia and far-right parties are above reproach and discussion. You come across as a shill for rich people who don't like having their private tax avoidance information shared. The news articles had plenty of liberal leaders with embarrassing information leaked, such as the PM of Iceland - so your claim that this is aimed against those you are trying to protect is obviously wrong.
- johansch 11y agoThey want to derive the maximum amount of exposure, page views and revenues from the leaked data in the form of web articles with ads, printed news papers with ads etc. Releasing the the actual data would be counterproductive to their own financial gains. Somewhat ironic, I think. (Yes, some of the 100+ news organizations are ad free, such as the mandatory tv license-paid state broadcaster/propaganda organ SVT from my country, Sweden, but they also have their own motives of wanting to control the data.)
- rfrank 11y agoThe leak contains large amounts of personal information on people who aren't necessarily guilty of anything illegal, correct? If that's the case, releasing the full leak comes with some very real ethical concerns.
- 1024core 11y ago> The leak contains large amounts of personal information on people who aren't necessarily guilty of anything illegal, correct? How do we know? That's just an assumption. It could also be that the leak contains information on some very powerful people who better not be crossed?
- raphman_ 11y ago> "In this trove there are administrative documents that could actually be brought to public knowledge, such as records of incorporation, shareholder registers or directors or creation of bank accounts. But there is especially a lot of personal information, such as private postal and email addresses, scans of passports for internal and external correspondences Mossack Fonseca, with many private items (such as vacation rentals, electricity bills or, more sadly, the discovery of cancer)". https://www.reddit.com/live/wp1fvdxxwb45/updates/02ec05f2-fa78-11e5-b94c-0e945010cea9 https://www.reddit.com/live/wp1fvdxxwb45/updates/02ec05f2-fa...
- arrrg 11y agoThat’s not contradictory. It may well be that the leak contains that and personal information that would be literally unreasonable to publish. That’s what ethics is all about: weighing different things against each other. The journalists widely shared the data with other journalists and outlets to make it easier to work through the data but probably also to combat the problem of being blind in certain ways …
- Techbrunch 11y agoFrom Le Monde in French: "Une partie (exploitable) de la fuite consiste en une base de données structurées des quelque 215 000 structures offshore de la firme panaméenne Mossack Fonseca avec, pour chacune, les dates de création, de dissolution, l’identité des actionnaires déclarés et leur lieu de domiciliation. Cette partie sera publiée en mai par le consortium international des journalistes d’investigation (ICIJ), qui a coordonné l’investigation." I'm too lazy to translate it for you but basically it says that part of the leak will be released in May. They also wrote an article explaining why they don't release everything: http://www.lemonde.fr/panama-papers/article/2016/04/04/pourquoi-le-monde-ne-publie-pas-l-integralite-des-donnees-des-panama-papers_4895241_4890278.html http://www.lemonde.fr/panama-papers/article/2016/04/04/pourq...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- myth_drannon 11y agoAnd nothing will happen to them. In Canada the rich get an amnesty and just have to repay some taxes. http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-revenue-kpmg-secret-amnesty-1.3479594 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-revenue-kpmg-secret-a... And they mention all these dictators. Why on earth Putin & Co will try to evade taxes and hide his money? Putin owns Russia, he is the taxman and the hangman. He doesn't have to hide anything.
- kbart 11y ago"he is the taxman and the hangman. He doesn't have to hide anything." I bet that the last Tsar followed the same logic..
- btreesOfSpring 11y agoThe laundering could be for a whole sets of reason. Two offhand examples; having money available for barred transactions due to sanctions[0] or having untraceable money available for intelligence or other related illicit activities. Some people rather have a gun and not need it than need a gun and not have it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_sanctions_during_the_Ukrainian_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_sanctions_during...
- varjag 11y ago> Why on earth Putin & Co will try to evade taxes and hide his money? There's plenty in Russia who believe that while his cronies live off bribes and embezzlement, Putin himself is a Platonic father of the nation. One argument you hear often is he doesn't need to steal anything because he could have everything. This has certain moralistic beauty of a man one with his country. It also provides a way for an average broke Russian to identify with the sacred figure. Finding out he earmarked some just in case undermines that and suggests Putin himself might not be so certain in near future. And while this revelation will have no immediate social consequence and indeed will be feverishly denied by his supporters, with time it will still sink in.
