4 ms·
It's amazing the logic hoops their supporters go through. I can't find the site (it was linked from another journal article on HN) again right now, but I went t
by matwood 11y ago
It's amazing the logic hoops their supporters go through. I can't find the site (it was linked from another journal article on HN) again right now, but I went to a journal trade site once and started reading the comments. The article was about open access, scihub, and how journals needs to be ready, but the comments I could only assume were paid shills.
There was one guy whose position was that journals needed to limit access because the layperson would not understand what they were reading. He was questioning a person employed in home care who admitted to use SciHub to read topics she was interested in because according to him she had no need for that knowledge. This is what open access to knowledge is up against.
- pak 11y agoYou are probably talking about the comments for this article: http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2016/03/02/sci-hub-and-the-four-horsemen-of-the-internet/ http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2016/03/02/sci-hub-and-th... I agree, some of the opinions tossed around by incumbents in the industry are mind-blowing. My favorites: "A PDF is a weapons-grade tool for piracy." ...And on parents of sick kids looking up articles: "Do you really think a search and downloading of technical medical literature means anything?"
- chris_wot 11y agoAnd they wonder why NaturalNews and other anti-vaccination sites get so many hits. The arguments they are using are utterly indefensible. They now have a real problem. They were able to be gatekeepers in the U.S. and other Western nations, but the instant one nation doesn't play ball and publishes all the material as it doesn't recognise international copyright... well, this has parallels to when India refused to recognise pharmaceutical patents. They had to rapidly change their business model to more favourable terms, because it suddenly (!!!) became clear to the pharmaceutical industry that this could destroy the value of their patents.
- matwood 11y agoThat's the one. Thanks!
- mdpopescu 11y agoThat's pretty much identical with the position of the Catholic Church for a very long time: laymen aren't able to understand the Bible so it should only be accessible to professionals. I don't know if the Catholics changed their opinion, but I think it would be important for science to be more accessible :)