20 ms·
I Drove Chevrolet's Bolt
- alkonaut 11y agoThe Bolt (if the numbers $30k and 200+ miles) means that a company that isn't Tesla can build a car that is competitive at least on range/price with the Model3. I thought Tesla had an advantage on battery tech and/or production that meant the competition had to produce vastly inferior (on range) cars, such as the leaf/i3 etc. If GM can produce a 200+ mile range EV at this cost, then Toyota, VW or BMW should soon be able to produce a good 200+ mile EV at a competitive price.
- fma 11y agoI don't know if GM used any of Tesla'a tech, but Elon Musk did open up all their patents. Anyone can jump onto the electric train.
- cmurf 11y agoThe first Model 3 is slated to ship late 2017. And Bolt early 2017. That's a solid 9+ month advantage for the Bolt.
- electic 11y agoAlso, Tesla will start production and deliveries in late 2017. That means most customers might expect to get their cars in 2018 but mostly likely 2019 and 2020.[1] [1] http://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/03/tesla-may-need-cash-to-deliver-on-the-model-3-analysts.html http://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/03/tesla-may-need-cash-to-delive...
- karmicthreat 11y agoTesla is in a bit of a bind. The model 3 may have been inconveniently too popular. If Tesla wants to deliver those cars in 2018 they may have to over build their capacity. The pre-sales will probably be in the 300K-350K range. That is equivalent to the Honda accord in popularity. Tesla is either going to have to hope for sustained demand at that level, build out a massive production capacity or spread deliveries out farther. I don't know how this will end up shaking out. They will have competition in 2018 onward. Probably from multiple OEMs. So I guess the next 2 year is really going to be the big test for Musk to see if they can switch from plucky upstart to Big Auto. More than a few companies have been destroyed by too much demand too fast.
- ryanhuff 11y agoIf you believe the intended positioning, the Bolt and the Model 3 are cars with EV power plants, but intended for different segments. The Model 3 is intended to be positioned as a premium vehicle (BMW 3 series, etc), while the Bolt seems to be similarly positioned to the Prius. So, its not a winner-take-all proposition.
- mikeash 11y agoHow does that intended positioning work, if not through price differentiation? Is it just a matter of the marketing?
- Grishnakh 11y agoI could be wrong, but judging by the photos, the Bolt does not appear to compete with the Prius: the Prius is much larger. The Bolt looks like it's maybe the size and shape of a Honda Fit. I'm pretty sure Priuses (the regular kind) have quite a bit more interior room than that.
- Grishnakh 11y agoTypical HN bullshit downmodding. If I'm wrong, write a post telling me how I'm wrong.
- _Robbie 11y agoThe 2016 Toyota Prius is 4.54 meters. The Bolt is 4.17 meters. Bolt specs: http://media.chevrolet.com/media/us/en/chevrolet/vehicles/bolt-ev/2017.tab1.html http://media.chevrolet.com/media/us/en/chevrolet/vehicles/bo...
- Grishnakh 11y agoThe length is a pretty crappy way to compare cars; but that alone shows the Bolt is significantly shorter. A better measure is the interior volume (for instance, a car and an SUV from the same mfgr will frequently share the same chassis (the SUV is a taller derivative but with same bottom stampings, suspension, engine, subframes, etc.), with the exact same wheelbase/width, but the SUV clearly has more interior volume). If you compare your link to the Prius (http://www.toyota.com/prius/features/weights_capacities/1223/1224/1225/1226 http://www.toyota.com/prius/features/weights_capacities/1223...), you'll see the Prius has larger dimensions for passengers (for instance, 1st row legroom is 41.6in Bolt, 42.3in Prius; 1st row hip room is 51.6in Bolt, 53.4in Prius), however less overall passenger volume (52.2 + 42.2 = 94.4 cu-ft Bolt, 93.1 cu-ft Prius, unfortunately the Prius doesn't list separate 1st vs 2nd row volume, but I suspect the Prius wins because the Bolt beats it in rear-seat legroom 36.5 vs 33.4, so the Prius is sacrificing rear-seat room), but the Prius has greater cargo capacity by quite a lot: 24.6 cu-ft vs. 16.9. (There's also a special "Two Eco" Prius which has a whopping 27.4 cu-ft cargo volume for some reason.) Overall these aren't that far apart, but it does seem to me the Prius is a generally larger car, with more cargo space and a more spacious front seat but with crappier rear-seat legroom. Also, the Prius has a much longer wheelbase (106.3 vs 102.4), and its height is much lower (58.1 vs 62.8). That explains why the Bolt gets similar volume from so much less length: it sits up a lot higher, sorta like a mini-SUV. Also, the Bolt's page even makes note that the EPA has no category for "crossover", so they call it a "small wagon", meaning GM itself would prefer to refer to it as a crossover. The Prius has never been called a crossover; it's clearly a hatchback car.