- skylan_q 11y agoWhy on earth Putin & Co will try to evade taxes and hide his money? Why would the anti-russia media focus on one powerful rich person as being bad? Gee, I wonder...
- branchless 11y agoTax avoidance in the UK is a big problem. We can't pay for our infrastructure because of these guys avoiding tax. But it's not just working people in the UK - working people all over the world are being denied services thanks to UK tax havens. Who is causing more problems for working people? Sparse terrorist attacks or day-in, year out tax avoidance depleting spending and raising land costs?
- sievebrain 11y agoTax avoidance in the UK is a big problem. We can't pay for our infrastructure because of these guys avoiding tax. Tax avoidance is undefinable so this sort of statement is meaningless. The UK can't pay for its infrastructure due to a massive structural deficit. Even if you start defining legal behaviour as immoral and try to grab more money from targeted companies or individuals, the amounts of revenue collected would be trivial compared to the size of the problem - and it'd be a one off hit. Once a country demonstrates that the rule of law is optional, investors start to flee. And that's the sort of avoidance that you can't tackle with any law.
- branchless 11y agoThe exact line drawn between tax efficiency and immoral tax avoidance is hard to pin-point, but I'm certain that I know a bunch of crooks filling their boots when I see it. These off-shore companies are not fair. Do your work, pay tax on it like the rest of us. As for the rule of law being optional. I pay my taxes yet these guys choose not to by using loop-holes. That is not the spirit of the law. I reject this kind of argument, it's very popular but it doesn't hold any weight with me. They could stop this kind of rubbish but they don't want to because people like Cameron are using it. Let's have land value tax now and stop this international hide and seek. We don't want these "investors" in the UK. UK banking funnels dirty money into property which ramps the price for workers. Banks they "help" by lending us insane amounts which absorb all our income (and require ultra low rates forever). None of this is of any help to the normal working person who is doing stuff of actual use that makes the world turn, like food production, doctors, etc. These guys are taking and giving nothing back. Tax them!
- sievebrain 11y agoI suspect this will end up fizzling out and not resulting in very much. From the Guardian articles it's becoming clearer that Mossack Fonseca is not some sort of mafioso outfit. Even the Guardian's own coverage has to admit that they do have compliance staff, do perform due diligence and do report things to the authorities. And they did close down operations when they got wind of illegal doings. So any stories have to become arguments about specific cases and debates about whether they could have done more in those cases, rather than the more juicy story they clearly want, implying that MF is some sort of criminal nexus that is being taken down by the journalistic establishment. If we look at the Swiss banking leak from a few years ago, there were thousands of account details leaked to the UK government which assigned hundreds of tax officers to investigate them. And it turned out that about two thirds of them had paid exactly the right amount of tax all along. Of the rest, actually proving criminal intent turned out to be impossible, so of the original 1000+ account holders, only one case was ever actually taken to court. The others were cleared up through fines. The resulting amount of revenue was trivial at only £135 million, probably the costs of the investigation itself consumed most of that. This wasn't UK specific, other countries also ended up finding the data was useless for prosecutions. The same was true of another case, when the Swiss authorities agreed to start sending tax information to the UK. The government thought it was in for a windfall and wrote the expected amounts into the budget. Red faces followed when the actual amount of unpaid tax turned out to be much lower than hoped for. Maybe the Iceland angle will result in a few heads rolling, who knows, but I'm willing to bet that most of these revelations end up having very little impact: the worst cases are all in places where the local law enforcement is too weak to prosecute presidents and other heads of state for corruption.
- typon 11y agoI think you're downplaying this more than you should. I got a very different impression listening to Nicholas Shaxson (author of [1]) on the BBC. Most if not all the world leaders involved in this leak are VERY likely trying to hide personal money from their own country, that alone is a huge deal. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Treasure-Islands-Uncovering-Offshore-Banking/dp/0230341721 http://www.amazon.com/Treasure-Islands-Uncovering-Offshore-B...).
