5 ms·
Let's not even talk about the fact that educational system is extremely inefficient and is prone to wasting student's time. One would think that after spending
by adamnemecek 11y ago
Let's not even talk about the fact that educational system is extremely inefficient and is prone to wasting student's time. One would think that after spending 6-8 hours a day for 12 years that you'd come out somewhat knowledgeable about something.
- meric 11y agoHaving moved into an English speaking country at 9, school helped me become fluent in English. I also attribute my arithmetic skills to my schooling, the calculus knowledge immediately put to use in the computer game I was writing. I also more or less enjoyed my history lessons. It helped me better immerse in Age of Empires at night.
- adamnemecek 11y agoInefficient isn't the same a absolutely useless.
- meric 11y ago'Somewhat knowledgeable about something'. I think I would qualify...
- kuschku 11y agoYou are if you come out of high school. You understand the global history since the neolithical times rougly, and your own contintents history since the 1500s pretty exactly. You understand how algebra, analysis, stochastic work, and can do simple mathematical proofs. You know the laws of physics, how and why things work, you have learnt general and special relativity, and even know parts of quantum mechanics, including being able to work with the probability functions of electrons. You know basic chemistry, understand what each element is, know a large part of organic and inorganic chemistry, have experimented with it, and can explain why some molecular bindings work, and why some don’t. You speak fluently 3 to 4 languages, and can read standard literature in them, as well as being able to write essays about cultural topics in them. You have had PE, know how to play a majority of sports, and have a physical condition where you are able to play them. You know the historical styles of art produced, and when and where they were produced, and have experience working in a majority of styles yourself. You know how our political system and our economy works, and know how to do accounting and taxes for yourself. You know how to start a company, and the trade offs of different types of incorporation. You are able to work in teams, can delegate work, know how to learn things from existing sources and do your own research, how to write scientific papers, can debate with others in a civil way. ________________________ Excerpted and translated from the curriculum for high school students in the German state of Schleswig-Holstein, 2012. (And I can attest that what I learnt in school fits this description)
- qrendel 11y agoAlmost no one graduating in the US would have even one of these skills, except possibly "knowing how to play a majority of sports." Most people graduating college wouldn't even have more than one or two of them, if any at all.
- kuschku 11y agoI heard people say such things, but I’m not sure if I can take that seriously. I mean, your school system can’t be that bad, right? What do you do in high school all day long then?
- tlunter 11y agoI think some resentful high school students that had a hard time often reflect American schooling poorly. I didn't have a supremely negative time (with the teaching at least) and I went to a standard 8:00-2:30 school in Massachusetts that had hour long blocks. I think we need to start taking more negative responses on the Internet as the extreme and not necessarily the norm.
- qrendel 11y agoMassachusetts seems to be consistently ranked as having one of the top public school systems in the US.[1][2][3] That might explain part of the discrepancy between your experience and my own. (Edit: In fact, it seems MA would be pretty competitive globally against other country's schools - 9th in math, 4th in reading, 2nd in math. On the other hand, the worst U.S. states are on par with Bulgaria and Kazakhstan, among others.[4]) [1] http://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/articles/how-states-compare http://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/articles/h... [2] https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-the-best-schools/5335/ https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-the-best-schools/5335/ [3] http://www.aecf.org/m/databook/aecf-2014kidscountdatabook-embargoed-2014.pdf http://www.aecf.org/m/databook/aecf-2014kidscountdatabook-em... [4] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesmarshallcrotty/2014/09/29/if-massachusetts-were-a-country-its-students-would-rank-9th-in-the-world/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesmarshallcrotty/2014/09/29/i...
- eggy 11y agoI agree. The first schools in the US were founded in the 17th century, but public school as a place for learning reading, writing and arithmetic came only in the last 175 to 200 years as the model we are largely familiar with today. Before that, schools were church and community driven, with parents expected to fill in the math and reading literacy if capable. Agrarian life was a family business. In modern public schools, children are age-segregated within a year of their birth dates, and a large portion of the day is spent on mundane administrative tasks such as lining up, going to your locker, moving classes, sitting down and getting quiet for a lecture or other class. I sent my first two children through the system against my wishes, but as a compromise with my wife at the time. I am now raising my youngest outside of the school system. People always throw out the 'socialization with peers' thing. IMHO, I think it is healthier for the child to socialize across the age groups - maybe a violin class with 40 to 60 year olds, a yoga class with 20, 30 or 40-somethings, play time with close-in-age children after they are out of school, or during the morning with other home-schooled children. Right now I am living in East Java, Indonesia, and my baby is being social with everyone in the village from other babies to 80 to 90 year olds. I am originally from Brooklyn, NY (born and raised), and could easily do the same thing there, especially nowadays with more 'outside of the box' parents than when I was raised there. Home schooling used to get a bad rap because a lot of fundamentalist religious parents wanted out of the public school system. I am an atheist, so this does not apply. I don't think you do any great harm either way with school or home schooling; it's a personal choice. I just feel it is more of an easy thing to do. And, no, I am not independently wealthy. I grew up poor, and I have just decided to live life a bit different to accommodate my family's values, which sometimes means minimal living, but not skimping on fun and creativity and activities which abound in many places if you just look.
- pink_dinner 11y agoI disagree. My wife was home schooled and has huge gaps in history, science, math, and English. Most of which I learned in public schools. While the public schools in the US need some work, many of the people I talked to that 'didn't learn anything' didn't want to put the time and effort into actually learning. Instead, time was spent on complaining about the system.