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoIt is totally up to the agend of the other companies. Theoretically, they should be able to since tesla has open sourced all its patents but I don't think many companies want to do that. EC cars are still a niche that only very few people drive. And it still requires tons of R&D which might not be worth it for the other companies. What is really going to be interesting is how well other car companies can build EC cars. I personally like the look of the tesla model 3 way better and at a similar price point, it is a no brainier to get a tesla for me (if I had the money). Also, I'm really interested in autonomous driving and tesla seems to be far ahead (I know lots of companies are catching up but autonomous driving is still in the higher end models.
- mdorazio 11y agoJust to nitpick: Tesla is, in fact, not at all far ahead of other auto manufacturers in terms of autonomous driving tech. At CES this year, pretty much everyone showed off significant achievements in their own self-driving cars, including fully autonomous road trips. Autopilot is basically the same as adaptive cruise control + traffic jam assist, both of which have been available in some vehicles (Audi comes to mind) for years. The difference is that the bigger OEMs are extremely wary of enabling these features in cars and getting into lawsuits as a result. Tesla has shown repeatedly with things like a giant touch screen that flaunts NHTSA guidelines that it just doesn't care about potential legal problems, and is more than happy to put somewhat unproven tech in the hands of drivers and hope for the best.
- casylum 11y agoTesla is not include Autopilot safety features out of the goodness of their hearts, they need to do it to stay competitive. http://money.cnn.com/2015/09/11/autos/automatic-braking-nhtsa-iihs/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/09/11/autos/automatic-braking-nhts...
- mikeash 11y agoNote that the Bolt's $30,000 price is after the Federal tax credit, while the Model 3's $35,000 price is before the tax credit. The Bolt's real price is more like $37,500. Still close enough, and there's the additional complication that Tesla will run past the end of the tax credits well before GM does at this rate, but not quite as cheap as it might sound from the PR.
- sirkneeland 11y agoGM also has a more expensive unionized-human::robot ratio in its manufacturing process, IIRC.
- csours 11y agoAverage Tesla pre-order price was around 42.5k (pre-rebate) yesterday. It will be interesting to see what the average is with all the added orders. EDIT: No info on average yet, will still be interesting to see what that number will be We'll also have to see how the options wind up comparing at that price point. Competition is a Good Thing! Disclaimer: I work for GM, etc.
- jakswa 11y agoCan you give source for that $42.5k number? I remember seeing a number like that, but I believe it was describing the average price later down the road, when people choose their additional options and click 'buy' on the real thing. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/715934657720639488 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/715934657720639488 The base price seems to be $35k.
- csours 11y agoGood call!
- mikeash 11y agoElon Musk said that he expected the average configuration to cost $42,500. There is no actual average price yet, as no options or pricing has been announced yet beyond the $35,000 base price, and nobody has actually been able to configure an order, and won't for a long time.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoTesla does not have and never had any battery tech. They use off-the-shelf Panasonic batteries that are exactly the same ones you put in flashlights[1]. Tesla made one major innovation. They realized that people will buy an electric car for $100,000. That's really it! They have an attractive and very good car, but it is market innovation that is Tesla's essential advantage. 1: http://www.amazon.com/NCR18650B-3400mAh-Rechargeable-Battery-Panasonic/dp/B00DHXY72O http://www.amazon.com/NCR18650B-3400mAh-Rechargeable-Battery...