- calebm 11y agoAnyone know how this tax sheltering works? The article mentioned "One leaked memorandum from a partner of Mossack Fonseca said: 'Ninety-five per cent of our work coincidentally consists in selling vehicles to avoid taxes.'" That would lead me to believe the "vehicle" for transferring wealth offshore might be selling vehicles - like selling yachts? Just a guess though.
- sievebrain 11y ago"Vehicle" in this context just means legal entity. It's the jargon of the space, it doesn't mean a mode of transport. The principle of offshore tax shelters is very simple. Countries tax activity that happens in their jurisdiction. Only America tries to tax activity that happens outside of America, and it's attempts to do so have caused huge problems for Americans everywhere (whilst raising trivial amounts of revenue). All other countries recognise that legitimate taxation is inherently region specific: a country that raises taxes from other countries is more properly called an empire. So countries tax things that happen inside their borders, and countries can set tax rates independently, and the world is full of small countries that don't require much revenue to operate. Hence, if you can shift your business activities from a high tax jurisdiction to a low tax jurisdiction, you can legally pay the lower rates of tax. Essentially all discussion of tax "avoidance" you may encounter revolves around the inherent difficulty of figuring out where a business actually is. For a person it's easy. A person is where their body is, and simply counting days spent in a country is sufficient to decide on tax residency. For a company it is not so easy because a company can do things in many places simultaneously. The rules that try to resolve this conundrum are extremely vague and thus, easily gamed. The case of the UK PM's father is instructive. His company had most of its meetings outside of the UK. This allowed them to argue that it wasn't a British company and thus shouldn't pay British taxes. If the British tax collectors want some of that revenue they'd need to argue that actually the business was done in the UK, really. That's a tricky argument. In the case of companies like Apple or Google, they set things up so their business is done in Ireland. They do this because the Irish people have repeatedly opted to allow very low (effectively zero) rates of corporation tax in order to attract skilled employment to a part of the world that would otherwise be fairly unattractive. Whilst technically Irish corporation taxes are not zero, their rules define the location of a business differently to some other countries, which means arrangements like the Double Irish become possible and that allows for moving profit out of Ireland essentially untaxed. The Irish people know this and allow it, because it has been a very powerful strategy for them and has made Dublin a business center of Europe. Some other countries like to complain about this, stating it's unfair competition, but all countries compete to attract businesses in various ways - often with direct subsidies rather than low tax rates. So their complaints ring somewhat hollow. In practice the money these big companies stash in the Bahamas will eventually get taxed anyway, because taxes apply when the money moves, and eventually that money will move. Probably back into the USA if/when a 'tax holiday' becomes politically acceptable.
- ttflee 11y agoThese keywords have been censored in Chinese microblog services, along with all news mentioning Panama Papers removed, due to obvious reasons.
- jamisteven 11y agoNobody from the US mentioned? This doc was definitely scrubbed.
- ep103 11y agoI saw another post elsewhere saying that that's planned for the future, this was just the first round initial release
- skylan_q 11y agoNo, it was created by George Soros with the help of some US institutions.
- ghrifter 11y agoI think its probably a hit job to smear Putin once again, especially because of rising conflicts in Azeribaijan and Armenia. "Big Leak of Data" but doesnt actually make the data public. I mean, seriously???
- skylan_q 11y agoThe FSA in Syria also broke the ceasefire just 2 days ago to the dismay of John Kerry and others, and the Russians still have great intel: Russian presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov says that some mass media are preparing an outspoken pre-planned media attack against Putin and his entourage, according to Russian news agency TASS. http://www.unian.info/world/1302754-kremlin-some-mass-media-prepare-outspoken-pre-planned-attack-against-putin.html http://www.unian.info/world/1302754-kremlin-some-mass-media-...
- mercurial 11y ago> I think its probably a hit job to smear Putin once again I thought "smear" was the same as "defame". If he is actually tax-evading and stealing Russia's money, it's, at worst, exposing some of the skeletons in his closet.