- wnevets 11y agosounds like an apple product.
- jakswa 11y agoI'll go out on a limb and call BS on this. An Amazon link doesn't do a good job saying Tesla has no battery tech. That I'm aware of, Tesla has at least designed some thermal management around their battery cells, to ensure optimal operating temperature (and extending battery lifetime, compared to air-cooled batteries like the initial LEAFs). http://insideevs.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/bltbattrygearbox-slide-1.jpg http://insideevs.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/bltbattrygea...
- mikeash 11y agoI imagine you've read that Tesla uses 18650 cells in their batteries. And it's true! But what you may not realize is that 18650 is just a size and shape. 18650 just means the cell is 18mm in diameter and 65mm long. Tesla uses these cells, but the guts aren't the same as what you'll find in something from Amazon.
- Gracana 11y agoMany sources online say those are the batteries that Tesla uses. Panasonic NCR18650Bs, and before that, Panasonic NCR18650As. Same as you buy on Amazon. This guy did a teardown[0] and did a single-cell discharge test and got a little under 3Ah.[1] [0] https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/pics-info-inside-the-battery-pack.34934/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/pics-info-inside-the... [1] https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/pics-info-inside-the-battery-pack.34934/page-28#post-969995 https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/pics-info-inside-the...
- csours 11y agoLook at externalities when you consider selling price: Tesla sells pollution credits to outside companies, which they can use to finance their operations to some degree. For legacy OEMs like GM, CAFE standards mean that selling 1 Bolt EV lets them sell several Cadillac Escalades which have a very nice profit margin. Disclaimer: I work for GM, but not on this product, and any opinions are my own.
- jakswa 11y agoI think you're right in saying that anyone could do it, but in my opinion, it depends on the economics of the battery packs. If we truly are seeing the costs come down, as Tesla hoped and GM seem to be showing, then it'll be exciting to see if any other players appear. GM reportedly scored an insane price of $145/kWh for their battery pack production http://insideevs.com/lg-chem-ticked-gm-disclosing-145kwh-battery-cell-pricing-video/ http://insideevs.com/lg-chem-ticked-gm-disclosing-145kwh-bat...
- fossuser 11y agoI know this is subjective and shouldn't matter, but I think the Bolt is ugly. In fact out of all the non-Tesla EVs the only one I don't find ugly is the Fiat 500e which is only sold in CA (and now Oregon) as a compliance car and its own CEO hates it. It is a nice little EV though. All of this also ignores the coming autonomous cars which I think are going to be here sooner than people realize (maybe this is the big part 2 of the model 3 reveal). When that happens I'm not confident the existing car companies will be able to compete - they're desperately trying to acquire the necessary tech now, but it's a little late.
- lotharbot 11y agodo you include hybrid EVs like the Volt and Prius in your "ugly" list? Personally, I love my Volt. I only use gasoline on rare occasions -- a couple of out-of-state trips per year -- but don't have to make long stops (30 minutes is long for me) at charging stations along the way. And I think it's a pretty cool looking car. But then, I'm over 30, so what do I know about cool?
- jadei 11y agoWhile we are talking hybrids, I love my ford fusion hybrid. Looks exactly like the gas fusions and has all the same options (well besides wheels and engines). Some owners even take off the hybrid badges on theirs.
- sremani 11y agoThere is a little bit of nuance you might have missed here, we are mostly discussing Plugins, and Prius has a plugin. Ford Fusion Energi is the worst thing that can happen to Plugins and Fusion Hybrid is a good car but does not belong in the discussion here.
- shifter 11y agoA typical time constant for a supercharger stop is 15 minutes.
- Shivetya 11y agoI am looking forward to the Bolt, might even go that route as I like the form factor a bit more than the traditional sedan route Tesla taking. That and I would like to do 200+ mile range EV before 2020 rolls around. The one thing that the Bolt raises more so than the 3 is that it will invalidate the pricing this year for any EV that gets under 100 mile range and wants to charge near 30k. When this car reaches the lot people are going to question how the other manufacturers think they can justify near 30k or 50k in the case of BMW pricing for sub 100 miles. Even Chevy might have some issues with range extender Volt which has 50 EV miles. I can imagine some shoppers thinking, it gives up 150EV miles for a gas engine? Then finally when the 3 is available in quantity the other manufacturers better have 200 mile range EVs of their own or severely discounted lower range EV. Most will use EVs to up their fleet fuel mileage but some may find a real market there. Granted even all those reservations for the 3 look nice but 300k isn't squat when up against numbers of all cars just sold in the US let alone world wide
- lotharbot 11y ago> "I can imagine some shoppers thinking, it gives up 150EV miles for a gas engine?" Sure -- I think the Volt is targeting a different use case, of people whose daily commutes are less than 40-50 total miles but who occasionally make long trips. It's basically the perfect car for me (I bought a 2013 Volt off-lease a few months ago.) I'm a stay-at-home dad, my wife works from home, and most of the driving I do is to locations within a 5-mile radius (family, church, the grocery store, and a handful of restaurants.) Two or three times per year, we travel out of state, at which point I'm glad for the ~340 mile combined range and would be disappointed with having to stop every 200 miles and sit for 30+ minutes waiting for a full charge. But for someone who regularly travels 50-200 miles per day, the Bolt or 3 or other EVs in that class might be a much better option.
- dangrossman 11y agoI'll be replacing a Leaf with a Bolt at the end of the year. I think it's an attractive looking car myself, and the hatchback form factor has grown on me. The tech features (10" tablet with android/carplay, built-in LTE wifi, rear camera mirror, birds-eye surround camera system, collision alerts) will all be exciting upgrades compared to the Leaf, which is a pretty barebones car even at the top trim level. The Model 3 could be my household's second car (currently a non-EV), but that's almost 3 years out for east coast delivery even if Tesla's perfectly on-time and 10x's their production capacity in a year. Plus, the purchase incentives will probably be long gone by then.
- akhilcacharya 11y agoDid you lease the Leaf or purchase outright?
- dangrossman 11y agoI bought a used 2012-SL with 15K miles for about $10K last year. Got a $500 EV charger on Amazon, and installed it for $125. I loved my first test drive in an EV and really don't want to go back to a conventional car as my daily driver. The 5-year-old battery only gets 70-some miles to a charge on a good day, so I'm looking forward to something longer range in the next year. That limits me to either a Bolt or a plug-in hybrid like the Volt. I'm leaning toward the Bolt, especially if I can get my hands on one before winter is in full swing.
- akhilcacharya 11y agoJust $10K? That's amazing! I was thinking that a leased new model of the Leaf (or preferably the Bolt) would be ideal given the battery issues.
- oDot 11y agoThe most important feature of the Teslas, in my opinion, is safety. If I had to choose between a Bolt and a Model 3 -- poor safety ratings would have been a deciding factor. Also, I hope it can't be "benchmark-optimized" like in web browsers.
- csours 11y agoI think I understand what you are saying, but official crash test ratings have not been released for either vehicle yet. I don't think crash test safety can be "benchmark-optimized" per se; outside companies do the testing and the proof is in the pudding, so to speak. However, there may be vehicle incidents that would not be covered by safety or crash tests. The safety dollars go to mitigating incidents with the highest rate of fatalities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_motor_vehicle_collisions#Proportion_of_deaths_by_type_of_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_motor_vehicle_... Disclaimer: I work for GM, but not on this product. Any opinions are my own.
- 762236 11y agoTesla has a history of addressing safety in a way that no other manufacturers seem to prioritize for (given that car design is over constrained and you have to compromise somewhere). I would be really surprised if the Bolt earned 5-star ratings in every category. On Tesla's Model S, they designed to achieve 5-star if the tests were applied everywhere on the car --- not just the official test points.