- rqebmm 11y ago"Just wait for what happens next" https://twitter.com/georgikantchev/status/716771770636898304?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://twitter.com/georgikantchev/status/716771770636898304...
- jfidmemdj 11y agoHow is this different than when Apple, Microsoft, Cisco, Oracle, HP and Google "hide" their money offshore in places like Ireland and the Cayman Islands, which helps them avoid repatriating their profits overseas and paying taxes on them?
- olegious 11y agoI'm surprised there is no American figures on the list. If some don't appear as more info is released, I'll seriously question the motivations behind this leak.
- mc32 11y agoLet's say it is biased, does it make it any less true these people used shell companies to obfuscate their holdings? Or, are you saying this behavior is okay and in which case it would not matter? If you look more carefully it does list some less known Americans.
- ab5tract 11y agoIf the leaked documents implicate important US figures, but the reporting of the leaks do not mention them, then the public will interpret that as "see, US figures are not engaging in this activity!". In other words, the reporting of this leak can be used to shame / reputation smack anyone who is on the current Western hit list while masking that behavior for anyone that the Western media outlets want to protect.
- mc32 11y agoYes, that's one take. Another take is exposing some is better than exposing none. This is like saying, hey the news mainly shows when white cops beat up on black suspects, but it doesn't much show when white cops beat up on white suspects, (or any other combination) so they should not show any.
- skylan_q 11y agoAs mentioned by another poster (who's comment is now dead?) How is this different than when Apple, Microsoft, Cisco, Oracle, HP and Google "hide" their money offshore in places like Ireland and the Cayman Islands, which helps them avoid repatriating their profits overseas and paying taxes on them? It isn't. The point of this is that Putin is doing it.
- cm2187 11y agoI don't think these companies "hide" any money there. I am sure they are reported in their financial statements. The fact that they are legally out of reach of the US IRS doesn't mean it is hidden.
- zepto 11y agoThere is no similarity at all. These corporations don't hide anything, although they do exploit tax loopholes.
- return0 11y agoWhat are the people in the list hiding (that corporations don't)?
- gnufied 11y agolets not be naive. A head of state can't have $2 billion in offshore saving without illegally sourcing some of that money. So for corporations, even though they are too evading tax, their sources of income is known. For many powerful individuals sources of income ins't known (and probably illegal)
- Ntrails 11y ago> A head of state can't have $2 billion in offshore saving without illegally sourcing some of that money Sure you say that now, but when President Trump comes to power is it still true? (I have no clue how much he is actually worth, just countering that heads of state can have significant legitimate private wealth)
- return0 11y ago> how the world’s rich and famous hide their money offshore It shouldn't be just the rich and famous. These schemes don't cost much. I'm sure many internet entrepreneurs use them, because they 're easy to setup and to do accounting (plus low taxes, ain't that sweet?). People have already stopped acting surprised when they read about big corp. dodging taxes. We live in a financially globalized world, but taxation has not been globalized. The main issue here is whether the companies are laundering money or used for illegal purposes. The tax evasion issue is too hard to solve with data exchange (which now exists). These people are always going to be finding new ways to avoid taxes. Perhaps governments should start acting smarter, like moving more to indirect taxation. Perhaps if this "leak" had happened a few years ago, when panama was still a tax haven it would have some real meat. Right now it seems like it will be used to divert attention.
- andreygrehov 11y agoThe government structures are completely broken from the inside out. We badly need a disruption in this sector. Digitally decentralized democracy, blockchain government, ethereum-based economy! Not sure. These are random thoughts, but I would love to see at least some baby steps towards this direction. Not an expert on this topic, but I can see there are potential opportunities for the world as a whole and, what's most important, its economy. I'm sure there is an emerging field coming soon around this niche. Most likely, it's just a matter of time.