- csours 11y agoI would agree that Tesla has a history of safety, and that is laudable. I hope you are surprised by the Bolt's safety rating when it comes out. It is really great that Tesla has prioritized safety. They do have a few things going for them that other OEMs don't: * Only two models in production, both of which are on the same architecture. (soon to be three) * No history of failure: - GM's X-frame - Really bad seatbelts: Nearly everyone until the 1980s - Chevy Corvair (Thanks Nader!) [1] - Pintos catching on fire - Audi 5000 unintended acceleration in the 1980s - Pontiac Fieros catching on fire - Ford Explorers rolling over - GM's key switch issue - Toyota's unintended acceleration When you look at all of those, you can see that at the time, either the engineers didn't care about safety (most OEMs until the 1970s), didn't prioritize safety, just missed something, or they didn't realize that a particular design had safety implications. Tesla has learned all of those lessons and that's great. Most other OEMs have also learned those lessons, and that's great too! 1. Nader has been credited with pushing for consumer safety generally and vehicle safety specifically. Disclaimer: again, all opinions are solely my own.
- iamdave 11y agoI'm interested as heck to know more about this instrumentation panel showing "technique" as an indicator for the car's energy consumption. Ostensibly using gamification to encourage more conscious driving?
- dangrossman 11y agoPretty much all hybrids and EVs do the gamification thing. Honda's got "eco score", Ford has "efficiency leaves", Nissan has "trees", etc. The more economically you drive, the more .. things .. you collect on the dashboard.
- iamdave 11y agoShows how behind I am. Last time I drove one of these eco-cars was a 2008 company car Prius.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoMy standard ICE Honda does this too. A green arrow to tell me to switch up/down a gear and a row if up to 5 green dots to tell me when I'm driving efficiently (e.g. accelerating gently or coasting to a stop, not harsh acceleration followed by hard braking).
- vvanders 11y agoThere's really not that much "technique" around driving an EV efficiently. Use regen braking and keep your speed down since most power goes to V^2 @ > 45mph.
- mikestew 11y agoRegen braking is lossy, you've squandered energy if you use it. Ideally, your power meter (in whatever form it takes on your particular model) should be smack in the "not using nor generating power" spot. Ideally, you watch traffic ahead and plan so that you just coast up to the light or stopped traffic and let rolling resistance slow you down. Congratulations, you're now a "hyper miler" who annoys everyone around you. That's all theoretical. In my Leaf, I can't be bothered, I just drive it. I do try to keep it under 65mph, 'cuz boy howdy does the range drop if you're hot footin'it.
- Keyframe 11y agoIn other news, Chevrolet ceased sales of new cars in Europe altogether. No more Chevrolet for Europe. GM needs this to work.
- ptaipale 11y agoThat's pretty much just a badging thing. GM sells European cars with the Opel badge (and Vauxhall in the UK). Chevrolet Volt was same as Opel Ampera, for example (but it had so bad sales that it was discontinued).
- Keyframe 11y agoTrue to an extent, because not all Chevrolet vehicles are re-branded nor are they available throughout Europe.
- ptaipale 11y agoIn fact, in December 2013 GM announced that it withdraws the Chevrolet brand from Europe, with just a couple of exceptions of "iconic vehicles" (Corvette and Camaro), plus the Russian market where they will continue. So, you can't really buy any new Chevrolet badged cars in Europe. http://www.chevrolet.co.uk/owners-area/important-customer-information.html http://www.chevrolet.co.uk/owners-area/important-customer-in... The Chevrolets sold in Europe were almost exclusively made in South Korea. American cars and car brands have a rather lousy quality reputation in Europe.
- phkahler 11y agoI'd really like to have an electric Corvette. If anyone wants to work on a conversion, I could get on board with that.
- bjelkeman-again 11y agoThere are a few individual efforts, here is one. http://news.boldride.com/2014/02/man-builds-electric-c3-corvette/35068/ http://news.boldride.com/2014/02/man-builds-electric-c3-corv...