- drjesusphd 11y agoThe internet does make direct democracy more feasible. One can engage public libraries to ensure everyone has internet access. This would need to be checked and balanced, but it effectively makes lower houses (House of Representatives, for example) obsolete.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mcbrown 11y agoWithout more context, the information here is titillating but not ultimately all that useful. Let's generalize the content so you can see what I mean: "A massive trove of documents was just leaked from a law firm that helps companies and individuals create and operate shell companies in [jurisdiction X]. We don't know what those shell companies are used for, but they could be used for wrongdoing! And this law firm was suspiciously focused on protecting its clients' identities, which further suggests wrongdoing." Jurisdiction X in this case in Panama. Ok, it sounds dubious to us 'Muricans. What if jurisdiction X was Delaware? Would you think the law firm was setting up shell companies for "wrongdoing", or because starting and operating a business is complicated and there are a variety of practical reasons to base your corporate in entities in Delaware rather than (say) Maine? Would you think the law firm is protecting its clients identities because of an effort to conduct fraud, or because law firms generally err on the side of preserving the sanctity of attorney-client privilege whenever possible? Now let's say Jurisdiction X is Ireland. Are the companies that use Irish shell companies engaged in wrongdoing? Or are they responding to the bizarre and complicated world of international regulation and taxation as any rational actor would? Certainly secrecy is not the goal - everyone, including the IRS, knows everything about how e.g. Apple uses Irish entities to conduct business. Now let's say Jurisdiction X is Cyprus. Are the shell companies for tax avoidance in the home country, or for the reasonable avoidance of double-taxation? One reason investment firms use structures based in Cyprus (or the Caymans, or BVI, or Luxembourg) is that these countries have mutual tax treaties with most Western nations, while the US does not. Those tax treaties ensure that the investor will end up paying taxes only in their own domicile, not the nation they invest in AND their own domicile. For US persons investing in (say) Poland through a Cyprus entity, they end up paying their full slate US taxes (NOT avoiding them - in fact they usually pay higher US taxes than they otherwise would, because for technical reasons the Cyprus blocker often results in paying ordinary income tax rates on what would otherwise be treated as capital gains) but they avoid having to pay BOTH Polish taxes AND US taxes. This is akin to the reasons why many/most private US businesses are set up as pass-through entities rather than corporations - avoiding double taxation is not the same as dodging taxes. * I'm not an expert on Panama, or international tax for that matter - I just have some experience dealing with these issues. So I can't say for sure in what specific purposes using a Panama entity is equivalent to using a Delaware entity or a Cyprus entity, vs. a blatant attempt to dodge taxes. All I know is that, from my own experience, there is a huge gap between the public PERCEIVED reasons why companies and individuals establish overseas shell corporations (tax avoidance! money laundering! bribery!) and the ACTUAL reasons they do so (procedural efficiency, clear legal rules, full payment of taxes but not OVERpayment of taxes, etc.).
- jedberg 11y agoAn interesting take from a commenter on my Facebook feed: "It's all good. Taxation is stealing, hiding wealth in off shore accounts is the only recourse left to the little man against large government greed."
- pvh 11y agoThis is why Facebook recently added a variety of new ways to illustrate your disappointment on posts.
- cylinder 11y agoCuriously they left off "rolleyes"
- feintruled 11y agoSeems to be a technique beloved of billionaires, not 'little men'.
- tobltobs 11y agoIn the eyes of those "Internet Libertarians" it is your own fault if you are not a billionaire.
- TillE 11y agoI don't think the juvenile arguments of Internet Libertarians really qualify as interesting.
- nsns 11y agoI think all this talk about the legality of using such services misses the point. It's about legitimacy, especially that of state leaders. While the western media might try to use it to delegitimize some non-western leaders, the leak actually works both ways. Any country leader who'd make a speech to tell her (or his) people she doesn't care about them or their country, would do nothing illegal, but would probably loose her power. It's the same here - the leak serves as proof that the national Elite in many countries is no longer "loyal" to its imagined community (aka nation).
- neves 11y agoDon't forget that the people that profit from selling financial services to corrupt leaders are so corrupt as them. Even if they speak flawless English and wear nice clothes.
- Swinx43 11y agoAm I the only one to find the reporting on this to be rather one sided? Sure we all know Putin is a shady character to say the least, but none in the US or the UK being directly reported on? Germany? France? Instead we get a token gesture in the way of Iceland's PM being implicated. The Guardian is losing a hell of a lot of credibility in my opinion for having this biased view being published. I say make all the documents available to the entire world. That is the only way it will be less media propaganda and more a true leak.