- slfnflctd 11y agoMy dream for years has been to get a '79 Stingray shell, build it as electric and do a fully modernized interior. I've just always loved that particular body style. Perhaps one day we'll be able to order totally custom cars and have robots build them for us at a reasonable price. Now that's what I'd call progress.
- lotharbot 11y agomy uncle used to do electric conversions, though he never had the money to try a Corvette. He did have a Corvair (which is totally different) he raced in electric car rallies, which tended to do really well in endurance events.
- vvanders 11y agoOne thing that always seems missing from these comparison articles is the Supercharger network. It makes such a huge difference, I just don't see how CCS catches up(not to mention that there's no long term planning around it).
- JulianMorrison 11y agoI'm guessing at some point they're gonna realize they have to come to Tesla cap in hand and ask to plug into theirs. Tesla might say yes. They want EVs to win, not just their particular brand. They're already giving away the juice. My guess is they'd just ask the other companies to shoulder their share of the bill.
- maxerickson 11y agoI doubt it, there's ~4,000 plugs right now, the Tesla "experience" gets watered down when you have to wait for the plebes to charge their POS daily driver. I wouldn't be real shocked if the Model 3 has to pay to charge. Not only because of the electricity cost, to keep the stations available.
- imglorp 11y agoDo we know if the fast charge power connectors going to be compatible? There's an industry standard SAE J1772 which Tesla at least has adapters to support.
- vvanders 11y agoCCS and CHAdeMO have similar voltages so I wouldn't be surprised if Tesla can use them(they already have an adapter for CHAdeMO).
- ams6110 11y agoUnless you specifically want a pure EV, a hybrid with a gasoline-powered generator onboard is going to be more practical. I have a different perspective because there are no superchargers within 50 miles, and in fact for the most common longer drives I make there are no SuperChargers within range of the vehicle. So they are a non-factor in any consideration I would have in deciding on a possible EV purchase.
- itg 11y agoOne thing I like about the Bolt over the Tesla 3 is the fact that it has buttons for climate control and basic music functions. I'm really not a fan of where your are forced to do everything on a giant touchscreen stuck to the middle of the dash.
- toddmorey 11y agoI thought I'd miss physical buttons, too, but I don't. I really don't. It's very easy to use the touchscreen in a Tesla. Plus, you do have physical buttons available for climate: they are on the steering wheel (if you decide to chose that option).
- awestley 11y agoAgreed. I had the same hesitation. Like most things with the Tesla, you need to experience it to truly appreciate it.
- marcoperaza 11y agoCan you safely operate the entertainment system while driving? With physical buttons, I can turn the volume knob or cycle through radio station presets without taking my attention off the road. With a touch screen, you don't get tactile feedback and modal dialogs or different screens can block controls, so you have to divert your gaze and attention to the screen. I haven't driven in a Tesla, so maybe they've figured it out.
- mdorazio 11y agoOnly if you use the steering wheel controls. Despite what others may believe, anything you need to do on the giant touch screen absolutely cannot be done safely while driving.
- mikeash 11y agoI wonder, is there actual evidence that physical buttons are better? I don't doubt that screwing with a touchscreen while driving is dangerous, but I have to wonder about the common wisdom that screwing with physical buttons while driving isn't.
- hristov 11y agoHe said the traction control engaged when accelerating out of some corners. That may be the result of high torque or a badly designed car. I really hope they do not make the mistake of making this a front wheel drive car. A front wheel drive car when combined with a high torque electric motor is basically asking for trouble. The high torque applied to the front wheels screws up the steering, makes it imprecise, causes understeer, or in extreme cases even the loss of steering control. This was a problem with the Chevy Spark electric. It was very fast but, when you slam on the gas, you lose all steering input and the car tends to veer to the right and there is nothing you can do about it. (except of course to let go of the gas, so you can get the steering back). Electric engines are so small there is a lot of flexibility designers have as to where to place them. It would be a huger mistake if bold designers placed them in the front. [Edit: I meant understeer not oversteer]
- Sir_Vival 11y agoLarge portions of people that live where it snows will only drive a front wheel drive (or all wheel drive) vehicle. My first car was a $400 rear wheel drive beast, so it doesn't bother me - but a lot of people think I'm crazy driving my (rear wheel) Camaro in the winter.