- cnp 11y agoGive it time.
- simonw 11y agoDavid Cameron's father is frequently mentioned in the news reporting I've seen.
- Swinx43 11y agoThat is true however it is a very far cry from adequate unbiased reporting. We get lengthy pieces on the "usual suspects" but a mere token gesture for the elite of other countries.
- deepnet 11y agohttp://www.theguardian.com/news/2016/apr/04/panama-papers-david-cameron-father-tax-bahamas http://www.theguardian.com/news/2016/apr/04/panama-papers-da... The Guardian reports the UK Prime Minister's father used the firm.
- lordnacho 11y agoWhy are there sovereigns listed? If you have your own country, and it's not known for the rule of law, why do you need a shell company in Panama? Aren't you above the law?
- ianferrel 11y agoMy guess is that people who currently have their own country that's not known for the rule of law want an escape hatch with assets that are secured by the rule of law, in case it turns out that in the future, their country is had by someone else.
- sjreese 11y agoWell team, we now know what DAVOS ( World Economic Forum ) is all about, cover for tax avoidance or evasion and a collection of customers for Mossack Fonseca LLC - Our job now is to see how much economic harm has been done by them not paying their fair share of taxes. (think Flint Water, EPA Supper Fund, and Higher Education fund etc. ) Based on this claw-backs of all or part of the taxes. And for Mossack Fonseca ( it has now to be part of the FCPA regulation with full reporting requirements to the CCB/ECB and the IMF ) - Without investment in people, innovation is cut off and people revert to the most primordial jobs and actions - we can have better with real education and distributed know-how where people work for the betterment for humankind.
- bitmapbrother 11y agoThe hypocrisy of these politicians attacking tech companies for not paying more tax all the while they're using offshore tax havens to hide their money.
- known 11y agoGovt can do nothing due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome
- vijayr 11y agoDoes anyone know how such a thing was pulled off? I mean, it is not like taking a paper clip from office. This is mind boggling amount of information - how can someone copy so much info and send it to a newspaper etc without setting off red flags? This is incredible.
- zorked 11y agoA single HDD worth of content isn't a mind boggling amount of information.
- dang 11y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?query=Panama%20Papers&sort=byPopularity&dateRange=all&type=story&storyText=false&prefix&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=Panama%20Papers&sort=byPopular...
- mbgaxyz 11y agoPot kettle black? "...most of the UK’s big media organisations shelter assets and cash flows offshore. Top of the hypocrites in this respect is The Guardian. They put their assets in the Caymans, and they used a Luxembourg tax shell designed by PriceWaterhouseCoopers to funnel cash flows beyond the reach of HMRC. " "Other media organisations using offshore entities include the Huffington Post – whose journalists criticised Amazon for doing the same. The owners of the Mail, News UK and The Telegraph also have various offshore tax-efficient structures." http://order-order.com/2016/04/04/media-organisations-using-offshore-havens/ http://order-order.com/2016/04/04/media-organisations-using-...
- stegosaurus 11y agoThe major issue with tax avoidance schemes is the effect on competition. It's kind of like the prisoner's dilemma. If no-one uses them, great. If everyone uses them, you have a lower effective tax rate and different policy outcomes to the ones expected, so there might be distortions. If others use them but you don't, you're at a competitive disadvantage. An analogy for the everyman - imagine that there's a loophole me and everyone else in my city could use as individuals to completely avoid tax. If I choose not to do so, I'm receiving, say, 20-30% less income than I would annually, putting me at a huge disadvantage when performing normal activities such as buying a home, say. I don't think that tax avoidance is immoral, I do think it should be fixed because of the distortion (favouring large businesses, which already generally have advantages due to scale). It's a bit like how one can be a marxist whilst also choosing to own private property. You can't exist without mimicing society to some extent.
- trump2016chalk 11y agoThat's why a simpler, SUPER simple tax plan would be the best. Also why I believe that the smaller the government, the more competition and innovation there can be!
- chaosmonkey 11y agoThe question is are these companies doing anything illegal?