- M4N14C 11y agoLived in upstate NY with a RWD Tacoma. Put snow tires and 200 pounds of sand in the back. It was fine, used to take it snowboarding through storms all the time.
- torgoguys 11y agoYep, this. I don't care about crazy good performance, but do want something I feel handles reliably in snowy and icy conditions. Call me an unskilled driver, but I don't feel as confident in bad conditions with rear wheel drive.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoYou're an unskilled driver. Traction is traction. No matter how a car handles it'll handle the same way on every surface, the traction threshold will be different. No matter which wheels are driven turning and braking is the same. In a straight line it front/rear doesn't really matter. RWD will slip out, FWD will just spin and in either case the driver (the one's that aren't the worst of the worst) will lift off the throttle before anything bad happens. In a modern car traction control will just work it's magic and you wouldn't even know. Ditto for turning from a stop. The driven wheels are irreverent to turning while slowing. The problem is in a long sweeping turn that the driver wants to accelerate out of, like a highway ramp. FWD will just plow straight into whatever is outside the turn. RWD will do the same thing but the car will be oriented differently. No matter which wheels are driven if you break traction in a turn you're going to go wide, better hope you've got enough space to correct it. The safety advantage with understeer is that if you do something monumentally stupid (e.g. drunk guy takes highway off ramp at 90mph) the front of the car with all it's crash test safety will be between you and the consequences of your actions. The RWD vs FWD thing is more of a "what I don't know can't hurt me." The novice won't notice a little bit of understeer whereas anyone will notice a little bit of oversteer and everyone who can't apply a reasonable amount of self control to their right foot should bend over, grab their ankles and spend their money on some snow tires. The Miata club of Alaska was featured in one of the car magizines (I forget which) and they basically said "Everyone that thinks we're insane for driving these cars year round in Alaska should know that the design characteristics that help maximize use of available traction in the dry don't stop working in the snow."
- brightball 11y agoI still don't understand why anyone would buy a Tesla 3 or a Bolt over a Volt at this point in time for recharge time and infrastructure.
- r00fus 11y agoAs a 2nd car (mainly for commuting) an electric vehicle is great.
- aetherson 11y agoYou shouldn't be downvoted for this. It's a legit comment. I feel like there's a pretty major hidden cost in hybrids in that you now have to maintain the gasoline engine (and potentially entire drivetrain) as well as the electric one. You kind of get the worst of both worlds there -- plus you have a weight penalty of course. I have very little use for >200 mile/day drives, so getting an electric that can handle my 99% driving case sounds better to me than getting a Volt which I'll still need to semi-regularly fill up and maintain.
- FunnyLookinHat 11y agoThis might sound ridiculous, but I really just don't want GM to win. The American automotive industry moved ridiculously slowly towards electric and alternative fuel vehicles, and ultimately is only doing so to sell units on what they perceive as a new niche. If I'm giving money to a company for a new type of transportation, it's going to be the one committing to the broad goals of bettering humanity, not just capitalizing on someone else proving the existence of a market. I'm not just behind Tesla, there are other companies like Arcimoto (https://www.arcimoto.com/ https://www.arcimoto.com/) that are putting significant effort into redesigning transportation from the ground up.
- jakswa 11y agoI'll echo this same sentiment. On one hand you've got what feels like pieces of GM trying to "turn an aircraft carrier around."[1] On the other hand you have a relatively nimble Tesla investing everything it has into making EVs affordable and desirable. And to me it's bleeding over into the consumer market. One just scored $8.5B worth of preorders, and the other shrugs off the prospect of even offering preorders, given the assertion that Tesla will hit 200k preorders and "suck the air out of the room[2]." [1]: http://www.wired.com/2016/01/gm-electric-car-chevy-bolt-mary-barra/ http://www.wired.com/2016/01/gm-electric-car-chevy-bolt-mary... [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4BIoNsAB8s&feature=youtu.be&t=12m34s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4BIoNsAB8s&feature=youtu.be...
- vinay427 11y ago> One just scored $8.5B worth of preorders, and the other shrugs off the prospect of even offering preorders, given the assertion that Tesla will hit 200k preorders and "suck the air out of the room[2]." What is so inherently superior about offering preorders? I'm honestly not sure what point you're making here.
- jakswa 11y agoNothing superior about offering preorders, besides the efficiency of the process (compared to a dealership model). That was me explaining why I thought the consumer market seems to agree. We don't have the numbers on Bolt because they don't offer preorders, but even if only 70% of the pre-orders go through with it, the Model 3 looks like it'll already be the best-selling U.S. car in its segment (small luxury).[1] Will it outsell the Bolt? It'll be amazing and exciting if they go head to head, but my guess is yes. 1: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2016-03-22/how-tesla-model-3-can-complete-its-take-over-of-the-u-s-luxury-market http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2016-03-22/how-tesla-...
- spectrum1234 11y agoWhy does every non Tesla electric look so ugly? And why does every article written by supposedly competent journalists not mention how ugly literally ever other electric car is when they discuss tradeoffs? It could very well be a close race between 2-5 electric cars. But attractiveness could be another reason 1 is the big winner.
- bitmapbrother 11y agoI've also wondered this. I find it hard to believe that a designer of an electric car, other than a Tesla, can honestly think they styled a beautiful vehicle. If I were to give them the benefit of the doubt then I would say that what they initially sketched on paper and what was ultimately produced was the fault of layers of institutional bureaucracy each meddling with the design until it looked nothing like what was envisioned. There was a time when most programmers did their own art. This is reminiscent of that time.
- dj_doh 11y agoI second these comments. It feels like they want to put A-grade designers for electric cars. Same can be said for BMW i3 and (NotSo)SmartFor2. They are joke to say the least.
- superuser2 11y agoMarket segmentation. There's no good reason cheap cars have to look worse than expensive cars, except that selling a cheap but expensive-looking car would cannibalize higher-margin luxury car sales. No competitor breaks this cycle because all major competitors for middle-class cars also have luxury divisions.
- spectrum1234 11y agoThis is the best reason I've seen yet. And good evidence that startups (yes Tesla is still a startup) will always be better at exploiting inefficiencies in larger companies.
- 11y ago
- 1024core 11y ago"the Bolt will feature 4G LTE connectivity and OnStar support, " ... so GM can track you and sell the data.
- gambiting 11y agoQuestion - why almost all electric cars have to be incredibly ugly? Like it's a requirement for a car to be electric almost. Nissan Leaf looks like a fridge turned sideways, BMW i3 looks like a collection of parts designed by different people which don't really match together, Vauxhall(Opel) Ampera looks like someone smashed a Prius with a hammer, Tesla's and BMW i8 look ok but these are premium cars, and now the Bolt has a back that looks like a back of one of those dummy cars they use for crash testing. I understand there's a push for "hey, I'm different, I'm electric!" but I know quite a few people who would be in a market for a new Leaf but they won't buy it because of the looks, it's almost like it's impossible to put electric motor and batteries into a shape that looks like a conventional car.
- nomercy400 11y agoThere should really be some additional metrics for these kind of reviews. So you got to drive a car for a testdrive/hour/week? How is maintenance? How are charging times? How does it compare to a normal car during its lifecycle? How much is the battery worth after 1000 charge cycles? How much will the car be worth when I want to sell it? With a normal car, I have an idea that I can fuel it 1000 times and it will still work, albeit the maintenance of which I have a general idea as well. How does translate to an EV car? I still have so many questions.
- warfangle 11y agoWhy does it look like a new balance?